You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?
November 16 2026 11.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?


Page 4 of 12 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Username Flag Horsham 24 Oct 16 11.53am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Leicester on paper aren't better than us really. People are getting carried away because they won the league - would swap Fuchs with Kelly, Huth or Morgan with Damo and Mahrez with townsends but other than that I don't see any superiority "on paper". My biggest issue with Pardew is I don't see any improvement - if results were poor but you could see evidence of us evolving then fair enough but it's bulls*** in my opinion. Tactically we have looked completely lost for a long long time and we only ever seem to look good when we do the exact thing pardew supposedly wants to come away from which is sitting deep and nicking a couple by set pieces/on the break. The reason we are good at those things are because of the defensive foundations laid out by Pulis.

Under pardew, as time goes on, we look weaker and weaker at the back - regardless of injuries. It's all well and good saying you want to change the style of play but the goals we've scored this season have typically mainly been from set pieces or headers from Benteke. The only change I see is us looking more flimsy at the back.

My point is we should expect to win more games given players we've signed under him, if we go on a little 3 game run it's nice but I honestly do not think many managers would've struggled to beat Sunderland Stoke and Boro with the players we had at our disposal. I just don't see us pushing on and fulfilling our actual potential under Pardew.


That's a pretty ridiculous thing to say though isn't it?

'People are getting carried away because they were the best team in the country last year'

What nonsense.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Mr_Flow Flag London 24 Oct 16 12.33pm

I can see where the OP is coming from. However, we're sitting mid-table and until we start to drop down the league, I don't really think it's the time to start pointing the finger at the manager.

I think the key thing here is expectation. What do people really expect and what would they regard as a good season? For me, avoiding a relegation battle and finishing 8-12 is a good season. We're on track to do that, so I think the team/manager is doing a good job.

Also, we're a team that's in transition. On Saturday, we controlled the game for long periods, and with better finishing, it would have been a completely different game. For the past few seasons, we had one system and one way of playing. We also used to chase the game for the vast majority of it. It's refreshing to see us changing and we won't be the finished article overnight.

I think we're pretty much on par for this season so far and hopefully this will continue.

 

cpj Flag Kent 24 Oct 16 12.53pm

Originally posted by Mr_Flow

I can see where the OP is coming from. However, we're sitting mid-table and until we start to drop down the league, I don't really think it's the time to start pointing the finger at the manager.

I think the key thing here is expectation. What do people really expect and what would they regard as a good season? For me, avoiding a relegation battle and finishing 8-12 is a good season. We're on track to do that, so I think the team/manager is doing a good job.

Also, we're a team that's in transition. On Saturday, we controlled the game for long periods, and with better finishing, it would have been a completely different game. For the past few seasons, we had one system and one way of playing. We also used to chase the game for the vast majority of it. It's refreshing to see us changing and we won't be the finished article overnight.

I think we're pretty much on par for this season so far and hopefully this will continue.

We've conceded first in 7 of our 9 games and only scored in the first half in 2 of those - nothing has changed there.

 

Mr_Flow Flag London 24 Oct 16 12.56pm

Originally posted by cpj

We've conceded first in 7 of our 9 games and only scored in the first half in 2 of those - nothing has changed there.

I mean in terms of possession rather than conceding first.

 

JacksonEagle Flag Croydon 24 Oct 16 1.13pm

Originally posted by Mr_Flow

I mean in terms of possession rather than conceding first.

I think that just proves how useless a statistic possession is...

 

Painter Flag Croydon 24 Oct 16 1.26pm

Originally posted by JacksonEagle

I think that just proves how useless a statistic possession is...

Goals are the only statistic worth reading.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 24 Oct 16 1.32pm

Originally posted by JacksonEagle

I think that just proves how useless a statistic possession is...

Yep agree

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 24 Oct 16 1.37pm

I've got mixed feelings.
If you look at the league table, the top five are in their own minI league, then you gave man u, Southampton and Everton who will finish above us which means best we can realistically hope for is 9th. We're currently one point off 9th in 11th so not to bad.
on the down side, I think AP seriously messed up by not getting a good no.10 in the transfer market. We still look predictable using the wingers but have little threat going through the middle. Should also have bought a fullback...

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 24 Oct 16 1.40pm

I agree with the folks on here who are somewhat alluding to "you get what you pay for". Even with Benteke up top we are an average prem side, we shouldn't go down but also shouldn't finish above 10th or so. Pardew is an average manager but the thing is we could definitely go up or down fortunes wise, with a new gaffer, so be careful what you wish for. The one thing that is very suspect with AP is initial tactical strategy and then the ability to adapt and change as the game plays out, he is pretty weak there, especially on the 2nd point.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Painter Flag Croydon 24 Oct 16 1.56pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

I agree with the folks on here who are somewhat alluding to "you get what you pay for". Even with Benteke up top we are an average prem side, we shouldn't go down but also shouldn't finish above 10th or so. Pardew is an average manager but the thing is we could definitely go up or down fortunes wise, with a new gaffer, so be careful what you wish for. The one thing that is very suspect with AP is initial tactical strategy and then the ability to adapt and change as the game plays out, he is pretty weak there, especially on the 2nd point.

If Pardew is an average manager, who do you think is above average, that we could realistically attract?
Like it or not we are an average Premier side and likely to be whoever is the manager.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 24 Oct 16 2.21pm

The thing is we wasn't even that bad, Leicester were better and deserved the 3 points but the only real difference is they took their chances and we didn't, was not really much different pardew could of done.

If you want to pick faults with anyone then it's the players on the pitch on sat for not taking our chances.

AP is a good fit for where we are as a club right now.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 24 Oct 16 2.27pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Or will we be branded as "fake fans" and "bed wetters".

The smugness from some fans was almost as cringeworthy as the smugness from himself after beating stoke Sunderland and Boro.

In the last 31 (yes, 31) games we've won 5 - that includes the 3 mentioned above.

Someone please make a case given our first 11, which genuinely has quality, that that is good enough.

All this "team in transition" is aload of turd as well. When we win games like we did against stoke it's because of the players we have on the pitch and the fact Pardew likes high intensity and power. Besides that he is clearly tactically inept - I thought that even when we were on a good run.

Expecting to get a fair bit of abuse and contemplated saying anything but in fairness I don't really care - some people really need to wake up.

Edited by Mstrobez (23 Oct 2016 4.48pm)

Erm, could it be that a number of members of the talented first 11 you mentioned, weren't here for the majority of that 31 game run?

We're mid-table a quarter of the way through the season - to want to 'slate' your manager for that is pathetic.

Also, if you honestly can't see a transition in how we're trying to play this season, I'd have to question whether you're actually watching the games - you can question Pardew's decision to implement it, but to suggest it's not happening is just being dishonest.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 24 Oct 16 2.30pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Leicester on paper aren't better than us really. People are getting carried away because they won the league - would swap Fuchs with Kelly, Huth or Morgan with Damo and Mahrez with townsends but other than that I don't see any superiority "on paper". My biggest issue with Pardew is I don't see any improvement - if results were poor but you could see evidence of us evolving then fair enough but it's bulls*** in my opinion. Tactically we have looked completely lost for a long long time and we only ever seem to look good when we do the exact thing pardew supposedly wants to come away from which is sitting deep and nicking a couple by set pieces/on the break. The reason we are good at those things are because of the defensive foundations laid out by Pulis.

Under pardew, as time goes on, we look weaker and weaker at the back - regardless of injuries. It's all well and good saying you want to change the style of play but the goals we've scored this season have typically mainly been from set pieces or headers from Benteke. The only change I see is us looking more flimsy at the back.

My point is we should expect to win more games given players we've signed under him, if we go on a little 3 game run it's nice but I honestly do not think many managers would've struggled to beat Sunderland Stoke and Boro with the players we had at our disposal. I just don't see us pushing on and fulfilling our actual potential under Pardew.

The fact you think this is true is exactly why you feel the way you do about Pardew - completely unrealistic.


Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (24 Oct 2016 2.30pm)

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 24 Oct 16 2.42pm

We're 11th in the Premier League and just lost away to the champions, who haven't lost at home in OVER A YEAR. Some serious spoilt brats amongst our ranks these days.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 24 Oct 16 2.43pm

Originally posted by We are goin up!

We're 11th in the Premier League and just lost away to the champions, who haven't lost at home in OVER A YEAR. Some serious spoilt brats amongst our ranks these days.

mental isn't it.

 


@sxp55555

citizensmudge Flag midlands 24 Oct 16 3.19pm

Originally posted by We are goin up!

We're 11th in the Premier League and just lost away to the champions, who haven't lost at home in OVER A YEAR. Some serious spoilt brats amongst our ranks these days.

The problem with the OP and the other cretins that post this kind of crap is they do so only out of a dislike for AP.Its not football based,they are never to be seen when we win or get a good result as it goes against their agenda.And I say agenda because that is exactly what it is.And that is what I despise about all of them,they are divisive in as much as they would hound out our manager because of their personal dislike of him without consideration of whats best for the football club at this present moment and going forward.That is why they are not genuine supporters imo,they care only for them selves and not the club which is exactly why they are all over a couple of losses with this incessant vomit but are nowhere to be seen when we win a few and play well.If you cant enjoy the good times but continuously soap box the bad you are either a troll or you have an agenda which in this case is of course AP.So when I say fvck off and support someone else,i genuinely mean it.Why should they be welcome on here with nothing but negative spew and only when the opportunity arises,why should the rest of us have to put up with people who would happily drop kick the manager up the Holmesdale Road regardless of how it affects the club and the fans all because of THEIR agenda.I find it offensive and just because its an online forum doesn't make it less so.

 

Mr_Flow Flag London 24 Oct 16 3.44pm

Originally posted by rikz

The thing is we wasn't even that bad, Leicester were better and deserved the 3 points but the only real difference is they took their chances and we didn't, was not really much different pardew could of done.

If you want to pick faults with anyone then it's the players on the pitch on sat for not taking our chances.

AP is a good fit for where we are as a club right now.

This.

We played well on Saturday, just didn't take our chances. It was just one of those games.

 

Dweeb Flag East London 24 Oct 16 4.16pm

Originally posted by Mr_Flow

This.

We played well on Saturday, just didn't take our chances. It was just one of those games.

But this was exactly the same arguement that was being deployed as last year when we didn't have Townsend or Benteke on board.

 


Taking the bungy jump since 1964. Never to see John Jackson in a shirt again

Sorry to see Lee Hills go, did we ever see Alex Marrow? We did January 2013

palace-metros Flag Redhill 24 Oct 16 4.28pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

It isn't my view of "success" at all, merely a more appropriate approach for where we are now than talking as though we're Barcelona. For the time being, anyway.

Funnily enough you go on to cite some of the reasons why I said what I said, so perhaps you'd better check that you disagree with me before biting my head off.

And I don't give a twopenny toss what other clubs do because I don't support them.

It appears we see the same shortcomings. However, we clearly disagree on the best route forward. Would you suggest that we did not need to change the playing style? If this is your view then I concur that experimentation is pointless. However, if a change is needed in order to progress the club to the "next level" (for us I guess that would be mid table rather than battling relegation), at what stage do you attempt to change the playing style then? I find myself agreeing with AP strangely enough in that we need to go this route and that it will be transitional since we can't change 2/3rds of the squad in one fell swoop. I am prepared to hold my breath, cross my fingers and give it time. I'd rather we do this than carry on with the old style which will only get us so far as a club. Is there a risk? Of course. Is Pardew the right manager? Spin a coin, but we could do worse.

 


Before you criticise someone, you should walk a mile in their shoes. That way, when you criticise them, you're a mile away and you have their shoes.

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 24 Oct 16 4.35pm

Originally posted by Matlock

You are spot on mstrobez everything you say is dead right to many palace fans looking at clueless Pardew though rose tinted glasses time for a change

Oh here she is, only appears when a couple of defeats have occurred. How are you sweetheart?

 

Page 4 of 12 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we allowed to start slating pardew again yet?