You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > roy out
October 26 2026 1.52pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

roy out


Page 17 of 231 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >
Skip Flag 19 Oct 20 9.59am

There aren't enough in my opinion. This has taken me back to the Peter Taylor days.


Originally posted by EddieMac

This post has been merged from a topic called 'please go hodgson' by becky

How many Roy OUT threads do we need????

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Oct 20 10.09am

I have reached the stage where I would far rather watch chess on live TV than watch us play our turgid brand of football.

Yesterday was totally and utterly dire and whoever we bring in, the football is the same.I suspect nothing will change whilst Hodgson is at the helm.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Oct 20 10.10am

Palace were set up to play like that from minute one, and it's all looking a bit suspiciously like the end of last season. We'll be in relegation trouble by Xmas and fans will ask how did it come be, we have some good attacking players, why do we cede possession to teams as bad as us? Hodgson is on a downward spiral and I don't think he has anything in the locker to turn it round.
"Hodgson pleased with Eagles defending" - yeah, when plan A is to put the whole team behind the ball from minute one of course you are going to be defending, possession stats are going to be in the low 30%, and attempts on the opposition goal are going to be counted on one hand. Actually none against Chelsea and one against Brighton, a penalty resulting from an obvious dive. Truly pathetic and the writing is on the wall.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 19 Oct 20 10.15am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Good post TL. A decent balance of both sides of the equation. I feel pretty much the same however my patience ran out about a year ago. I hope your wife's treatment goes well, there are always more important things than football.

The very best of luck for your wife's cancer treatment. That IS the only thing that matters

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Oct 20 10.15am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Palace were set up to play like that from minute one, and it's all looking a bit suspiciously like the end of last season. We'll be in relegation trouble by Xmas and fans will ask how did it come be, we have some good attacking players, why do we cede possession to teams as bad as us? Hodgson is on a downward spiral and I don't think he has anything in the locker to turn it round.
"Hodgson pleased with Eagles defending" - yeah, when plan A is to put the whole team behind the ball from minute one of course you are going to be defending, possession stats are going to be in the low 30%, and attempts on the opposition goal are going to be counted on one hand. Actually none against Chelsea and one against Brighton, a penalty resulting from an obvious dive. Truly pathetic and the writing is on the wall.

I wholeheartedly concur.

At home we have played 3 PL games, scored 3 goals, 1 from the penalty spot.Our possession stats in these games :
Southampton 29%, Everton 42% and against Brighton 34%.

I believe that supporters have had enough, there is only so much we can take.

 

Arthur Waite Flag Portsmouth 19 Oct 20 10.16am

Sadly. Hodgson needs to go.

The club has invested in some new additions and they must be wondering what is going on.

We were playing Brighton (our historic rivals) and at home although venue means nothing these days with no crowd. Before the game, Hodgson said that Eze has been bought to play!
Eze didnt play, so what is that about? Is it about Brighton??
Brighton are not a great team- they are ok.
Are Brighton better than Palace? No, because, overall we have better players
Why, then are we set up in this way, almost making a statement that we are playing Real Madrid?
I can understand this strategy and tactics against, say, Liverpool or Man City, as they have better players, but this was Brighton!

As a fan going back to the 1970s, this is not pretty, nor is it attractive and to be blunt, it is embarrassing.

Players like Eze, Zaha, Batsman, must be so frustrated with this style of play EVERY game.

After the game, it was clear that Hodgson was satisfied and made comments that we kept going until the end. By conceding possession 100% of the time, we literally invited Brighton to score and even more so, with the substitutions that he made.

Sadly, Hodgson OUT, ........please

I would like Mr. Parish to act now.

 

Arthur Waite Flag Portsmouth 19 Oct 20 10.23am

Having re read my negative post (which I stand by), it should also be said that Tyrick Mitchell played his heart out, but there were signs of him becoming tired and starting to make errors, because he is young and inexperienced. Why wasn't he substituted, as he has played a lot of games? We don't want him to be burnt out. Other players gave their all, albeit handcuffed in this system like Townsend.

The manager needs to take full responsibility. The players followed instructions.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 19 Oct 20 10.29am

Thanks for the well wishers regarding my wife. The weekend's football should be about escapism from our everyday worries was my point. It should be about more than a desperate clinging on for survival. Whether you are a ST holder, an armchair supporter, or somewhere in between, once a club gets into your blood you can't just walk away from it. Whether it is Roy, the players or both, they need to dig in right now and give back to the fans. I believe we have a group of players capable of more, but you just increasingly start to feel that perhaps Roy doesn't feel the same way. If he can't change then I hope he steps down rather than it turn ugly, as I think his comments re: Zaha may start to turn the dressing room if Wilf doesn't take too kindly to being accused of not doing enough.

Come on Roy, surprise us.

Edited by taylors lovechild (19 Oct 2020 10.30am)

 

jeeagles Flag 19 Oct 20 10.31am

Originally posted by Helmet46


I keep saying I’d bring Eddie Howe in and move Roy upstairs and in a guidance role. I really struggle with this as I love Roy to bits but yesterday, for me, was frankly horrific. We were at home, against our closest rivals and we just sat back. As soon as he took our Striker off and made us even more defensive (if that was even possible) the writing was on the wall. Should have been 3 subs in my view. Benteke up top to hold it up, PVA for Mitchell, switching Zaha to the left and swapping Eze with Schlupp to play him through the middle.

But it’s all about opinions.

Edited by Helmet46 (19 Oct 2020 9.55am)

Why would you reward a failing manager with a cushy job? I see your intention is to try and be respectful, and prephaps two years ago we could have asked Roy to help with a managed transition but we are currently on a run of 2 wins in 13.

No manager worth his salt would accept a role in a job where the old manger is still linguring around.

Not sure if Howe is the right man for the job, but we have an estabilished, experienced, and professional group of players. Even if he doesn't succeed, it's very unlikely we'd get relegated with the squad we have. Worth a punt.

 

Jacey Flag 19 Oct 20 10.32am

Originally posted by Arthur Waite

Sadly. Hodgson needs to go.

The club has invested in some new additions and they must be wondering what is going on.

We were playing Brighton (our historic rivals) and at home although venue means nothing these days with no crowd. Before the game, Hodgson said that Eze has been bought to play!
Eze didnt play, so what is that about? Is it about Brighton??
Brighton are not a great team- they are ok.
Are Brighton better than Palace? No, because, overall we have better players
Why, then are we set up in this way, almost making a statement that we are playing Real Madrid?
I can understand this strategy and tactics against, say, Liverpool or Man City, as they have better players, but this was Brighton!

As a fan going back to the 1970s, this is not pretty, nor is it attractive and to be blunt, it is embarrassing.

Players like Eze, Zaha, Batsman, must be so frustrated with this style of play EVERY game.

After the game, it was clear that Hodgson was satisfied and made comments that we kept going until the end. By conceding possession 100% of the time, we literally invited Brighton to score and even more so, with the substitutions that he made.

Sadly, Hodgson OUT, ........please

I would like Mr. Parish to act now.

Can only agree with you.
As a gesture of respect to Roy,perhaps he should be our Director of Football,assisting and giving advice to any new manager,Eddie Howe,possibly???

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Oct 20 10.37am

Originally posted by Jacey

Can only agree with you.
As a gesture of respect to Roy,perhaps he should be our Director of Football,assisting and giving advice to any new manager,Eddie Howe,possibly???

My understanding is that Eddie Howe wants a break from football. He is probably enjoying life away from the rigours of football management at his abode near Poole Harbour.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 19 Oct 20 10.37am

Originally posted by jeeagles

Why would you reward a failing manager with a cushy job? I see your intention is to try and be respectful, and prephaps two years ago we could have asked Roy to help with a managed transition but we are currently on a run of 2 wins in 13.

No manager worth his salt would accept a role in a job where the old manger is still linguring around.

Not sure if Howe is the right man for the job, but we have an estabilished, experienced, and professional group of players. Even if he doesn't succeed, it's very unlikely we'd get relegated with the squad we have. Worth a punt.

You’re right - it would only be out of respect as Roy doesn’t deserve to be ‘sacked’ but does need to be replaced and perhaps would offer something ‘upstairs.’
I, for example, would never have re-employed Freedman and Roy is worth 10x him (in my opinion).


Edited by Helmet46 (19 Oct 2020 10.40am)

 

Pigglelet Flag Deepest Darkest Sussex 19 Oct 20 10.46am

Originally posted by Jacey

Can only agree with you.
As a gesture of respect to Roy,perhaps he should be our Director of Football,assisting and giving advice to any new manager,Eddie Howe,possibly???

I doubt if any new manager worth his salt would welcome advice from Mr H about how to defend for 90% of the game and I think, as fans, we would want to see a fresh approach too.

 


"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt."
Mark Twain.

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 19 Oct 20 10.54am

Roy's post match interview said it all really. Nothing really wrong. Nearly got all three points.

Is he really unaware of how awful Palace have become?

Stats can be misleading but the stats for Palace tell the story.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

HerneBayPalace Flag Herne Bay 19 Oct 20 10.59am

Last season heading up to a home fixture was a very sad experience, I went as I had a season ticket and had paid for it but I'd probably have rather stayed home. The excitement to watch my team on a Saturday is slowly disappearing.

Sitting in the main stand nearer the WH Lane end, I didn't see a Palace goal at my end all year ! May as well have stayed in the bar until the second half.

3 wins in 14 I think it is, off the back of last season from the restart.

1 shot on target from a penalty against Brighton AT HOME is worse than woeful, it's unforgiveable.

I would admit that within those 14 fixtures, there were some tough fixtures but it is just the way we get beat and the performances.

I didn't even celebrate the penalty yesterday. It was a soft decision and we knew what would happen after, so there wasn't much chance of us putting Brighton to the sword.

Neutrals hate to watch us and if you are the opposition manager, you must think we really are sh*te and a team to be patient with and pick off.

I actually feel sorry for Zaha, what must he think?! It is embarrassing and the players must talk about it in training and in the changing room.

We have a squad that is now capable to finish in the top half, IMO.

Roy is now no longer the answer, but I would suggestion the question is who else would we have?

Steve Parish needs to make a decision soon.

We have Fulham next and if we get beat, surely he has to go?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 19 Oct 20 11.04am

Originally posted by Willo

My understanding is that Eddie Howe wants a break from football. He is probably enjoying life away from the rigours of football management at his abode near Poole Harbour.

I believe he stated he wanted a break until Christmas. Perhaps it is all set up for him to take over in January?

 

Arthur Waite Flag Portsmouth 19 Oct 20 11.15am

Like some others today, I don’t believe Eddie Howe is the answer. Not sure who is, but it needs an new injection of ideas, strategy, tactics, and a platform to allow some skilful, creative footballers to flourish.

Again, I would agree that Hodgson staying on in some capacity would be a wrong move too.

I hope Mr Parish reads this forum so he knows what fans actually think!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Oct 20 11.38am

Originally posted by Eaglehamster

Roy's post match interview said it all really. Nothing really wrong. Nearly got all three points.

Is he really unaware of how awful Palace have become?

Stats can be misleading but the stats for Palace tell the story.

Yep.

 


COYP

nead1 Flag 19 Oct 20 11.41am

Well, if he did, he would know what some fan's think but I am sure he is more than capable of making up his own mind! My thoughts are that some perspective needs to be shown - for sure it was a poor performance from Palace and the inability to do anything much in an attacking sense was really disappointing. Watching on TV, you could sense Brighton would equalise and possibly then get a winner - at least that didn't happen.
There were some positives - the central defensive partnership looked really solid and Riedewald was outstanding in midfield. He showed what he could do last season when he was MOM against Arsenal when playing at left back.
That said, the Chelsea second half and this match were certainly poor but before then, the start had been fine and the football ok. My sense would be to put it down to a "bad day at the office" and move on. Roy and Ray will be more than aware of what needs to be done and I think Palace will both beat Fulham next week and go on a decent run - the fundamentals of a good team are there.
I also suspect he will make a change at left back. Teams have clearly been targeting Mitchell and it showed both yesterday and at Chelsea - the PL is a brutal environment for a young player to learn his trade.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 19 Oct 20 11.53am

Originally posted by Arthur Waite

Like some others today, I don’t believe Eddie Howe is the answer. Not sure who is, but it needs an new injection of ideas, strategy, tactics, and a platform to allow some skilful, creative footballers to flourish.

Again, I would agree that Hodgson staying on in some capacity would be a wrong move too.

I hope Mr Parish reads this forum so he knows what fans actually think!

He used to but sadly I’m not entirely convinced that many chairman really give much of a toss what the fans think, these days.

 

Page 17 of 231 < 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > roy out