You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Cummings turns on Boris.
November 21 2026 10.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cummings turns on Boris.


Page 11 of 14 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
CrazyBadger Flag Ware 27 May 21 2.10pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

No point in debating with you if you don't take evidence into account.

The plan was in place. It was found lacking in 2016. Many areas of weakness weren't addressed. The plan was then poorly implemented, partially due to Ministry weaknesses which were pointed out in Exercise Cygnet.

This the same plan, that "Before the pandemic we were assessed as in a better position than almost any other country to survive a pandemic and cope well"?

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 2.13pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

This the same plan, that "Before the pandemic we were assessed as in a better position than almost any other country to survive a pandemic and cope well"?

No, obviously not. How could a UK plan review itself against international plans

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 2.20pm

Pandemics historically have killed as many people as the wars that have beset this world, yet the resources committed to pandemic prevention and response are a fraction of the resources we commit to security. This paper examines the COVID-19 pandemic of 2020 by analysing the preparedness and responses of the UK, the USA, Germany, and South Korea. We will evidence that the UK and USA lacked the levels of preparedness that global health reports indicated, and that their responses were diametrically opposite of those of Germany and South Korea. We argue that decades of deregulation and privatization due to neoliberal, free-market economics by the UK and USA led to the Great Recession of 2008. This, in turn, led to economic collapse and austerity (increased neoliberalism), which negatively impacted investment in healthcare in the UK and USA. This resulted in very different levels of preparedness and responses by the four countries under the microscope.

[Link]

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 2.21pm

On Oct. 24, 2019—45 days before the world’s first suspected case of COVID-19 was announced—a new “scorecard” was published called the Global Health Security Index. The scorecard ranked countries on how prepared they were to tackle a serious outbreak, based on a range of measures, including how quickly a country was likely to respond and how well its health care system would “treat the sick and protect health workers.” The U.S. was ranked first out of 195 nations, and the U.K. was ranked second.

[Link]

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 27 May 21 2.28pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Just take a look at Exercise Cygnus and its recommendations.

The plan isn't a party issue initially but how the plan is implemented certainly is. And, moreover, making sure each area of the response teams is properly ready is the responsibility of the Minister, no question.

Hypothetical and practical are not the same thing. Knowing about potential problems and being able to realistically fix them are also quite different.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 2.30pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Hypothetical and practical are not the same thing. Knowing about potential problems and being able to realistically fix them are also quite different.

Ah, so basically Ministers aren't responsible for their Departments. Thanks for the clarification.

Or perhaps you are saying four years is too short a time to e.g. replace out of date PPE.

Edited by Mapletree (27 May 2021 2.31pm)

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 27 May 21 2.51pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Pandemics historically have killed as many people as the wars that have beset this world, yet the resources committed to pandemic prevention and response are a fraction of the resources we commit to security. This paper examines the COVID-19 pandemic of 2020 by analysing the preparedness and responses of the UK, the USA, Germany, and South Korea. We will evidence that the UK and USA lacked the levels of preparedness that global health reports indicated, and that their responses were diametrically opposite of those of Germany and South Korea. We argue that decades of deregulation and privatization due to neoliberal, free-market economics by the UK and USA led to the Great Recession of 2008. This, in turn, led to economic collapse and austerity (increased neoliberalism), which negatively impacted investment in healthcare in the UK and USA. This resulted in very different levels of preparedness and responses by the four countries under the microscope.

[Link]

Originally posted by Mapletree

On Oct. 24, 2019—45 days before the world’s first suspected case of COVID-19 was announced—a new “scorecard” was published called the Global Health Security Index. The scorecard ranked countries on how prepared they were to tackle a serious outbreak, based on a range of measures, including how quickly a country was likely to respond and how well its health care system would “treat the sick and protect health workers.” The U.S. was ranked first out of 195 nations, and the U.K. was ranked second.

[Link]

aren't they a little contradictory? We were best prepared, but due to lack of funding, we weren't?

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 2.58pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

aren't they a little contradictory? We were best prepared, but due to lack of funding, we weren't?

The assessment of preparedness takes into account a variety of issues. We should have been in a strong position based on the economy of the country, our approach to crisis management and the healthcare infrastructure, according to an assessment done before the pandemic

In an assessment completed after, it became clear we weren't as ready as we should and could have been. We 'lacked the levels of preparedness that global health reports indicated', i.e. the kind of report referenced from October 2019. And also our responses at the time the pandemic hit were weak due to the 'neo liberalism' that had become ingrained.

We had frittered away our natural advantage and our response was poor once it hit.

Still want to argue the Government did as good a job as could be expected?

 

DanH Flag SW2 27 May 21 3.01pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Hold on. Surely a plan to deal with a Pandemic is not a party issue, neither would it have been written recently. We have known about pandemics for a long time.

You can't blame this government for having no blueprint to fall back on, as much as you would like to.

I’m with you on this bit. It’s neglect going back years. I guess it’s the decision of spending money on something that *might* happen rather than something that *is* happening for any government.

Any large organisation will have a disaster plan in place for any large scale unforeseen events so the fact that there was not one for a global pandemic makes you wonder what else they would be completely ill prepared for.

 

jeeagles Flag 27 May 21 3.20pm

Originally posted by DanH

I’m with you on this bit. It’s neglect going back years. I guess it’s the decision of spending money on something that *might* happen rather than something that *is* happening for any government.

Any large organisation will have a disaster plan in place for any large scale unforeseen events so the fact that there was not one for a global pandemic makes you wonder what else they would be completely ill prepared for.

No government or opposition anywhere in the world had prepared properly for a pandemic.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 3.25pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

No government or opposition anywhere in the world had prepared properly for a pandemic.

Really?

After experiencing a sharp growth in COVID-19 cases early in the pandemic, South Korea rapidly controlled transmission while implementing less stringent national social distancing measures than countries in Europe and the USA. This has led to substantial interest in their “test, trace, isolate” strategy.

[Link]

 

Orange1290 Flag 27 May 21 3.27pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

No government or opposition anywhere in the world had prepared properly for a pandemic.


Sure but some countries had been investing significantly more each year for decades into their health systems. It's also not about the actual amounts but also how that money is spent. From what I've seen much of the money going into the NHS has been siphoned off by consultants and senior management rather that improving the infrastructure of the NHS that touches those that needs its services. Therefore the actual investment is even less than many other countries who have managed to push their investment into actual beds and staff to service those beds.


Edited by Orange1290 (27 May 2021 3.28pm)

 


Pro China, EU & Palestine

Mapletree Flag Croydon 27 May 21 3.38pm

Originally posted by Orange1290


Sure but some countries had been investing significantly more each year for decades into their health systems. It's also not about the actual amounts but also how that money is spent. From what I've seen much of the money going into the NHS has been siphoned off by consultants and senior management rather that improving the infrastructure of the NHS that touches those that needs its services.

Do you have proof of this? For example in comparison with other large healthcare systems such as the US?

It is a stick that proponents of privatisation like to use to beat the NHS. My old employer, a massive US healthcare provider, would do some pretty underhand things to get a toe in the door of the NHS and I am sure has some nice 'relationships' with Government Ministers and their advisors.

Overall the Dept of Health & Social Care spends £212bn per annum. £22.65m of that goes to consultants. This would include IT and data analytics type work. The US spends $50bn on consultants.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 27 May 21 3.40pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Ah, so basically Ministers aren't responsible for their Departments. Thanks for the clarification.

Or perhaps you are saying four years is too short a time to e.g. replace out of date PPE.

Edited by Mapletree (27 May 2021 2.31pm)

More straw man?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 27 May 21 3.48pm

Originally posted by DanH

I’m with you on this bit. It’s neglect going back years. I guess it’s the decision of spending money on something that *might* happen rather than something that *is* happening for any government.

Any large organisation will have a disaster plan in place for any large scale unforeseen events so the fact that there was not one for a global pandemic makes you wonder what else they would be completely ill prepared for.

Everything I would guess. We have a history of being slow to wake up in the West. WW2 is a good example.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 27 May 21 4.02pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

The assessment of preparedness takes into account a variety of issues. We should have been in a strong position based on the economy of the country, our approach to crisis management and the healthcare infrastructure, according to an assessment done before the pandemic

In an assessment completed after, it became clear we weren't as ready as we should and could have been. We 'lacked the levels of preparedness that global health reports indicated', i.e. the kind of report referenced from October 2019. And also our responses at the time the pandemic hit were weak due to the 'neo liberalism' that had become ingrained.

We had frittered away our natural advantage and our response was poor once it hit.

Still want to argue the Government did as good a job as could be expected?

Again, wasn't arguing that we did a good job; or that we did a bad job, more that the blame game is in full flow and that regardless of mistakes or previous decisions made, to say that someone else would have done better is an easy argument, and that's all that seems to happen nowadays. All for holding people to account, but don't kid me that the opposition wouldn't have made similar 'mistakes' too.
They had some very difficult decisions to make, in incredibly difficult circumstances and they made them(whether they were 'correct' or not).

Don't forget that we've come out the other end ahead of nearly everyone else with a fully effective and efficient vaccination program.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 27 May 21 4.21pm

I think Cummins has informed us what we really already suspected anyway.

There are other culprits of course, namely the opposition labour party's complete inability to do anything else but support the government, and the media's concoction of implausible reasons for every Johnson cock-up.

'Boris Johnson's Covid Churchill Moment' springs to mind.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 27 May 21 4.36pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

I think Cummins has informed us what we really already suspected anyway.

There are other culprits of course, namely the opposition labour party's complete inability to do anything else but support the government, and the media's concoction of implausible reasons for every Johnson cock-up.

'Boris Johnson's Covid Churchill Moment' springs to mind.

So now everyone believes Cummins? Interesting

 

The Dolphin Flag 27 May 21 6.00pm

As I see it - politics aside - the PM and his Ministers are not responsible for 30 odd years of cut backs by successive Governments.
They have done a bit of course but from Blair through Cameron beds have been slashed as much as investment in infrastructure.
They all think short term to get re-elected and it is not in the best interests of the country.
The constant of course is the generally useless - but not always - Civil Service who are meant to run everything behind the scenes but regularly fail to do so.
PPE was hardly Hancock's fault.
The fact it wasn't there is the prick who didn't order its fault.
Whoever was in charge would have been hamstrung by previous mistakes and some very poor employees in my opinion.
Did Boris get stuff wrong - bloody right he did - but I defy anyone without the benefit of hindsight to have got it right.
It is really easy to throw brickbats after the event and DC looks a complete arse in my eyes.
Bile and vitriol being the order of the day.


Edited by The Dolphin (27 May 2021 6.02pm)

Edited by The Dolphin (27 May 2021 6.03pm)

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 27 May 21 7.50pm

Originally posted by Orange1290

"In summary, little evidence seems to exist to prove the belief that the NHS is the “envy of the world”, at least if we are talking about the developed world. The UK’s health service surely provides adequate and often excellent care, but many questions remain about whether that care is as good as the standards of our cultural and physical neighbors in Europe and the rest of the world. The author believes that the British public deserves a rational debate about how best to finance, organize and provide healthcare in the UK today.

[Link]

Recently hmg approached the NHS to try to change things for the better. Whether that be less managers or more space, each time it is met with the bma walking around Russel Square with placards saying don't touch our nhs.
Rational debate is not possible I'm afraid.
It gets political as a battle is what the other side want. A shame but how it is.

 

Page 11 of 14 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Cummings turns on Boris.