You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Good bye Roy
November 16 2026 3.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Good bye Roy


Page 31 of 36 < 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 >
RichardJP Flag Epsom 14 Feb 24 2.30pm

I definitely want to see the back of Roy and as soon as possible. But maybe it is prudent to wait for the right person to takel us forward into next season. I am a big fan of McKenna and think he'd be a great fit at Palace. Obviously if Ipswich get promotion, he won't be available.

Talk of Southgate is surely ridiculous. Managing the elite from your country is a very different game from managing a football club and Southgate has almost no experience at club level.

As for long ball football, wow. If the ball isn't in your possession, then it's most likely going to end up in the opposition's. Like an awful, wild clearance from goal, unless it's passed accurately, then it's just coming straight back at you. The days of long ball are dead.

 


Glasner’s Glaziers

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 14 Feb 24 2.35pm

This is a tough one for Parish.

Normally, sustained poor results and a dose of fan disquiet do for a manager. In this case, there are other very significant factors.

The big one is injuries and the timing of returns for those players. We know that our performances are far better with Olise and Eze on the field, and perhaps just Eze and Guehi returning will improve things.
Along with that, there seems to be serious doubt about the calibre of any replacement available at this stage of the season and the knock on effect to next season.
Finally, as we are not currently in the relegation zone, there is a level of uncertainty as to how much panic is warranted.

This isn't just a question of Hodgson bad. It is a perfect storm for indecision.

 

pssguy Flag 14 Feb 24 3.11pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

This is a tough one for Parish.

Normally, sustained poor results and a dose of fan disquiet do for a manager. In this case, there are other very significant factors.

The big one is injuries and the timing of returns for those players. We know that our performances are far better with Olise and Eze on the field, and perhaps just Eze and Guehi returning will improve things.
Along with that, there seems to be serious doubt about the calibre of any replacement available at this stage of the season and the knock on effect to next season.
Finally, as we are not currently in the relegation zone, there is a level of uncertainty as to how much panic is warranted.

This isn't just a question of Hodgson bad. It is a perfect storm for indecision.

And there may well be until the end of the season. I suspect the FA are sweating on Everton and Forest's point counts. They will either want a team relegated on point count alone or so well clear that they can apply a defendable points deduction that still keeps them safe. Forest finishing, say, in 17th 3 points ahead of Palace is probably their worst nightmare

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 14 Feb 24 3.27pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

This is a tough one for Parish.

Normally, sustained poor results and a dose of fan disquiet do for a manager. In this case, there are other very significant factors.

The big one is injuries and the timing of returns for those players. We know that our performances are far better with Olise and Eze on the field, and perhaps just Eze and Guehi returning will improve things.
Along with that, there seems to be serious doubt about the calibre of any replacement available at this stage of the season and the knock on effect to next season.
Finally, as we are not currently in the relegation zone, there is a level of uncertainty as to how much panic is warranted.

This isn't just a question of Hodgson bad. It is a perfect storm for indecision.

Although it would appear that a great many would like to see Hodgson gone now, this is a well reasoned post. I don't think Hodgson is going anywhere until the end of the season. It looks like either Parish has someone lined up for next season in mind already, depending on circumstance (PL survival), or he can't attract anyone suitable of note in the here and now to replace Hodgson for the remainder of the season. Hodgson should have gone long before now based on Parish's historical record with other managers.
Understandable really, word does tend to get round in the workplace.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (14 Feb 2024 4.21pm)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 14 Feb 24 3.28pm

Originally posted by RichardJP

I definitely want to see the back of Roy and as soon as possible. But maybe it is prudent to wait for the right person to takel us forward into next season. I am a big fan of McKenna and think he'd be a great fit at Palace. Obviously if Ipswich get promotion, he won't be available.

Talk of Southgate is surely ridiculous. Managing the elite from your country is a very different game from managing a football club and Southgate has almost no experience at club level.

As for long ball football, wow. If the ball isn't in your possession, then it's most likely going to end up in the opposition's. Like an awful, wild clearance from goal, unless it's passed accurately, then it's just coming straight back at you. The days of long ball are dead.

It's possible to be far more direct than we are without it being long ball football as per the eighties. Two things we could do immediately are:

Free kicks: get them straight into the box more or less from wherever they are - except perhaps right in our own half.

Passing out from the back: instead of side to side and backwards, get the ball upfield quicker. We could consider perhaps Munoz, Ayew and Mateta as targets - they need to make the runs.

I believe both would speed up our tempo and reduce the pressing our midfield and defence come under.

One thing that has been annoying me is sideways pass, sideways pass, back pass. The other is free kicks ending up with our keeper with no attacking advantage gained at all. You can't help but feel the shape and system Roy employs isn't working, hasn't worked and needs to change. Hence many calling for a new manager, myself included.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 14 Feb 24 3.35pm

Originally posted by pssguy

And there may well be until the end of the season. I suspect the FA are sweating on Everton and Forest's point counts. They will either want a team relegated on point count alone or so well clear that they can apply a defendable points deduction that still keeps them safe. Forest finishing, say, in 17th 3 points ahead of Palace is probably their worst nightmare

I don't think Everton will be in trouble unless they get a further deduction. It seems unlikely that their current deduction will be overturned but they will stay up regardless.
I suspect that any punishment Forest get will be next season.

Of course, there is the Man City situation. If they were relegated, it would mean only two going down. Sadly, I can't see the FA having the balls to do it.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 14 Feb 24 3.40pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I don't think Everton will be in trouble unless they get a further deduction. It seems unlikely that their current deduction will be overturned but they will stay up regardless.
I suspect that any punishment Forest get will be next season.

Of course, there is the Man City situation. If they were relegated, it would mean only two going down. Sadly, I can't see the FA having the balls to do it.

The FA know if they send Man City down, the Premier is over and Super League will commence. They can see what the Arabs are bringing to the top level. Big bucks. Bloody huge in fact, with plenty more to come. Dont bite the hand that feeds you.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 14 Feb 24 3.43pm

Originally posted by RichardJP

I definitely want to see the back of Roy and as soon as possible. But maybe it is prudent to wait for the right person to takel us forward into next season. I am a big fan of McKenna and think he'd be a great fit at Palace. Obviously if Ipswich get promotion, he won't be available.

Talk of Southgate is surely ridiculous. Managing the elite from your country is a very different game from managing a football club and Southgate has almost no experience at club level.

As for long ball football, wow. If the ball isn't in your possession, then it's most likely going to end up in the opposition's. Like an awful, wild clearance from goal, unless it's passed accurately, then it's just coming straight back at you. The days of long ball are dead.

Totally with you on the management.

With regard to long ball, if they change the offside rule to give the attacker another metre allowance (eg. Onside if any part of the body overlaps a defender body part) well then I could see long balls working again.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 14 Feb 24 3.44pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

The FA know if they send Man City down, the Premier is over and Super League will commence. They can see what the Arabs are bringing to the top level. Big bucks. Bloody huge in fact, with plenty more to come. Dont bite the hand that feeds you.

Why would a league with just 5 super clubs competing for the title be ‘over’?

The Saudi league is already starting to collapse on itself with rubbish attendances and players struggling to settle - I can’t see that being a big thing too much longer.

It takes a lot more than funding to make a great league, and that applies to both the PL and the Saudi league.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 14 Feb 24 3.44pm

If Southgate ends up here I will not be renewing my ST

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 14 Feb 24 3.55pm

Southgate would be a disappointing choice. Let him cut his teeth some place else. Which is admittedly a weird thing to say about an England manager

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 14 Feb 24 4.18pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I don't think Everton will be in trouble unless they get a further deduction. It seems unlikely that their current deduction will be overturned but they will stay up regardless.
I suspect that any punishment Forest get will be next season.

Of course, there is the Man City situation. If they were relegated, it would mean only two going down. Sadly, I can't see the FA having the balls to do it.

You do know they are facing a 2nd charge

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

PatrickA Flag London 14 Feb 24 4.24pm

When people say they expect Hodgson to see out the season as manager, I can see where they are coming from.
However, let's just say we lose at Everton on Monday (which would be no surprise) and then fail to win at home to Burnley, leaving us say a point outside the relegation zone?
Some may say this is unduly negative and pessimistic, but surely Parish will have to have a realistic alternative primed if this occurs (and I don't mean Paddy Mc as caretaker).

 

est1905 Flag 14 Feb 24 4.32pm

Originally posted by Lazy


You are a F+++++g clueless T++++r, who knows F++k all about anything

Thanks for the fanmail. Take it you're not keen on my opinion?


Maybe put an argument up instead of the teenaged uninspired insults.....?

Hmm, thought not.

 

est1905 Flag 14 Feb 24 4.39pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad


You have know idea how the long ball system works, it is about keeping the ball in the opponents half, that is the reason why in Patrick's post Pulis first question is does anyone have a long throw, it is not about elbows and thugs, when the ball goes over the full back he is pressured into giving a throw away, this is why Wimbledon and Coppell's Palace left the grass longer so it wouldn't roll out over the goal line, it was a premeditated system that the big clubs hated, and we had our most successful seasons


Neither do you. You have as much coaching experience as I have. Less from reading your comments.

You seem such a genius that has thought of tactics that no one else has. I wonder why that is?
I'm guessing it is because there is not a chance in hell that your long ball theory would work in the modern game. But we'll never know because there is not a manager on the planet stupid enough to try it these days.
Plus you and people like you talk about Roy Hodgson's style of play being boring, negative and uninspiring. That's your opinion and you are entitled to it. In fact in many ways I dont disagree with you but how much of the ball do you honestly think we would see if we played the Crazy Gang way? The answer is the same as Wimbledon used to. Very little.

 

RichardJP Flag Epsom 14 Feb 24 4.40pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Why would a league with just 5 super clubs competing for the title be ‘over’?

The Saudi league is already starting to collapse on itself with rubbish attendances and players struggling to settle - I can’t see that being a big thing too much longer.

It takes a lot more than funding to make a great league, and that applies to both the PL and the Saudi league.

I absolutely disagree with this.

Having been at the Al-Narrs vs Al-Hilal, Old Firm type derby in November, with a full stadium, the place was rocking and the fans mental.

Then again for the Riyadh Seasonn Cup between Al-Nassr, Al-Halal and Inter Miami.
The 2 Riyadh sides utterly humiliated Inter Miami, in front of packed crowds, even without Ronaldo or Neymar entering the pitch at all. Inter Miami losing 4-3 (a very flattering result for them) then 6-0. Just show's how rubbish the American sides are.

I'm afraid, agree with their business model or not, they're here to stay. However their league is a little like the WSL, with a few decent sides and a huge gap between them and the rest.

 


Glasner’s Glaziers

southnorwoodhill Flag 14 Feb 24 4.40pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

When people say they expect Hodgson to see out the season as manager, I can see where they are coming from.
However, let's just say we lose at Everton on Monday (which would be no surprise) and then fail to win at home to Burnley, leaving us say a point outside the relegation zone?
Some may say this is unduly negative and pessimistic, but surely Parish will have to have a realistic alternative primed if this occurs (and I don't mean Paddy Mc as caretaker).

I think if Parish had someone already lined up then Roy would have been gone by now. Others have gone for less. If the game scenario you suggest becomes reality and the board decides Roy has to go, who else is there at this late stage? Paddy until the end of the season? That's going to be fun...

 

est1905 Flag 14 Feb 24 4.44pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Apparently McKenna doesn't want to join while Ipswich are still in with a shout at promotion.

For me, we should wait until the season is over and then go all in for Edwards of Luton.

We would be a perfect step for him, near the top of his realistic possibilities.

He'd get us playing front foot, physical football but still be pragmatic when needed.

What more can he realistically achieve there?

Thats a pretty good shout. Edwards has done the almost impossible at Luton. As for Mcenna, I think we'd have a chance with him even if they got promotion. Its a choice between an established club with better players and a newly promoted one that is going to be one of the favourites for instant relegation. If thinking of my career I know what I'd choose. Can totally understand why he wants to see through this season with Ipswich though. A promotion looks good on the CV. If he fails its still not the end of the World.

 

est1905 Flag 14 Feb 24 4.54pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

This is a tough one for Parish.

Normally, sustained poor results and a dose of fan disquiet do for a manager. In this case, there are other very significant factors.

The big one is injuries and the timing of returns for those players. We know that our performances are far better with Olise and Eze on the field, and perhaps just Eze and Guehi returning will improve things.
Along with that, there seems to be serious doubt about the calibre of any replacement available at this stage of the season and the knock on effect to next season.
Finally, as we are not currently in the relegation zone, there is a level of uncertainty as to how much panic is warranted.

This isn't just a question of Hodgson bad. It is a perfect storm for indecision.

Good points, I've thought for a while now (with both my brain cells) that waiting till the summer is the right thing to do if the right man is available then. I personally dont rate Cooper at all and the media seem to talk him up because he is free. Seems pretty obvious the owners aren't keen or he'd have been approached by now.
I was told as far back as last summer that Paolo Fonseca was keen and the feeling from Palace was mutual. It may be true, it may not be but I think its quite telling that Fonseca will not be free of his contract with Lille until this summer.

 

KWIL37 Flag Co Tipperary 14 Feb 24 5.03pm

Originally posted by est1905

Thanks for the fanmail. Take it you're not keen on my opinion?


Maybe put an argument up instead of the teenaged uninspired insults.....?

Hmm, thought not.

OMG Are you for real ? have a look at all the petty and juvenile insults you threw at eagleman13 on the Franca’s Opportunity thread who is a long time and much respected member on the HOL site . Pot calling the kettle, you nasty little man you should be ashamed of yourself.

 


This could be heaven or this could be hell .

Page 31 of 36 < 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Good bye Roy