You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > roy out
October 26 2026 1.51pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

roy out


Page 16 of 231 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 >
lefty27 Flag ipswich 18 Oct 20 8.47pm

I’m starting to turn, it’s so dull. I am a bit of the ‘careful what you wish for’ brigade but today was s***, dull, crap, boring, unimaginative and a bit embarrassing. We have to be the worst watch in the league, such dour negative football and yet we have some of the most creative forwards.

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 18 Oct 20 9.06pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Look - I admit I was one of those Roy "be careful what you wish" for supporters..!!

But after today enough is enough - IMO all good things come to an end and I now think we have reached that point.

After the Man U game, I must admit I thought - yeah OK things are progressing..!!

But then after Chelsea where we didn't even give it a go and then again today which was arguably even worse..!!

As I said enough is enough and Roy's "Dire Ball" tactics just ain't good enough and/or acceptable - time to go..!!

We have the talent in the squad but Roy's tactics just don't allow them to express their talent.

We were screaming out today for someone to link attack and defence, but Eze was left on the bench.

The one time we did do Jario put Batsman through and he buried it - but just offside. But that was only once in the whole game.

Just not good enough and that ain't the players it's management and tactics.

I saw SP sitting in the stands, he must have been thinking "what the hell" - I know I would was..!!

Time has come - thanks Roy but it's time to bring in someone that can move us on take us away from "Dire Ball" and allow the squad to show/fulfil it's undoubted talent..!!

One other point showed today that time to give Mitchell a rest and that Ward's time is also run - bring on both PVA and Clyne..!!

At least we didn't lose, but in fairness if I were a Brighton fan I'd be spitting feathers..!!

Come on SP time to act - Dyche or Howe for me..!!

COYP

Had to pop on for the first time in a few years to check current opinion. This nails it for me. Roy will keep us up every year, which is admittedly better than the previous managers who could only do it once. However in our 8th season we surely need to be pushing on. At least have a go. So anyone dynamic please, we have decent enough players.

I also can't understand why Luka, who is surely our most important player, isn't playing, but I imagine you've covered that elsewhere!

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 18 Oct 20 10.20pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Exactly class footballer who can actually pass the ball. Roy to get us safe by NY in comes Howe, you heard it here first!

Could well be.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 18 Oct 20 10.28pm

Originally posted by doombear


They presumably don'd count the Batshuayi effort because he was cms offside.

..from being placed about sixth in the table tonight, very easy to push aside and forget.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 18 Oct 20 10.32pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

So on that basis you believe we are playing to the height of our talents. Doesn’t bode well does it?

why do you always claim to know what another poster is actually meaning. brighton have spent 109 million and couldn't beat a team playing as badly as we did today. brighton are not a very good team considering the cash they have spent.

i am not beating myself up as i've seen worse displays watching palace over the years. people need to chill out a bit.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 18 Oct 20 11.02pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

why do you always claim to know what another poster is actually meaning. brighton have spent 109 million and couldn't beat a team playing as badly as we did today. brighton are not a very good team considering the cash they have spent.

i am not beating myself up as i've seen worse displays watching palace over the years. people need to chill out a bit.

So have I, but not with a team as talented as this one. I think people forget this is the costliest assembled group of players we have ever put onto a football pitch. You wouldn’t believe it after some of our displays and as for today’s match, we were very lucky to get a draw.

 

Knightstar Flag Guildford 18 Oct 20 11.07pm

I agree it was a poor performance but it was still nearly 3 points. Like it or not Roy does get results, even if we end up being a counter-attacking side with low possession. He will keep us in the Premier League and for me that's what matters. What needs to happen for us to progress is new ownership with real money, so we can invest in the club on all fronts. That's the priority for me and then we can seriously aspire to better things. Until then I think Roy remains a good choice.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 19 Oct 20 12.14am

Originally posted by Knightstar

I agree it was a poor performance but it was still nearly 3 points. Like it or not Roy does get results, even if we end up being a counter-attacking side with low possession. He will keep us in the Premier League and for me that's what matters. What needs to happen for us to progress is new ownership with real money, so we can invest in the club on all fronts. That's the priority for me and then we can seriously aspire to better things. Until then I think Roy remains a good choice.

nearly 3 points from a dubious penalty... at home(if that even counts anymore), against our rivals - c'mon no one should accept that, especially when we have 3 20 mil players on the bench...

 


This was once a quality forum....

slubglurge Flag welling 19 Oct 20 8.13am

If we continue this ultra passive approach we will definitely go down

 

slubglurge Flag welling 19 Oct 20 8.16am

Sitting back and waiting for yhe inevitable to happen. That two games running with barely a shot in anger is pathetic and add that to recent defeats at Liverpool Leicester Villa and Wolves with the same approach and you have a recipe for relegation

 

slubglurge Flag welling 19 Oct 20 8.20am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'please go hodgson' by becky

Bring back Big Sam. The football was much better and he got the best out of Benteke

 

gaz1959 Flag Bamford Lancashire 19 Oct 20 8.21am

One thing for sure unless we change our defend defend and defend again we are relying on 3 worst teams or we are going down. Yesterday was embarrassing or do brighton have a much better squad ?

 

Knightstar Flag Guildford 19 Oct 20 8.25am

Everyone is blaming Roy's tactics but the players must also except their share of responsibility. Sky
reported yesterday that we are 20th in the league for number of passes and passing accuracy. On that basis is it any wonder that we struggle? Surely Roy doesn't train them to misspass!

 

EddieMac Flag 19 Oct 20 8.26am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'please go hodgson' by becky

How many Roy OUT threads do we need????

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 19 Oct 20 8.35am

Originally posted by cryrst

Potter gets a tune out of the weed with a squad of a similar quality it pains me to say. You could match the players in ability across both teams.

yet they almost went down & we were safe before lockdown.

be careful what you wish for.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


jeeagles Flag 19 Oct 20 8.55am

Originally posted by Knightstar

Everyone is blaming Roy's tactics but the players must also except their share of responsibility. Sky
reported yesterday that we are 20th in the league for number of passes and passing accuracy. On that basis is it any wonder that we struggle? Surely Roy doesn't train them to misspass!

From what former players have said, Roy's training is based on formation, formation, formation. No individual skill, no set players. Our team rarely loses it's shape. We are difficult to break down and will catch teams on the break here and there.

He also, repeatedly set up with three defensive midfielders that were poor passes last season which constantly put us under pressure. This year he's switched to two, which will make the situation worse. Thankfully Reidewald has finally been given a chance but I still think we need a midfield 3.

It's the same old mistakes from Roy time and time again, there's no sign of us building towards anything, there's no indication that Roy has anything in the locker to turn this around.

When Dunk was sent off yesterday, he did at least look fired up for the game, which is more than I can say of our team.

I'd hope Parish is looking around to see who he can bring in.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 19 Oct 20 9.27am

It is a mad statistic that in (I think) the last 24 games in which we've taken the lead we haven't lost, winning 19 of them. Based on that and a solid points total for 5 games, in which being honest 7 points is probably more than many of us might have expected given the teams we were playing, you should read that paragraph and think 'Wow, what a good job Roy is doing'. But for me it is covering up a worrying trend.

I said throughout last season that if the points dry up people will quickly turn on Roy due to his negative approach, but now I think most of us are getting to the point where even points aren't enough. In the past people would've said that had we won people wouldn't be complaining, but I think even if we had won many of us still would be complaining this time.

We are living through bleak times and many of us have a multitude of worries. The Palace games should be the one highlight of the week but they are actually making me feel worse these days. I know there are bigger things in the world - my wife has been told her cancer has spread and will have to start more chemo next week - but Roy has to understand right now we need something to believe in beyond just grinding out points like a homeless guy w@nking off a monkey to pay for a sandwich. The hard part is, sacking Roy would be like sticking your grandad in a nursing home (in fact that analogy is probably quite literal in this case).

I'm going to hope Steve has a word in Roy's ear to let him know that fans have been calling Dignitas to ask if they take football teams. Who knows, maybe we'll turn Fulham over and Zaha will smile when he scores. Or maybe I'll go back to paying a homeless man to w@nk off a monkey.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 19 Oct 20 9.47am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

It is a mad statistic that in (I think) the last 24 games in which we've taken the lead we haven't lost, winning 19 of them. Based on that and a solid points total for 5 games, in which being honest 7 points is probably more than many of us might have expected given the teams we were playing, you should read that paragraph and think 'Wow, what a good job Roy is doing'. But for me it is covering up a worrying trend.

I said throughout last season that if the points dry up people will quickly turn on Roy due to his negative approach, but now I think most of us are getting to the point where even points aren't enough. In the past people would've said that had we won people wouldn't be complaining, but I think even if we had won many of us still would be complaining this time.

We are living through bleak times and many of us have a multitude of worries. The Palace games should be the one highlight of the week but they are actually making me feel worse these days. I know there are bigger things in the world - my wife has been told her cancer has spread and will have to start more chemo next week - but Roy has to understand right now we need something to believe in beyond just grinding out points like a homeless guy w@nking off a monkey to pay for a sandwich. The hard part is, sacking Roy would be like sticking your grandad in a nursing home (in fact that analogy is probably quite literal in this case).

I'm going to hope Steve has a word in Roy's ear to let him know that fans have been calling Dignitas to ask if they take football teams. Who knows, maybe we'll turn Fulham over and Zaha will smile when he scores. Or maybe I'll go back to paying a homeless man to w@nk off a monkey.

I have remained firmly on the fence with regards to Roy, I would never vehemently defend nor persecute him as I always viewed both arguments as actually quite valid and had yet to take a side.

I have been reluctant to comment so far but reading your post, particularly the bold, I have to admit the pendulum is starting to swing for me and I almost have a feeling of being robbed of watching Palace play the majority of weekends the last few seasons with this being yet another, irrespective of the result. I actually feel less worried about us then I feel perplexed by our performances these days with patience now beginning to strain.

Wishing the best for your wife.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 19 Oct 20 9.55am

Originally posted by jeeagles

From what former players have said, Roy's training is based on formation, formation, formation. No individual skill, no set players. Our team rarely loses it's shape. We are difficult to break down and will catch teams on the break here and there.

He also, repeatedly set up with three defensive midfielders that were poor passes last season which constantly put us under pressure. This year he's switched to two, which will make the situation worse. Thankfully Reidewald has finally been given a chance but I still think we need a midfield 3.

It's the same old mistakes from Roy time and time again, there's no sign of us building towards anything, there's no indication that Roy has anything in the locker to turn this around.

When Dunk was sent off yesterday, he did at least look fired up for the game, which is more than I can say of our team.

I'd hope Parish is looking around to see who he can bring in.


I keep saying I’d bring Eddie Howe in and move Roy upstairs and in a guidance role. I really struggle with this as I love Roy to bits but yesterday, for me, was frankly horrific. We were at home, against our closest rivals and we just sat back. As soon as he took our Striker off and made us even more defensive (if that was even possible) the writing was on the wall. Should have been 3 subs in my view. Benteke up top to hold it up, PVA for Mitchell, switching Zaha to the left and swapping Eze with Schlupp to play him through the middle.

But it’s all about opinions.

Edited by Helmet46 (19 Oct 2020 9.55am)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 19 Oct 20 9.58am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

It is a mad statistic that in (I think) the last 24 games in which we've taken the lead we haven't lost, winning 19 of them. Based on that and a solid points total for 5 games, in which being honest 7 points is probably more than many of us might have expected given the teams we were playing, you should read that paragraph and think 'Wow, what a good job Roy is doing'. But for me it is covering up a worrying trend.

I said throughout last season that if the points dry up people will quickly turn on Roy due to his negative approach, but now I think most of us are getting to the point where even points aren't enough. In the past people would've said that had we won people wouldn't be complaining, but I think even if we had won many of us still would be complaining this time.

We are living through bleak times and many of us have a multitude of worries. The Palace games should be the one highlight of the week but they are actually making me feel worse these days. I know there are bigger things in the world - my wife has been told her cancer has spread and will have to start more chemo next week - but Roy has to understand right now we need something to believe in beyond just grinding out points like a homeless guy w@nking off a monkey to pay for a sandwich. The hard part is, sacking Roy would be like sticking your grandad in a nursing home (in fact that analogy is probably quite literal in this case).

I'm going to hope Steve has a word in Roy's ear to let him know that fans have been calling Dignitas to ask if they take football teams. Who knows, maybe we'll turn Fulham over and Zaha will smile when he scores. Or maybe I'll go back to paying a homeless man to w@nk off a monkey.

Good post TL. A decent balance of both sides of the equation. I feel pretty much the same however my patience ran out about a year ago. I hope your wife's treatment goes well, there are always more important things than football.

 

Page 16 of 231 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > roy out