This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
There is a degree of subjectivity involved here. If my daughter had this merchant parading around in front of her I doubt I’d be that sanguine. Exactly how do you legislate for this type of thing or expect business to have a policy that will not get them sued. I am sure there are perfectly nice and safe Trans people but I don't see how you can separate them from the perverts. It's no good saying well arrest them if they do something wrong that is not much comfort to the victim. The only sensible thing is to ensure women and children are safe in changing rooms, toilets, health clubs etc by banning anyone with a p****. If a Trans person has had the fully monty then I thing they should be allowed in.
Edited by Badger11 (04 Sep 2021 9.58am)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
We can do that easily by acknowledge there is a conflict between the rights of women/girls and the rights of transwomen. The rights of women and children to have a safe place to get changed and use the toilet outweighs the rights of transwomen. That's all the silent majority is really asking for. I have to smile at the supporters of 'moderate' social liberalism who are aghast that it inevitably goes too far. There's a wanton blindness to the statistics. A permanent attachment to 'this feels right' because it tickles their egalitarian core. There's a deliberate ignoring or excuse culture over the practical results of social changes.....some even go so far as to say they are desirable as they suit some other larger goal. The moral of the story is that the 'slippery slope' is not always a logical fallacy. It depends upon how much money and propaganda is put behind ideologies. The 'silent majority' have been talked about for generations. Let history tell you just how effective they have been in ever stopping anything they were against. Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Sep 2021 10.15am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Exactly how do you legislate for this type of thing or expect business to have a policy that will not get them sued. I am sure there are perfectly nice and safe Trans people but I don't see how you can separate them from the perverts. It's no good saying well arrest them if they do something wrong that is not much comfort to the victim. The only sensible thing is to ensure women and children are safe in changing rooms, toilets, health clubs etc by banning anyone with a p****. If a Trans person has had the fully monty then I thing they should be allowed in.
Edited by Badger11 (04 Sep 2021 9.58am) I’m sure you’re right Badger and until the last few years this isn’t an issue which would have even occurred to many people.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
There is a degree of subjectivity involved here. If my daughter had this merchant parading around in front of her I doubt I’d be that sanguine. Of course not. This kind of thing cannot be permitted, and no compromises are possible. I expect the lines to be redrawn so that a sensible balance can be found which is acceptable to the majority. Those on the extremes, whether perverts or anti-lgbt activists, will just have to accept it.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The 'silent majority' have been talked about for generations. Let history tell you just how effective they have been in ever stopping anything they were against.
Amen to that. Swap the word 'silent' for 'cowardly', and you get a more accurate description. This trans s*** is lunacy. Absolute, full-on, madness. And yet people are silent about it? No. Shout out from the roof-tops about it. Refuse to even countenance it. Call it out for the 'Emperors New Clothes' BS it is. Full-on degeneracy and yet again promoting utterly sterile and self-destructive lifestyles as something society need to celebrate. Why do they want you all so cowed that you have to be silent with regards to these beyond insane attempts to re-write the core of what it means to be fully human?
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Of course not. This kind of thing cannot be permitted, and no compromises are possible. I expect the lines to be redrawn so that a sensible balance can be found which is acceptable to the majority. Those on the extremes, whether perverts or anti-lgbt activists, will just have to accept it. It’s not going to happen when one groups feelings are regarded as inviolate whilst another’s are demonised as bigotry.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Amen to that. Swap the word 'silent' for 'cowardly', and you get a more accurate description. This trans s*** is lunacy. Absolute, full-on, madness. And yet people are silent about it? No. Shout out from the roof-tops about it. Refuse to even countenance it. Call it out for the 'Emperors New Clothes' BS it is. Full-on degeneracy and yet again promoting utterly sterile and self-destructive lifestyles as something society need to celebrate. Why do they want you all so cowed that you have to be silent with regards to these beyond insane attempts to re-write the core of what it means to be fully human? 20 years ago, I might have agreed with you, but not now. I have had recent experience within my own family. Not once, but twice. I can assure you it is neither "lunacy" nor "degeneracy"! It was a very difficult and exhausting situation for everyone involved, but eventually resulted in two people coming to terms with themselves and being happy. That has, in turn, brought everybody else closer. In the past, I think both of those involved would have been unhappy, confused, ostracised and possibly suicidal. I lost a nephew to suicide many years ago, when his family could not accept he was gay. Celebration is not needed. Understanding and acceptance is enough.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Amen to that. Swap the word 'silent' for 'cowardly', and you get a more accurate description. This trans s*** is lunacy. Absolute, full-on, madness. And yet people are silent about it? No. Shout out from the roof-tops about it. Refuse to even countenance it. Call it out for the 'Emperors New Clothes' BS it is. Full-on degeneracy and yet again promoting utterly sterile and self-destructive lifestyles as something society need to celebrate. Why do they want you all so cowed that you have to be silent with regards to these beyond insane attempts to re-write the core of what it means to be fully human? They are a silent majority because they don't want to be associated with loudmouth , racist, extreme right wing scumbags. I'm not really so sure why you are so threatened by a man that wants to wear a dress?
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
They are a silent majority because they don't want to be associated with loudmouth , racist, extreme right wing scumbags. I'm not really so sure why you are so threatened by a man that wants to wear a dress? How about if that same man wants to get changed next to your wife or daughter?
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
I'm not really so sure why you are so threatened by a man that wants to wear a dress? I don't know whether Alex Ferguson felt threatened by Beckham when he saw a picture in the paper of his star player wearing a dress, but I think it wasn't long afterwards that they parted company.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
How about if that same man wants to get changed next to your wife or daughter?
All he has are what he thinks are insults to anyone who actually points that out.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
How about if that same man wants to get changed next to your wife or daughter? I've answered that Teddy. Read back, I made my view very cleary. Read back a couple of pages and you'll see it. The biggest problem with a lot of these arguments that bigoted dinosaurs such as Stirling and Matov get involved and try and push their extreme hateful right wing views, and quash sensible conversation. They don't really care about women's rights. They've state how they are at odds with femism in countless posts. But they are also anti-gay, anti-trans, anti-imigration, anti-anything but white. Don't get me wrong. The far left go way to far on this issue. Unfortunately, they live in that bitter world forever. Whilst claiming to support a multi-culteral team. Their views and alignment with terrorist organisat PA is damaging for this website, and by association a damaging reflection on the club and it's fanbase. Edited by jeeagles (04 Sep 2021 10.10pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
I've answered that Teddy. Read back, I made my view very cleary. Read back a couple of pages and you'll see it. The biggest problem with a lot of these arguments that bigoted dinosaurs such as Stirling and Matov get involved and try and push their extreme hateful right wing views, and quash sensible conversation. They don't really care about women's rights. They've state how they are at odds with femism in countless posts. But they are also anti-gay, anti-trans, anti-imigration, anti-anything but white. Don't get me wrong. The far left go way to far on this issue. Unfortunately, they live in that bitter world forever. Whilst claiming to support a multi-culteral team. Their views and alignment with terrorist organisat PA is damaging for this website, and by association a damaging reflection on the club and it's fanbase. Edited by jeeagles (04 Sep 2021 10.10pm) Apologies Jeeagles, you did. I missed that one.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
I've answered that Teddy. Read back, I made my view very cleary. Read back a couple of pages and you'll see it. The biggest problem with a lot of these arguments that bigoted dinosaurs such as Stirling and Matov get involved and try and push their extreme hateful right wing views, and quash sensible conversation. They don't really care about women's rights. They've state how they are at odds with femism in countless posts. But they are also anti-gay, anti-trans, anti-imigration, anti-anything but white. Don't get me wrong. The far left go way to far on this issue. Unfortunately, they live in that bitter world forever. Whilst claiming to support a multi-culteral team. Their views and alignment with terrorist organisat PA is damaging for this website, and by association a damaging reflection on the club and it's fanbase. Edited by jeeagles (04 Sep 2021 10.10pm) You say you aren't 'far left', yet here you are using their buzzwords: that was a very bbs-like post. As for your description about people you don't personally know. Ok, tell, me what I have said that proves I 'hate' any individual? Otherwise, you have just proven yourself a liar. You don't have any answers other than to talk about 'extremism' and 'hate' and insults about opinions you disagree with. The 'hate' only appears to come from you, the apparent centrist. You imply my position means I can't support non white people in a football team....that level of understanding is very rudimentary it was almost comic to read. I've supported CP for forty years, who the hell are you to suggest otherwise. As for calling PA a 'terrorist organisation'? That's another lie. People can obviously make informed criticisms but that one is a lie as they don't support violence of any kind. I suppose once someone starts lying it's easy to continue.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jeeagles
They are a silent majority because they don't want to be associated with loudmouth , racist, extreme right wing scumbags. I'm not really so sure why you are so threatened by a man that wants to wear a dress? Extremes on one side of an argument spur on extremes on the other. It's a dynamic that spurs both of them on. Clearly someone waving their wang and saying 'I'm a lady' is out of order, as is the 'eagerness' of categorising people as trans, but at the same time so is the tarring of all trans people as some kind of degenerate force. Most people in life have their struggles and just want to strike a balance in life. Edited by BlueJay (05 Sep 2021 5.15am)
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
As for calling PA a 'terrorist organisation'? That's another lie. People can obviously make informed criticisms but that one is a lie as they don't support violence of any kind.
There I would agree with you, but at the same time it is entirely accurate to say that there are clearly very few degrees of separation between the individual who fronts a group you endorse and extremist. The leader of the party you endorse has been open and vocal in celebrating the deaths of both Africans and Gay people to HIV. He promotes hatred of Jews and celebrates Neo Nazi-ism. This isn't someone who operates by degrees, he is an extreme individual and one you pose notably little resistance to, to the point that you're a proponent of his party. An unemotive 'informed criticisms' for PA and stark contrast to the endless angry tomes aimed at sweeping demographics you forever take issue with (funnily enough the same ones this neo nazi does - you're alike in meaningful ways). It's an outlook that only 'works' in environments that are demographically and politically incredibly finite. That and situations where people have no option but to listen. Both are ultimately examples of failed socialisation as much as personal politics. Anyone with integrity or character heads to the exits when this stuff is front and centre and who can blame them. Unfortunately then there is little to stop the resulting vacuum filling with ever more ramped up versions of the same. Edited by BlueJay (05 Sep 2021 5.51am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
There I would agree with you, but at the same time it is entirely accurate to say that there are clearly very few degrees of separation between the individual who fronts a group you endorse and extremist. The leader of the party you endorse has been open and vocal in celebrating the deaths of both Africans and Gay people to HIV. He promotes hatred of Jews and celebrates Neo Nazi-ism. This isn't someone who operates by degrees, he is an extreme individual and one you pose notably little resistance to, to the point that you're a proponent of his party. An unemotive 'informed criticisms' for PA and stark contrast to the endless angry tomes aimed at sweeping demographics you forever take issue with (funnily enough the same ones this neo nazi does - you're alike in meaningful ways). It's an outlook that only 'works' in environments that are demographically and politically incredibly finite. That and situations where people have no option but to listen. Both are ultimately examples of failed socialisation as much as personal politics. Anyone with integrity or character heads to the exits when this stuff is front and centre and who can blame them. Unfortunately then there is little to stop the resulting vacuum filling with ever more ramped up versions of the same. Edited by BlueJay (05 Sep 2021 5.51am) It's valid to make criticisms of anyone and Mark Collet is no different. What I would say is that you characterise his views as if you know them. Yet I suspect you read those from some write up opposed to him rather than actually heard them. If accurate I certainly don't support what you wrote. How accurate is your description? Does Collet get an opportunity to respond to these descriptions? No he doesn't. Would you like an opportunity to put these to Mark Collet himself? I doubt it....but you're happy to write it. Also, PA were described as a terrorist organisation. It's not good enough to play shifting sands and talk about 'a few degrees', because its current leader has views you disagree with. No, PA are very clear....they don't support violence in pursuit of political aims. Also, let it also be clear, what you wrote are not the positions of PA. False impressions should not be allowed to stand. The manifesto is what they stand on. I've also said several times, I don't support PA because of Mark Collet, I support it and several others because of their stated aims., which aren't what you wrote Just like millions voted Labour without that being a vote for Corbyn Also, If you want to talk about PA make a PA thread. I wonder just why that is? Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Sep 2021 11.02am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It's valid to make criticisms of anyone and Mark Collet is no different. What I would say is that you characterise his views as if you know them. Yet I suspect you read those from some write up opposed to him rather than actually heard them. If accurate I certainly don't support what you wrote. How accurate is your description? Does Collet get an opportunity to respond to these descriptions? No he doesn't. Would you like an opportunity to put these to Mark Collet himself? I doubt it....but you're happy to write it. Also, PA were described as a terrorist organisation. It's not good enough to play shifting sands and talk about 'a few degrees', because its current leader has views you disagree with. No, PA are very clear....they don't support violence in pursuit of political aims. Also, let it also be clear, what you wrote are not the positions of PA. False impressions should not be allowed to stand. The manifesto is what they stand on. I've also said several times, I don't support PA because of Mark Collet, I support it and several others because of their stated aims., which aren't what you wrote Just like millions voted Labour without that being a vote for Corbyn Also, If you want to talk about PA make a PA thread. I wonder just why that is? Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Sep 2021 11.02am) The taliban tried pulling the same PR stunt. My objection with the far left, is that they enable the far right. When the far left lose an argument, they label people racist (why this thread started). Which is partly what the silent majority don't bother engaging them. The far right are much much worse. They are genuinely racists. When they've been exposed, they simply label everyone as a lefty. They claim to be "silent majority" but aren't. They use cracks in use looney left views as a foot in the door to recruit. They constantly make disingenuous claims that they don't want harm to come to people, but the reason for their existence is to strip people of their rights based on the race, believes, or sexuality. This is why the silent majority don't bother engaging with them either.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.