You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy IN. Stop scapegoating him!
November 10 2026 10.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy IN. Stop scapegoating him!


Page 17 of 26 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >
AERO Flag 22 Jul 20 6.48pm

That's the worry for Steve parish.We are in the entertainment business.We are certainly not getting value for money.

 

lexmark87 Flag 22 Jul 20 8.40pm

roy should have walked at the end of last season when he realised parish was not going to back him.
thats why i blame him for the mess we are in. a new manager would have insisted on a transfer kitty.
parish gets away with murder with roy at the helm.

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 22 Jul 20 9.17pm

Originally posted by lexmark87

roy should have walked at the end of last season when he realised parish was not going to back him.
thats why i blame him for the mess we are in. a new manager would have insisted on a transfer kitty.
parish gets away with murder with roy at the helm.

Isn't that what has lead to our current predicament? Managers bought in to keep us up but can only do so if they are backed up with a transfer kitty. We now have the legacy of that. The well has run dry. Can't spend what we don't have.

 

jeeagles Flag 23 Jul 20 1.23pm

Originally posted by Mwncisee

Isn't that what has lead to our current predicament? Managers bought in to keep us up but can only do so if they are backed up with a transfer kitty. We now have the legacy of that. The well has run dry. Can't spend what we don't have.

The only manager with a massive net outlay on players was BFS. Roy inherited all those players 6 months later.

I think the issue with between Roy and Parish is clear.

A friend of my flatmate came round last night. She was upset that her boyfriend of quite some time only meets her once a week and won't invest more in their relationship. She keeps giving him one more chance, he agrees to everything then does nothing. She keeps going round for their once a week visit. The worst that can happen for him is that she walks off, and he doesn't like her that much anyway so no bit loss for him. Otherwise, he keeps getting an easy shag every Wednesday without having to lift a finger... she also likes going to Palace matches so I might give cucking her number (although she is quite annoyiong).

Anyway,

Roy keeps keeping us up, which is what Parish wants, he keeps asking for investment, Parish keeps saying no becuase he doesn't really want to invest in Roy. The worst that will happen for Parish is the Roy will walk. He can then bring someone new in knowing he's saved up some cash for transfers to entice a decent manager in. Repeat every couple of years.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 23 Jul 20 2.24pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

The only manager with a massive net outlay on players was BFS. Roy inherited all those players 6 months later.

I think the issue with between Roy and Parish is clear.

A friend of my flatmate came round last night. She was upset that her boyfriend of quite some time only meets her once a week and won't invest more in their relationship. She keeps giving him one more chance, he agrees to everything then does nothing. She keeps going round for their once a week visit. The worst that can happen for him is that she walks off, and he doesn't like her that much anyway so no bit loss for him. Otherwise, he keeps getting an easy shag every Wednesday without having to lift a finger... she also likes going to Palace matches so I might give cucking her number (although she is quite annoyiong).

Anyway,

Roy keeps keeping us up, which is what Parish wants, he keeps asking for investment, Parish keeps saying no becuase he doesn't really want to invest in Roy. The worst that will happen for Parish is the Roy will walk. He can then bring someone new in knowing he's saved up some cash for transfers to entice a decent manager in. Repeat every couple of years.

Parish originally planned to spend in ' cycles ' but has been unable to stick to that in order to keep Palace in the Premier League.

Yours is an interesting theory but I don't think it stacks up. Parish can't legislate for when Roy decides to walk...he may have only recently agreed another 12 months but he could change his mind and then at short notice Parish has to recruit a new manager and free up a transfer kitty which may or may not exist.

Only twice have Palace brought in a group of players in recent times as I recall. The shower of s***e under Holloway and then the signings under Allardyce.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 23 Jul 20 2.31pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Parish originally planned to spend in ' cycles ' but has been unable to stick to that in order to keep Palace in the Premier League.

Yours is an interesting theory but I don't think it stacks up. Parish can't legislate for when Roy decides to walk...he may have only recently agreed another 12 months but he could change his mind and then at short notice Parish has to recruit a new manager and free up a transfer kitty which may or may not exist.

Only twice have Palace brought in a group of players in recent times as I recall. The shower of s***e under Holloway and then the signings under Allardyce.

Maybe Parish is utterly convinced of Roy being true to his word and that he will fulfil his contract regardless of what happens. I don't know his history enough to know whether he has ever walked of his own volition before.

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 23 Jul 20 6.04pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

The only manager with a massive net outlay on players was BFS. Roy inherited all those players 6 months later.

I think the issue with between Roy and Parish is clear.

A friend of my flatmate came round last night. She was upset that her boyfriend of quite some time only meets her once a week and won't invest more in their relationship. She keeps giving him one more chance, he agrees to everything then does nothing. She keeps going round for their once a week visit. The worst that can happen for him is that she walks off, and he doesn't like her that much anyway so no bit loss for him. Otherwise, he keeps getting an easy shag every Wednesday without having to lift a finger... she also likes going to Palace matches so I might give cucking her number (although she is quite annoyiong).

Anyway,

Roy keeps keeping us up, which is what Parish wants, he keeps asking for investment, Parish keeps saying no becuase he doesn't really want to invest in Roy. The worst that will happen for Parish is the Roy will walk. He can then bring someone new in knowing he's saved up some cash for transfers to entice a decent manager in. Repeat every couple of years.

I'd bet every manager is always asking for more than he gets, that's human nature. A bit of a case of Occam's Razor. We haven't spent money because we don't have it.

 

jeeagles Flag 23 Jul 20 8.37pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Maybe Parish is utterly convinced of Roy being true to his word and that he will fulfil his contract regardless of what happens. I don't know his history enough to know whether he has ever walked of his own volition before.

The cycles was a decent plan, but things go wrong and you have to firefight a lot of the time when you are punching above your weight.

Under Pardew I thought we were going for one marquee signing per transfer window. Which also seemed a good stratergy, as long as we built the team around the players we signed.

Roy has never walked. He's said before in previous jobs that he should have resigned but was to arrogant. His words not mine.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Jul 20 11.04pm

There is going to be an end of season discussion regarding the way forward.
A de-brief etc etc and a vision going forward.

Edited by Willo (23 Jul 2020 11.08pm)

 

PatrickA Flag London 24 Jul 20 5.17am

The Mail is running a story today that Hodgson is set for crunch talks about his future.
The story outlines a difference in philosophy between him and some of the hierarchy at the club in terms of recruitment with Hodgson wanting experienced players as opposed to the younger players that the club wish to recruit.
Nothing of real substance in the story and possibly not a revelation to observers of Hodgson’s preference for experience and also the fact he only has a one year contract so youth is not a priority for him.
I don’t believe Hodgson would want to bow out on potentially 8 successive defeats , but if a new manager became available more aligned to the club’s future plans it may not be a surprise if he steps down.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 24 Jul 20 6.48am

Originally posted by PatrickA

The Mail is running a story today that Hodgson is set for crunch talks about his future.
The story outlines a difference in philosophy between him and some of the hierarchy at the club in terms of recruitment with Hodgson wanting experienced players as opposed to the younger players that the club wish to recruit.
Nothing of real substance in the story and possibly not a revelation to observers of Hodgson’s preference for experience and also the fact he only has a one year contract so youth is not a priority for him.
I don’t believe Hodgson would want to bow out on potentially 8 successive defeats , but if a new manager became available more aligned to the club’s future plans it may not be a surprise if he steps down.

Back him or sack him.

 


One more point

southnorwoodhill Flag 24 Jul 20 6.54am

Originally posted by Badger11

Back him or sack him.

Sack him, back the new guy. No more McCarthy and Kouyate types please. Prioritise areas in need, it's not rocket science.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 24 Jul 20 6.55am

Originally posted by PatrickA

The Mail is running a story today that Hodgson is set for crunch talks about his future.
The story outlines a difference in philosophy between him and some of the hierarchy at the club in terms of recruitment with Hodgson wanting experienced players as opposed to the younger players that the club wish to recruit.
Nothing of real substance in the story and possibly not a revelation to observers of Hodgson’s preference for experience and also the fact he only has a one year contract so youth is not a priority for him.
I don’t believe Hodgson would want to bow out on potentially 8 successive defeats , but if a new manager became available more aligned to the club’s future plans it may not be a surprise if he steps down.

That's interesting. That was one of the points I have been making - having a manager on a short term deal hardly lends itself to a policy of driving down the age of the squad by recruiting younger players that the manager won't be there to develop.

Could be nothing in it, but equally it could be a way of parting company without actually having to sack Roy which I think would be a sad ending considering the good he has done over the course of his tenure.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Jul 20 8.15am

I don't have a 'Hotline' to the hierarchy whereby I am in receipt of a running commentary about the latest events at the club but the expectancy has been that Hodgson would be in situ for the start of the season.
To rid Hodgson of his duties is risky for the club given that he has secured survival for 3 seasons.
I really don't believe I was given a 'Bum steer'.

Edited by Willo (24 Jul 2020 9.42am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Jul 20 9.32am

Originally posted by PatrickA

The Mail is running a story today that Hodgson is set for crunch talks about his future.
The story outlines a difference in philosophy between him and some of the hierarchy at the club in terms of recruitment with Hodgson wanting experienced players as opposed to the younger players that the club wish to recruit.
Nothing of real substance in the story and possibly not a revelation to observers of Hodgson’s preference for experience and also the fact he only has a one year contract so youth is not a priority for him.
I don’t believe Hodgson would want to bow out on potentially 8 successive defeats , but if a new manager became available more aligned to the club’s future plans it may not be a surprise if he steps down.

The club have already recruited Nathan Ferguson and we have been scouting Ipswich midfielder Flynn Downes who has been dubbed "Flynedine Zidownes" ! Others as well.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 24 Jul 20 9.55am

Let’s face it the Mail would only have to read these pages to get this story up and running.
It’s hardly a revelation that Palace need experience and youth. Proven ability is what we actually need regardless of age. There is always the possibility of friction , if all Hodgson gets is hopeful kids.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Jul 20 10.13am

Originally posted by Willo

There is going to be an end of season discussion regarding the way forward.
A de-brief etc etc and a vision going forward.

Edited by Willo (23 Jul 2020 11.08pm)


This suggests that there may be disagreement between different parties within the club, so, perhaps, Willo, the Mail may not be too far off beam. Time, of course, will tell. All we can hope is that the discussions will result in an agreed way forward and that all parties will be singing off the proverbial when the new season starts.

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 24 Jul 20 10.51am

Always over a good conspiracy theory so going to put an 'out there' theory forwards. And before I get shot down I know it contray to previous posts and positions I have taken lol.

SP has always liked Dyche and possibly regrets missing the opportunity to get him when he was swayed bt FDB's presentation at interview of a new sexy way of Palace playing with what we had and when that proved to be a fools errand Dyche was then unavailable and we got Roy.

Dyche is now more available than he was due to his falling out of love with the Burnley board over investment. But, problem is SP can't attract Dyche if there is no real war chest. So SP uses the 7 (soon to be defeats in a row to have showdown talks with Roy. Get the signing of a younger player over the line quickly (the first time we have done do in a very very long time) to give the impression the club wants to sign new and exciting young talent and leak to press the club is frustrated the manager is only wanting older experienced players. That then changes the perception of the narrative to the outside world and may con other managers (Dyche) that the club has more going for it than it really does.

Edited by Mwncisee (24 Jul 2020 10.52am)

Edited by Mwncisee (24 Jul 2020 10.52am)

Edited by Mwncisee (24 Jul 2020 10.53am)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Jul 20 11.07am

Conspiracy theories - bring them on! They're more fun than the dross we've been watching for much of the season.

 

PatrickA Flag London 24 Jul 20 11.23am

You would hope the club would already have a managerial plan in place for the new season.
It’s only around 6 weeks away after all.
Perhaps Hodgson was offered a 1 year deal as an ‘insurance policy’ in case we couldn’t get a preferred candidate this summer.
Even though Sorloth, Meyer and Riedewald have not set the world alight when featuring it may be that some at the club question why this is the case.
They could also have a concern that a similar pattern may emerge with young new signings under Hodgson and are questioning whether it’s a risk they want to take.

 

Page 17 of 26 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy IN. Stop scapegoating him!