You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 16 2026 5.10pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus (LOCKED)


Page 344 of 753 < 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 >
BlueJay Flag UK 13 Sep 20 6.04pm

Face masks could be giving people Covid-19 immunity, researchers suggest - [Link] More on the viral load school of thought. Just a hypothesis from an expert in the field but possibly worth noting.


Quote

Face masks may be inadvertently giving people Covid-19 immunity and making them get less sick from the virus, academics have suggested in one of the most respected medical journals in the world.

The commentary, published in the New England Journal of Medicine, advances the unproven but promising theory that universal face mask wearing might be helping to reduce the severity of the virus and ensuring that a greater proportion of new infections are asymptomatic.

If this hypothesis is borne out, the academics argue, then universal mask-wearing could become a form of variolation (inoculation) that would generate immunity and “thereby slow the spread of the virus in the United States and elsewhere” as the world awaits a vaccine.

It comes as increasing evidence suggests that the amount of virus someone is exposed to at the start of infection - the “infectious dose” - may determine the severity of their illness. Indeed, a large study published in the Lancet last month found that “viral load at diagnosis” was an “independent predictor of mortality” in hospital patients.

Wearing masks could therefore reduce the infectious dose that the wearer is exposed to and, subsequently, the impact of the disease, as masks filter out some virus-containing droplets.

Better still, as data has emerged in recent weeks suggesting that there can be strong immune responses from even mild or asymptomatic coronavirus infection, researchers say that any public health strategy that helps reduce the severity of the virus - such as mask wearing - should increase population-wide immunity as well.

This is because even a low viral load can be enough to induce an immune response, which is effectively what a typical vaccine does.

While this hypothesis needs to be backed up with more clinical study, experiments in hamsters have hinted at a connection between dose and disease. Earlier this year, a team of researchers in China found that hamsters housed behind a barrier made of surgical masks were less likely to get infected by the coronavirus. And those who did contract the virus became less sick than other animals without masks to protect them.

Some observations found in humans seem to support this as well. In a coronavirus outbreak on a closed Argentinian cruise ship, for example, where passengers were provided with surgical masks and staff with N95 masks, the rate of asymptomatic infection was 81 per cent. This is compared with 20 per cent in earlier cruise ship outbreaks without universal masking.

Still, Dr Monica Gandhi, an infectious disease physician at the University of California, San Francisco, and one of the paper’s authors, has stressed that the commentary has its limitations and should not be construed as anything other than a theory.

“To test the variolation hypothesis, we will need more studies comparing the strength and durability of SARS-CoV-2–specific T-cell immunity between people with asymptomatic infection and those with symptomatic infection, as well as a demonstration of the natural slowing of SARS-CoV-2 spread in areas with a high proportion of asymptomatic infections,” she told the Sunday Telegraph.

“However, it is true that the proportion of asymptomatic infection being increased by masking might increase the proportion of the population who achieve at least short-term immunity to the virus while we await a vaccine.”

Dr Julian Tang, Honorary Associate Professor of Respiratory Sciences at the University of Leicester, has shared Dr Gandhi’s cautious optimism.

“This idea of 'variolation' - a term originally derived from the smallpox pre-vaccine era - is quite feasible and may add to the protective physical effects of universal masking - by low level stimulation of the wearer's immune system as it is exposed to low levels of airborne SARS-CoV-2, which can induce an immune response but without any overt infection and disease,” she said.

She added: “This is after all the response to a typical vaccine - where the recipient's immune systems are stimulated, subclinically, to produce protective immune responses to combat the infection if exposed at a future date.

“Of course, more formal studies are required to confirm this effect, and there are likely natural experiments ongoing around the world at the moment.”


This could be another contributing factor to add to the list of how future infections pan out.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 13 Sep 20 6.14pm

Once the numbers are really on the up, there's an argument that testing become a bit whack-a-mole anyway, but with a backlog of 185,000 tests already and swabs being sent to to Italy and Germany perhaps that's even more true now [Link]

 

Eden Eagle Flag Kent 13 Sep 20 7.50pm

A surgeon explaining why face masks do not work

[Link]

If there is any value to the masks then these should be changed frequently and put on with care - so not sure using the same one for days on end or leaving them in the glove box of your car for next time you visit the supermarket has the same effect?

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 13 Sep 20 8.16pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

Face masks could be giving people Covid-19 immunity, researchers suggest - [Link] More on the viral load school of thought. Just a hypothesis from an expert in the field but possibly worth noting.


Quote

Face masks may be inadvertently giving people Covid-19 immunity and making them get less sick from the virus, academics have suggested in one of the most respected medical journals in the world.

The commentary, published in the New England Journal of Medicine, advances the unproven but promising theory that universal face mask wearing might be helping to reduce the severity of the virus and ensuring that a greater proportion of new infections are asymptomatic.

If this hypothesis is borne out, the academics argue, then universal mask-wearing could become a form of variolation (inoculation) that would generate immunity and “thereby slow the spread of the virus in the United States and elsewhere” as the world awaits a vaccine.

It comes as increasing evidence suggests that the amount of virus someone is exposed to at the start of infection - the “infectious dose” - may determine the severity of their illness. Indeed, a large study published in the Lancet last month found that “viral load at diagnosis” was an “independent predictor of mortality” in hospital patients.

Wearing masks could therefore reduce the infectious dose that the wearer is exposed to and, subsequently, the impact of the disease, as masks filter out some virus-containing droplets.

Better still, as data has emerged in recent weeks suggesting that there can be strong immune responses from even mild or asymptomatic coronavirus infection, researchers say that any public health strategy that helps reduce the severity of the virus - such as mask wearing - should increase population-wide immunity as well.

This is because even a low viral load can be enough to induce an immune response, which is effectively what a typical vaccine does.

While this hypothesis needs to be backed up with more clinical study, experiments in hamsters have hinted at a connection between dose and disease. Earlier this year, a team of researchers in China found that hamsters housed behind a barrier made of surgical masks were less likely to get infected by the coronavirus. And those who did contract the virus became less sick than other animals without masks to protect them.

Some observations found in humans seem to support this as well. In a coronavirus outbreak on a closed Argentinian cruise ship, for example, where passengers were provided with surgical masks and staff with N95 masks, the rate of asymptomatic infection was 81 per cent. This is compared with 20 per cent in earlier cruise ship outbreaks without universal masking.

Still, Dr Monica Gandhi, an infectious disease physician at the University of California, San Francisco, and one of the paper’s authors, has stressed that the commentary has its limitations and should not be construed as anything other than a theory.

“To test the variolation hypothesis, we will need more studies comparing the strength and durability of SARS-CoV-2–specific T-cell immunity between people with asymptomatic infection and those with symptomatic infection, as well as a demonstration of the natural slowing of SARS-CoV-2 spread in areas with a high proportion of asymptomatic infections,” she told the Sunday Telegraph.

“However, it is true that the proportion of asymptomatic infection being increased by masking might increase the proportion of the population who achieve at least short-term immunity to the virus while we await a vaccine.”

Dr Julian Tang, Honorary Associate Professor of Respiratory Sciences at the University of Leicester, has shared Dr Gandhi’s cautious optimism.

“This idea of 'variolation' - a term originally derived from the smallpox pre-vaccine era - is quite feasible and may add to the protective physical effects of universal masking - by low level stimulation of the wearer's immune system as it is exposed to low levels of airborne SARS-CoV-2, which can induce an immune response but without any overt infection and disease,” she said.

She added: “This is after all the response to a typical vaccine - where the recipient's immune systems are stimulated, subclinically, to produce protective immune responses to combat the infection if exposed at a future date.

“Of course, more formal studies are required to confirm this effect, and there are likely natural experiments ongoing around the world at the moment.”


This could be another contributing factor to add to the list of how future infections pan out.

More fcuking guesswork. It's a coronavirus. We have tons of historic data about them. They don't have 'second waves'. The curve of this one matches all previous recorded coronaviruses. As stated earlier, all the vulnerable are already killed off by it. Or at least most of them. The death rate will indeed rise over the coming months, as it has every year since viruses existed. Some years are worse than others, I'll speculate that this seasons deaths will be lower than average as the vulnerable are now too scared to go anywhere or meet anyone.

So don't kill your grannie. Just don't ever see her again and she'll die anyway.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (13 Sep 2020 8.19pm)

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Sep 20 8.32pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3557434]

More fcuking guesswork. It's a coronavirus. We have tons of historic data about them. They don't have 'second waves'. The curve of this one matches all previous recorded coronaviruses. As stated earlier, all the vulnerable are already killed off by it. Or at least most of them. The death rate will indeed rise over the coming months, as it has every year since viruses existed. Some years are worse than others, I'll speculate that this seasons deaths will be lower than average as the vulnerable are now too scared to go anywhere or meet anyone.

So don't kill your grannie. Just don't ever see her again and she'll die anyway.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (13 Sep 2020 8.19pm)

Good points.

Not that common sense exists in public policy anymore.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Sep 20 10.46pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3557434]

More fcuking guesswork. It's a coronavirus. We have tons of historic data about them. They don't have 'second waves'. The curve of this one matches all previous recorded coronaviruses. As stated earlier, all the vulnerable are already killed off by it. Or at least most of them. The death rate will indeed rise over the coming months, as it has every year since viruses existed. Some years are worse than others, I'll speculate that this seasons deaths will be lower than average as the vulnerable are now too scared to go anywhere or meet anyone.

So don't kill your grannie. Just don't ever see her again and she'll die anyway.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (13 Sep 2020 8.19pm)

Worth another repost and you’ll have read my thoughts on the different cultures of older people in Britain compared to Southern Europe and France.

 


COYP

BlueJay Flag UK 14 Sep 20 1.44am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3557434]

More fcuking guesswork. It's a coronavirus. We have tons of historic data about them. They don't have 'second waves'. The curve of this one matches all previous recorded coronaviruses. As stated earlier, all the vulnerable are already killed off by it. Or at least most of them. The death rate will indeed rise over the coming months, as it has every year since viruses existed. Some years are worse than others, I'll speculate that this seasons deaths will be lower than average as the vulnerable are now too scared to go anywhere or meet anyone.

So don't kill your grannie. Just don't ever see her again and she'll die anyway.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (13 Sep 2020 8.19pm)

SARS and MERS certainly did a number on people in various ways that other coronaviruses didn't, so they're not all identical in every way. The same with immunity, with some coronaviruses it's short-lived, for others it lasts for years and so that feeds into how these viruses can spread. When something is new and as contagious as covid-19, opinion stated as fact doesn't really mean much, because it will be what it will be one way or the other. It has unique characteristics (for starters, in the worldwide picture it's starting to look like covid-19 might not be particularly seasonal, instead 'just' extremely contagious) and exactly how the next few months will pan out isn't something that is known.

If you read the article you'd see that there is good logic (inoculating against viruses is nothing new) and more specific emerging data around viral load so it's something worth registering as a possibility at least to those open to information and seeing where it leads in future studies. Inoculating against smallpox was 'guesswork' has history to it, combine that with the pertinent studies and and it Point being for the minor inconvenience of wearing a mask in certain situations, it's possible at least that you're putting yourself in a better situation in numerous ways. To me that is useful for people to consider, be aware of, and for further studies to be done. Sharing studies and developing thoughts from those well known in the field perhaps conveys something of value that blanket 'no i'm right, you're wrong' b0llock swinging fails to.


Edited by BlueJay (14 Sep 2020 3.48am)

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 14 Sep 20 10.30am

[Link]

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 14 Sep 20 10.32am

I'm on the bus with 30 people, going into work where I'll be in a room with ten, with over 100 in it.
But tomorrow for my son's birthday, I'm only allowed six in the house. That's the bulls*** half-arsed crap that grates so much.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Sep 20 10.52am

Living in a gated community has never been so appealing.

Trouble is I’m not sure if I could even trust some people I’d think of inviting going by the

‘We’re not allowed to’ and the condoning of snitching 5-6 months ago.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Sep 20 10.59am

Originally posted by BlueJay

SARS and MERS certainly did a number on people in various ways that other coronaviruses didn't, so they're not all identical in every way. The same with immunity, with some coronaviruses it's short-lived, for others it lasts for years and so that feeds into how these viruses can spread. When something is new and as contagious as covid-19, opinion stated as fact doesn't really mean much, because it will be what it will be one way or the other. It has unique characteristics (for starters, in the worldwide picture it's starting to look like covid-19 might not be particularly seasonal, instead 'just' extremely contagious) and exactly how the next few months will pan out isn't something that is known.

If you read the article you'd see that there is good logic (inoculating against viruses is nothing new) and more specific emerging data around viral load so it's something worth registering as a possibility at least to those open to information and seeing where it leads in future studies. Inoculating against smallpox was 'guesswork' has history to it, combine that with the pertinent studies and and it Point being for the minor inconvenience of wearing a mask in certain situations, it's possible at least that you're putting yourself in a better situation in numerous ways. To me that is useful for people to consider, be aware of, and for further studies to be done. Sharing studies and developing thoughts from those well known in the field perhaps conveys something of value that blanket 'no i'm right, you're wrong' b0llock swinging fails to.


Edited by BlueJay (14 Sep 2020 3.48am)

SARS-1 and MERS didn’t have a 2nd wave. I’m assuming that your opinion and that of these studies is that we continue restricting everyone and damage the economy and employment to shield the vulnerable who can shield anyway, and incidentally what the govt are reluctantly starting to hint at.

And while the fretting over the usual leftover recovery and implications of being infected with a serious illness carries on we allow thousands of cancer and cardiac patients to not be seen, to be refused treatment when they finally are after 6+ months, until possibly they’re critical to be operated on in empty hospitals, if they’re lucky. Just struggling with the medics or government behavioural scientists’ moral viewpoints.

 


COYP

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 14 Sep 20 2.31pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

SARS and MERS certainly did a number on people in various ways that other coronaviruses didn't, so they're not all identical in every way. The same with immunity, with some coronaviruses it's short-lived, for others it lasts for years and so that feeds into how these viruses can spread. When something is new and as contagious as covid-19, opinion stated as fact doesn't really mean much, because it will be what it will be one way or the other. It has unique characteristics (for starters, in the worldwide picture it's starting to look like covid-19 might not be particularly seasonal, instead 'just' extremely contagious) and exactly how the next few months will pan out isn't something that is known.

If you read the article you'd see that there is good logic (inoculating against viruses is nothing new) and more specific emerging data around viral load so it's something worth registering as a possibility at least to those open to information and seeing where it leads in future studies. Inoculating against smallpox was 'guesswork' has history to it, combine that with the pertinent studies and and it Point being for the minor inconvenience of wearing a mask in certain situations, it's possible at least that you're putting yourself in a better situation in numerous ways. To me that is useful for people to consider, be aware of, and for further studies to be done. Sharing studies and developing thoughts from those well known in the field perhaps conveys something of value that blanket 'no i'm right, you're wrong' b0llock swinging fails to.


Edited by BlueJay (14 Sep 2020 3.48am)

Did you read it? Because I think you may have missed some bits.

"Face masks may be inadvertently..." Guess.
"...academics have suggested..." Guess.
"...face mask wearing might be helping..." Guess
"If this hypothesis is borne out, the academics argue..." Guess

And the real whammy.....

"Dr Monica Gandhi... has stressed that the commentary has its limitations and should not be construed as anything other than a theory."

If that's not guesswork what am I missing?

Also, I never said Covid-19 was seasonal. Or any virus for that matter, I said this season, ie autumn/winter.
I didn't say they were all identical either, I stated they all behave the same.

So who is b0llock swinging?

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Sep 20 3.00pm

Has this thread been censored by Downing Street lol?

 


COYP

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 Sep 20 5.38pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I'm on the bus with 30 people, going into work where I'll be in a room with ten, with over 100 in it.
But tomorrow for my son's birthday, I'm only allowed six in the house. That's the bulls*** half-arsed crap that grates so much.

It's not neccesarily the crowds spreading it.
Its peoples actions and behaviour. How many on that bus or in that office kiss,hug or share items.
Not many I would guess.
Contamination or contact is the biggest spreader.
Hence why the cases are proved to be rising in the house within family units.
Bolton nearly 200 cases per 100k. Thats huge and a majority are through family units.
If deaths dont shoot up then I think it will be relaxed in a few weeks. Although ICU admittance is rising so may well go up.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 14 Sep 20 11.20pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

SARS-1 and MERS didn’t have a 2nd wave. I’m assuming that your opinion and that of these studies is that we continue restricting everyone and damage the economy and employment to shield the vulnerable who can shield anyway, and incidentally what the govt are reluctantly starting to hint at.

And while the fretting over the usual leftover recovery and implications of being infected with a serious illness carries on we allow thousands of cancer and cardiac patients to not be seen, to be refused treatment when they finally are after 6+ months, until possibly they’re critical to be operated on in empty hospitals, if they’re lucky. Just struggling with the medics or government behavioural scientists’ moral viewpoints.

I was highlighting to the poster the fact that viruses (even coronaviruses) have stark differences between them which makes declaring as fact how future ones will behave pointless. We do not exactly know what the next say three or four months hold for us. It's hardly unlikely though that we'll have case numbers very much higher than they are now in a month or two. What we call that isn't really that important to me.

As for assuming I'm posting these studies due to wanting to restrict or further restrict and damage the economy, that's possibly more revealing of your own views towards all of this than my own. It's the working back and rubbishing of anything that isn't targetted towards a preferred outcome. I don't see the point in that.

I've been on record countless times saying that I would not support another lockdown for instance. That in itself does not automatically follow that I am not interested in developing science around treatments, preventative measures, vaccines, hypotheses and so on.

And yes I certainly agree that partly through terrible luck, and also a really lopsided allocation of resources, a great many have suffered and indeed died over this past year of conditions other than this virus.

Edited by BlueJay (15 Sep 2020 12.48am)

 

BlueJay Flag UK 14 Sep 20 11.43pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3557605]

Did you read it? Because I think you may have missed some bits.

"Face masks may be inadvertently..." Guess.
"...academics have suggested..." Guess.
"...face mask wearing might be helping..." Guess
"If this hypothesis is borne out, the academics argue..." Guess

And the real whammy.....

"Dr Monica Gandhi... has stressed that the commentary has its limitations and should not be construed as anything other than a theory."

If that's not guesswork what am I missing?

Also, I never said Covid-19 was seasonal. Or any virus for that matter, I said this season, ie autumn/winter.
I didn't say they were all identical either, I stated they all behave the same.

So who is b0llock swinging?

You harped on about 'guesswork' in your other message while using half of the very same message to, in your own words, 'speculate', just as you have speculated countless times before. Am I going through every example of your speculation and guesswork to label it as such? No. Hold yourself to a standard too if you're going to offer pointlessly one dimensional interpretations of an article.

Inoculation, in its original sense, is a proven reality with certain viruses. Smallpox for instance. Viral load is too. A combination of instances of breakouts where masks were worn and clinical coronavirus animal studies demonstrating that lower exposure resulted in less severe cases has led scientists to explore this area, which would seem to be a rather sensible idea. Sorry if that offends you in some way. In the very post you excitedly informed us was guesswork I had already stated right at the top that it's "just a hypothesis.." just as in my following message I stated that it's worth exploring as a possibility, so I'm not sure what you think you're adding. You going HAHA GUESSWORK adfinitum, is neither here nor there since neither me nor the article has stated the hypothesis as fact in the first place. I don't have time to endlessly argue the toss about nothing over and over. If the article is of interest take it as such, if it isn't then don't.

Edited by BlueJay (15 Sep 2020 12.51am)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 15 Sep 20 11.13am

While our media carry on with the fear mongering and the supporters of muzzle wearing...oh sorry...mask wearing continue to advocate for your compliance have a read about how Sweden are doing.

[Link]

Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Sep 2020 11.14am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The Dolphin Flag 15 Sep 20 1.25pm

As with Tony Blair - if Neil Ferguson told me it was raining outside I would check for myself.
A useless forecaster and a liar to boot!

 

W12 15 Sep 20 2.29pm

The main things that have stood out for me in this manufactured crisis are (1) That liberals/progressives are overtly authoritarian in nature (especially women) (2) That people in generally will go a lot further in terms of doing what they are told without questioning it and (3) Most importantly, the government (any government) have very little to do with actually running this country compared to media and many other non elected parties. Democracy is a total illusion.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 15 Sep 20 6.05pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

You harped on about 'guesswork' in your other message (I mentioned it once)while using half of the very same message to, in your own words, 'speculate'(based on hitoric evidence), just as you have speculated countless times before(untrue, back that up). Am I going through every example of your speculation and guesswork to label it as such? (You accused me of not reading the article so I posted some of the relevant quotes from the article, not your own, which call it theory, not fact) No. Hold yourself to a standard too if you're going to offer pointlessly one dimensional interpretations of an article. (It doesn't need interpretation, one of the authors said so)

Inoculation, in its original sense, is a proven reality with certain viruses(Indeed it is, and they've been looking for a coronavirus vaccine for decades). Smallpox for instance (Nothing like a coronavirus though, what's the relevance?). Viral load is too. (True as well) A combination of instances of breakouts where masks were worn and clinical coronavirus animal studies demonstrating that lower exposure resulted in less severe cases has led scientists to explore this area,(This bit is where the guesswork is) which would seem to be a rather sensible idea. Sorry if that offends you in some way It doesn't). In the very post you excitedly informed us was guesswork I had already stated right at the top that it's "just a hypothesis.." just as in my following message I stated that it's worth exploring as a possibility, so I'm not sure what you think you're adding. You going HAHA GUESSWORK adfinitum, is neither here nor there since neither me nor the article has stated the hypothesis as fact in the first place. (Little rant ) I don't have time to endlessly argue the toss about nothing over and over (Effectively saying you have no arguement). If the article is of interest take it as such, if it isn't then don't. Guess what? I didn't

Edited by BlueJay (15 Sep 2020 12.51am)

Also, what are these stark differences in coronaviruses? The have ALL behaved the same in the past.

Please try to keep your reply civil if you reply.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Page 344 of 753 < 340 341 342 343 344 345 346 347 348 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic