This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Culture is downstream from law. Many people think their attitudes aren't influenced heavily from what they are told is desirable by the media and culture and school system, which itself takes its lead from law, which is decided by elites. If you look at public perceptions on climate change for example, being of an age I can remember when this was regarded as 'kook' territory. Yet, both legal and media, education changes affect and change public opinion....and suddenly what was minority opinion becomes majority. Going to a more controversial example. In sixties America there was strong support for the segregation laws. There was no majority public support for that change, yet the Democrats pushed it through and the culture changed later. Gay 'marriage' is another example of this......It's all part of the myth of Democracy being this organic thing than some imagine it to be. The reality is that the mainstream is an approved pathway laid down from on high, with rewards for being part of that mainstream. The majority adapt to whatever the mores are of the time coming from that. Whatever the age and whatever its attitudes most people fitted right into that because that's normal human nature and how you get on. The counter culture is by definition outside of it and traditionally persecuted. Now what is beneficial to society to a whole and what the motivations are of that age's particular elites are different questions entirely. Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Jun 2022 3.52am) It just isn't! It's decided by those we choose to represent us. If we don't like the law, then we collectively can act to change it. We have the power. That you feel we use that power unwisely, or not at all because too many either disagree with you, or are disinterested, then tough. That doesn't mean there is a bunch of elite people in control. It just means that the majority have decided not to interfere with the way things are. That's their choice. The power is in their hands. Whether they use it, or not. The reality of climate change and the need to do something to stave off its worst consequences has certainly changed. It needed to. The media has played an important role in informing the people and leading them to the position where they understand the imperatives involved. That's to be welcomed, not condemned. This has nothing to do with these mythical elites you and others want to heap all the world's troubles upon. It is to do with leadership, and the ability to convey important information. Social change isn't new. It always takes time to get the majority on board, so again, leadership by example is a positive thing. Making strong, cogent arguments changes attitudes. It has changed mine on many issues over the years, as it has most people, even you I suspect though I doubt you will admit it
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
An election is a poll of opinion as to who should form the Government. No it isn't. Opinion polls have no direct consequences. Elections do. You don't just express an opinion on who you want to represent you. You express a choice. Should your choice be in the majority, that choice gets elected. Even if the choice is not who you chose, they still represent you and make laws on your behalf.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
No it isn't. Opinion polls have no direct consequences. Elections do. You don't just express an opinion on who you want to represent you. You express a choice. Should your choice be in the majority, that choice gets elected. Even if the choice is not who you chose, they still represent you and make laws on your behalf. And that vote is based on an opinion. An election is a poll of those opinions.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
And that vote is based on an opinion. An election is a poll of those opinions. As every choice you make is based on your opinion of what is best, you are arguing semantics for their own sake. An "opinion poll" has another word, apart from just opinion. Taking a poll means collecting opinions. Holding an election means making choices. Of course, I remember the "alternative vote referendum". The MP's did decide that matter for themselves. No referendum in the UK has the force of law. Any held are always consultative, despite what some seem to think. The MPs have the power, the right and the duty, to ignore a referendum result if they believe it to be unwise. They may decide not to use that power, but should events and circumstances so demand, they could. You can argue for reforming the electoral system. That's another debate. What you cannot argue is what we have now is not as I have described it, and to get any reforms achieved means it must be done within the current system.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
It just isn't! It's decided by those we choose to represent us. If we don't like the law, then we collectively can act to change it. We have the power. That you feel we use that power unwisely, or not at all because too many either disagree with you, or are disinterested, then tough. That doesn't mean there is a bunch of elite people in control. It just means that the majority have decided not to interfere with the way things are. That's their choice. The power is in their hands. Whether they use it, or not. The reality of climate change and the need to do something to stave off its worst consequences has certainly changed. It needed to. The media has played an important role in informing the people and leading them to the position where they understand the imperatives involved. That's to be welcomed, not condemned. This has nothing to do with these mythical elites you and others want to heap all the world's troubles upon. It is to do with leadership, and the ability to convey important information. Social change isn't new. It always takes time to get the majority on board, so again, leadership by example is a positive thing. Making strong, cogent arguments changes attitudes. It has changed mine on many issues over the years, as it has most people, even you I suspect though I doubt you will admit it I'm not sure you are correct on this. A tiny number of folk pretty much run everything on a macro level. After a general election, they simply adapt to the new regime and carry on as before. A full on communist revolution would remove most of them, but only to be replaced by another. After the NAZIs were overthrown, the top table was largely hanged but most of those who ran the show under Hitler pretty much continued on in their same roles under Adenauer. I agree, it is not some sinister Hollywood conspiracy rubbish with men in dark suits in secret locations talking like Ming the Merciless. I suspect most of the "elite" do not know each other and are never likely to meet. But I think it impossible to argue that they do not pull the important strings on a macro level. It's just how nature operates.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
I'm not sure you are correct on this. A tiny number of folk pretty much run everything on a macro level. After a general election, they simply adapt to the new regime and carry on as before. A full on communist revolution would remove most of them, but only to be replaced by another. After the NAZIs were overthrown, the top table was largely hanged but most of those who ran the show under Hitler pretty much continued on in their same roles under Adenauer. I agree, it is not some sinister Hollywood conspiracy rubbish with men in dark suits in secret locations talking like Ming the Merciless. I suspect most of the "elite" do not know each other and are never likely to meet. But I think it impossible to argue that they do not pull the important strings on a macro level. It's just how nature operates. If they do, and that's a big "if" which we can leave aside for now, then they do so because that's what the majority of people have chosen. If enough aren't concerned about these issues to the point that they demand change and vote for people who would deliver it, then that's their choice. The power always rests with us. We just need to make the arguments and find the leaders to convince enough others to get what we want.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
If they do, and that's a big "if" which we can leave aside for now, then they do so because that's what the majority of people have chosen. If enough aren't concerned about these issues to the point that they demand change and vote for people who would deliver it, then that's their choice. The power always rests with us. We just need to make the arguments and find the leaders to convince enough others to get what we want. It depends if you are talking about political power, manifestos and the like or those whose decisions truly filter down on your day-to-day. They are not synonymous. Politicians generally enter the fray with grand designs that are eroded and streamed by the realpolitik that the decisions that impact direct on real life are actually made elsewhere. And someone needs to research the point and present an accurate Venn diagram. It would put heated political debate into some perspective.
|
|
| W12 27 Jun 22 2.16pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
If they do, and that's a big "if" which we can leave aside for now, then they do so because that's what the majority of people have chosen. If enough aren't concerned about these issues to the point that they demand change and vote for people who would deliver it, then that's their choice. The power always rests with us. We just need to make the arguments and find the leaders to convince enough others to get what we want. How would I vote to remove the influence of Bill Gates, Ursula von der Leyen, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, Agustín Carstens or Larry Fink? (to name but a few). Your arguments are childish in the extreme.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
As every choice you make is based on your opinion of what is best, you are arguing semantics for their own sake. An "opinion poll" has another word, apart from just opinion. Taking a poll means collecting opinions. Holding an election means making choices. Of course, I remember the "alternative vote referendum". The MP's did decide that matter for themselves. No referendum in the UK has the force of law. Any held are always consultative, despite what some seem to think. The MPs have the power, the right and the duty, to ignore a referendum result if they believe it to be unwise. They may decide not to use that power, but should events and circumstances so demand, they could. You can argue for reforming the electoral system. That's another debate. What you cannot argue is what we have now is not as I have described it, and to get any reforms achieved means it must be done within the current system. How do you suggest we change the electoral system when those affected by it can ignore any opinion they don't like?
|
|
|
Originally posted by W12
How would I vote to remove the influence of Bill Gates, Ursula von der Leyen, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, Agustín Carstens or Larry Fink? (to name but a few). Your arguments are childish in the extreme. Influence rests with many people. Just look at the power people with an active mind, or savvy presentation, can earn big money on the internet these days as "influencers". Would you like to remove them too? Presumably so your "influence" dominates. I'd vote against that. For someone who makes the kind of arguments you do, to call mine "childish" is probably the most ridiculous claim I have read from you. And it has some fierce competition!
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| W12 28 Jun 22 10.59am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Influence rests with many people. Just look at the power people with an active mind, or savvy presentation, can earn big money on the internet these days as "influencers". Would you like to remove them too? Presumably so your "influence" dominates. I'd vote against that. For someone who makes the kind of arguments you do, to call mine "childish" is probably the most ridiculous claim I have read from you. And it has some fierce competition! I'm not talking about people selling eyeliner mate as you well know. You are making equivalence of social media influencers and people who head organisations with real transnational geopolitical power. Disingenuous and childish.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
How do you suggest we change the electoral system when those affected by it can ignore any opinion they don't like? As we are all affected by it, and all subject to the law, I don't get the point you are trying to make. I would certainly like us to change our system to a STV version of PR, which would encourage the growth of a greater number of local parties and independents, and for our MPs to vote with their consciences more often, reducing the power of the whips. Doubtless this would result in many more coalitions, in which compromises would be necessary, but it would also stop any one party dominating for too long and ensure we adopted a middle of the road approach with no big lurches to the left or right. If people knew their vote counted and that there was always someone in their area who shared their views who they could approach, then the current level of cynicism about politics ought to diminish and engagement increase. Getting it done isn't so easy. It's not in the interests of either major party, especially the Tories. However, with every prospect of a hung Parliament after the next GE I would not be surprised if the Lib Dems and the SNP included a move to PR in their manifestos as their price for joining a coalition. We'll see.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by W12
I'm not talking about people selling eyeliner mate as you well know. You are making equivalence of social media influencers and people who head organisations with real transnational geopolitical power. Disingenuous and childish. If you don't think political influencers exist on the internet then you are seriously naive. You have only to follow some links provided on these pages to know that. Organisations exist for good reasons. They need managers to run them. None of that is new. In today's world, we need transnational organisations. The world would be a mess without them. Of course, they need oversight, which is why every country governs itself and none are bound by decisions they don't make themselves. Those who oppose the efforts that the UN and WEF, as examples, are making to stabilise and co-ordinate worldwide responses, are so short-sighted and ignorant it takes my breath away sometimes.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Home or away? Have a good one Stirling. My Euros are on home- but for how long? To be sure to be sure!
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
My Euros are on home- but for how long? To be sure to be sure! With a day trip in to the EU-to see how the other half live!
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
The GOP would overturn the filibuster to impose a national abortion ban if it wins the midterms, ex-RNC chief suggests - [Link] Sounds farfetched on the surface but isn't particularly. The professed intention to leave this to the States has already been put in doubt by several saying how they intend to push for a national aproach. Talk of freedoms and privacy by those would would strip them away from others is hardly a rarity, and you'll see how brazenly little they care about such things when they have the option to act. Let's not forget that McConnell stopped Obama's last Supreme Court nomination for a year in order to allow Trump to fill that vacancy because it was'an election year'. and the voters should have a say. Then 'a week' prior to the 2020 presidential election McConnell installed a Trump court pick. it's all about pushing through their agenda come what may, while dems just endlessly pontificate.
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
My Euros are on home- but for how long? To be sure to be sure! Home in NI obvs!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.