You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We have Zaha
November 16 2026 4.13am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We have Zaha


Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
waterfordpal Flag 29 Aug 21 10.10am

People here have short memories - some of you have made your minds up that Wilf should go and that has affected how you watch the games.
Yesterday he wasn't as brilliant as we know he can be BUT he still had a decent game compared to everyone else- 7 out of 10.
Gallagher also played well BUT wasn't as fantastic as people want to think - 8 out of 10 not 10 out of 10 the way some have described it.
Kouyate MUST go - can't pass to a team mate even when no opposition near him.
Andersen who is a great signing probably had a 5 out of 10 game so why pick on Wilf ?
Be patient and Wilf will still have a very good season.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 29 Aug 21 11.30am

Originally posted by Badger11

I can't find the post but somebody mentioned that Wilf's best form is when he has a partner in crime e.g. Bolaise or Townsend and now Eze.

I think that is spot on when we have another threat apart from Zaha it gives him more space. So with any luck with the players to come into the team Wilf's form should pick up.

Yeah, Eze seemed to be his protégé who he worked well with. Perhaps he'd benefit from being the senior guiding light and it might encourage him to reflect on his own temperament when he considers the influence it may have.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 29 Aug 21 11.35am

The thing about Zaha is that he inevitably attracts two or more defenders thus leaving space for more enterprising support.

The trouble has always been that nobody has taken advantage of this.

Gallagher can fill this role and, even more so, will Eze when he is back, maybe Olise if he is as good as expected.

 

General Flag 29 Aug 21 12.54pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

To be honest Brauny this has been something I've noticed with Wilf for some time now.. a hangover from Roy's way of playing I don't know.. Maybe... But he certainly seems very Conservative these days compared to the Wilf we used to know in my opinion...

It’s called not wasting energy on pointless runs. Or managing a game when forward options are limited or when centre midfielder is not quite in position so lose the ball and counter attack is on. Or many other reasons even Man City do it or Barca do it. Etc etc.

He saved his energy for the cross that created goal number 1.

And the split pass to McArthur for goal number 2.

Keep passing how you do Mr Zaha who is not 19 years old anymore and been kicked or dragged back for near 10 years and can’t be expected to be Messi or Ronald every minute!

 

Mojo87 Flag 29 Aug 21 3.11pm

Originally posted by waterfordpal

People here have short memories - some of you have made your minds up that Wilf should go and that has affected how you watch the games.
Yesterday he wasn't as brilliant as we know he can be BUT he still had a decent game compared to everyone else- 7 out of 10.
Gallagher also played well BUT wasn't as fantastic as people want to think - 8 out of 10 not 10 out of 10 the way some have described it.
Kouyate MUST go - can't pass to a team mate even when no opposition near him.
Andersen who is a great signing probably had a 5 out of 10 game so why pick on Wilf ?
Be patient and Wilf will still have a very good season.


Look stop projecting that folks want Wilf to go, when the REAL short memories here is that Wilf himself wants to go and has repeatedly spoken of his desire to do so on multiple occasions. He put in a transfer request only 2 years ago:

[Link]

And clearly this desire hasn't waivered since then hence Parish's comments early this Summer of what a potential transfer could look like:

[Link]

So it's only natural for there to be detailed scrutiny on his performances each game as folks don't know if his heart is truly in it, especially given how tempermental he is which makes him prone to wearing his heart on his sleeve.

But in terms of performance I thought Zaha had a much better second half but was above average at best. To have an objective assessment of performances, WhoScored ranked Palace players as the following out of 10:

1. Gallagher 8.84
2. Benteke 8.24
3. Ayew 7.70
4. McArthur 7.10
5. Kouyate 6.89
6. Ward 6.64
7. Mitchell 6.63
8. Guaita, Guehi, Zaha 6.54
11. Anderson 6.53

[Link]

BBC had Zaha lowly ranked with only Guaita and Ayew worse:

[Link]

Evening Standard however did give Zaha 7/10 alongside McArthur with Gallagher highest with 8/10:

[Link]

So somewhere along the lines of 6-7 out of 10 seems a fair assessment to his performance yesterday I would say is a balanced view.

Edited by Mojo87 (29 Aug 2021 3.13pm)

 

Zaha127 Flag 29 Aug 21 4.32pm

People are forgetting that Zaha has done great considering the quality of players he had with him.

If you put Zaha in another side with better players e.g. AC Milan he would obviously play a lot more better.

Palace can get the best of him by signing a few other quality players so they aren't reliant on one player.

Olise could be a good signing. Eze of course might take a while to get settled due to the nature of his injury.

If Palace also signed players like Matheus Pereira (before July) and Odsonne Edouard you would also see more goals and assists every week from Zaha. As Pereira would have been a great signing and has a lot of creativity and proven in the EPL. Edouard would also be a decent acquisition.

Edouard, Nketiah or another striker could still be possible.

Gallagher will definitely help can defend and great going forward. Palace are still missing another creative midfielder, another winger potentially and striker of course.

Edited by Zaha127 (29 Aug 2021 4.33pm)

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 29 Aug 21 7.44pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

To be honest Brauny this has been something I've noticed with Wilf for some time now.. a hangover from Roy's way of playing I don't know.. Maybe... But he certainly seems very Conservative these days compared to the Wilf we used to know in my opinion...

tbf if theres nothing ahead of him or 2/3 marking him he is better to go forward than run into a blind alley.

maybe in his youth he woule just try and take on the entire team but maturity has taught him retaining possession is more valuable

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Pete53 Flag Hassocks 02 Sep 21 9.48am

We have Zaha. Yes we do. It's just occurred to me that the transfer window has come and gone and Wilf is still with us. In the past, as closing day approached, we'd be nervously waiting to see he'd stay or go. Not so much this time. I'm not sure if any other club even made any overtures in his direction.

I am pleased he has remained with Palace, with one reservation, that he gives his all this season. With lots of exciting new players around him, and a new coach/manager, hopefully this may lift his spirits.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Sep 21 10.15am

He needs to re-learn his game. Perhaps the new coaching staff can show him the way.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 02 Sep 21 10.36am

It’s better than a move. He’s surrounded with new young stars and a world star player as manager. Most speak french and English AND he’s still got the Palace faithful who keep reminding everyone He’s just too good for you. So Wilf you are at a career changing time. Live up to the song and take us into Europe.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 02 Sep 21 10.40am

New coaching, better players around him, pressure off. Teams don't run the tactic - take out Wilf, take out Palace. He's not that important any more.

Once his ego gets over that, I sincerely hope he can start to enjoy himself and we will see a new Zaha.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 13 Oct 21 6.48am

Interesting that Mark Bright is talking about Wilf to Newcastle making sense: [Link]

Given Bright has Parish's ear this might mean there's something in this. From Wilf's perspective it might be his only real chance (albeit an outside one) of winning a major trophy before he retires.

Vieira seems to have put a bit of fire back in Zaha's belly, but at the same time he also seems to have created a team that with a bit more investment might survive Wilf leaving. Personally I hate what has happened at Newcastle and think it would be sad to see Wilf end up there, but from the club's perspective it might be able to milk far more money from any deal than it might have expected at this stage.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 13 Oct 21 7.08am

With Palace new strategy of high intensity youth it might be a sensible time to let Wilf go. He is performing well and having less tantrums. By the time his contract is up he will be nudging 30. Would he want to drop his earnings like all the other out of contract players had to do? Unlikely. January window will be interesting. It may well be his last chance to join a bigger club that is going to become a huge club. Good luck to him. I can see the logic.

Edited by dreamwaverider (13 Oct 2021 7.11am)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 13 Oct 21 8.36am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

With Palace new strategy of high intensity youth it might be a sensible time to let Wilf go. He is performing well and having less tantrums. By the time his contract is up he will be nudging 30. Would he want to drop his earnings like all the other out of contract players had to do? Unlikely. January window will be interesting. It may well be his last chance to join a bigger club that is going to become a huge club. Good luck to him. I can see the logic.

Edited by dreamwaverider (13 Oct 2021 7.11am)

Do you really think he is performing well? To me he seems to have lost some pace, is reluctant to take people on and frequently misplaces passes. So much so that I am wondering if he is carrying an injury and needs some time on the bench.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 13 Oct 21 10.58am

Newcastle feels like a very real option. They are going to buy, but they won’t be able to attract top top talent, so someone like Zaha (a top half, but not top 4 player) would fit the mould and help them progress.

Meanwhile, whilst I love him, his powers are dropping and if we can get good money for him that we can use to pick up another couple of starlets it could be a good deal for all. And with our current style we are not as dependent on him as we once were.

Its still not the CL football he wants, but its not out of the question that they could get there within a couple of years. City did it in 3 or 4 I think.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 13 Oct 21 11.27am

I've said on here a few times now, that as much as I was a big fan, his days are numbered. He's definitely improved since PV has worked on him, but if Newcastle really are interested, then we should get as much money as we can for him and use it wisely to buy new, young talent. Preferably Gallagher.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 Oct 21 11.41am

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

I've said on here a few times now, that as much as I was a big fan, his days are numbered. He's definitely improved since PV has worked on him, but if Newcastle really are interested, then we should get as much money as we can for him and use it wisely to buy new, young talent. Preferably Gallagher.

Surely this is just agent and media speculation at the moment as the new owners have hardly got their feet under the table yet

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 13 Oct 21 11.45am

Financially a move to Newcastle could benefit Palace and Wilf.

Palace could reasonably expect Newcastle to meet their valuation and Wilf gets probably his last chance of a big transfer related pay day.

From a footballing perspective I'm not sure it ticks Wilf's boxes. It's going to take a while for Newcastle to get the right infrastructure in place and if Champions League football is his ambition I can't see that happening for at least 2-3 years.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 13 Oct 21 11.57am

Its quicker than we'll be able to give it to him!

And he's put himself in the shop window for the last couple of years and nobody has been interested.

This could genuinely be his only shot at a higher level of football

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 13 Oct 21 12.12pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Its quicker than we'll be able to give it to him!

And he's put himself in the shop window for the last couple of years and nobody has been interested.

This could genuinely be his only shot at a higher level of football

It will be quicker than us as I doubt we will ever be able to provide it !

But he has said he wants to leave to play in CL football - even with all the money behind them, there are no guarantees that Newcastle will get there anytime soon.

The move that Wilf wanted was to Arsenal when they were qualifying for the CL . He could be in his early 30's before Newcastle are in that position.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We have Zaha