You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > NHS needs a total review
November 21 2026 9.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

NHS needs a total review


Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 15 Dec 22 2.34pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

'The East German health system is widely regarded as the most advanced in the Communist world. It is also considered a model by the West Germans, whose less comprehensive program is threatening to become impossibly expensive'.

Did they have 7 millions waiting for treatment in the DDR?

Socialist states generally have good medical care.

And, of course, the best sex workers.....


Has East Germany reverted to communism then? The communist world - what does that consist of these days.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 15 Dec 22 3.12pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

'The East German health system is widely regarded as the most advanced in the Communist world. It is also considered a model by the West Germans, whose less comprehensive program is threatening to become impossibly expensive'.

Did they have 7 millions waiting for treatment in the DDR?

Socialist states generally have good medical care.

And, of course, the best sex workers.....


I think you have a good point here. In Cuba I know that they have a good health care system but then doctors are only paid a few pounds a day so that's how they afford it, lets implement that policy over here.

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 15 Dec 22 3.31pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Very few students will ever repay the debt, as it incurs ridiculous interest. My daughter has a well paid job, having obtained a masters degree. She is repaying every month but will never repay it in full. Sorry off topic

I understand that. The problem is that many potential students don’t, so it disincentives them. It’s really another tax on the highest earners, those who benefit most from a degree, but it’s widely misunderstood.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 15 Dec 22 3.43pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I understand that. The problem is that many potential students don’t, so it disincentives them. It’s really another tax on the highest earners, those who benefit most from a degree, but it’s widely misunderstood.

Given the nursing profession is so pivotal, and to a certain extent vocational, I would like to see any qualification funded, even if partly, by the Government.

I don't have any idea nor inclination to sufficiently investigate how that may work at any level, or if it currently does, however I think the societal reward would be great enough to justify something at least resembling this. The profession can be highly demanding and as previously mentioned, is an absolute necessity, so therefore the renumeration should reflect this.

A basic understanding of supply+demand should validate this stance however my very, very limited knowledge or insight leads me to believe that the supply is currently both less than the demand and under further threat. I have previously made clear my stance on the NHS and I do fear for it long term if conditions, including management and pay for staff, are not addressed.

Edited by Nicholas91 (15 Dec 2022 3.46pm)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 15 Dec 22 3.45pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I think you have a good point here. In Cuba I know that they have a good health care system but then doctors are only paid a few pounds a day so that's how they afford it, lets implement that policy over here.

I recall that the NHS sent managers to Cuba to study how their health care worked.

Also that the staff of a hospital actually built it from scratch!

 

Stirlingsays Flag 15 Dec 22 3.53pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

I recall that the NHS sent managers to Cuba to study how their health care worked.

Also that the staff of a hospital actually built it from scratch!

You can't get the communists out of your mind at the moment Steely.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 15 Dec 22 3.58pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

I recall that the NHS sent managers to Cuba to study how their health care worked.

Also that the staff of a hospital actually built it from scratch!

Obligation. A mate is married to a Cuban girl and lives there he is always going about Obligation (not sure what the Cuban word is). Basically everybody has to pull their weight for the community.

 


One more point

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 15 Dec 22 6.54pm

Personally I'd never vote for woke liberals like Stalin.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 15 Dec 22 6.59pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

You mentioned this before but I'm not sure that it's true. The role of some nurses has been upscaled into nurse practitioners but not all of them. When I mentioned to my staff nurse wife that you had said that nurses no longer have to feed or toilet patients her response was "I wish"

Does she eerr ya no bring her ummm uniform home some times. Ummm ya no just so like you can like umm look at her and make sure it like fits ok like ya no

Edited by cryrst (15 Dec 2022 7.02pm)

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 15 Dec 22 7.00pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I think you have a good point here. In Cuba I know that they have a good health care system but then doctors are only paid a few pounds a day so that's how they afford it, lets implement that policy over here.

Blimey Russell square would be like a ha ha .

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 15 Dec 22 11.06pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Given the nursing profession is so pivotal, and to a certain extent vocational, I would like to see any qualification funded, even if partly, by the Government.

I don't have any idea nor inclination to sufficiently investigate how that may work at any level, or if it currently does, however I think the societal reward would be great enough to justify something at least resembling this. The profession can be highly demanding and as previously mentioned, is an absolute necessity, so therefore the renumeration should reflect this.

A basic understanding of supply+demand should validate this stance however my very, very limited knowledge or insight leads me to believe that the supply is currently both less than the demand and under further threat. I have previously made clear my stance on the NHS and I do fear for it long term if conditions, including management and pay for staff, are not addressed.

Edited by Nicholas91 (15 Dec 2022 3.46pm)

In many ways the student loan system is a way of the government funding the qualifications as only the highest earners will ever pay it back. However, it's not well understood, and it puts off people, as who wants a large debt around your neck increasing with high interest rates for your working life?

I am conflicted as my wife is a nurse who works in the way we all hope to be cared for, with devotion, skill and compassion. She deserves more money, but I also know that we cannot afford to give her it at the moment. She works in a clinic, but also does bank shifts on wards. How anyone can handle the pressures on some wards is a wonder. Only today I saw three security officers having to restrain a patient. In my youth you would not see a security officer in a hospital! Imagine the Emergency Department at midnight on Saturday, already overrun with delays, having to deal with abusive, aggressive, drunken men and women who have injured one another. Who wants to willingly care for them, let alone show compassion? Yet they do.

I also hear of situations which are very wasteful. Low quality administration managed by unimpressive people. This isn't so unusual in any big organisation, but it still irks to see it.

I don't see a quick and easy solution to any of the issues. Each one will need its own new long term strategy, with an overall destination as the aim. I do though wonder if the current banding system for pay rates needs to be revisited. There are already higher rates in London and the SE. Maybe we need to pay much higher rates to those who work in the most challenging areas, like the ED and neurological wards? Thus reducing the need to pay agency staff at even higher rates. The qualifications are equal, but the work isn't.

I am sure that some costs can be saved by better management, efficient use of resources and technology, but ultimately we are going to have to pay more. I stopped paying NI 13 years ago, but use the NHS more now than ever. That seems to me to be an obvious change that will have to be made before too long.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Dec 22 11.49pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Personally I'd never vote for woke liberals like Stalin.

He's more Blair than Corbyn.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 16 Dec 22 12.09am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

In many ways the student loan system is a way of the government funding the qualifications as only the highest earners will ever pay it back. However, it's not well understood, and it puts off people, as who wants a large debt around your neck increasing with high interest rates for your working life?

I am conflicted as my wife is a nurse who works in the way we all hope to be cared for, with devotion, skill and compassion. She deserves more money, but I also know that we cannot afford to give her it at the moment. She works in a clinic, but also does bank shifts on wards. How anyone can handle the pressures on some wards is a wonder. Only today I saw three security officers having to restrain a patient. In my youth you would not see a security officer in a hospital! Imagine the Emergency Department at midnight on Saturday, already overrun with delays, having to deal with abusive, aggressive, drunken men and women who have injured one another. Who wants to willingly care for them, let alone show compassion? Yet they do.

I also hear of situations which are very wasteful. Low quality administration managed by unimpressive people. This isn't so unusual in any big organisation, but it still irks to see it.

I don't see a quick and easy solution to any of the issues. Each one will need its own new long term strategy, with an overall destination as the aim. I do though wonder if the current banding system for pay rates needs to be revisited. There are already higher rates in London and the SE. Maybe we need to pay much higher rates to those who work in the most challenging areas, like the ED and neurological wards? Thus reducing the need to pay agency staff at even higher rates. The qualifications are equal, but the work isn't.

I am sure that some costs can be saved by better management, efficient use of resources and technology, but ultimately we are going to have to pay more. I stopped paying NI 13 years ago, but use the NHS more now than ever. That seems to me to be an obvious change that will have to be made before too long.

It truly does require a far greater mind, and almost definitely a meeting of many superior minds, than mine and unfortunately my despair/panic, highlighting and griping is of very little use.

There are deep problems at many levels yes, however I would not level any ire at individuals, it seems an accumulative and long term snowballing of issues leading to the current position.

I am, I dare to suggest, at least knowledgeable and cognitively capable to enough of an extent to understand how student loans create some sort of provision for 'funding' these careers however I fear it's not enough to provide real incentive and assurances to those wishing to pursue it. I'd like to see more but again would have not the foggiest as to how this can be achieved beyond far more and significant funding.

Whilst we still do have magnificent individuals, such as your wife, with similar sentiment I fear my expression of the highest admiration and gratitude is not enough. I am still amazed by those who not only fail to offer this but actually 'give them grief' as I would colloquially and ineloquently put it.

I certainly agree that this needs both a holistic, long term strategy proposed alongside short-medium term, tactical solutions aligning to reaching the direction/destination of travel. I can only sincerely hope that resolutions are identified, pursued and achieved before catastrophe really does strike. Once again, my utmost gratitude, to your wife and others, will remain for the time being.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Dec 22 6.13am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle


I also hear of situations which are very wasteful. Low quality administration managed by unimpressive people.

This can be a big problem and over the years many of my wife's colleagues have left because of the way that they have been treated by their managers who are obviously unsuited for the job.

Wifey was entitled to seven weeks holiday a year and her manager wanted her to take them in one week slots outside of school holidays despite have an autistic son at school. After several years I finally managed to persuade her to leave and join another hospital where they would treat her as a human being and not just as an asset.

Last week she volunteered to be seconded to a local hospital for the winter months and arrived to be given just two shifts totalling 14 hours for the first week. When saying to her ward sister (who looks to be in her twenties) that she couldn't survive on 14 hours and needed more shifts the response was "If you don't want to work here you don't have to"

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 16 Dec 22 8.13am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

This can be a big problem and over the years many of my wife's colleagues have left because of the way that they have been treated by their managers who are obviously unsuited for the job.

Wifey was entitled to seven weeks holiday a year and her manager wanted her to take them in one week slots outside of school holidays despite have an autistic son at school. After several years I finally managed to persuade her to leave and join another hospital where they would treat her as a human being and not just as an asset.

Last week she volunteered to be seconded to a local hospital for the winter months and arrived to be given just two shifts totalling 14 hours for the first week. When saying to her ward sister (who looks to be in her twenties) that she couldn't survive on 14 hours and needed more shifts the response was "If you don't want to work here you don't have to"

Awful and ridiculous.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

The Dolphin Flag 16 Dec 22 8.19am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Given the nursing profession is so pivotal, and to a certain extent vocational, I would like to see any qualification funded, even if partly, by the Government.

I don't have any idea nor inclination to sufficiently investigate how that may work at any level, or if it currently does, however I think the societal reward would be great enough to justify something at least resembling this. The profession can be highly demanding and as previously mentioned, is an absolute necessity, so therefore the renumeration should reflect this.

A basic understanding of supply+demand should validate this stance however my very, very limited knowledge or insight leads me to believe that the supply is currently both less than the demand and under further threat. I have previously made clear my stance on the NHS and I do fear for it long term if conditions, including management and pay for staff, are not addressed.

Edited by Nicholas91 (15 Dec 2022 3.46pm)

Train all Doctors, nursing, clinical staff etc.for free.
They sign a Contract before training that they are obligated to work in the NHS for "x" years after they are fully qualified.
Say 5 years for nurses, 10 years for Doctors and so on.
Anyone who leaves - unless through illness - in those periods should have to repay the cost of training which will reduce pro-rata as the cut off date approaches.
This would get more people in the system, better working conditions working with fellow employees rather than agency staff and in the long term save the NHS a fortune because agency staff are charged out at huge rates per day.
This is an idea that could work in my opinion.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 16 Dec 22 8.21am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Train all Doctors, nursing, clinical staff etc.for free.
They sign a Contract before training that they are obligated to work in the NHS for "x" years after they are fully qualified.
Say 5 years for nurses, 10 years for Doctors and so on.
Anyone who leaves - unless through illness - in those periods should have to repay the cost of training which will reduce pro-rata as the cut off date approaches.
This would get more people in the system, better working conditions working with fellow employees rather than agency staff and in the long term save the NHS a fortune because agency staff are charged out at huge rates per day.
This is an idea that could work in my opinion.

Agreed I've been saying this for years and I would extend it to teachers as well. I cannot believe one of the major parties hasn't thought of it.

As long as they stay in the public sector their student loans etc. should be reduced on an annual basis until eventually cleared at which point if they wish to join the private sector so be it.

 


One more point

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 16 Dec 22 8.42am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Train all Doctors, nursing, clinical staff etc.for free.
They sign a Contract before training that they are obligated to work in the NHS for "x" years after they are fully qualified.
Say 5 years for nurses, 10 years for Doctors and so on.
Anyone who leaves - unless through illness - in those periods should have to repay the cost of training which will reduce pro-rata as the cut off date approaches.
This would get more people in the system, better working conditions working with fellow employees rather than agency staff and in the long term save the NHS a fortune because agency staff are charged out at huge rates per day.
This is an idea that could work in my opinion.

Something like that Dolphin certainly.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

The Dolphin Flag 16 Dec 22 8.47am

The reason they won't do it is the initial cost and the fact that politicians only seem to think in terms of 3-5 years.
If this Government started this now it would be a vote winner and people could look forward to a better NHS in 5-10 years time.
Degrees for nurses should be a no no and there should also be a commitment to reduce management staff by say 50% over ten years while at the same time increasing clinical staff by the same amount.
Commit to building "x" hospitals over a ten year period as well.
All enshrined in statute so that if another party pulls the plug they will as such be wrecking the NHS in the eyes of the public.
It is all so easy if they had the guts to implement it

Edited by The Dolphin (16 Dec 2022 8.48am)

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 16 Dec 22 9.00am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

The reason they won't do it is the initial cost and the fact that politicians only seem to think in terms of 3-5 years.
If this Government started this now it would be a vote winner and people could look forward to a better NHS in 5-10 years time.
Degrees for nurses should be a no no and there should also be a commitment to reduce management staff by say 50% over ten years while at the same time increasing clinical staff by the same amount.
Commit to building "x" hospitals over a ten year period as well.
All enshrined in statute so that if another party pulls the plug they will as such be wrecking the NHS in the eyes of the public.
It is all so easy if they had the guts to implement it

Edited by The Dolphin (16 Dec 2022 8.48am)

My feeling is perhaps not 'easy' but certainly do/achievable.

I agree absolutely in the short-termism, as I have mentioned previously, leading to the culmination and aggregation of issues over a longer time span.

The NHS should be almost be segregated entirely from all other matters which are open to political influence and therefore investment. It's all games until you yourself end up in any need of sincere medical help. I wonder how many (politicians etc) have reached something circling an end of life or critical situation stage for themselves or a loved one and perhaps thought the NHS is something to be cherished more so than they had done?

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Page 4 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > NHS needs a total review