You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Akshata Murty tax affairs
November 21 2026 9.56pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Akshata Murty tax affairs


Page 11 of 14 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >
Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 17 Apr 22 12.17pm

i see this discussion taking political sides again. divide and conquer , and all that.

I have no political axe to grind. Assigning oneself to any political party ensures you keep the elites in power. It's a distraction from what is actually happening in Governance.

The issue is that a UK resident, major shareholder in several large international companies, has swerved a large tax bill due to diligent accounting. Companies, some of which, got major furlough and monetary assistance from the UK Government.

As a moral judgment, you think someone like that should be swerving taxes ? Especially when their income has so many zero's on the end of it that i could count.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 17 Apr 22 12.41pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

i see this discussion taking political sides again. divide and conquer , and all that.

I have no political axe to grind. Assigning oneself to any political party ensures you keep the elites in power. It's a distraction from what is actually happening in Governance.

The issue is that a UK resident, major shareholder in several large international companies, has swerved a large tax bill due to diligent accounting. Companies, some of which, got major furlough and monetary assistance from the UK Government.

As a moral judgment, you think someone like that should be swerving taxes ? Especially when their income has so many zero's on the end of it that i could count.

Well said. However, I think the issue rather more is that the Chancellor has swerved the tax, a tax for which he is responsible. He and his household are the beneficiaries and intend to be longer term through inheritance tax 'swerving' too.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 18 Apr 22 12.15am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Are you saying an NRI can’t hold property or assets in India?

Well, I'm not saying that, I'm paraphrasing what Nimesh Shah, chief executive of the accountancy firm Blick Rothenberg, said in The Times. Who probably knows a tad more than us about tax affairs. Maybe it's Indian law?

I don't have a link as I read it the hard copy. It was printed a week or two ago. I'm sure you would find it if you wanted to.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 18 Apr 22 12.23am

Originally posted by Mapletree

She will pay uk tax if she is resident in the UK for at least 15 of the 20 tax years immediately before the relevant tax year. I am not aware she will be required to’become’ a British citizen, she will just be taxed on an arising not a remittance basis.

OK, hands up, I meant 'be treated as', not 'become'. My bad.

Whatever, she pays more than you do at the moment, and when she dies, will have paid far, far more into the UK coffers than you, unless she leaves the country.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 18 Apr 22 12.28am

Originally posted by Mapletree

As a non-resident she has no right to NHS services unless she pays for them.

That must be awkward.

Edited by Mapletree (17 Apr 2022 12.17pm)

What? Now, come on, is she a resident or a non-resident? Make your mind up.

You think she didn't go to a private clinic to give birth? And all the ante/post natal treatment? And schooling the kids at fee payiig schools?

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 18 Apr 22 12.33am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

cut

I note that you have no integrity. You make a false statement, you can't back it up, so you ignore the poster.

You are becoming like BJ.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

BlueJay Flag UK 18 Apr 22 1.05am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3714337]

"Vast numbers"? Really? Or just the SJW idiots.

You did indeed quote my posts, but for some reason felt the need to inform me of what you think they mean, instead of what I typed (which is a recurrent theme!).

And now, unsurprisingly, you flounce off again.

Here are your own words:

"Any remittance that she pays is likely more than the average outraged idiot pays. Nobody else really cares."

"If enough of you outraged idiots assemble outside Parliament and protest about the non dom law, it will get changed."

"Life's not fair, but neither are humans. .. Start a movement. Get all your toddler mates to help."


"I didn't call anyone interested in changing anything 'outraged idiots'. I advised the idiots to change the things they are outraged about."

????


Rudi is entirely right. You called tax payers and those protesting who take issue, outraged idiots. Public statement of fact I'm afraid.

The conversation is primarily about how in a two party system, clicking your fingers and removing corruption is far from a formality. It's not an 'SJW' issue, it's systemic and an an extent happens across the political spectrum.


Edited by BlueJay (18 Apr 2022 1.14am)

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 18 Apr 22 1.20am

Originally posted by BlueJay

Here are your own words:

"Any remittance that she pays is likely more than the average outraged idiot pays. Nobody else really cares."

"If enough of you outraged idiots assemble outside Parliament and protest about the non dom law, it will get changed."

"Life's not fair, but neither are humans. .. Start a movement. Get all your toddler mates to help."


"I didn't "call anyone interested in changing anything 'outraged idiots'". I advised the idiots to change the things they are outraged about. "

????


Rudi is entirely right. You called tax payers and those protesting who take issue, outraged idiots. Public statement of fact I'm afraid.

The conversation is primarily about how in a two party system, clicking your fingers and removing corruption is far from a formality. It's not an 'SJW' issue, it's systemic and an an extent happens across the political spectrum.


Where have I mentioned taxpayers? Highlight the word "taxpayer" in any of those statements. Everyone pays tax. But not all taxpayers are outraged idiots. Only you and your chums. Everyone breathes air, why not accuse me of insulting hardworking air breathers.

Where have I called protesters "outraged idiots"? The key phrase is "If enough of you outraged idiots assemble outside Parliament and protest about the non dom law, it will get changed". As in, if the idiots go and protest, they will have done something, instead of being just idiots.

Comprehension really isn't your thing is it.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

BlueJay Flag UK 18 Apr 22 1.29am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3714633]

Where have I mentioned taxpayers? Highlight the word "taxpayer" in any of those statements. Everyone pays tax. But not all taxpayers are outraged idiots. Only you and your chums. Everyone breathes air, why not accuse me of insulting hardworking air breathers.

Where have I called protesters "outraged idiots"? The key phrase is "If enough of you outraged idiots assemble outside Parliament and protest about the non dom law, it will get changed". As in, if the idiots go and protest, they will have done something, instead of being just idiots.

Comprehension really isn't your thing is it.

You say that she likely pays 'more' than 'the average outraged idiot pays', implying that said 'idiots' more than likely pay some tax, hence are tax payers. You're being purposefully disingenuous.

You state that it will be 'outraged idiots' assembling outside parliament. You also call those wishing to start a movement or react in some way 'toddlers'.

You're now saying that they are still in fact idiots in your view, but may also be 'something else'. It's absurd comment, after absurd comment.

There's no point going back and forth on facts.

Edited by BlueJay (18 Apr 2022 1.39am)

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 18 Apr 22 1.56am

Originally posted by BlueJay

You say that she likely pays 'more' than 'the average outraged idiot pays', implying that said 'idiots' more than likely pay some tax, hence are tax payers. You're being purposefully disingenuous.

You state that it will be 'outraged idiots' assembling outside parliament. You also calls those wishing to start a movement or react in some way 'toddlers'.

You're now saying that they are in fact idiots, but may also be 'something else'. It's absurd comment, after absurd comment.

There's no point going back and forth on facts.

Fcuk me! This takes lying to the next level. All of this is in this thread.

I originally said she pays "Not the millions that everyone expects her to pay of course, but far more than Joe Public pays individually." April 11th. You disagreed, and I, basically, called you an outraged idiot. Although, I now realise that it missed you.

I didn't state that anyone would assemble outside Parliament.

I didn't call anyone a toddler. I replied to EverybodyDannsNow on April 14th, as he said a 4 year old could pick apart the idea of 'if it's legal, it's fair' (I have no idea why he thinks that anyone said that), but I suggested his toddler mates might help. He brought up 4 year olds.

So, let's actually set out the facts as they were written. Rather than the revised edition of facts as presented by you.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

BlueJay Flag UK 18 Apr 22 7.23am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3714635]

Fcuk me! This takes lying to the next level. All of this is in this thread.

I originally said she pays "Not the millions that everyone expects her to pay of course, but far more than Joe Public pays individually." April 11th. You disagreed, and I, basically, called you an outraged idiot. Although, I now realise that it missed you.

"Any remittance that she pays is likely more than the average outraged idiot pays. Nobody else really cares."

"If enough of you outraged idiots assemble outside Parliament and protest about the non dom law, it will get changed."

None of that related to one person. You have literally said that people that have a problem with this are outraged idiots, and that it's indicative of who would protest it.

"I didn't state that anyone would assemble outside Parliament."

See above. You're arguing with yourself again.


On this very page you say "if the idiots go and protest, they will have done something, instead of being just idiots." so you're still sweepingly calling people with a view contrary to yours idiots (while simultaneously being affronted that people would accuse you of that). You can't get enough of doing so, and across multiple threads have this ridiculous 'prove that I mean what I've clearly just said' approach.

"I didn't call anyone a toddler"... "I suggested his toddler mates might help. He brought up 4 year olds."

Aka you did call people that.

I don't care what you call people, but you repeatedly come out with this outlandish stuff and are then indignant when any of what you say is quoted back. These coin toss takes with accompanying endless pages of pearl clutching and claims of "lies! misrepresentation!" that follow are a complete waste of time. Post what you're happy with and actually believe - it's a bit late to rewind after the fact.


Edited by BlueJay (18 Apr 2022 5.21pm)

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 18 Apr 22 9.26am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3714627]

OK, hands up, I meant 'be treated as', not 'become'. My bad.

Whatever, she pays more than you do at the moment, and when she dies, will have paid far, far more into the UK coffers than you, unless she leaves the country.

No, she doesn’t pay more than me

As far as I can see she pays no tax. The charge she pays is lower than my tax, even not taking into account NIC.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 18 Apr 22 10.07am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3714629]

I note that you have no integrity. You make a false statement, you can't back it up, so you ignore the poster.

You are becoming like BJ.

What are you drivelling on about now? You post one word from one of my posts and that bilge. You carry on defending and apologising for the Sunaks. We know who the mug is.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 18 Apr 22 10.13am

Shouldn’t really give someone the time of day while they sit there at home calling anyone an idiot for having an opinion or being angry about anything that is blatantly wrong and wrong by design and fine with the person(s) in power using it. I expect he picks up The Daily Mail frothing at the mouth every single morning without fail. But everyone else is an outraged idiot for not accepting the status quo or believing they can change all the unfairness in a century old two party system. Idiot? Ironically THE ranter.

 


COYP

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 18 Apr 22 10.14am

Originally posted by Mapletree

What, in Hong Kong?

She paid the ‘annual charge’ but not tax on her earnings. Do keep up.

Incorrect again, she paid UK tax on her UK earnings in addition to paying a fee for non dom status.

She has UK income from at least one company, Catamaran Ventures UK and paid tax on that.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 18 Apr 22 10.16am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3714628]

What? Now, come on, is she a resident or a non-resident? Make your mind up.

You think she didn't go to a private clinic to give birth? And all the ante/post natal treatment? And schooling the kids at fee payiig schools?

May I suggest you occasionally check facts. Google is your friend

She is indeed resident but not ordinarily resident.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 18 Apr 22 10.27am

Originally posted by HKOwen

Incorrect again, she paid UK tax on her UK earnings in addition to paying a fee for non dom status.

She has UK income from at least one company, Catamaran Ventures UK and paid tax on that.

This is an owner operated private equity company investing in Indian businesses, one of which went bust recently. In the financial accounts I can see no sign of any distribution of earnings.

There is however a loan to the company in Murthy’s name.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 18 Apr 22 10.38am

Originally posted by Mapletree

No, she doesn’t pay more than me

As far as I can see she pays no tax. The charge she pays is lower than my tax, even not taking into account NIC.

It's just another attempt to claim that people are somehow envious or idiotic if they're not high fiving Sunak, and giving a free pass to his wife who is resident here, took advantage of hundred of thousands in furlough cash, and is 'fortunate' enough to gain lucrative government contracts to the tune of tens of millions benefiting both her and her husband. All while avoiding up to £20 million in UK tax by choosing to be non-domiciled, as others continue to pay their way and contribute.

Certainly for someone in Sunak's position the ethics of this can be questioned. People know 'them and us' when they see it from the 'servants of the people', and criticising tax loopholes designed by the rich, for the rich can only be a good thing, no matter if some are angered by opposition to the status quo. Our 'elected representatives' don't need additional encouragement to mug off the average hard working Brit, they need the opposite.

Edited by BlueJay (18 Apr 2022 3.59pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 18 Apr 22 8.49pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

It's just another attempt to claim that people are somehow envious or idiotic if they're not high fiving Sunak, and giving a free pass to his wife who is resident here, took advantage of hundred of thousands in furlough cash, and is 'fortunate' enough to gain lucrative government contracts to the tune of tens of millions benefiting both her and her husband. All while avoiding up to £20 million in UK tax by choosing to be non-domiciled, as others continue to pay their way and contribute.

Certainly for someone in Sunak's position the ethics of this can be questioned. People know 'them and us' when they see it from the 'servants of the people', and criticising tax loopholes designed by the rich, for the rich can only be a good thing, no matter if some are angered by opposition to the status quo. Our 'elected representatives' don't need additional encouragement to mug off the average hard working Brit, they need the opposite.

Edited by BlueJay (18 Apr 2022 3.59pm)

It’s amazing how some have excused this sham. They’ve taken the ‘good on them for being rich’, a view I share, to ‘good on them for taking advantage of their position over us’. It’s frankly weird and I’m done with them until they’re gone. I’ll be spoiling my General Election ballot paper. They’re all on the take from the rest of us. It’s so blatant it’s unbelievable.

 


COYP

BlueJay Flag UK 18 Apr 22 9.21pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It’s amazing how some have excused this sham. They’ve taken the ‘good on them for being rich’, a view I share, to ‘good on them for taking advantage of their position over us’. It’s frankly weird and I’m done with them until they’re gone. I’ll be spoiling my General Election ballot paper. They’re all on the take from the rest of us. It’s so blatant it’s unbelievable.

Yes, it makes a mockery of both those making ends meet, and those thriving who 'genuinely' pay their way into the countries' coffers. We're being mugged off every which way by those we trust to represent us. At least spoiling a ballet makes your feelings known. I'll likely join you as I certainly don't see Con or Lab as supporters of Joe Public at this time.

Edited by BlueJay (18 Apr 2022 9.21pm)

 

Page 11 of 14 < 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Akshata Murty tax affairs