You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Culture War
November 8 2026 7.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Culture War


Page 4 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
BlueJay Flag UK 21 Sep 21 2.51pm

Originally posted by rikz

There's a massive difference between racism and systemic racism, I'm sure they've all been called names, along with overweight kids, ginger kids etc in this country it doesn't matter what colour or religion you are, if you work hard enough you can achieve whatever you want.

Sounds like Miss World style idealism.

I would definitely say that in terms of racism we've come a long way are far more reasoned and fair than many countries. With that said, it's easy to decide on someone else behalf that there is little holding them back. It goes without saying that being non white in a largely white society is an additional challenge to face which comes bundled with numerous junk preconceptions, rather than it being some kind of gift that keeps on giving.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 21 Sep 21 2.59pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

The problem with fobbing everything off as 'virtue signalling' is that eventually actual virtue gets thrown in there too since almost every act of decency becomes cynically viewed as some kind of 'put on' designed to influence or dictate to others. It's a perspective that inevitably damages and diminishes the moral compass of anyone making it their mantra.

Exactly this - it's the laziest defence imaginable

 

rikz Flag Croydon 21 Sep 21 2.59pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

Sounds like Miss World style idealism.

I would definitely say that in terms of racism we've come a long way are far more reasoned and fair than many countries. With that said, it's easy to decide on someone else behalf that there is little holding them back. It goes without saying that being non white in a largely white society is an additional challenge to face which comes bundled with numerous junk preconceptions, rather than it being some kind of gift that keeps on giving.

Next time you go in a hospital have a look around at the doctors, next time you walk past a dentist have a quick look inside. British Indians don't seem to have a problem.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 21 Sep 21 3.04pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Yup but a one off is no good it needs to be weekly or a complete withdrawal. I never even noticed it this one how many other people missed it including the social media companies.

It's not just social media players need to go after UEFA and FIFA and their shameless pathetic small fines for whole stadiums abusing players.

Hit em where it hurts, threaten to withdraw from the champions league and international matches. I doubt they will because that means the players will suffer as well.

Well if you want to be taken seriously you have to have skin in the game.

So unless footballers actively seek to harm themselves commercially and professionally (by withdrawing from all major tournaments) they don't really believe it?

It puts the responsibility to solve a problem on people who are not responsible for it - there are lots of causes I support without doing so financially or harming my career - I do not follow that logic that this means I don't really care.

Most of these players have risked a backlash from a percentage of their own club and national team fans to support this cause, for no obvious personal gain.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 21 Sep 21 3.04pm

Originally posted by rikz

There's a massive difference between racism and systemic racism, I'm sure they've all been called names, along with overweight kids, ginger kids etc in this country it doesn't matter what colour or religion you are, if you work hard enough you can achieve whatever you want.

Do people still believe this sh*te?

It's not even true if you're white.

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (21 Sep 2021 3.05pm)

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (21 Sep 2021 3.05pm)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Sep 21 3.18pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

So unless footballers actively seek to harm themselves commercially and professionally (by withdrawing from all major tournaments) they don't really believe it?

It puts the responsibility to solve a problem on people who are not responsible for it - there are lots of causes I support without doing so financially or harming my career - I do not follow that logic that this means I don't really care.

Most of these players have risked a backlash from a percentage of their own club and national team fans to support this cause, for no obvious personal gain.

Yup if you want change you have to be serious about it, that may not be fair but its life.

Dr King and his followers understood that, they went to gaol many times and risked beatings etc. I am not suggesting our players do that but they could start to put pressure on the football authorities and ramp it up if they don't get any action.

If they are not prepared to do that then why should the rest of us bother.

Edited by Badger11 (21 Sep 2021 3.19pm)

 


One more point

rikz Flag Croydon 21 Sep 21 3.23pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Do people still believe this sh*te?

It's not even true if you're white.

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (21 Sep 2021 3.05pm)

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (21 Sep 2021 3.05pm)

How is it not true ?

 

BlueJay Flag UK 21 Sep 21 3.25pm

Originally posted by rikz

Next time you go in a hospital have a look around at the doctors, next time you walk past a dentist have a quick look inside. British Indians don't seem to have a problem.

I'm not sure that being underpaid and working countless hours in a hospital is indication that you're appreciated. Let's take a look at CEOs and see who's path to the top is made easier and who does or doesn't have a problem getting there despite their abilities..

Edited by BlueJay (21 Sep 2021 3.26pm)

 

BlueJay Flag UK 21 Sep 21 3.27pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

So unless footballers actively seek to harm themselves commercially and professionally (by withdrawing from all major tournaments) they don't really believe it?

It puts the responsibility to solve a problem on people who are not responsible for it - there are lots of causes I support without doing so financially or harming my career - I do not follow that logic that this means I don't really care.

Most of these players have risked a backlash from a percentage of their own club and national team fans to support this cause, for no obvious personal gain.

In general I'm not even in favour of pinning identity to online contributions, but it has to be said that facebook, twitter and instagram have a complete monopoly and just don't do enough to stop disruptive and laws breaking individuals from using their product. At least on FB identity is linked to the account. If Instagram and Twitter do the same then they can more easily boot off those only there to behave in such a manner.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 21 Sep 21 3.28pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

I'm not sure that being underpaid and working countless hours in a hospital is indication that you're appreciated. Let's take a look at CEOs and see who's path to the top is made easier and who does or doesn't have a problem getting there despite their abilities..

I'm not saying it's impossible for anyone to make a good life for themself, just that there are of course different and additional challenges along the way and it trivialises the reality to pretend that there isn't.

Yeah let's take a look at CEOs, the majority will tend to be white straight males. 92% of the population is white, its just basic maths isn't it. Let's see who are CEOs in China, India, Thailand, Ghana, Turkey etc o yeah diversity only matters in western countries doesn't it.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 21 Sep 21 3.31pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Yup if you want change you have to be serious about it, that may not be fair but its life.

Dr King and his followers understood that, they went to gaol many times and risked beatings etc. I am not suggesting our players do that but they could start to put pressure on the football authorities and ramp it up if they don't get any action.

If they are not prepared to do that then why should the rest of us bother.

Edited by Badger11 (21 Sep 2021 3.19pm)


I just fundamentally disagree.

If the bar is Dr King, I think you can basically dismiss every cause in modern history.

You can believe in a cause without being MLK.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 21 Sep 21 3.36pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

In general I'm not even in favour of pinning identity to online contributions, but it has to be said that facebook, twitter and instagram have a complete monopoly and just don't do enough to stop disruptive and laws breaking individuals from using their product. At least on FB identity is linked to the account. If Instagram and Twitter do the same then they can more easily boot off those only there to behave in such a manner.

To be clear, I believe social media companies should and could do a lot more to help - my point was that footballers shouldn't have to harm their own pockets for people to believe they're serious.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 21 Sep 21 3.48pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

To be clear, I believe social media companies should and could do a lot more to help - my point was that footballers shouldn't have to harm their own pockets for people to believe they're serious.

I don't disagree, I was just making a more general point really. Yes, I don't think it's reasonable to expect them to flee from platforms that are so embedded into society that it's akin to telling someone not to walk down the street if someone outside calls them the n word. At the same time, it is a balancing act because if we're going to give a reaction to every idiot hurling out slurs then it doesn't make for a very settled life. That's why the platforms should snuff out user and stuff that crosses the line legally.

 

jeeagles Flag 21 Sep 21 3.51pm

Originally posted by rikz

How is it not true ?

Wealth is a bigger factor.

If you've got rich parents you can attend higher achieving schools, where you'll likely get more support and be surrounded by higher achieving pupils who lift each other up.

You'd be able to get into better universities, and get by without the need of part time jobs.

Parental subsidies will be able to assist in allowing wealthier graduates to get on intern schemes rather than graduate schemes, where due to the lack of wage, you'll be exposed to a greater level of experience rather than doing grunt work.

That will then put you in a much better position to get the top jobs.

On top of that, if your parents/social group have better jobs, they'll be able to pass on experience as to how best to navigate difficult situations and office politics.

No matter what your ethnicity, you'll be starting at an advantage if your parents are wealthy and successful.

Despite saying all this, I think that a parents primary goal is to work hard to provide a future for their children. If they want to put the investment in they should be able to. Otherwise you just start a race to the bottom. That's not to say society should do more to help people level up.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 21 Sep 21 3.57pm

Originally posted by rikz


92% of the population is white, its just basic maths isn't it.

"from 2001 to 2011, the percentage of the population of England and Wales that was White British decreased from 87.4% to 80.5%"

I would be interested to know what it is in 2021

Over 50% of FTSE 100 boards have no ethnic representation on their boards. Maths init.


Edited by BlueJay (21 Sep 2021 4.02pm)

 

rikz Flag Croydon 21 Sep 21 3.59pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Wealth is a bigger factor.

If you've got rich parents you can attend higher achieving schools, where you'll likely get more support and be surrounded by higher achieving pupils who lift each other up.

You'd be able to get into better universities, and get by without the need of part time jobs.

Parental subsidies will be able to assist in allowing wealthier graduates to get on intern schemes rather than graduate schemes, where due to the lack of wage, you'll be exposed to a greater level of experience rather than doing grunt work.

That will then put you in a much better position to get the top jobs.

On top of that, if your parents/social group have better jobs, they'll be able to pass on experience as to how best to navigate difficult situations and office politics.

No matter what your ethnicity, you'll be starting at an advantage if your parents are wealthy and successful.

Despite saying all this, I think that a parents primary goal is to work hard to provide a future for their children. If they want to put the investment in they should be able to. Otherwise you just start a race to the bottom. That's not to say society should do more to help people level up.

People are born with massive advantages but in this country it still doesn't stop anyone else achieving what they want. Let's face it most people don't achieve what they want because they're neither intelligent or talented enough and unless you was blessed with good looks then you will more than likely live an average life.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Sep 21 4.00pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow


I just fundamentally disagree.

If the bar is Dr King, I think you can basically dismiss every cause in modern history.

You can believe in a cause without being MLK.

Okay but the players started this and have achieved very little if they want change they have to up the anti.

I made several suggestions but they are just that it's for the players to do something and if it is constructive such as boycotts I have no doubt the public will support them.

Taking the knee has become a formality like players shaking hands before the game and then spending 90 minutes winding each other up.

 


One more point

jeeagles Flag 21 Sep 21 4.08pm

Originally posted by rikz
Yeah let's take a look at CEOs, the majority will tend to be white straight males. 92% of the population is white, its just basic maths isn't it. Let's see who are CEOs in China, India, Thailand, Ghana, Turkey etc o yeah diversity only matters in western countries doesn't it.

Just because other countries aren't as diverse as us doesn't mean we shouldn't be.

I don't believe in quotas for quotas sake. It should be achieved on merit. One of the problems Britain seemed to have going into the 70's were that all the top jobs were reserved for an old school tie clique who didn't necessarily have the skills to be in their positions. If we'd kept a more global outlook then maybe we would have had quite the decline that we did.

If you look at the Premier League we have created the best league in the world by taking the best talent from all around the world.

Also, if people want to promote a strong sense of community values that keep people on the straight and narrow, then it is important to include people. On the Fever Pitch - Rise of the Premier League show Les Ferdinand talks about how he couldn't go to football matches as a kid due to racism. These stories get passed on from parent to child and create an idea that people aren't part of their community based on their race, religion, or origin. This isn't limited to race or religion, I've seen people from Ireland, Scotland, Wales, the north of England, working class backgrounds (who are all white) all make statements about how they are excluded from society. Gestures and action are required to break that preconception. Strong parenting is required, but they can't do this alone, especially if that parent has experience historic discrimination.

As a online community, we aren't helping the situation when claims like "they are diluting the gene pool" aren't helping the situation. All it does is assist in pushing people further to the fringes.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 21 Sep 21 5.11pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Just because other countries aren't as diverse as us doesn't mean we shouldn't be.

I don't believe in quotas for quotas sake. It should be achieved on merit. One of the problems Britain seemed to have going into the 70's were that all the top jobs were reserved for an old school tie clique who didn't necessarily have the skills to be in their positions. If we'd kept a more global outlook then maybe we would have had quite the decline that we did.

If you look at the Premier League we have created the best league in the world by taking the best talent from all around the world.

Also, if people want to promote a strong sense of community values that keep people on the straight and narrow, then it is important to include people. On the Fever Pitch - Rise of the Premier League show Les Ferdinand talks about how he couldn't go to football matches as a kid due to racism. These stories get passed on from parent to child and create an idea that people aren't part of their community based on their race, religion, or origin. This isn't limited to race or religion, I've seen people from Ireland, Scotland, Wales, the north of England, working class backgrounds (who are all white) all make statements about how they are excluded from society. Gestures and action are required to break that preconception. Strong parenting is required, but they can't do this alone, especially if that parent has experience historic discrimination.

As a online community, we aren't helping the situation when claims like "they are diluting the gene pool" aren't helping the situation. All it does is assist in pushing people further to the fringes.

So why are we so diverse compared to other nations ? Why do so many migrants flee to western Europe, North America, Australia, New Zealand ? Maybe its not quite as bad for etthnice minorities in predominantly white Christian countries.

 

jeeagles Flag 21 Sep 21 5.33pm

Originally posted by rikz

So why are we so diverse compared to other nations ? Why do so many migrants flee to western Europe, North America, Australia, New Zealand ? Maybe its not quite as bad for etthnice minorities in predominantly white Christian countries.

As a nation we have excellent values, both historically and in the present day. Some people want to slander our past, but in reality we've always been ahead of most of the the world in terms of equal opportunities, tolerance, and equality.

Christianity does have some real positive welcoming values too. When people mention that we are a white christian country, they are often saying it when they are talking about excluding people from our country because they don't think people from different backgrounds can fit in. That view is country to Christian beliefs, said by people who aren't Christian.

Fact is, that if you are a successful, progressive society, then people will want to come to your country. If you want people to stop wanting to come here, the only real way is to become a regressive state. This isn't to say we shouldn't have controls on allowing people to enter the country - although those entry conditions should be down to ability, and not race or religion.

On top of that, you've pretty much listed all of the developed world as places people go to.... where else would you expect them to go?

 

Page 4 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Culture War