You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > New Zealand shooting at mosques
November 21 2026 10.42pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

New Zealand shooting at mosques


Page 4 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Stirlingsays Flag 15 Mar 19 3.10pm

Originally posted by blackheatheagle

Very very sad news.

Given some comments in media (UK and outside) and here few points i would like to highlight.

- Cliche of `terror has no religion`. Well, we all know that but which also should not mean how religion become a fatal weapon for terror. I see various of Muslim touch-point much more like pointing the finger that `see, not only Muslims act terror`. Meanwhile i also see the motivation to check at other side defending `this is self-motivated action, he is ill etc`. None of this give me a clear picture.

- Christian and Muslim rooted countries have a very common difference.

Christian countries passed through fighting independence of individual and shed blood for this. Milestones like Magna Carta, French revolution or many other which simply get over monarchism from government and religion perspective. On top of this, replaced this with an evolving environment which gives priority to individual and human right which was fed by science and education.

Whereas, there is nearly no Muslim country (or a few which has no influence) had similar experience. This stability ended up with a conflict with new-world order which was managed and ruled by above movements.

Thus, Muslim countries can easily consume Jihadi-mindset (which is similar to Crusades period) which end up having millions of people who would not refrain to be part of any terrorist act. (PS here: This ain`t a justification of Islam, i oppose all religious)

This is also root cause of the failure of `so-called democracy` in Iraq or Arab Spring. I remember myself laughing with my ass when Bush and Blair was stating their objective is bringing democracy to Middle-East which ended millions of people`s live and triggered an environment which created various of terrorist groups. Democracy is required by individuals and can be granted if they fight for it, it can not be delivered by any dictations. Removing those dictators without any reliable placement was a suicide. Like it would be suicide if somehow people get over monarchic government or church by replacing nothing meaningful.

And for sure, we can not deny the fact of official terror on Earth which is run by conflicting strategies of official governments. Having no strategy and staying desperate against refugee flooding (which was triggered by so-called democratic Arab Spring) is one sample.

I would not be optimistic to wait nations who has no democratic mindset to be democratic and follow the evolution which West followed. But sounds like i am also becoming pessimistic that whatever is happening (terror, refugees, extremism) nowadays will boost polarization and will end-up self-saving solutions by governments by ignoring mutual concurrence which is supposed to be only regional and / or global solution.

Edited by blackheatheagle (15 Mar 2019 3.05pm)

A good and interesting post, cheers.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 15 Mar 19 3.20pm

Originally posted by W12

I don’t really see Christianity in this country peddling anything. Just quite nice people on the whole going to church.

You can thank the reformation for that.
Without it, Catholicism would be the primary religion like in Spain, Italy, and South America.

This would be a very different country. The modern world has been created by casting off the shackles of religious dogma and employing science.

 

W12 15 Mar 19 3.25pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

You can thank the reformation for that.
Without it, Catholicism would be the primary religion like in Spain, Italy, and South America.

This would be a very different country. The modern world has been created by casting off the shackles of religious dogma and employing science.

Don't think it was entirely the reformation but I'm nit picking. Yes generally agree.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 15 Mar 19 3.25pm

my fear is another terrorist atrocity to atone for the previous one. Any day now. Wherever we are living.


and the cycle going on ad infinitum.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 15 Mar 19 3.32pm

Originally posted by W12

Don't think it was entirely the reformation but I'm nit picking. Yes generally agree.

The benefits of the modern world including education have allowed the transition over time but I'm sure that the catalyst for all of this including the industrial revolution and scientific enlightenment began when we threw off the straight jacket of Catholicism.

 

becky Flag over the moon 15 Mar 19 3.36pm

Originally posted by W12

I don’t really see Christianity in this country peddling anything. Just quite nice people on the whole going to church.

No, they don't peddle anything (although some of the more evangelistic churches do get 'out there', but if you think that Christians just go to church then you couldn't be more wrong!

just a few examples of current activity (and at no cost to the State or local authorities)....

- running day centres for homeless/refugees/old people
- running free English courses for immigrants of all nationalities
-lay chaplains in hospitals and hospices who will sit with the sick and dying who have no-one else to be with them, visit those who have no other visitors
- lay chaplains in prisons trying to assist those who truly want to reform, visiting with those whose family have disowned them or can't get to see them.
- local churches run befriending groups for the lonely and housebound
- supply and run food banks
- organise and provide for hot food runs for the homeless on a nightly basis

....and most if not all of it is done without a fanfare, without preaching and without looking for any reward other than being true to their faith.

.....then these quite nice people go to church Sundays and give thanks for all they have that these people they help don't.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

W12 15 Mar 19 3.56pm

Originally posted by becky

No, they don't peddle anything (although some of the more evangelistic churches do get 'out there', but if you think that Christians just go to church then you couldn't be more wrong!

just a few examples of current activity (and at no cost to the State or local authorities)....

- running day centres for homeless/refugees/old people
- running free English courses for immigrants of all nationalities
-lay chaplains in hospitals and hospices who will sit with the sick and dying who have no-one else to be with them, visit those who have no other visitors
- lay chaplains in prisons trying to assist those who truly want to reform, visiting with those whose family have disowned them or can't get to see them.
- local churches run befriending groups for the lonely and housebound
- supply and run food banks
- organise and provide for hot food runs for the homeless on a nightly basis

....and most if not all of it is done without a fanfare, without preaching and without looking for any reward other than being true to their faith.

.....then these quite nice people go to church Sundays and give thanks for all they have that these people they help don't.

It's rare these days to want to thank someone for correcting yourself. I agree they are generally more than nice people, they are morally truthful because actions speak so much louder than words.

 

laddo Flag london 15 Mar 19 3.57pm

Of course, typical of the right, you just yell I’m on the left. Actually I’m slightly different. Where many on the left would happily engage in debate with the far-right, I just call it as it is.

There are some on here with their mock remorse who also in other threads praise, almost hero-worship, Tommy Robinson. This is a man who describes Islam as the enemy. Is it any wonder that with such mouthpieces of hate having a platform that events like this morning in New Zealand happen?

Let’s have it straight. Isis and the tommy Robinson right are cut from the same cloth. Both groups are intolerant of others and have warped ideologies albeit one grounded in religion, the other in nationalism. In an ideal world I’d love to put you all on a remote island with weapons and say ‘fill your boots lads’. Neither would be a loss to society.

 


laddo

"People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist".
David Brent.

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 15 Mar 19 4.01pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

What ideas are these?

Are you suggesting that someone using a set of circumstance as a reason to kill people means that those circumstances are not real?

Loopy logic right there.

Nelson Mandela used Apartied as a reason to be a terrorist. Does that mean that Apartied did not exist?

All of the usual stuff on birth rates, genetics, takeover of our culture etc.

No, I’m not suggesting that at all - I’m suggesting that someone who routinely blames the left for consequences of their beliefs, who fails to recognise the consequence of their own, is a hypocrite.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 15 Mar 19 4.02pm

When I was a youngster mum always told me that if you wanted to find a nice girl go to church.

I should have listened because I spent most of my time looking for them behind the local chippie.

Anyway she was talking about her era not mine because even then it was out of date advice.....because I shouldn't think there are too many 'fresh out of the vat' eligible females to be found in the pews even then let alone these days.....unless 'Songs of Praise' is doing the rounds.

Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Mar 2019 4.03pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 15 Mar 19 4.03pm

Originally posted by W12

It's rare these days to want to thank someone for correcting yourself. I agree they are generally more than nice people, they are morally truthful because actions speak so much louder than words.

I think we must not confuse good people who exhibit 'Christian' attitudes by helping other people and those promoting scientific ignorance, ridiculous fairy stories and the worship of invisible beings.

These things are separate.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 15 Mar 19 4.04pm

Originally posted by laddo


Let’s have it straight. Isis and the tommy Robinson right are cut from the same cloth.

Tommy Robinson doesn't kill people that he doesn't agree with

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 15 Mar 19 4.06pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

It's all because of the disgusting right wing narrative of division, walls and getting people to hate on other people, politicians also to blame with posters saying breaking point

Do you have to try and make political capital out of everything?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 15 Mar 19 4.09pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

All of the usual stuff on birth rates, genetics, takeover of our culture etc.

No, I’m not suggesting that at all - I’m suggesting that someone who routinely blames the left for consequences of their beliefs, who fails to recognise the consequence of their own, is a hypocrite.


So the truth is responsible for these murders? Weird way of thinking about it.....What are you suggesting? That people shut up?

When the next Islamic attack happens.....are you going to suggest that we close down Mosques because that's where the twisted motivations originated from?


Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Mar 2019 4.10pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Invalid user 2019 Flag 15 Mar 19 4.12pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

You are on this site saying, words to the effect, that it doesn't matter if white people or indeed, you must have meant all races, are mixed out of existence


Really? You're going to give the, 'if only we could get along' message? How many examples throughout history do you need?

I would suggest that it is this attitude that provides far more motivation for morons like this guy than anything else.



I've said nothing about wanting anyone mixed out of existence. I've just stated that I don't care if people I know are mixed race or white. They are not less 'of this place' to me as a result if they are born here and I'm not doing a colour count. That's it. There are more white people and indeed most other races than have ever existed in the history of the world anyway. I specifically suggested in the very message you replied to that I want immigration to be limited through Brexit because of societal issues it causes. That's hardly the attitude of someone who wants to let the world in. It's about getting along with whoever is already here where possible.

At the end of the day I hold and express a nuanced view and you follow or followed a white resistance group on social media that is off it's nut and is followed by people who actually self identify as extremists in their profiles and make incredibly out there comments, so I hardly think I need to listen to you find fault with my mundane outlook. To say that anything in my post or outlook in any way motivates acts of terror is clearly ludicrous. You're acting out because of the particular flavour of this act of extremism. Blame the individual. I have no need to paint any of these scumbags, whatever the ideology, as anything other than what they are.

I'm happy with my post as a whole which is below, rather than you picking out the few select bits you disagree with about aspiring to get along to leap to a conclusion where I'm partially responsible for the motivations of people like this guy. My proximity to individuals like this man is ancient oceans wide.

--------------

Original Message

A sickening act.


I'm pleased I've criticised both religious extremism and racial resistance groups on here. It's all too easy online to plug into these fringe movements or to go down an us vs them road to radicalisation. This guy announced what he was going to do before posting his muddled and cliched 'white genecide' ethno state manifesto on a chan site, live streaming his heinous acts to anyone interested. It's important to see the dignity in all, not get warped ideas about who does and doesn't truly belong in their own country. The regular focus on genetic themed racial stuff that is suddenly ever present on here for instance is alienating, unhelpful and a rung on the ladder this leads nowhere pleasant.

Hrolf makes a good point about how violence begets violence. Previous attacks add weight to the likelihood of attacks like this, and this in turn will no doubt tip some religious radical over the edge. I've never been for mass immigration, making a country only about benefiting elites through cheap labour. It does have an impact on stability of a country and can cause friction within communities. Religion can complicate and result in insular communities that hold age old beliefs detached from that of the country. Possibly Brexit will put the breaks on things if it actually ever happens. Even if it does though, it's important to remember that at that point the country is what it is. People still have to learn to get along in peace and to try to find commonality rather than differences no matter how hard or futile that may sometimes appear. We see here what the alternative to doing that is.


Edited by dollardays (15 Mar 2019 4.21pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 15 Mar 19 4.19pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

All of the usual stuff on birth rates, genetics, takeover of our culture etc.

No, I’m not suggesting that at all - I’m suggesting that someone who routinely blames the left for consequences of their beliefs, who fails to recognise the consequence of their own, is a hypocrite.

It's easy to oversimplify on a message board.

I lay blame with the Left for being the useful idiot for those that promote mass immigration and multiculture for their own ends despite it causing many problems for the people they traditionally represent.

I believe that all the ideas you list are perfectly reasonable and demonstratable. None of this is justification for murdering innocent people in the same way that Islamist atrocities cannot be justified.

For me, the bottom line is that all of this is predictable when you put incompatible cultures together.
You don't have to be an extremist to see that but it is an environment where extremism will breed.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (15 Mar 2019 4.21pm)

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 15 Mar 19 4.28pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


So the truth is responsible for these murders? Weird way of thinking about it.....What are you suggesting? That people shut up?

When the next Islamic attack happens.....are you going to suggest that we close down Mosques because that's where the twisted motivations originated from?


Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Mar 2019 4.10pm)

That’s your truth; I can’t be bothered to recycle a debate that’s been had 100 times, but everyone believes their view to be the truth, hence why they believe it.

I’m not suggesting anything of the sort; just pointing out the hypocrisy of you saying the media are lying to put blame on the right, when you readily lay blame to the left.

Let’s be clear; I’ve never suggested closing down anything, just highlighted an inconsistency.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 15 Mar 19 4.33pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

It's easy to oversimplify on a message board.

I lay blame with the Left for being the useful idiot for those that promote mass immigration and multiculture for their own ends despite it causing many problems for the people they traditionally represent.

I believe that all the ideas you list are perfectly reasonable and demonstratable. None of this is justification for murdering innocent people in the same way that Islamist atrocities cannot be justified.

For me, the bottom line is that all of this is predictable when you put incompatible cultures together.
You don't have to be an extremist to see that but it is an environment where extremism will breed.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (15 Mar 2019 4.21pm)

I’m sure there are nuanced differences in his beliefs and those expressed on here, but the key ideas are the same.

I have no issue with you laying blame on the left for some of the reasons raised, but it’s not a competition - my post was more to highlight that there are dangerous consequences of both sides of the debate, and I struggle to see how you could argue it’s a lie that right-wing politics has played a part here.

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 15 Mar 19 4.37pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

That’s your truth; I can’t be bothered to recycle a debate that’s been had 100 times, but everyone believes their view to be the truth, hence why they believe it.

I’m not suggesting anything of the sort; just pointing out the hypocrisy of you saying the media are lying to put blame on the right, when you readily lay blame to the left.

Let’s be clear; I’ve never suggested closing down anything, just highlighted an inconsistency.

I've seen muslims committing acts of terror declared not 'real muslims' by people on account of their actions and so those communities have no need to reflect. They should. We don't need to sugar coat it.

This individual had a clear, consistent and repeated thread of angry racial ideology that ran through his manafesto, so we don't need to cobble together reasons to ignore that either.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 15 Mar 19 4.40pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

That’s your truth; I can’t be bothered to recycle a debate that’s been had 100 times, but everyone believes their view to be the truth, hence why they believe it.

I’m not suggesting anything of the sort; just pointing out the hypocrisy of you saying the media are lying to put blame on the right, when you readily lay blame to the left.

Let’s be clear; I’ve never suggested closing down anything, just highlighted an inconsistency.

When Islamists kill people we are told that Islam is not to blame. So how are people who hold a particular view responsible for this?

I don't agree that a belief is the same as the factual truth. If something can be demonstrated then it is a fact and not just a somebodies 'truth'.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (15 Mar 2019 4.40pm)

 

Page 4 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > New Zealand shooting at mosques