This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Play Eze from start, instill some confidence in him and we have one h..ll of a player.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
I mean who could have predicted this scenario. He a central midfielder, who likes the no10 space. Roy doesn’t play a number10 nor does he like any attacking or creative minded players in central areas, or at all tbh. Qpr fans said do not play him out wide. Odd thing is Eze said after signing he had conversations with Roy about his position before signing. Shame that position is now seemingly the bench. You’ve got to ask why we signed him on the first place. Roy will kill his confidence by making him Townsend mk11. We will not see the best of Eze until Roy’s moved on. Hope Eze has the patience. Eze at QPR mainly played as a No 10 and was afforded the freedom to roam in more central areas. Given that I had seen him play for QPR before he signed for us, I could not see where he could fit into our team and believe I asserted these very sentiments on HOL.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
At the moment Roy seems to make it a straight choice between Eze or Schlupp in the wide left position in a 4 man midfield. Indeed, and having engaged in conversation with supporters outside HOL, this same view was expressed. Eze, Meyer,Camarasa are seemingly just not a fit for Hodgson. I suspect that he would much have preferred to have signed Giroud rather than Batshuayi.Probably would have preferred to have signed the likes of Capoue or Cleverley. Edited by Willo (01 Nov 2020 11.07am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by samprior
My feeling is he'll play his way into the team. He looks an unbelievable talent that and once he does hold down a position we'll all be better off for it. Barring injury I reckon by the WBA game he'll be a key component in the lineup. The only way he’ll get into Roys team is when he has the defensive drills coached into his play. We won’t see the free bird at QPR. He will have that coached out of him. Roy will be showing him videos of Townsend on repeat before he’s allowed a starting place.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
Have a look at the way Villa line up today. There is no reason why we can’t fit all our best attacking players into the team. Schlupp has some uses but we will never progress while he starts. 3-0 down in first half
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
The only way he’ll get into Roys team is when he has the defensive drills coached into his play. We won’t see the free bird at QPR. He will have that coached out of him. Roy will be showing him videos of Townsend on repeat before he’s allowed a starting place. The creative talent that he has can't be coached out of him. Perhaps the position he's asked to play may restrict him though. But as I said a talent like him will find a way in to the team... and if he has to learn a few defensive responsibilities along the way then so be it. It's a lot easier to ve a 'freebird' in a midtable championship team without much pressure on you than it is to perform week in week out in the Prem. Edited by samprior (01 Nov 2020 2.32pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by samprior
The creative talent that he has can't be coached out of him. Perhaps the position he's asked to play may restrict him though. But as I said a talent like him will find a way in to the team... and if he has to learn a few defensive responsibilities along the way then so be it. It's a lot easier to ve a 'freebird' in a midtable championship team without much pressure on you than it is to perform week in week out in the Prem. Edited by samprior (01 Nov 2020 2.32pm) There’s so many examples that disprove that theory e.g Bale at Madrid. I’m pleased you have faith in Roy that he will incorporate a talent like Eze into the team. I certainly do not share the same faith. From the beginning players like camarasa, Meyer, benrahma and Sarr do not fit the mould of players he considers for his philosophy of how the game should be played. It’s actually not about Eze.. it’s about Roy and how he sets the team up. I also believe talent can be coached out of you. If you are coached day in day out in a certain way you stop doing things that come naturally to you. AWB started out as a winger. He had the talent which is why he made it into the youth setup. He was then identified as having certain attributes and he was coached to improve them. As we saw ourselves and is evident at united, whatever talent he had as a forward thinking player seems to have left him.
Edited by MonsterMunch (01 Nov 2020 2.46pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
There’s so many examples that disprove that theory e.g Bale at Madrid. I’m pleased you have faith in Roy that he will incorporate a talent like Eze into the team. I certainly do not share the same faith. From the beginning players like camarasa, Meyer, benrahma and Sarr do not fit the mould of players he considers for his philosophy of how the game should be played. It’s actually not about Eze.. it’s about Roy and how he sets the team up. I also believe talent can be coached out of you. If you are coached day in day out in a certain way you stop doing things that come naturally to you. AWB started out as a winger. He had the talent which is why he made it into the youth setup. He was then identified as having certain attributes and he was coached to improve them. As we saw ourselves and is evident at united, whatever talent he had as a forward thinking player seems to have left him.
Edited by MonsterMunch (01 Nov 2020 2.46pm) AWB wasn't good enough as a winger hence converted very successfully to the good defensive full back that ManU bought. The Palace coaching staff deserve great credit for this, no criticism at all.
|
|
|
Originally posted by rollercoaster
AWB wasn't good enough as a winger hence converted very successfully to the good defensive full back that ManU bought. The Palace coaching staff deserve great credit for this, no criticism at all. Not sure where you drew criticism from for palace converting him to £50m full back...? My point is he was plenty good enough to be picked up by palace as a kid, as a winger.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
I don’t think anybody is disputing Roy’s ability to turn a winger into a full back. The point I was trying to make is that it is abundantly clear Roy will not consider Mavericks, however talented if they cannot also do the defensive work to the required level he demands. It doesn’t matter how creative/influential they are. it’s the shape first then the players second. . It’s not players first and then build the shape around them. Some may argue it’s done him well so far, which is true to a certain extent, however nauseating his football is.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
We’re on the same page about Roy’s preference for team shape over game changing talent. Totally agree
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.