This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Nice one.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I don't think anyone has suggested that there isn't a shortage of HGV drivers throughout Europe. The issue is whether Brexit has put us in a worse position relatively to other European countries? If drivers can find plenty of work in their own countries, why come to the UK where they are regarded, at least by some, as unwelcome, and the pay and conditions inferior. Brexit hasn't caused the problem, but it has made finding a solution harder. Imagining there is a pool of suitable labour at home ready and willing to be trained to drive HGV's, with the training facilities already in place, and that this can all be done quickly, is totally unrealistic. We have a short to medium term problem which won't be solved by opening our doors again to the EU. Nor, I suspect, elsewhere. Substantially increasing the training facilities, alongside making the job more attractive, both for the pay and the facilities on offer, will bring a longer-term improvement, but the same can be said for many other areas which are suffering a labour shortage. This won't be solved in my lifetime! We will have to get used to the shortages, empty shelves and closures due to lack of staff. Oh, and Hrolf blaming it all on immigration.
|
|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
Funny how on both the Belgian link-5000 drivers short, and the Irish link-4000 drivers short- they both use gb as an example of how not to do it-100000 drivers short! Oh my oh my, where on earth did it all go wrong Nigel? Boris? Jacob-and nanny? Poland has 60% of the UK population and a driver shortage of 124,000. What would that figure be if all those drivers hadn’t gone home? EU membership hasn’t helped them much.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Is this the one you're on about cryst? You are bang on about the facilities & the problem of the 'nimbys', Pay & working conditions are a major factor along with 'Driver Hours' which an awful lot of people have totally missed & have not even addressed. I have both an 'LGV' & a PCV license tho due to my age am not able to do a re-test as would be required by law. Simply put a driver can work/drive 9hrs a day, 3 times a week & 10hrs twice a week. After 4.5hrs the driver MUST take a break of 45mins. As you can imagine, planning your route to enable that to happen is a nightmare, most drivers take their break wherever they are tipping their load, usually with no facilities to use. Clearly not in my back yard then
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Poland has 60% of the UK population and a driver shortage of 124,000. What would that figure be if all those drivers hadn’t gone home? EU membership hasn’t helped them much. Even using the worst case scenario , they still have a better percentage than us TED! A French friend of mine told me the current joke they are using, "due to the lack of turkeys this christmas , (unless from Poland and Brasil that bojo is begging for), what are the british going to put on their christmas dinner of carrots, parsnips, broccoli and potatoes? Laughing stock!
|
|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
Even using the worst case scenario , they still have a better percentage than us TED! A French friend of mine told me the current joke they are using, "due to the lack of turkeys this christmas , (unless from Poland and Brasil that bojo is begging for), what are the british going to put on their christmas dinner of carrots, parsnips, broccoli and potatoes? Laughing stock! Not sure about that CP - a higher shortage for a lower population?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Not sure about that CP - a higher shortage for a lower population? And chicken tastes nicer than turkey anyway imo.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
And chicken tastes nicer than turkey anyway imo. And turkey gives you wind. I’m still letting fly after last Christmas.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Charming theory Hrolf but not working in practice. Your fellow countrymen will not do the work. And you talk free market but you are the strongest advocate against free movement of labour on this site. And with your views informed by a Britain for the British angle it is a view that ignores the fact that our empire and ongoing wealth would not have occurred without the influx of fresh blood. It is unarguable that we all have pesky foreign blood coursing through our veins including you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Charming theory Hrolf but not working in practice. Your fellow countrymen will not do the work. And you talk free market but you are the strongest advocate against free movement of labour on this site. And with your views informed by a Britain for the British angle it is a view that ignores the fact that our empire and ongoing wealth would not have occurred without the influx of fresh blood. It is unarguable that we all have pesky foreign blood coursing through our veins including you. Yup British workers too good to do the menial jobs let johnny foreigner do them, music to the ears of the big bosses. HGV shortages predate Brexit and whilst it hasn't helped the fault lies with the employers we did not know the full details of the Brexit deal but the government made it very clear early on that post Brexit unskilled labour would not be imported. Any business that relied on unskilled labour should have responded to that instead they did nothing now they are wringing their hands. As for the unemployed the government needs to take action there are jobs and these people should take them until they can find their dream job.
One more point |
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Not sure about that CP - a higher shortage for a lower population? You"re right Ted, Poland are higher, but I think they are the exception, Germany are a lot better off with a 20 million surplus on our population. If we do get long term higher rates for the working man, thats great, but it wasn"t the aim of these in charge, just happening because of the shortage which they didn"t for see. As for turkey, it"s a must have at christmas, compared to chicken, great cold and makes great soup at the end of the festivities!
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Charming theory Hrolf but not working in practice. Your fellow countrymen will not do the work. And you talk free market but you are the strongest advocate against free movement of labour on this site. And with your views informed by a Britain for the British angle it is a view that ignores the fact that our empire and ongoing wealth would not have occurred without the influx of fresh blood. It is unarguable that we all have pesky foreign blood coursing through our veins including you. It's already working. Wages are increasing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
That sounds like lines from Johnson's upcoming keynote speech to the Tory Party conference. The trouble is it is so full of holes, it doesn't have a chance of floating. Other than on a lake of Daily Mail readers. It's cloud-cuckoo-land to imagine we have either a pool of potential British people just waiting for an uplift in pay and conditions to grab these jobs, or that the training resources exist to prepare them if there was. Any improvement arising from this kind of solution is very long term at best, and uncertain for sure. Eventually they may help, as might a shift to rail, where practical, along with technology. We though have immediate problems. How do you think they can be solved?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
You"re right Ted, Poland are higher, but I think they are the exception, Germany are a lot better off with a 20 million surplus on our population. If we do get long term higher rates for the working man, thats great, but it wasn"t the aim of these in charge, just happening because of the shortage which they didn"t for see. As for turkey, it"s a must have at christmas, compared to chicken, great cold and makes great soup at the end of the festivities! The smell of turkey bones being boiled to make soup after several days of eating leftovers in every conceivable way is not one I cherish but Christmas Day day tea of cold turkey, spuds, stuffing, etc, with piccalilli, red cabbage & pickled onions is a happy memory. Turkeys must have been much bigger back then!
|
|
|
The difference between us and Poland is that they can easily draft in foreign workers from one of the other 26 countries in the EU where the shortage is not so bad. That's what makes our situation worse than theirs. It will take a long time to rebalanced the UK economy and there will be a lot of large bumps in the road. Stock up on pasta, flour, bog roll and firewood. At least middle Englanders can participate in their favourite pastime of moaning for a good few years. The Mogg said it would be 50 years. Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Poland has 60% of the UK population and a driver shortage of 124,000. What would that figure be if all those drivers hadn’t gone home? EU membership hasn’t helped them much.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
It's already working. Wages are increasing. And where's the arbitrary cut off point? That's one issue I have with nationalism. If you are descended from the Huguenots you are British. If from 1st generation Latvians you are foreign. If from the 50,000 Poles who settled here after the War..? On the main topic, this is one argument where the tensions are such that I find it hard to make a firm stance. I am still to be convinced that Brexit has done anything but harm to this country and it will get worse. However, the current driver issue has as much to do with increased working conditions from the origin country of former drivers. And you are correct in terms of local wages and working conditions. In fact, you had an unlikely ally this morning on this point from a spokesperson from the TUC (always said you were a lefty!). Low wages and awful working conditions were made possible by this country's lax employment protection and allowed foreign workers to be "exploited". Of course, they did not see it as such as they were happy to work for peanuts as it was twice the peanuts they could get picking cabbages in Romania. Unfortunately, with them gone, the farmers and haulers now have to persuade the British workers to take on the jobs on the same terms and the brits are saying "no". Trouble is, the German Miracle largely existed on Germans (and later Turks) willing to take a cut to work in order to build up to something better. OK they would as they felt lucky just to be alive. However, the current crop of our people seem less inclined to accept those terms, meaning wages rise, inflation rises and businesses at the margin that only survived through "exploitation" going to the wall thereby leading to unemployment or them passing the cost down the chain thus causing further inflation and...
|
|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
Even using the worst case scenario , they still have a better percentage than us TED! A French friend of mine told me the current joke they are using, "due to the lack of turkeys this christmas , (unless from Poland and Brasil that bojo is begging for), what are the british going to put on their christmas dinner of carrots, parsnips, broccoli and potatoes? Laughing stock! I think you mean laughing gravy there CP. Which, to this day, remains the best name for a dog I've ever heard and was the name we gave to our London to Brighton cycling team in 2008. It was the name of Stan Laurel's dog in the 1930 Laurel and Hardy film Laughing Gravy. Just thought I'd mention it......
Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry. |
|
|
Originally posted by martinelliff
The difference between us and Poland is that they can easily draft in foreign workers from one of the other 26 countries in the EU where the shortage is not so bad. That's what makes our situation worse than theirs. It will take a long time to rebalanced the UK economy and there will be a lot of large bumps in the road. Stock up on pasta, flour, bog roll and firewood. At least middle Englanders can participate in their favourite pastime of moaning for a good few years. The Mogg said it would be 50 years. Yes but that doesn’t explain the reasons for driver shortages which are occurring in countries still within the EU so can’t be entirely Brexit related.
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by mezzer
I think you mean laughing gravy there CP. Which, to this day, remains the best name for a dog I've ever heard and was the name we gave to our London to Brighton cycling team in 2008. It was the name of Stan Laurel's dog in the 1930 Laurel and Hardy film Laughing Gravy. Just thought I'd mention it......
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.