You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson to stay
November 16 2026 3.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hodgson to stay


Page 16 of 41 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 >
YT Flag Oxford 30 May 23 9.58pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Dont take Roy out of the equation, i am sure he would take a years contract, and i am in the opinion that McCarthy can be groomed to take over the role, at just the time when the youngsters will be ready, its a massive gamble to employ Potter but also his entourage that will come with him.

Last time I looked, he was still signed as a player for Celtic.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 30 May 23 10.00pm

Originally posted by Zaha127

Who would you like as Palace manager? Rodgers, Potter, Cooper or anyone else?

I would like Roy for one final year give him a new RB, midfielder, winger and striker and top 10 can be a possibility. Long term would not mind Kompany or Carrick so if makes sense to give Roy one more year and Kompany/Carrick after a year can be a possibility.

Don't really understand this obsession with 'young' low experience managers, especially when a manager rarely sticks around for 2 years and it's clearly Freedman who calls the shots on transfers - evidenced by us seemingly signing Lerma with no manager in charge.

Ignore the fancy suit and everything that goes with it and Mark Robins' CV makes a total mockery of Carrick's but he doesn't get a mention.

Why would we not go for someone with >10 years' experience? Go for someone who's actually had to deal with a downturn in form and got a side out of it.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 May 23 10.11pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

Don't really understand this obsession with 'young' low experience managers, especially when a manager rarely sticks around for 2 years and it's clearly Freedman who calls the shots on transfers - evidenced by us seemingly signing Lerma with no manager in charge.

Ignore the fancy suit and everything that goes with it and Mark Robins' CV makes a total mockery of Carrick's but he doesn't get a mention.

Why would we not go for someone with >10 years' experience? Go for someone who's actually had to deal with a downturn in form and got a side out of it.

I hold Mark Robins in high regard.
He gained promotion for Coventry from League Two into League One then into the Championship and into the play-offs for a place in the PL.
Coventry had to play home games at Birmingham for a couple of seasons whilst he was at the helm.

Edited by Willo (30 May 2023 11.36pm)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 30 May 23 10.13pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

Don't really understand this obsession with 'young' low experience managers, especially when a manager rarely sticks around for 2 years and it's clearly Freedman who calls the shots on transfers - evidenced by us seemingly signing Lerma with no manager in charge.

Ignore the fancy suit and everything that goes with it and Mark Robins' CV makes a total mockery of Carrick's but he doesn't get a mention.

Why would we not go for someone with >10 years' experience? Go for someone who's actually had to deal with a downturn in form and got a side out of it.

100% with you on this

If it was any normal job, you'd be asking them to tell you about a time when:
You brought through youth
You managed a wantaway star
You progressed a stable team
You were flexible in your system
How you restructured a team after the loss of key players
etc
etc
etc

 

The Dolphin Flag 31 May 23 6.43am

No to Potter, Rogers and co - all failures one way or another.
I have no idea who but would like a younger Manager from lower down the leagues with Roy and Ray to help him through.

 

The Dolphin Flag 31 May 23 6.43am

If Everton ditch Dyche that would do for me - no Roy or Ray required though

 

PJEagle Flag London 31 May 23 6.51am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

If Everton ditch Dyche that would do for me - no Roy or Ray required though

The only manager who hasn't failed Palace is Hodgson. Another season of Roy and Ray, mentoring Paddy would be a good way forward. If not then the two leading candidates would be in my view Cooper if he leaves Forest, or Potter, who did a great job at Brighton and got much better results at Chelsea than Lampard?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 02 Jun 23 9.57am

I remain to be convinced that Hodgson wants a full year. It's one thing to do a rescue job over two and a half months and 10 matches - quite another to do a full season with its constant demands.

Having said that, he may have agreed to be the back-up if Parish can't get someone else in, hence the rumours re Potter. I don't see thatit as Hodgson's nose being put out of joint.

Time, of course, will tell.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 02 Jun 23 10.18am

I don’t get this , keep Roy as a mentor for Paddy. If Paddy needed a mentor he shouldn’t be given the job . Who ever does the job has to be full on, it can’t be someone having their strings pulled by someone else.
All due respect to him , but McCarthy would be a massive risk, his first eight games would amount to a trial for his ability, Palace can not risk that, though it would give Roy thirty games this time to get it sorted.
The league gets better more demanding every season, Palace have improved ,just to appear to stand still in many ways, and that at least must continue, but only someone with some sort of high level track record for dealing with the problems of maintaining a presence in the Premier league should be considered.

Edited by Putitout (02 Jun 2023 10.20am)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 02 Jun 23 10.37am

Originally posted by Putitout

I don’t get this , keep Roy as a mentor for Paddy. If Paddy needed a mentor he shouldn’t be given the job . Who ever does the job has to be full on, it can’t be someone having their strings pulled by someone else.
All due respect to him , but McCarthy would be a massive risk, his first eight games would amount to a trial for his ability, Palace can not risk that, though it would give Roy thirty games this time to get it sorted.
The league gets better more demanding every season, Palace have improved ,just to appear to stand still in many ways, and that at least must continue, but only someone with some sort of high level track record for dealing with the problems of maintaining a presence in the Premier league should be considered.

Edited by Putitout (02 Jun 2023 10.20am)

Agreed. Paddy needs to go elsewhere and gets his training and experience and if he succeeds come back.

There were siren voices on here ages ago about Shaun Derry becoming our manager but hindsight has shown he is more a put the cones out guy not the manager.

 


One more point

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Jun 23 10.48am

Originally posted by Badger11

Agreed. Paddy needs to go elsewhere and gets his training and experience and if he succeeds come back.

There were siren voices on here ages ago about Shaun Derry becoming our manager but hindsight has shown he is more a put the cones out guy not the manager.

Shaun Derry does have managerial experience at both Notts Co and Camb Utd.
Whilst at Notts Co he signed Hayden Mullins from Birmingham.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 02 Jun 23 11.21am

Originally posted by Willo

Shaun Derry does have managerial experience at both Notts Co and Camb Utd.
Whilst at Notts Co he signed Hayden Mullins from Birmingham.

And how did he get on at those clubs? That was my point Willo.

He left us with some saying he should be our manager and did not cover him self in glory where he managed so he is more of an assistant to the manager.

Edited by Badger11 (02 Jun 2023 11.21am)

 


One more point

dreamwaverider Flag London 02 Jun 23 11.25am

Roy would have to be a safe bet with regular health checks. In the last ten games we have been exceptional.
New striker, two wing backs. Lermer. Keep Guehi. Don’t re sign Zaha.

Bring back Banks and Raki Saki.
Try out some more of our youth.

That should give us top 10.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 02 Jun 23 11.39am

Oh and get hold of Jack Clarke. Massive future.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 02 Jun 23 11.40am

Originally posted by Badger11

Agreed. Paddy needs to go elsewhere and gets his training and experience and if he succeeds come back.

There were siren voices on here ages ago about Shaun Derry becoming our manager but hindsight has shown he is more a put the cones out guy not the manager.

Disagree completely, if Roy stays for a year with Ray and Paddy at the end of the season Roy being a truthful and objective man, can access whether after a year of coaching he is up yo it, if Roy dosent stay then no.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Jacey Flag 02 Jun 23 12.04pm

Even if parties agree for Roy to stay for one more year,we will have to face same issues next year.
There are some talented managers out now and we coud do a lot worse than looking at Rogers,Potter or Cooper if he decides cto walk away from Forest.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 02 Jun 23 3.30pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Even if parties agree for Roy to stay for one more year,we will have to face same issues next year.
There are some talented managers out now and we coud do a lot worse than looking at Rogers,Potter or Cooper if he decides cto walk away from Forest.

are you a Brighton Troll ? Brendan Rodgers is a busted flush....his teams can never defend.

we need to stick with Croydon Roy

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

dreamwaverider Flag London 02 Jun 23 3.55pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Even if parties agree for Roy to stay for one more year,we will have to face same issues next year.
There are some talented managers out now and we coud do a lot worse than looking at Rogers,Potter or Cooper if he decides cto walk away from Forest.

There are always talented managers kicking around

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 02 Jun 23 4.29pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

There are always talented managers kicking around

yup, and even more Alan Pardew type managers available for employment.

To employ a Carlo Ancelloti or Maurizio Pochetinno is a very rare thing indeed.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

est1905 Flag 02 Jun 23 5.11pm

Originally posted by Putitout

I don’t get this , keep Roy as a mentor for Paddy. If Paddy needed a mentor he shouldn’t be given the job . Who ever does the job has to be full on, it can’t be someone having their strings pulled by someone else.
All due respect to him , but McCarthy would be a massive risk, his first eight games would amount to a trial for his ability, Palace can not risk that, though it would give Roy thirty games this time to get it sorted.
The league gets better more demanding every season, Palace have improved ,just to appear to stand still in many ways, and that at least must continue, but only someone with some sort of high level track record for dealing with the problems of maintaining a presence in the Premier league should be considered.

Edited by Putitout (02 Jun 2023 10.20am)

This is absolutely right. As I have said many times you do not risk a 100m+ annual income on the abilities of a novice. Mentoring? What complete rubbish. Who ever did that and made a success of it?
If Parish went down that road he'd deserve to be relegated. Trust me all you romantics out there who have an obsession with ex players. Its not going to happen. Lets put a business head on instead of a misty eyed fans one eh?

 

Page 16 of 41 < 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hodgson to stay