You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine
November 22 2026 2.56am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Israel / Palestine


Page 48 of 80 < 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 >
Kermit8 Flag Hevon 30 Jul 14 10.48am

Quote nickgusset at 30 Jul 2014 10.18am

Quote Stirlingsays at 30 Jul 2014 4.55am

Quote nickgusset at 30 Jul 2014 2.33am

[Link]


Here you link to a webpage that I can only describe as anti semitic.

On this page it too claims that Israel 'created' Hamas so that it could have an unacceptable enemy to fight.

You say it only did it to sow division yet you link to a webpage that says it went far beyond that.

From Hamas's wiki page on its creation in 1970.
'Yassin and his charity were completely peaceful towards Israel during this time'.

Israel may or may not have intended to sow division.....But it is completely unproven and nonsense to suggest that Israel intended to create another enemy for itself......Which the page you have linked to states.

It's not anti semitic. It's written by a jew and discusses why it isn't anti semitic.
I think what's interesting is that it states that Hamas leaders who have striven for peace have been bumped off...

The perpetuation of war is very Orwell Ian don't you think?


Edited by nickgusset (30 Jul 2014 10.19am)


Going by the media and even on here it appears that the Israeli apologists/turning a blind eye types are getting fewer by the day. They, at last, are being forced to wake up to an unpalatable and brutal reality which has been going on for many years and which they thought was the preserve of only the do-gooding left to be concerned about which, by default, had meant tacit support from them for Likud's belligerence.

Hopefully, the slaughter and destruction in Gaza by Israel - this time started remember after the murder of those three teenagers NOT by Hamas and not even in or close to Gaza- has woken them from their apathy and they are now rightfully questioning Israel's real motives in the whole mess over the last 18 years since the election after Rabin's assassination.

I remember at the time just before his murder Israel was split roughly 50/50 for the pursuit of peace and a two-state solution.

A few days ago it was reported that nearly 90 per cent support what is happening in Gaza.

That's a massive shift and could help to explain how the government is able to operate now with impunity.

Has Israeli society become more inward looking? Enough to give the thumbs-up to the mass slaughter of children every few years?

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Jul 14 11.00am

Quote Stirlingsays at 30 Jul 2014 4.55am

Quote nickgusset at 30 Jul 2014 2.33am

[Link]


Here you link to a webpage that I can only describe as anti semitic.

On this page it too claims that Israel 'created' Hamas so that it could have an unacceptable enemy to fight.

You say it only did it to sow division yet you link to a webpage that says it went far beyond that.

From Hamas's wiki page on its creation in 1970.
'Yassin and his charity were completely peaceful towards Israel during this time'.

Israel may or may not have intended to sow division.....But it is completely unproven and nonsense to suggest that Israel intended to create another enemy for itself......Which the page you have linked to states.

Israel did encourage and support a fledgling Hamas back in its early days, as it undermined Fatah and the PLO. I don't think it was as deliberate as creating an enemy that was justifiable, but about breaking the power that Fatah, PLO and PFLP held over Gaza and the West Bank.

Ironically Hamas isn't an unacceptable enemy, as the PA works quite closely with the Israeli security. Its fact that the PA has no real capacity to enforce its authority on groups such as the Military wing of Hamas and the assorted spliter cells and factions operating in Palestine and the occupied territories.

Most people fail to realise that Hamas also provides about 60-75% of the welfare, education and housing support to Palestinians.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 30 Jul 14 11.24am

Yep - 80% per cent of Gazans rely on aid to survive since the blockade started 7 years ago. Hamas may not be everyone's cup of tea but if they are helping to feed, healthcheck and school your child then you will be thankful even if you abhor what they stand for.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 30 Jul 14 11.31am

Shady Israeli propaganda initiative #2319: [Link]

I feel like throughout this thread those of us who are siding with the Palestinians have been on the defensive. Arguments tend to go something like:

Nick: "Look at this awful thing Israel are doing"
Matt: "Shut up you lefty Guardianista, I suppose you support Hamas then"
Nick: "No, I dislike Hamas but the crimes Israel are committing are far worse"
Matt: "You basically don't care about innocent Israelis, try going there and leaving the comfort of your own bubble, like I once did"

So I'd like to go on the offensive, with two simple questions...

1) If we are in agreement that there are terrible atrocities being committed by both sides, why is it that the West still supports Israel, both in terms of arms, finance and politics, and how can this be justified?

2) It's easy to call for Hamas to destroy tunnels and their rockets, but this is equivalent to calling for Israel to destroy their iron dome, entire military facility, nuclear weapons programme, end arms ties with the US and end the blockade etc etc. because you are in effect asking a nation at war to totally sever its military capabilities. What would you say a reasonable compromise for the Israelis would be were Hamas/Fatah to agree to what Israel's demands?

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

Stirlingsays Flag 30 Jul 14 11.33am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Jul 2014 11.00am

Quote Stirlingsays at 30 Jul 2014 4.55am

Quote nickgusset at 30 Jul 2014 2.33am

[Link]


Here you link to a webpage that I can only describe as anti semitic.

On this page it too claims that Israel 'created' Hamas so that it could have an unacceptable enemy to fight.

You say it only did it to sow division yet you link to a webpage that says it went far beyond that.

From Hamas's wiki page on its creation in 1970.
'Yassin and his charity were completely peaceful towards Israel during this time'.

Israel may or may not have intended to sow division.....But it is completely unproven and nonsense to suggest that Israel intended to create another enemy for itself......Which the page you have linked to states.

Israel did encourage and support a fledgling Hamas back in its early days, as it undermined Fatah and the PLO. I don't think it was as deliberate as creating an enemy that was justifiable, but about breaking the power that Fatah, PLO and PFLP held over Gaza and the West Bank.

Ironically Hamas isn't an unacceptable enemy, as the PA works quite closely with the Israeli security. Its fact that the PA has no real capacity to enforce its authority on groups such as the Military wing of Hamas and the assorted spliter cells and factions operating in Palestine and the occupied territories.

Most people fail to realise that Hamas also provides about 60-75% of the welfare, education and housing support to Palestinians.


Of course the non charity aspects of Hamas are unacceptable. It is labelled a terrorist group by most democracies as far as I'm aware.

Its constitution is akin to a Nazi one in regards to Jews.

Some of the right in Israel may regard Hamas as an excuse but most are right to see it for what it is.....An organization that if it had the means is an existential threat to their existence.


Edited by Stirlingsays (30 Jul 2014 12.02pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 30 Jul 14 11.42am

Quote Kermit8 at 30 Jul 2014 11.24am

Yep - 80% per cent of Gazans rely on aid to survive since the blockade started 7 years ago. Hamas may not be everyone's cup of tea but if they are helping to feed, healthcheck and school your child then you will be thankful even if you abhor what they stand for.


In a war there is a dehumanization process that occurs. The rocket fire enables Israeli citizens in general have far less sympathy than would be normal.

It is a fear and fight response that is typical of human nature and an easy example can be seen in the general support for civilian bombing campaigns by both the German and British peoples during the second world war.

Hamas declares continual war on Israel with ceasefires/truces only intended as strategy. This gives Israel the right to attack it.....Just not in the fashion it currently is using.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 30 Jul 14 11.44am

If there's a blockade on Gaza, how are they getting the missiles they're firing at Israel?

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 30 Jul 14 11.50am

Another UN School shelter hit by Israel today with 3,000 in the compound

Move over Mladic and Karadzic you blockading, siege- enforcing murdering b@stards. Oh,...wait. My mistake. Not necessary.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Stirlingsays Flag 30 Jul 14 11.57am

Quote serial thriller at 30 Jul 2014 11.31am

Shady Israeli propaganda initiative #2319: [Link]

I feel like throughout this thread those of us who are siding with the Palestinians have been on the defensive. Arguments tend to go something like:

Nick: "Look at this awful thing Israel are doing"
Matt: "Shut up you lefty Guardianista, I suppose you support Hamas then"
Nick: "No, I dislike Hamas but the crimes Israel are committing are far worse"
Matt: "You basically don't care about innocent Israelis, try going there and leaving the comfort of your own bubble, like I once did"

So I'd like to go on the offensive, with two simple questions...

1) If we are in agreement that there are terrible atrocities being committed by both sides, why is it that the West still supports Israel, both in terms of arms, finance and politics, and how can this be justified?

2) It's easy to call for Hamas to destroy tunnels and their rockets, but this is equivalent to calling for Israel to destroy their iron dome, entire military facility, nuclear weapons programme, end arms ties with the US and end the blockade etc etc. because you are in effect asking a nation at war to totally sever its military capabilities. What would you say a reasonable compromise for the Israelis would be were Hamas/Fatah to agree to what Israel's demands?


Israel is a western looking democracy in the middle east that contains millions of Jews with historical/family links to Europe/US. Hence the west is automatically inclined towards it.

Taking out the racial/ideological aspects Israel is protected because the alternative is far worse for the west.

Look at the region....Look at who support and fund the Palestinians outside of the west....Therein lies that answer.

Your other question has already been answered multiple times in this thread.

Hamas's rockets and tunnels don't protect them at all.

Hamas continue with it because fighting Israel militarily is obviously an expression of hate but also because that is what their constitution calls for.

Importantly it is what ensures that they continue to receive funds from the anti semites in Iran and around the Arab and Western world.

As for an Israel compromise for the rockets and tunnels? This doesn't make sense to me. You are seeing the Israeli reaction to rockets and tunnels....They will use the IDF to periodically destroy tunnels and reduce rocket fire......That appears now to be the response for both Labour and Likud.

What is the incentive for Israel to compromise? And tell me.....What is the point of compromising with Hamas for Israel?

They have the military option.

We will probably be seeing rinse and repeat every five years or so.

Edited by Stirlingsays (30 Jul 2014 2.57pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 30 Jul 14 1.57pm

[Link]

 


Pro USA & Israel

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 30 Jul 14 2.42pm

If borders are closed, and the tunnels lead to Israel, where are they getting the rockets from or parts from?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 30 Jul 14 3.02pm

Quote nickgusset at 30 Jul 2014 2.42pm

If borders are closed, and the tunnels lead to Israel, where are they getting the rockets from or parts from?


Arab Israelis from the tunnels pointing towards Israel. Maybe covert Egyptian tunnels that escape the authorities.

The test will once the IDF finish and leave Gaza......Hamas's stockpile must be running low.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 30 Jul 14 5.15pm

I think we should just drop a nuke on the lot of them.

Sorted the japs out.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 30 Jul 14 5.55pm

Quote legaleagle at 30 Jul 2014 9.32am

Quote Stirlingsays at 30 Jul 2014 4.55am

Quote nickgusset at 30 Jul 2014 2.33am

[Link]


Here you link to a webpage that I can only describe as anti semitic.

On this page it too claims that Israel 'created' Hamas so that it could have an unacceptable enemy to fight.

You say it only did it to sow division yet you link to a webpage that says it went far beyond that.

From Hamas's wiki page on its creation in 1970.
'Yassin and his charity were completely peaceful towards Israel during this time'.

Israel may or may not have intended to sow division.....But it is completely unproven and nonsense to suggest that Israel intended to create another enemy for itself......Which the page you have linked to states.


The Israeli government "encouraged" and "used " HAMAS, yes, of that there seems little doubt. To weaken Fatah and "divide and rule" in the occupied territories and to reduce political pressure for a feasible two state solution. HAMAS was happy to be used in the short -term to increase its own strength, "used" Israel for its own ends, and has arguably come out "ahead" in the longer "game". History is littered with unlikely bedfellows being "supportive" to prepare on both sides (as each sees it) better for the end game (viz Nazi-Soviet pact 1939-41).

But, as with so much short-term thinking, the genie has come out of the bottle and bit them back. Just the same as "us" re jihadists in Afghanistan in the late 70's/early 80's against the Soviet Union, "us" encouraging various jihadi groups to use London as a base in the 80's/90's,and in a contemporary context, just like us with groups like ISIS in Syria.

No more, no less.

Edited by legaleagle (30 Jul 2014 9.33am)

Edited by legaleagle (30 Jul 2014 9.34am)

Edited by legaleagle (30 Jul 2014 9.47am)

Excellent post.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Stirlingsays Flag 30 Jul 14 6.10pm

Quote pefwin at 30 Jul 2014 5.55pm

Quote legaleagle at 30 Jul 2014 9.32am


The Israeli government "encouraged" and "used " HAMAS, yes, of that there seems little doubt. To weaken Fatah and "divide and rule" in the occupied territories and to reduce political pressure for a feasible two state solution. HAMAS was happy to be used in the short -term to increase its own strength, "used" Israel for its own ends, and has arguably come out "ahead" in the longer "game". History is littered with unlikely bedfellows being "supportive" to prepare on both sides (as each sees it) better for the end game (viz Nazi-Soviet pact 1939-41).

But, as with so much short-term thinking, the genie has come out of the bottle and bit them back. Just the same as "us" re jihadists in Afghanistan in the late 70's/early 80's against the Soviet Union, "us" encouraging various jihadi groups to use London as a base in the 80's/90's,and in a contemporary context, just like us with groups like ISIS in Syria.

No more, no less.


Edited by legaleagle (30 Jul 2014 9.47am)

Excellent post.


I missed that post.....Yeah, I'd pretty much agree with that.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 30 Jul 14 6.19pm

So do you now agree Stirling, that Israel was in some way responsible for the rise of Hamas in Palestine? something you previously denied.

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 30 Jul 14 6.27pm

Oh dear, I see we have got to the point where criticising the Israeli Government is anti-Semitic.

It seems that the sole issue put forward for the killing spree is Hamas but even Hamas no longer refer to their Charter and it is now often used by Jews to excuse genocide, even though Hamas has changed its views. However Hamas is a violent organisation born out of the violence of the environment.

The current conflict was precipitated by the murder of young adults / youths by both sides, and had nothing to with Hamas. The world attention on MY-17 seen as a good time to bury bad news.

The real issue for Hamas is that in the last 18 months all funding for Hamas has dried up leaving only Qatar as a funding stream. Hamas' time is limited and the issue is that the evil that will take its place is far worse. Without the traditional parties, the relatively moderate Sunni Palestinians will welcome ISIS similar to Sadam Husssein's minority ethnic tribes in Iraq.

Perhaps the economy of Israel has got so intertwined with militarism that they need an enemy to justify the US funding, the required "Lebensraum" and social structures within society.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

ghosteagle Flag 30 Jul 14 6.28pm

Quote pefwin at 30 Jul 2014 6.27pm

Oh dear, I see we have got to the point where criticising the Israeli Government is anti-Semitic.

It seems that the sole issue put forward for the killing spree is Hamas but even Hamas no longer refer to their Charter and it is now often used by Jews to excuse genocide, even though Hamas has changed its views. However Hamas is a violent organisation born out of the violence of the environment.

The current conflict was precipitated by the murder of young adults / youths by both sides, and had nothing to with Hamas. The world attention on MY-17 seen as a good time to bury bad news.

The real issue for Hamas is that in the last 18 months all funding for Hamas has dried up leaving only Qatar as a funding stream. Hamas' time is limited and the issue is that the evil that will take its place is far worse. Without the traditional parties, the relatively moderate Sunni Palestinians will welcome ISIS similar to Sadam Husssein's minority ethnic tribes in Iraq.

Perhaps the economy of Israel has got so intertwined with militarism that they need an enemy to justify the US funding, the required "Lebensraum" and social structures within society.

Excellent post.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 30 Jul 14 6.38pm

Quote nickgusset at 30 Jul 2014 6.19pm

So do you now agree Stirling, that Israel was in some way responsible for the rise of Hamas in Palestine? something you previously denied.


I don't know how I can make it any clearer.

All alone I stated that Israel help create an organization that eventually became what we call Hamas.

You linked to a page that stated that Israel deliberately created an enemy to fight with. Israel didn't create the 'Hamas' we see today whatsoever.

I regard any suggestion along those lines as deliberate misinformation.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 30 Jul 14 6.45pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 30 Jul 2014 6.38pm

Quote nickgusset at 30 Jul 2014 6.19pm

So do you now agree Stirling, that Israel was in some way responsible for the rise of Hamas in Palestine? something you previously denied.


I don't know how I can make it any clearer.

All alone I stated that Israel help create an organization that eventually became what we call Hamas.

You linked to a page that stated that Israel deliberately created an enemy to fight with. Israel didn't create the 'Hamas' we see today whatsoever.

I regard any suggestion along those lines as deliberate misinformation.

Before I posted that link I also intimated that they deliberately set up Hamas for their own ends, you denied this.
Yet you agree with legaleagle who said pretty much the same thing.

 

Page 48 of 80 < 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine