You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Good bye Roy
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Good bye Roy


Page 26 of 36 < 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 >
Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 09 Feb 24 7.58am

Originally posted by DenTyler

I am so fed up with moaning. I have watched all of the press conference now.

I have to say I would love nothing more than Roy to shove mine and all of us bitching about things at the moment down our throats and I really mean that. I would love to see him turn it around and get a good send off at the end of the season.

He seems like a decent bloke and when you hear ex players speak about him, most (if not all) say good things about him.

However the frustration of the stubborn way he is going about things and the utter dross we are having to watch is leading to this weeks toxic posts on here and atmosphere at games. We can't all be wrong and he is really not helping himself (not that he probably cares about that).

It is clear he is here for now and probably until the end of the season. I want to get behind the team again. I want to enjoy the games again I just can't see it happening though.

Mirrors exactly my thinking DenTyler, great post.

I'm trying not to let frustration turn into vitriol and personal attacks on somebody who has previously done the exact job he was employed to do which was keeping our club afloat as a PL outfit. Some gratitude has to exist there.

If a level headed, if not objective, dissatisfaction and concern can be claimed, and the club do not take action, there's a fine line between voicing this and involving yourself in histrionics.

I've never wanted to run CPFC nor have I ever considered myself worthy of managing the first XI. I just want to have something to look forward to throughout the season and cheer on my local club. The opportunity to do that has felt a bit absent recently and doesn't look to be returning any time soon.

Edited by Nicholas91 (09 Feb 2024 7.59am)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

PatrickA Flag London 09 Feb 24 8.24am

I remember hearing Hodgson discussing his approach to his work over the course of a season.
He said he doesn't look at it on a game to game basis, but instead at tranches of 6 or so games at a time.
The presumption is that allows him some sort of objectivity so he can balance off the shocking defeats v Arsenal and Brighton against the 6 points obtained in the home games v Brentford and Sheffield United.
So far over the course of the season we are on just over a point a game which would keep us up.
The real test will be whether be can maintain this return without his better players in forthcoming weeks.
A point here and there, or narrow defeats won't do it.
We will need to beat the likes of Burnley and Luton to offset the likely defeats by Liverpool and Manchester City.
As fans we look at it on game by game basis and think 'he has to win this game or that game' to stay, whereas the club probably take a more rounded look.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Feb 24 8.53am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Mirrors exactly my thinking DenTyler, great post.

I'm trying not to let frustration turn into vitriol and personal attacks on somebody who has previously done the exact job he was employed to do which was keeping our club afloat as a PL outfit. Some gratitude has to exist there.

If a level headed, if not objective, dissatisfaction and concern can be claimed, and the club do not take action, there's a fine line between voicing this and involving yourself in histrionics.

I've never wanted to run CPFC nor have I ever considered myself worthy of managing the first XI. I just want to have something to look forward to throughout the season and cheer on my local club. The opportunity to do that has felt a bit absent recently and doesn't look to be returning any time soon.

Edited by Nicholas91 (09 Feb 2024 7.59am)

We are 'Birds on the same twig' on this matter.

I for one have not looked forward to watching our games for some time due to abject results and the dearth of entertainment.
My dear wife has opined that I have taken leave of my senses making an arduous journey to and from Selhurst Park given my incessant whingeing and fulmination, wearing a face like a thunderclap and unable to bridle my tongue.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 09 Feb 24 9.07am

Originally posted by Willo

We are 'Birds on the same twig' on this matter.

I for one have not looked forward to watching our games for some time due to abject results and the dearth of entertainment.
My dear wife has opined that I have taken leave of my senses making an arduous journey to and from Selhurst Park given my incessant whingeing and fulmination, wearing a face like a thunderclap and unable to bridle my tongue.

I think that's a pretty large twig Willo with many a bird upon it at the moment!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Feb 24 9.25am

Originally posted by Nicholas91


I think that's a pretty large twig Willo with many a bird upon it at the moment!

Many a bird has perched on my 'Branch' (Not large twig) !

Injecting some seriousness into the debate,it is the model of plausibility that the persistent ordure will continue and an abject performance and defeat against Chelsea will increase the calls for the removal of Mr Hodgson.Toxicity could be prevalent on Monday night.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 09 Feb 24 9.44am

Originally posted by Willo

Many a bird has perched on my 'Branch' (Not large twig) !

Injecting some seriousness into the debate,it is the model of plausibility that the persistent ordure will continue and an abject performance and defeat against Chelsea will increase the calls for the removal of Mr Hodgson.Toxicity could be prevalent on Monday night.

I am currently in the state of both fearing and welcoming this scenario.

I don't want to see Roy end in a shambles, suffer any more than necessary or for things to feel rock-bottomish at the club. That's a highly undesirable outcome for me.

Equally however my faith and hope is so low that any catalyst for change does not seem the worst thing in the world.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Therealeaglestilidie Flag 09 Feb 24 9.51am

Highlights from Roy's press conference:

“Furthermore Michael has picked up another serious injury which is absolutely devastating for him, for the club, for everyone really. Strangely enough, it was one of those situations where so many things went wrong that could have gone right, but we don’t have hindsight".

You were 3-0 down in a game that was lost. What did you think he was going to do score 4 goals Roy. You don't need hindsight, every fan who was there or following the game was screaming, no!!

“It was the perfect storm in every respect, but injuries do happen. That is the bottom line. They happened in this game, and now we are trying to seek reasons why exactly could it have happened when it happened, but it could have happened at any time. There is no question of that. He could have come on for five minutes and done that, he could have not come on at all and then done it in the first training session here".

You knew he was struggling and you made the call to risk him at 3-0 down. You are culpable Roy.

“For me, it’s another element of incredible bad luck we have suffered recently".

You make your own luck Roy.

“What do we do? We make sure we get on with it, we make certain we do our best to prepare the team that are there to play, and you hope that some of them are going to come up and show elements of their play that we haven’t seen because they haven’t been given the chance up to now.”

Oh I see Roy we just have to hope that something happens then with players that you have failed to prepare for this moment by integrating them into the team over the past six months.

“Our squad is getting so much smaller and they play in the area where we are missing players,” Hodgson said. “Both [Ahamada and França] have benefitted from time [here].

“They understand more what we are trying to do and their game is constantly improving. Now for them, when they get a chance, they have to really grasp that".

Can you enlighten us all Roy on what exactly you are trying to do tactically as for the love of God I don't think any of us have a clue.

Signs of Gaslighting Behaviour:

Blatant Lies. You know the person is lying.

Deny, Deny, Deny. That's not what I meant. You know what they said.

Using What You Love Against You.

Love and Flattery.

Words Versus Actions.

 


I'm so Palace I don't even know it

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Feb 24 10.15am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I am currently in the state of both fearing and welcoming this scenario.

I don't want to see Roy end in a shambles, suffer any more than necessary or for things to feel rock-bottomish at the club. That's a highly undesirable outcome for me.

Equally however my faith and hope is so low that any catalyst for change does not seem the worst thing in the world.

I can only reiterate that I will not gallivant down the path of apportioning culpability directly against the Board, Steve Parish or Mr Hodgson.

I will however assert that should the club persevere with Mr Hodgson and we are relegated with him at the helm, all hell will break loose, supporters will be boiling steaming and raging, spitting out fury akin to hail from machine gun fire.There will be boiling with enmity hot as a deep-fat fryer.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 09 Feb 24 11.25am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Roy would be best to stop talking in public.

Here is his latest nonsensical comments on BBC website....

Speaking again on Thursday, when looking ahead to Monday's match against Chelsea, Hodgson rejected supporters' claims that Olise already had a physical issue but confirmed he has now suffered a hamstring blow.

"It's devastating for him, for the club, for everybody really," Hodgson said.

"I don't think he was carrying an injury, I think it was more fatigue."

Why can't they admit that collectively they cocked up on various occasions with Olise's complex and serious hamstring injury and attempted recovery. To claim it was fatigue is ludicrous. Based on that comment alone, Roy is a liability to our players welfare. It is quite shocking.

I am out of steam for Roy and his judgement. He needs help.


It's part of the job to speak in public.

He has not said anything which is not valid.

It is very clear the player had no injury but the medical/fitness staff suggested not to play him for the full 90min only 45.

What is the issue?

You really think if he knew he had hamstring issue he would put him on and the player would not care either come on Roy is not that type of person also you cant get away with doing that like you could in old days.

The game he shouldnt have played in was the win against Sheff Utd it was very clear he was not fit yet people wont say that because he was a big part of the win.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 09 Feb 24 12.02pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

It's part of the job to speak in public.

He has not said anything which is not valid.

It is very clear the player had no injury but the medical/fitness staff suggested not to play him for the full 90min only 45.

What is the issue?

You really think if he knew he had hamstring issue he would put him on and the player would not care either come on Roy is not that type of person also you cant get away with doing that like you could in old days.

The game he shouldnt have played in was the win against Sheff Utd it was very clear he was not fit yet people wont say that because he was a big part of the win.

The issue is that anyone watching the game with half a braincell knew that the game was already lost.

To risk our best player is beyond idiotic.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 09 Feb 24 1.48pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

ah yes. We got the best wheelchair squad in any hospital.

the worst we ever had ? that would be a rogues gallery of expensive dross......Shefki Kuqi, Benteke, elderly Edgar Davids....all rubbish.

my point being, the bottom 6 teams in this League have many excellent players. We are barely capable of keeping up with them.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (08 Feb 2024 7.57pm)

That wasn’t your original point at all - you said that we only had 4 or 5 players worthy of wearing the shirt - you didn’t mention injuries as qualification for that remark/assertion.

When I outlined there at least 14 in the current squad - you’ve completely ignored it - and started going on about players from yesteryear..!!

So my question is where is the relevance to your initial point/assertion that only 4 or 5 players in the current squad worthy of wearing the shirt..!!

For clarity - I look it at it totally differently in that I believe we are only 2 or 3 quality additions to the squad - plus a decent Manager who will get the most out of the squad - from being a real force to be reckoned with in the Prem..!!

Which is why if we go down with this squad it will be such a travesty and waste of 11 years of building - when we are on the verge of having a young squad backed up by an excellent academy - that could/will become a Prem force.

Going down would mean we would have to start all over again - would be such a waste - bordering on criminal..!!

COYP

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 09 Feb 24 2.25pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

The issue is that anyone watching the game with half a braincell knew that the game was already lost.

To risk our best player is beyond idiotic.


The game wasn't lost.

A game is not lost until the final whistle.

You should know better being a Palace fan look at the ups and down this club has gone through in a game.

We was 2 down to Man City not to long ago and managed 2-2.

You are throwing around the term risk life is a risk.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 09 Feb 24 2.52pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

The game wasn't lost.

A game is not lost until the final whistle.

You should know better being a Palace fan look at the ups and down this club has gone through in a game.

We was 2 down to Man City not to long ago and managed 2-2.

You are throwing around the term risk life is a risk.

Semantics, the game was lost. You and Roy must be the outliers.

Risk, as in the increased likelihood of a partly injured player re-injuring themselves

Or risk, as in the threat to our survival chances without our best player

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 09 Feb 24 3.19pm

The game was lost at half time.

In terms of the Man City game it was totally different. We were only 1-0 down at half time, and even though City went 2-0 up, that is always said to be a dangerous scoreline because if the opposition pulls 1 back, it's totally different game and that's what happened.

3-0 down at half time, and especially considering the way we played - it was lost.

The fact that the second half was more of balanced affair (ie. 1-1) was probably more because Brighton took their foot off the gas.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 09 Feb 24 4.04pm

Originally posted by Willo

I can only reiterate that I will not gallivant down the path of apportioning culpability directly against the Board, Steve Parish or Mr Hodgson.

I will however assert that should the club persevere with Mr Hodgson and we are relegated with him at the helm, all hell will break loose, supporters will be boiling steaming and raging, spitting out fury akin to hail from machine gun fire.There will be boiling with enmity hot as a deep-fat fryer.

Willo, As an eminent contributor to Homesdale and judging by your recent comments and mood, which may not be as vitriolic as your suggested outcome in the event of relegation above, but nevertheless shows great concern, who would you hold culpable for our recent decline if it's not one of those you refer to in your comment above?

 

Painter Flag Croydon 09 Feb 24 7.36pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Semantics, the game was lost. You and Roy must be the outliers.

Risk, as in the increased likelihood of a partly injured player re-injuring themselves

Or risk, as in the threat to our survival chances without our best player

Was the Crystanbul game lost, same scoreline at halftime.

Roy is taking the blame, but the player knows his own body, he could of said he didnt feel ready to play. End of story nobody would of made him play.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 09 Feb 24 9.02pm

Originally posted by Painter

Was the Crystanbul game lost, same scoreline at halftime.

Roy is taking the blame, but the player knows his own body, he could of said he didnt feel ready to play. End of story nobody would of made him play.

Pretty sure the Liverpool game was 1-0 at half time. Which is a different scenario again.

 

EddieMac Flag 09 Feb 24 10.02pm

Well this thread hasn’t lived up to its title. Roy going no where.

 

Fanofzhiyi Flag Kent 09 Feb 24 10.04pm

Originally posted by Painter

Was the Crystanbul game lost, same scoreline at halftime.

Roy is taking the blame, but the player knows his own body, he could of said he didnt feel ready to play. End of story nobody would of made him play.

The Crystanbul game from my memory we still had very offensive players on the pitch, bolasie, Murray, gayle…..Delaney . There was a strong belief at 3-1 we could get something. The energy was very different against Brighton. Every fibre of my being was screaming at Roy not to do it, especially knowing the fixtures laying ahead of us.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 09 Feb 24 10.20pm

It's inconceivable that alternatives haven't been discussed or approached as there have been so many poor performances and results.

The likelihood is that most aren't prepared to stake their reputation an a squad that's not only over reliant on two players but also lacks balance regarding players able to play on the front foot, show any ability to use their body or put their head on a ball.

Having seen the young lads playing a few times now you can make the argument that they are worth a go based on how poor some of the older players have been but it's a reach to say they're they're hugely talented and being ignored.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (09 Feb 2024 10.21pm)

 

Page 26 of 36 < 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Good bye Roy