This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I don't see how. The law appears quite straightforward. The defence about Boris was that it was just a spontaneous event that he got caught up in by mistake. Sunak was even more hard-done by. But in Starmers case, the meal was pre-planned, as evidenced by that memo. You can make the work-related argument for say lunch, which I assumed originally was the case here because you have something to eat and then go back out on the metaphorical cobbles. Who can deny somebody the chance to grab a bite to eat half way through the day? But at the end of the day? You get something to eat on the way home or wait until you are back are your hotel or similar. I would have guessed the safest bet for somebody in Starmers position would have been a packed lunch. He is guilty, based on the letter of the law. Seems pretty clear to me and I suspect the legal advice he had received. So he resigns as a matter of 'principle'. Changes the narrative. The question is who follows him? But I cannot see him surviving this. However, to be fair, I said the same about Johnson but Starmer is not in his league when it comes to this political malarkey.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I suspect Starmer, who remember is a lawyer, is very confident he hasn't broken the law. My understanding is that the rules at the time required you not to socialise indoors with anyone other than your immediate family. There were though exceptions, one of which "if the gathering is reasonably necessary for the purposes of campaigning in an election".
You clearly have not researched this. The use of the campaigning get-out still comes with the proviso of it being only with one other person. Starmer was eating with people, in a pre-planned meal, at the end of a day of campaigning. That most clearly falls outside of the law. As I said, lunch could be excused but why would eating a meal in such a large gathering at the end of the day be justified? Makes little sense. His only defence is the same one that Johnson claimed in that the gathering was a work-related one. And we know how that ended.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I suspect Starmer, who remember is a lawyer, is very confident he hasn't broken the law. My understanding is that the rules at the time required you not to socialise indoors with anyone other than your immediate family. There were though exceptions, one of which "if the gathering is reasonably necessary for the purposes of campaigning in an election". So it would seem that what happened would have been OK, even if it wasn't spontaneous, but pre-planned. Eating together at the end of a long day, and continuing to consider things, is not that unusual when in the middle of a campaign. For me, that's reasonable defence which has enough doubt as to mean no fine will be issued. It's a million miles away from Johnson's blatant disregard for the rules, for which he has already been fined, with more to come. Johnson is also the Prime Minister, whose Government wrote the rules. Starmer isn't. The Tories searching for spoonfuls of mud to throw, when their man is plastered in it from head to toe, seem likely to regret this if, as I expect, nothing happens to Starmer. He has just made life even more difficult for Johnson, and it already looked bad enough. We'll see. Not writing the rules is an odd defence. Not many people accused of any misdemeanours wrote the rules either.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Not writing the rules is an odd defence. Not many people accused of any misdemeanours wrote the rules either. It is the poorest defence of all. You could argue that Downing street is Boris Johnsons place of work. Hence his defence had some credibility. But a constituency office in Durham? If Johnson got fined, based on the law as it was, then I really struggle to see how Starmer escapes. It's the pre-planning of the evening meal that nails him. Clearly not a spontaneous act.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Not writing the rules is an odd defence. Not many people accused of any misdemeanours wrote the rules either. It's not meant to be a defence! It's a fact, though, which matters in the political arena in which they both work. It wouldn't count in a court of law, but it could in the court of public opinion.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
It is the poorest defence of all. You could argue that Downing street is Boris Johnsons place of work. Hence his defence had some credibility. But a constituency office in Durham? If Johnson got fined, based on the law as it was, then I really struggle to see how Starmer escapes. It's the pre-planning of the evening meal that nails him. Clearly not a spontaneous act. Downing St isn't Johnson's only place of work, is it? Nor is it, only his place of work. The primary difference was though that what was organised there has been clearly regarded as being "parties". Social gatherings to mark a departure, or celebrate an event. Starmer was there to campaign. Eating at the end of a day, with those involved, isn't a party.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
You clearly have not researched this. The use of the campaigning get-out still comes with the proviso of it being only with one other person. Starmer was eating with people, in a pre-planned meal, at the end of a day of campaigning. That most clearly falls outside of the law. As I said, lunch could be excused but why would eating a meal in such a large gathering at the end of the day be justified? Makes little sense. His only defence is the same one that Johnson claimed in that the gathering was a work-related one. And we know how that ended. Are you able to provide a link to the regulations as they applied at the time?
|
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
It is not about whether or not any of the events. were a " party ". It is about whether or not the breached the rules in force at the time. Starmer is cynically gambling the Durham police will their precedent of not issuing a fine on a first offence, rather a warning. It is quite pathetic all round on both parties that in a time of significant crisis the political bandwidth is being expended on the semantics of what is a party and whether one tweet past a certain time is enough to constitute work And also, who really gives a hoot? The biggest noise is from the left. Screaming "Daily Mail" slur, diversion tactics, etc. The voters couldn't give a damn. If Starmer gets a fine, he will resign, he has no choice now, but the idiot in charge will continue to be PM.
Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers |
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Are you able to provide a link to the regulations as they applied at the time?
You should not meet with other campaigners indoors. It is safer to meet outdoors, where the risk of catching or spreading COVID-19 is much lower, but 2 metre social distancing should still be maintained. Operational collection and delivery of campaign literature should be handled on a click and drop or doorstep drop procedure as for other goods deliveries during the pandemic. Only rarely will two people be required indoors at the same location to manage bulk delivery handling. You should keep these interactions to a minimum to reduce contact and follow the guidance on how to stop the spread of coronavirus at all times As far as my non-qualified understanding of the law is, this negates any claims about necking a curry with a load of other people from your political party as being an intrinsic part of campaigning but, as always, happy to be corrected.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
It is not about whether or not any of the events. were a " party ". It is about whether or not the breached the rules in force at the time. Starmer is cynically gambling the Durham police will their precedent of not issuing a fine on a first offence, rather a warning. It is quite pathetic all round on both parties that in a time of significant crisis the political bandwidth is being expended on the semantics of what is a party and whether one tweet past a certain time is enough to constitute work Exactly if he is guilty he will receive a ticking off same as Cummings did. He can then say that's not the same as a fine so not guilty. It's a lawyers trick. If he is guilty of course.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
You should not meet with other campaigners indoors. It is safer to meet outdoors, where the risk of catching or spreading COVID-19 is much lower, but 2 metre social distancing should still be maintained. Operational collection and delivery of campaign literature should be handled on a click and drop or doorstep drop procedure as for other goods deliveries during the pandemic. Only rarely will two people be required indoors at the same location to manage bulk delivery handling. You should keep these interactions to a minimum to reduce contact and follow the guidance on how to stop the spread of coronavirus at all times As far as my non-qualified understanding of the law is, this negates any claims about necking a curry with a load of other people from your political party as being an intrinsic part of campaigning but, as always, happy to be corrected. It seems that was updated. This is from the BBC:- "On 30 April, England was under "Step 2" rules, which had been introduced on 12 April. Gathering indoors with people from outside your household or support bubble was against the law. There was an exemption for "work purposes", although working from home was recommended in the guidance, but the rules did not mention socialising at work. And there was an exemption if "the gathering is reasonably necessary for the purposes of campaigning in an election"."
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
You should not meet with other campaigners indoors. It is safer to meet outdoors, where the risk of catching or spreading COVID-19 is much lower, but 2 metre social distancing should still be maintained. Operational collection and delivery of campaign literature should be handled on a click and drop or doorstep drop procedure as for other goods deliveries during the pandemic. Only rarely will two people be required indoors at the same location to manage bulk delivery handling. You should keep these interactions to a minimum to reduce contact and follow the guidance on how to stop the spread of coronavirus at all times As far as my non-qualified understanding of the law is, this negates any claims about necking a curry with a load of other people from your political party as being an intrinsic part of campaigning but, as always, happy to be corrected. No, not these regulations. Those that apply to employees at their work place please.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
This whole affair just shows how petty and farcical politics in this country has become. Those in government get there every minutae of their life judged, regardless of the job their doing(and I'm not saying the current lot have done a good job btw), whilst the sole purpuose of the opposition is to point fingers and say 'look what they've done wrong'. Finding it mighty humourous that partygate has come back to bite Starmer in a karmic episode only before seen on 'My name is Earl'. Someone mentioned their are some good MPs/Politicians out there, I can't see any from where I'm standing. And certainly none of them are running for or are being elected to Party Leader status. I've been banging his drum for years, but Dan Jarvis is now MP for Barnsley having given up the mayoral role for South Yorkshire. He is so obvious a candidate it hurts. So obvious, indeed, that the party will chose another unelectable numpty as part of their unwritten policy of periodic shoot-in-own-foot.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
No, not these regulations. Those that apply to employees at their work place please. Sorry. A bit confused. Starmer was up in Durham to take part specifically in political campaigning. There were rules relating to that, as I have listed them. Starmer clearly broke those rules. Now you could make an argument that Starmer was actually working but by his own admission, he was in Durham specifically for the purpose of political campaigning. But lets go with the idea that this was a works event. The alleged breach occurs after the 'work' has been completed with a team meal booked in advance for that based on the leaked memo. Organised by any definition. Therefore he is guilty as charged. Just as Johnson was.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
They're no Eric and Ernie, that's for sure.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.