You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tax rises needed 'to prevent NHS misery'
November 21 2026 10.42pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tax rises needed 'to prevent NHS misery'


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Midlands Eagle Flag 24 May 18 1.17pm

Originally posted by serial thriller

The people 'contributing next to nothing' are the elderly, whose number is also going up year on year and who are in most need of medical support and social care. How are we supposed to solve that crisis without turning to migration?

There are other ways to contribute apart from paying tax and most pensioners contribute to the economy by spending.

This particular pensioner is still working and paying high levels of both Corporation and Income Tax and tends to spend quite a lot too

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 24 May 18 1.17pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

The simplest way of funding the increase necessary for the NHS to function is simply to scrap brexit.



***GRENADE***

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 24 May 18 1.23pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


***GRENADE***

A soggy fart, more like

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 24 May 18 1.23pm

I think you will find the changing demographics of the country would make a far bigger impact on the costs for a single year than the whole total for any (disputed or unsubstantiated) migrant cost.


In the next 15 years the growth in the number of over 65s will be bigger than that of all persons under 65. It a similar problem as pensions with longevity but this time the illnesses that come with longevity. A person over 65 generally costs the NHS over 3 times as much as someone under 65 years.


The biggest problem is the NHS itself for several reasons (this isn't an all inclusive or exhaustive list):


1 It under sells its on reasearch to pharma's teh buys back at full price.

2 It undertakes unneccesary operations and services, like fertility, and some plastic surgery.

3 It conflates public and private services with teh easier and more profitable services being cherry picked and done by the same individual but for profit outside the NHS.

4 It has no written scope to describe the boundaries of what is avaialble. For example should all citizens of the UK be able to access drugs that cost 40K a month but merely delay death by a few months.

5 Better but more costly surgical procedures etc, saving those which would have died.

5 Post surgery or hospital care, and bed blocking.

6 The dicotomy that it campaigns to increase overall health of the nation costing money, whilst having to deal with more chronic disease related to old age like diabetes, heart conditions or senility; which costs massive amounts of money.

7 Containg supervirus caused by poor drug prescribing, hospital cleaniness etc.

Society needs to decide what it wants and what it is willing to pay for before doing the costings. Costings should be a constraint and not the allowed run up Tsunami-like.

Perhaps we would be better to relax regulations on smoking drinking etc; perhaps the elderly pay more tax.

We need to make decisions first rather than chuck money at a public monolith which many see as so sacred it can not be questioned.

Anyway enough about the NHS lets get back to debating sending the Windrush generation home because they now cost too much.


Edited by pefwin (24 May 2018 1.30pm)

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 24 May 18 1.31pm

Originally posted by serial thriller

Where are the ghettos? Tower Hamlets or Stoke on Trent? Or is it Londonderry, where levels of poverty exceed the previous two even though most immigrants are Irish?

There is a big difference between us and Japan which is that in most of the cases of migration in to our country, migrants are coming from areas where we have extended our political authority. In the case of Commonwealth migrants, that means that many of them are actually citizens, coming from countries like Jamaica where they were British subjects before we even took Ireland.

In the more modern case of the EU, we were one of the earlier entrants who aggressively pushed for the inclusion of Eastern European and Baltic states. This allowed our banks to push tarriff free loans on them (and allowed us to fly for peanuts and get pissed in Krakow, Split etc). Then when their citizens took advantage of free movement the other way, we took their cheap trade but routinely demonized them using some of the oldest cultural stereotypes in the book.

Unless Britain takes some responsibility for our actions abroad we will be condemned to repeat history over and over again. And as im sure you could more eloquently summarise than me, it is the poor on both sides that suffer.

**Correction**

 


Pro USA & Israel

Stirlingsays Flag 24 May 18 1.31pm

Originally posted by pefwin

Anyway enough about the NHS lets get back to debating sending the Windrush generation home because they now cost too much.

Nope, a country doesn't renege upon those who have been here for decades, even though it was a mistake to provide citizenship to them originally. They should have been here on a 'foreign worker' basis.

This country needs to stop running an immigration ponzi scheme on the British tax payer. Our relaxed attitude to immigration has given us a larger problem in regardless to pensioners.

The idea that has been suggested that we can only just carry on importing more and more young foreigners here is an incoherent and illogical argument.

The 'no borders' left who want the minority votes and those sections of the economic right who want cheap labour have selfishly buggered up this country.

The economic right keep quiet while the left just lie and deny.

The answer is in automation and in having guest 'foreign workers' not giving citizenship rights to people to bring in their dependents.

Edited by Stirlingsays (24 May 2018 1.32pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 24 May 18 1.34pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Nope, a country doesn't renege upon those who have been here for decades, even though it was a mistake to provide citizenship to them originally. They should have been here on a 'foreign worker' basis.

This country needs to stop running an immigration ponzi scheme on the British tax payer. Our relaxed attitude to immigration has given us a larger problem in regardless to pensioners.

The idea that has been suggested that we can only just carry on importing more and more young foreigners here is an incoherent and illogical argument.

The 'no borders' left who want the minority votes and those sections of the economic right who want cheap labour have selfishly buggered up this country.

The economic right keep quiet while the left just lie and deny.

The answer is in automation and in having guest 'foreign workers' not giving citizenship rights to people to bring in their dependents.

Edited by Stirlingsays (24 May 2018 1.32pm)


You do realise this a thread about the NHS, you should start a fresh one on immigration.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Stirlingsays Flag 24 May 18 1.39pm

Originally posted by pefwin

You do realise this a thread about the NHS, you should start a fresh one on immigration.

I start enough threads as it is, how about you start one.

No offence meant but the only person I really listen to about evolving threads is the OP as it's their thread. Most long threads take twists and turns.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jeeagles Flag 24 May 18 1.40pm

If all these people want the NHS to have more money then there's nothing stopping them putting their hand in their own pocket and donating. Or, if you are happy to pay more, why don't you just go private?

Whilst I don't have a general issue with immigration, I can't see why we don't make people pay a minimum contribution before accessing services paid through tax. I'm Germany I think you have to live there for 6 years before you are entitled to anything so it's not an EU restriction. Last time my sister in law had a baby literally everyone else on her ward was Eastern European. Maternity care is very expensive and shouldnt be given to people who just want to turn up in the UK for a few years, have a baby, then move back home.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 24 May 18 1.54pm

Seeing as the brilliant NHS seems to be making us all live longer...in turn creating its own issues, why not start a Euthanasia dept to allow those (more often than not most expensive clients) to choose if they wish to no longer be a burden; saving the costs on the public purse but also controlling population rates in the process.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Stirlingsays Flag 24 May 18 1.58pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

Seeing as the brilliant NHS seems to be making us all live longer...in turn creating its own issues, why not start a Euthanasia dept to allow those (more often than not most expensive clients) to choose if they wish to no longer be a burden; saving the costs on the public purse but also controlling population rates in the process.

Better still....lets go full 'Logan's Run'!

Ah...those memories of a young Jenny Agutter.

Oh hang on...I'm 48...perhaps not.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 May 18 2.05pm

Originally posted by pefwin

I think you will find the changing demographics of the country would make a far bigger impact on the costs for a single year than the whole total for any (disputed or unsubstantiated) migrant cost.


In the next 15 years the growth in the number of over 65s will be bigger than that of all persons under 65. It a similar problem as pensions with longevity but this time the illnesses that come with longevity. A person over 65 generally costs the NHS over 3 times as much as someone under 65 years.


The biggest problem is the NHS itself for several reasons (this isn't an all inclusive or exhaustive list):


1 It under sells its on reasearch to pharma's teh buys back at full price.

2 It undertakes unneccesary operations and services, like fertility, and some plastic surgery.

3 It conflates public and private services with teh easier and more profitable services being cherry picked and done by the same individual but for profit outside the NHS.

4 It has no written scope to describe the boundaries of what is avaialble. For example should all citizens of the UK be able to access drugs that cost 40K a month but merely delay death by a few months.

5 Better but more costly surgical procedures etc, saving those which would have died.

5 Post surgery or hospital care, and bed blocking.

6 The dicotomy that it campaigns to increase overall health of the nation costing money, whilst having to deal with more chronic disease related to old age like diabetes, heart conditions or senility; which costs massive amounts of money.

7 Containg supervirus caused by poor drug prescribing, hospital cleaniness etc.

Society needs to decide what it wants and what it is willing to pay for before doing the costings. Costings should be a constraint and not the allowed run up Tsunami-like.

Perhaps we would be better to relax regulations on smoking drinking etc; perhaps the elderly pay more tax.

We need to make decisions first rather than chuck money at a public monolith which many see as so sacred it can not be questioned.

Anyway enough about the NHS lets get back to debating sending the Windrush generation home because they now cost too much.


Edited by pefwin (24 May 2018 1.30pm)

I agree with much of what you say but immigration is a factor whether you or others like it or not. A rapidly rising population must increase pressure on an already struggling service.

 

becky Flag over the moon 24 May 18 2.06pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

No tax on much of their wealth though which is the big problem. That and gold plated pensions, which are being funded by tax and the work of the young. BT etc have to plug their pension deficits by cutting jobs, wages, benefits etc of current staff not the ones who creamed it off the top for years and are now retired.

Also any wealth that is taxed is taxed at a significantly lower rate than income.


I get sick and tired of hearing about these gold plated pensions that we are all supposed to have. It is mainly civil servants, local authority workers and former employees of major companies who have these, and they are very much the minority of pensioners! I have a small annuity, bought and paid for myself and virtually taxed out of existence - and that's the reality for many. many others too.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 24 May 18 2.06pm

Originally posted by pefwin


You do realise this a thread about the NHS, you should start a fresh one on immigration.

There should indeed be a thread on immigration, a catch-all if you like, so S and H can carry on about it 24 hours a day.

So the rest of us could debate on-topic, which often lasts no longer than the opening few posts.

But you know what, they would never go there..........

 

Stirlingsays Flag 24 May 18 2.13pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

There should indeed be a thread on immigration, a catch-all if you like, so S and H can carry on about it 24 hours a day.

So the rest of us could debate on-topic, which often lasts no longer than the opening few posts.

But you know what, they would never go there..........

You do realise you just made a post that wasn't about the NHS.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

cryrst Flag The garden of England 24 May 18 2.16pm

The money wasted on the NHS seems to be on managers and more managers.
I think the reason is this:
When they f##k up they have to pay compo
These managers of managers are there to check double check and triple check to try to avoid the f ups.
Surely this equates to more on salaries and pensions etc than just to pay out any legitimate compo.
And even with all this 'protection' they still have mistakes.
more could go on the frontline care without this policy of trying to protect a potential issue.
I believe many large companies don't have insurance like we would need as it is cheaper to pay claims from their cash reserves than the policy cost.
It doesn't mean you don't fight the cases just that you can't protect against everything.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 24 May 18 2.17pm

Originally posted by becky

I get sick and tired of hearing about these gold plated pensions that we are all supposed to have. It is mainly civil servants, local authority workers and former employees of major companies who have these, and they are very much the minority of pensioners!

My late father had one of these gold plated pensions. He was a senior civil servant and his excellent pension package was in part a consolation for earning less in his 45 year working life than he would have earned in the private sector.

On the other hand my own pension was so small that I commuted it all for cash and had my kitchen rebuilt so for the rest of my life I have to live on my wits and a state pension

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 May 18 2.18pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

You do realise you just made a post that wasn't about the NHS.

You know that people just want to bury their heads in the sand when they make posts like that.

Next, he will be telling us that immigration will have no effect on water supply or road congestion.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 24 May 18 2.19pm

Originally posted by cryrst

The money wasted on the NHS seems to be on managers and more managers.
I think the reason is this:
When they f##k up they have to pay compo

My wife is a nurse in a local hospital and she probably spends one third of her working week in form filling as every slight detail has to be logged in case there is a legal comeback

 

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 24 May 18 2.23pm

Originally posted by becky


I get sick and tired of hearing about these gold plated pensions that we are all supposed to have. It is mainly civil servants, local authority workers and former employees of major companies who have these, and they are very much the minority of pensioners! I have a small annuity, bought and paid for myself and virtually taxed out of existence - and that's the reality for many. many others too.


Oh come on Becks...your a pensioner,you paid in all your working life but not enough...now pay more you cheeky scoundrel,these youngsters are not happy,that you are or will be a burden. You know my view on this...fck em !

 

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tax rises needed 'to prevent NHS misery'