This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
I don’t accept that Zaha and Eze can’t play in the same team, although I can see Roy could may reservations due to his conservatism. Ah Patrick. Unfortunately, I can't argue with your analysis. I think you hit it dead on.
Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth. |
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
We’re on the same page about Roy’s preference for team shape over game changing talent. He's not. Right now it's not his job to manage Eze's development and although I hate to write that it's the truth. Roy's job is to keep us up. He can kill as many careers and as much joy as necessary but the truth is he just needs to keep us up and the carnage of damaged careers or boring, mindless games is just the cost of that. I don't like it but it's the reality. I'm glad I only have to watch it, not live it.
Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth. |
|
|
Originally posted by redshift
He's not. Right now it's not his job to manage Eze's development and although I hate to write that it's the truth. Roy's job is to keep us up. He can kill as many careers and as much joy as necessary but the truth is he just needs to keep us up and the carnage of damaged careers or boring, mindless games is just the cost of that. I don't like it but it's the reality. I'm glad I only have to watch it, not live it. Playing Eze gives us a higher chance of winning games and thus staying up imo. However Roys ethos is playing to not lose rather than playing to win. I bore myself sometimes with going on about it.. but nothing will change with Roy.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EddieMac
Take away heading a ball from Guita’s kick outs then there is no reason for Schlupp to keep Eze out of the team. Schlupp does not cover in defence like a lot of people think and this myth about his amazing solo runs that he goes on is nonsense. He takes off like a bat out of hell and looses the ball 99 times out of 100. Schlupp with that left-foot provides some balance on the left side and he adds more physicality than Eze.He is also more used to the 'Hodgson way' having worked with the manager longer than Eze. I suppose supporters will ponder as to whether Hodgson specifically asked for Eze to be purchased or whether the club saw the opportunity to purchase a young flair player who was highly rated in the Championship and perhaps could have been deployed as a Zaha replacement. Edited by Willo (02 Nov 2020 9.16am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by redshift
Roy's job is to keep us up. He can kill as many careers and as much joy as necessary but the truth is he just needs to keep us up and the carnage of damaged careers or boring, mindless games is just the cost of that. Another of the downsides is that it will put decent players off joining us as no quality players will want to come to Palace just to warm the bench
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
But it’s only Roy’s apparent insistence on seeing it as a straight choice between Schlupp and Eze that causes the issue. Exactly, It is Roy’s job to find away to fit the players into the team. No player has a right to just start every game. It will be interesting to see what he does know the Ayew is back. Ayew has never had a set position but Roy will try get him straight back in.
|
|
|
Give Eze a starting number and his confidence will grow! Him and Riedewald ought to be played together..creativity vs donkey work (Schlupp and 2 x Mac)
|
|
|
Originally posted by viveasheagle
Interesting debate. I was impressed when by Eze in first couple of games with his shimmies and that he looked to find a forward pass. A few games in and the shimmies have not changed and whilst he has not been bad he is not influencing the games from the sub's bench in a way that say to the manager you can't leave me out next time. Schlupp has his critics but he is strong quick and direct plus good in the air. Our results in general are better when Schlupp plays. Correct.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Today’s press conference reaffirmed where Eze stands in the pecking order. Stupid comments from Roy. He clearly didn’t want him and was not his choice if that’s what he believes. Eze is competing with Schlupp?? We all knew this would happen. I’ve resigned to the fact we’ve got Roy and nothing will change until he’s gone. Can you imagine if we had signed Benrahma or Sarr would have been the same lame excuses as to why he can’t play players. Actually fed up to the back teeth of his prehistoric football. Parish and Dougie need to take ownership of this situation .. money wasted on Camarasa, Meyer and potentially Eze. Why are we signing these type of players! We all know Roy doesn’t want them- how can there be such a disconnect. If Jairo is anything to go by maybe we’ll see Eze flourish in 2 years time.. Edited by MonsterMunch (07 Nov 2020 8.56am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
Stupid comments from Roy. He clearly didn’t want him and was not his choice if that’s what he believes. Eze is competing with Schlupp?? We all knew this would happen. I’ve resigned to the fact we’ve got Roy and nothing will change until he’s gone. Can you imagine if we had signed Benrahma or Sarr would have been the same lame excuses as to why he can’t play players. Actually fed up to the back teeth of his prehistoric football. Edited by MonsterMunch (07 Nov 2020 8.56am) I have heard umpteen such sentiments about the style of football under Hodgson but in the final analysis he has ensured we have stayed in the PL for 3 seasons and this could well extend to 4 seasons. I agree with your sentiments concerning Benrahma and Sarr.My view is that Benrahma would have suffered the same fate as Eze and the same for Sarr who is deployed mainly on the right and Townsend would have been preferred to him. I very much suspect that Batshuayi is only playing because Ayew has been unavailable.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I have heard umpteen such sentiments about the style of football under Hodgson but in the final analysis he has ensured we have stayed in the PL for 3 seasons and this could well extend to 4 seasons. I agree with your sentiments concerning Benrahma and Sarr.My view is that Benrahma would have suffered the same fate as Eze and the same for Sarr who is deployed mainly on the right and Townsend would have been preferred to him. I very much suspect that Batshuayi is only playing because Ayew has been unavailable. Of course this is true and the usual charlton syndrome comments will be peddled, however this is not how football should be played. Ripping the excitement and passion from the game. This is not palace. I aspire for more from my club. No self entitlement here just higher aspirations and the belief he could be doing more with what he has. It’s early days with Eze, but the signs are already there, another attack minded player being criminally unused. This lad is such a talent. Hope Roy doesn’t ruin him.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I have heard umpteen such sentiments about the style of football under Hodgson but in the final analysis he has ensured we have stayed in the PL for 3 seasons and this could well extend to 4 seasons. I agree with your sentiments concerning Benrahma and Sarr.My view is that Benrahma would have suffered the same fate as Eze and the same for Sarr who is deployed mainly on the right and Townsend would have been preferred to him. I very much suspect that Batshuayi is only playing because Ayew has been unavailable. Nonetheless I think you will agree that there is a massive disconnect between the flair players mentioned and Hodgson's own football philosophy. To turn Eze into a Schlupp doesn't bode well. As someone mentioned, the next manager is going to have a big job turning round years of Hodgson's catenaccio tactics, instilling a more balanced approach between attack and defence. Which brings me back to the first point: why do we bring in talented offensive minded players who only end up spending time on the bench, or shoe-horned into Hodgson's system, usually in a position that is not natural to them? Edited by southnorwoodhill (07 Nov 2020 9.39am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
Nonetheless I think you will agree that there is a massive disconnect between the flair players mentioned and Hodgson's own football philosophy. To turn Eze into a Schlupp doesn't bode well. As someone mentioned, the next manager is going to have a big job turning round years of Hodgson's catenaccio tactics, instilling a more balanced approach between attack and defence. Which brings me back to the first point: why do we bring in talented offensive minded players who only end up spending time on the bench? I presume ultimately it is SP who signs the cheque, surely by now he must be wondering what is going on? Apropos Eze, I saw him plough his furrow for QPR and I simply could not see him fitting into the team under Hodgson.I had similar thoughts about Benrahma. John Lundstram of Sheff Utd could well be available in January and he is far more suited to 'Roy ball' than Eze or Benrahma. I suspect, Hodgson would have far preferred that we signed a genuine 'Target man' rather than Batshuayi.Might have had a celebration if we lured Giroud or Carroll !
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Apropos Eze, I saw him plough his furrow for QPR and I simply could not see him fitting into the team under Hodgson.I had similar thoughts about Benrahma. John Lundstram of Sheff Utd could well be available in January and he is far more suited to 'Roy ball' than Eze or Benrahma. I suspect, Hodgson would have far preferred that we signed a genuine 'Target man' rather than Batshuayi.Might have had a celebration if we lured Giroud or Carroll ! Roy's brief,is to somehow keep us up for yet another season,nothing more,nothing less.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.