This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by palace99
i think Wilf made his decision immediately after the low ball Arsenal and then Everton bids were rejected 4 years ago. I could understand his disappointment with Arsenal (however, offering only £40m and then signing Pepe instead for £72m had nothing to do with Palace), however, Everton FFS. That season he was terrible and pretty much sulked his way through every game. During the next year or so i read he had changed agents 2 or 3 times and at one point signed up with one of the 'mega' agents in order to get a move. None materialised. In the last few years he has knuckled down and his performances have improved, although he is not the player he was 5 or so years ago. I suspect the advice he was given was keep your head down, take your big salary and when you are a bosman the offers will come. I think a 2 year offer from any Champions League club is a no brainer. That Everton flirting was a real insult. f*** me Wilf, you were better then then pricks even then when they weren't in relegation battles. I think he did well to have that summer forgotten by us as I remember a lot of disdain towards him At this point, I've accepted and made my peace with him leaving this summer finally, to the point I'd be a bit disappointed if he didn't. It just feels like the right time while he can still get a club that enables him to do his thing in the CL for a few seasons before the middle East calls. I'm sure we'd find some sort of exciting replacement that won't ever quite live up to what we expect from Wilf (and that's OK) and Ebs and Olise have taken his role as the match winners. We can't put the transition off forever
|
|
|
Originally posted by Daddyorc
Yawn. Thank you for your insightful contribution to this debate
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Thank you for your insightful contribution to this debate Indeed. I think Wilf has always had half an eye on 'bigger things' than Palace which would fit with just about every other footballer currently employed within the game. The likes of Jack Grealish, who I think is an interesting comparison, got their big move early, from his boyhood club who are now in Europe, and had it work out for them whereas for Wilf it did not. I always wonder if Sir Alex would have been a different story for him altogether. Wilf is such a unique player that I think it was always going to be hard for him to integrate seamlessly into another team let alone a 'big' one. The difference at Palace is the team seems almost moulded to accommodate him whereas bigger clubs were highly unlikely to do this. A comparable player is Saint-Maximin for Newcastle who seems to have dropped down their pecking order upon the arrival of major funds and a manager looking to mould a team beyond one tricky winger. It's been a marriage made in heaven for us. We've survived in the PL despite being unable to procure several top level attacking players over the years as we could rely upon Wilf to provide a huge proportion of our attacking threat, which he can do single-handedly. Unfortunately only a team like ours, with limited funds available, would be willing to accommodate a player like Wilf for this purpose. Bigger teams, his desired destination, do not and thus have not looked to. He can help keep a team in the PL but cannot, as no player could, fire a team single-handedly to silverware let alone major success. The 200k p/w at 30, and with us seemingly above the 'just fight for survival' cohort of PL teams now is truly a litmus test the club, fans and Wilf. I'd like to suggest that saying he may not now be worth such a contract can be an opinion existent alongside the acknowledgement of just how monumental he has been for us as a player and his unparalleled contribution to our team over the past 15 years. I would suggest Wilf's desire to move on from Palace is a brutal reality fans have to expect and accept as much as Wilf will have to with the opinion that he may now not be worth that sort of contract and it would not reflect good business for the club.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Jacey
Poor little Wilf,so many offers and options that he needs yet more time to consider them all. Edited by Jacey (14 Jun 2023 10.03pm) sickening? Come on have a word with yourself. A player takes a while to consider his future. Hardly unexpected, hardly a unique situation.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Daddyorc
Yawn. quote=Palace in the Blood;3803102] I am sorry I think it is time for Wilf to go. Yes he has been a major player and to use that much over used phrase a legend but there are many reasons the time has come to say thank you but goodbye. It is madness for a club of our size and finances to pay anyone 200k per week Similarly a player whose star is definitely on the wane be offered a 4 year deal. it is unlikely he will be a first choice starter for more than the first year and then an impact sub? Extending Wilf's contract will have a number of effects Firstly it will restrict the money we can pay new recruits and hence calibre Secondly it restricts the development of our own academy players who may or may not be good enough but they need the oportunity Thirdly Any proposed Wilf replacement will not sign for us The current Wilf hasn't decided is really detrimental to our future. In my view we should withdraw our offer and start to plan for the life without him. Find a player that suits us in terms of age, talent , financial feasability and most important fit to the ethos of Crystal Palace. This may sound harsh but football is harsh. I realise that replacing Wilf is not simple but we are no longer a 1 man team. We need to plan for the future and can not stay rooted in the past. By not moving forward now all we are doing is putting off an inevitable descision for another time when suitable replacements may not be available I tend to agree. And if we could sign say Jack Harrison, I'd take him on modest wages vs a 30yrd Wilf on mega bucks all day. AS always it feels like this window is pivotal. We're got a really exciting nucleus of a team, and a couple of good signings could really help us kick on. As much as I love Wilf, c. 4years on c.200k will end up being a millstone.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
I tend to agree. And if we could sign say Jack Harrison, I'd take him on modest wages vs a 30yrd Wilf on mega bucks all day. AS always it feels like this window is pivotal. We're got a really exciting nucleus of a team, and a couple of good signings could really help us kick on. As much as I love Wilf, c. 4years on c.200k will end up being a millstone. It will be best for Palace and Wilf if he moves on. Unfortunately for Wilf and the club he moves to it won't be easy, as he has a difficult personality
|
|
|
Originally posted by Jacey
Wisdom dictates that the much debated offer of this quite ridiculous salary should be withdrawn immediately. ..blimey you've got two big Crystal balls haven't you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Great way to talk about the guy who has kept us up for ten years. He is out of contract and perfectly entitled to do what he pleases. They are entitled to do that while his contract is still running. It ends 30th June. I get your point but as a grown man of 30 years he should just front up and do an Mbappe and say what his intentions are...he should have done it ages ago. If he wants to go then fvcking go, if he wants to stay, then stay but don't take the piss with wages as that will set a precedent we can't afford. Its all bollox really Edited by HesHereHesThere (16 Jun 2023 3.40pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Jacey
Wisdom dictates that the much debated offer of this quite ridiculous salary should be withdrawn immediately. Correct
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by Palace in the Blood
I am sorry I think it is time for Wilf to go. Yes he has been a major player and to use that much over used phrase a legend but there are many reasons the time has come to say thank you but goodbye. It is madness for a club of our size and finances to pay anyone 200k per week Similarly a player whose star is definitely on the wane be offered a 4 year deal. it is unlikely he will be a first choice starter for more than the first year and then an impact sub? Extending Wilf's contract will have a number of effects Firstly it will restrict the money we can pay new recruits and hence calibre Secondly it restricts the development of our own academy players who may or may not be good enough but they need the oportunity Thirdly Any proposed Wilf replacement will not sign for us The current Wilf hasn't decided is really detrimental to our future. In my view we should withdraw our offer and start to plan for the life without him. Find a player that suits us in terms of age, talent , financial feasability and most important fit to the ethos of Crystal Palace. This may sound harsh but football is harsh. I realise that replacing Wilf is not simple but we are no longer a 1 man team. We need to plan for the future and can not stay rooted in the past. By not moving forward now all we are doing is putting off an inevitable descision for another time when suitable replacements may not be available An absolutely superb post and very much echoing my sentiments.
|
|
|
I think a 2 year deal would be better. He still has somthing left in the tank to offer. Then he can head off to the Saudi leagues
|
|
|
Well, we should all know in less than two weeks.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
In less than 2 weeks, Wilfs contract expires. Right now on 1 July he is out of contract. You answer your own question. He is out of contract. No longer a Palace player and thus not our problem. If we support his rehabilitation only for him to sign on elsewhere when fit I would be a bit miffed!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.