This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Coronavirus (LOCKED)
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Stoke sub normal 11 Sep 20 9.11pm |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Oh well that's me done being a smoker; although the story that smoking helps ward off C19 went quiet. If there were truth I cant see it being highlighted though. Ironically if true it would be a form of homeopathic treatment I suppose. 
You smoke? Really? Killing yourself, and others through passive smoking? And then expect everyone to listen to dubious speculation on 'long covid'? Think about it. If you were really that worried about dying from a lung disease, you might consider quitting the fags!
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers
|
Stirlingsays 11 Sep 20 9.24pm |
|
|
Tips hat.
Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Sep 2020 9.25pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
cryrst The garden of England 11 Sep 20 10.00pm |
|
|
[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3556918]
You smoke? Really? Killing yourself, and others through passive smoking? And then expect everyone to listen to dubious speculation on 'long covid'? Think about it. If you were really that worried about dying from a lung disease, you might consider quitting the fags!
My point wasnt being righteous it was that a report early doors put smoking as a potential resistance to C19. Just that. If it was proved I could welcome you to the club.
|
Eaglecoops CR3 12 Sep 20 9.13am |
|
|
I do find it a little strange Cryrst that you have such strong feelings about the dangers of Covid and yet you smoke, which we all know is the biggest killer of the lot.
Maybe if you could put Covid into the thought process that you have for smoking you might be a little less concerned.
I reckon if you were to list all of the ways you could die and put a percentage chance of it happening to each one, I bet Covid wouldn’t even make the top 10 unless you already have another pre-existing condition.
I don’t wish to be critical of you for smoking because it’s your choice and as an ex smoker myself I know how difficult it is to pack up but I do struggle to reconcile your thinking given smoking would probably be in the top 3 of the above mentioned list.
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 12 Sep 20 1.31pm |
|
|
[Link]
Steve Baker. One of a few currently sticking their head out of the erm, window.
COYP
|
cryrst The garden of England 12 Sep 20 3.20pm |
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I do find it a little strange Cryrst that you have such strong feelings about the dangers of Covid and yet you smoke, which we all know is the biggest killer of the lot.
Maybe if you could put Covid into the thought process that you have for smoking you might be a little less concerned.
I reckon if you were to list all of the ways you could die and put a percentage chance of it happening to each one, I bet Covid wouldn’t even make the top 10 unless you already have another pre-existing condition.
I don’t wish to be critical of you for smoking because it’s your choice and as an ex smoker myself I know how difficult it is to pack up but I do struggle to reconcile your thinking given smoking would probably be in the top 3 of the above mentioned list.
So I cant be worried for others or myself because I smoke.
|
Eaglecoops CR3 12 Sep 20 5.26pm |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
So I cant be worried for others or myself because I smoke.
I don’t recall saying anything about others. I just believe that anyone who smokes doesn’t have a huge regard for their own health given modern evidence as to its dangers.
|
BlueJay UK 12 Sep 20 5.34pm |
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I do find it a little strange Cryrst that you have such strong feelings about the dangers of Covid and yet you smoke, which we all know is the biggest killer of the lot.
Maybe if you could put Covid into the thought process that you have for smoking you might be a little less concerned.
I reckon if you were to list all of the ways you could die and put a percentage chance of it happening to each one, I bet Covid wouldn’t even make the top 10 unless you already have another pre-existing condition.
I don’t wish to be critical of you for smoking because it’s your choice and as an ex smoker myself I know how difficult it is to pack up but I do struggle to reconcile your thinking given smoking would probably be in the top 3 of the above mentioned list.
It's not really a comparable concern. To my view smoking is certainly ill advised, but one of these situations results in something that may impact you after decades, and the other is a virus that either does or doesn't impact you in the moment. As such for those in the most impacted demographics it would make sense to be more immediately concerned by the latter.
Edited by BlueJay (12 Sep 2020 5.36pm)
|
Stirlingsays 12 Sep 20 5.41pm |
|
|
There is no 'may impact' you with smoking for the vast majority....you really need something like the 'Churchill gene' to avoid serious affects and that's a small percent of us.
It will impact your health within weeks depending upon usage level and while it's a bit of a chunky comparison it will definitely kill a far higher percentage of people who smoke than this virus will kill those who catch it.
It's just why the reaction to this has been pure hysteria compared to how we economically react to cancer or heart attacks and strokes.
It's fear of the new...fear over holistic reason.
Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Sep 2020 5.44pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Stoke sub normal 12 Sep 20 7.05pm |
|
Originally posted by cryrst
My point wasnt being righteous it was that a report early doors put smoking as a potential resistance to C19. Just that. If it was proved I could welcome you to the club.
Not sure if you are being flippant here. But let's assume you're not for the time being. Taking up smoking to reduce the chances of getting a virus (that probably won't kill you) is as ludicrous as shutting down the economy to try and stop a virus (that probably won't kill you). The cure is deadlier than the disease.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers
|
Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Stoke sub normal 12 Sep 20 7.14pm |
|
|
By the way, you may have noticed that the media are now reporting positive tests instead of deaths. This is because positive tests are rising. Scary stuff. How about reporting deaths, which aren't rising? Or if they do mention deaths, reporting a low figure with the caveat that they died "witin 28 days of testing positive"? Which means if they die in a car crash, or commit suicide, it's a C-19 death?
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers
|
cryrst The garden of England 12 Sep 20 7.34pm |
|
|
[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3557205]
By the way, you may have noticed that the media are now reporting positive tests instead of deaths. This is because positive tests are rising. Scary stuff. How about reporting deaths, which aren't rising? Or if they do mention deaths, reporting a low figure with the caveat that they died "witin 28 days of testing positive"? Which means if they die in a car crash, or commit suicide, it's a C-19 death?
older people are contracting it at a higher rate now. Close contact is what is spreading it in the home. The family indoors sharing stuff. Crockery, cutlery,towels,cuddles etc. All normal stuff I know but now I think the deaths will rise but only old and underlying health so they would probably be dead soon anyway!
|
Forest Hillbilly in a hidey-hole 12 Sep 20 7.52pm |
|
|
Because all the vulnerable people are already dead ?
Job Done.
You can do what you want with statistics. It's the raw data, and continuity in how it's gathered is the top priority
I disengage, I turn the page.
|
cryrst The garden of England 12 Sep 20 8.11pm |
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
Because all the vulnerable people are already dead ?
Job Done.
You can do what you want with statistics. It's the raw data, and continuity in how it's gathered is the top priority
Strangely that is probably what is being looked into. If, and a big if deaths do not rise substantially then it may well allow a slow return to normality. Long term issues,as posted about are also I would think be getting some observation. If the outcome is minimal deaths and proof of a very low long term problem, very low then that could be enough for boris to call it a day on the restrictions. As it stands the infection numbers are rising so now it's just time which will enable some positive moves forwards. It could be done by xmas or still be here in march.
|
BlueJay UK 13 Sep 20 12.40am |
|
|
Smoking is clearly a big health negative. In fact other than becoming seriously obese, a long term alcoholic or drug addict I can't think of any bad health choice that virals it. My point stands though, that it's chalk and cheese. Smoking is an increasing drag on health over a course of time, most often decades. It's not an overnight disaster one way or the other, nor from any rational perspective is anything substantively negative going to happen to anyone as result of smoking for a period of weeks. That would be a real outlier of outliers.
I agree though that long term smoking will kill a serious percentage of those that partake, far more than covid. The flipside, making direct comparison a bit of a non start is that if covid does impact you very badly, you'll be struggling for your last breath after in 40 days rather than 40 years. One is an issue very much in the here and now, one is a long term health choice.
|
BlueJay UK 13 Sep 20 12.51am |
|
|
[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3557205]
By the way, you may have noticed that the media are now reporting positive tests instead of deaths. This is because positive tests are rising. Scary stuff. How about reporting deaths, which aren't rising
They will of course be rising, hopefully not to the numbers we saw before though. A combination of it already ripping through old folks homes (less to bump off), the weeks long delay in case rises leading to deaths (just as we saw first time around), and the number of cases still no doubt being substantively lower than they were in the first wave (due to testing not being anywhere near as widespread) no doubt all factor in.
My hope would be that we're not having 1000+ a day deaths again. For the reasons stated, and somewhat improved treatments, I think we'll fall short of that. It's worth noting based on the stats in other countries and here first time around, that the situation can change drastically within 5 or 6 weeks, so we perhaps shouldn't get too caught up on the nobody is dying train of thought.
Edited by BlueJay (13 Sep 2020 12.55am)
|
BlueJay UK 13 Sep 20 12.55am |
|
|
Pfizer proposes expansion of late-stage coronavirus vaccine trialPfizer proposes expansion of late-stage coronavirus vaccine trial - [Link]
|
The Dolphin 13 Sep 20 8.10am |
|
|
We are testing more and testing more in hot spot areas as well so positive tests will naturally rise. Hospitalisation and deaths will be the key and with the rise in cases being so recent we will not know the consequences for a week or more yet - that will be the acid test surely? If positive tests don't return dire consequences then maybe we are getting to the situation where the virus can be lived with as such. Let's hope that is the case anyway because we cannot afford full lockdown again!
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 13 Sep 20 8.35am |
|
|
I’ll add that the differences in human interaction in France and Spain compared to Britain will be a factor, especially a lot of older people who will find it easy to postpone hugging etc, contrary to left wing, govt control loving bed wetters and also the younger generation who can’t stop hugging each other as if they’re not going to see each other again for 2 years. I wouldn’t be surprised if our hospitalisations and deaths are much lower per different numbers.
Tourism in particularly Spain might also be a factor and of course you won’t hear their aggressive testing policy in hospitals on everyone inside a hospital,
If the high positives here (not illness or cases really or even infectious a lot of the time if it’s fragments of Covid from up to 6 months ago) do not result in deaths, it’ll be funny waiting for more ‘give it 2 weeks’ after a few too many people are in a pub or something.
COYP
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 13 Sep 20 10.39am |
|
|
[Link]
Carl Heneghan on the rule of 6 and more of the government’s mish mash handling.
COYP
|