This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by W12
Not mine mate and calling it democracy is just sophistry If the will of the people is not carried out then we are dictated to by someone else's "collective wisdom" The fact that the majority have always been against mass immigration is probably the greatest example of this. Like it or not, it is yours, just as it is everyone's in the UK. Your duty is to help choose the MP who you send to represent you. Once done, they take over. Don't like what they do? Change them after 5 years.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Your opinion. I suspect that most voters expect their MPs to carry out what they said in their manifestos and when they don't and they fail to call for a by election the voters punish them at the next opportunity. I presume you saw nothing wrong in Nick Clegg and the Lib Dems abandoning a key pledge to abolish tuition fees because in your words "What you might expect of an MP makes no difference to what their job actually is." Funny because the electorate disagreed with you Clegg and his gang were sacked at the earliest available opportunity. To repeat I am not against an MP changing their mind on a major policy or deciding to joining another party but if they expect the public to support them they need to do the decent thing and resign and fight a by election on that issue. By the way your view on MPs stems from Edmund Burke who said it after he was elected and then got sacked at the next GE. He's was just an opinion as well, Burke is often quoted by both sides however he also did some pretty representable things maybe in the future MPs will quote Boris, who knows. Edited by Badger11 (08 Jun 2022 9.30am) What people expect of their MP is reflected in how they vote. That's their right and many MPs, being fearful of that, take heed of it. However, their over-riding responsibility is to their conscience and the need to do what it tells them is best for their constituents and the country. There have been countless rebels over the years, refusing to vote for policies they disagreed with. Nick Clegg and the LibDems changed policy on tuition fees, so we could have a functioning government, not because they believed they were right. They were widely misunderstood over that, and paid the price demanded by a misguided (think the Daily Mail) electorate, just as the Brexit rebels did. No MP need resign just because he falls out with his party. We elect MPs, not parties or labels. I fully understand that's not how most think, but it is nevertheless correct. I know where the definition of a MP's role was first clarified but Churchill confirmed it years later and it is now the accepted principle by all, except the hard left.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
What people expect of their MP is reflected in how they vote. That's their right and many MPs, being fearful of that, take heed of it. However, their over-riding responsibility is to their conscience and the need to do what it tells them is best for their constituents and the country. No MP need resign just because he falls out with his party. We elect MPs, not parties or labels. I fully understand that's not how most think, but it is nevertheless correct. I know where the definition of a MP's role was first clarified but Churchill confirmed it years later and it is now the accepted principle by all, except the hard left. I thought that was the job of the Whips.......
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
What people expect of their MP is reflected in how they vote. That's their right and many MPs, being fearful of that, take heed of it. However, their over-riding responsibility is to their conscience and the need to do what it tells them is best for their constituents and the country. There have been countless rebels over the years, refusing to vote for policies they disagreed with. Nick Clegg and the LibDems changed policy on tuition fees, so we could have a functioning government, not because they believed they were right. They were widely misunderstood over that, and paid the price demanded by a misguided (think the Daily Mail) electorate, just as the Brexit rebels did. No MP need resign just because he falls out with his party. We elect MPs, not parties or labels. I fully understand that's not how most think, but it is nevertheless correct. I know where the definition of a MP's role was first clarified but Churchill confirmed it years later and it is now the accepted principle by all, except the hard left. Please show where in the constitution it outlines an MPs role and responsibility? It doesn't and should. So you have an opinion on how MPs should operate and so have I and until Parliament or the courts define it they are simply opinions. However I stand by mine when ever MPs betray the electorate they are sacked at the next opportunity so I suggest your opinion may not be in line with the rest of the voters.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by becky
I thought that was the job of the Whips....... They often seem to think so, but no it isn't. The whips job is to try to minimise rebellions on behalf of the government, often by using threats and promises. Theirs is an unsavoury occupation. Though I suspect you already accept that and were just having a little dig.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Please show where in the constitution it outlines an MPs role and responsibility? It doesn't and should. So you have an opinion on how MPs should operate and so have I and until Parliament or the courts define it they are simply opinions. However I stand by mine when ever MPs betray the electorate they are sacked at the next opportunity so I suggest your opinion may not be in line with the rest of the voters. As we don't have a constitution, that's obviously impossible. What your, my and any other voter's opinion of this might be is largely irrelevant. What matters is how those elected understand their role, and that has been defined for them by their leaders over the centuries. If it matters so much, then enough people need to return candidates prepared to make this an issue and have it legally defined the way you think fit. Until then our MPs will go on behaving as their conscience dictates. Some already hold to your approach. That's their decision, but others don't and that's theirs too. MPs who use their conscience to reach decisions don't "betray" their voters! Quite the reverse! They aren't sheep. You might as well send a voting machine to Parliament and save a lot of expense. We need people to think, challenge and rebel on occasions. You didn't like the one in question, but there will come a time when you do, and will be very grateful your MP is fully engaged.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
As we don't have a constitution, that's obviously impossible. What your, my and any other voter's opinion of this might be is largely irrelevant. What matters is how those elected understand their role, and that has been defined for them by their leaders over the centuries. If it matters so much, then enough people need to return candidates prepared to make this an issue and have it legally defined the way you think fit. Until then our MPs will go on behaving as their conscience dictates. Some already hold to your approach. That's their decision, but others don't and that's theirs too. MPs who use their conscience to reach decisions don't "betray" their voters! Quite the reverse! They aren't sheep. You might as well send a voting machine to Parliament and save a lot of expense. We need people to think, challenge and rebel on occasions. You didn't like the one in question, but there will come a time when you do, and will be very grateful your MP is fully engaged. The OBE is in the post
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Of course I don't know all their thoughts. What I know is what I heard and saw, and that is what I am describing. They acted with integrity, putting their over-riding commitment to always act in what they believe is the best interests of the country above any thoughts of self-preservation. They knew the consequences, but their consciences did not allow them to be swayed. We need more people like that, and far less lobby sheep. So brexit mps who believe it is in the uk’s best interest are all wrong.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
So brexit mps who believe it is in the uk’s best interest are all wrong. They are probably not proper MPs and shouldn’t be in office. Trade unionists and rebel rousers most likely.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
They are probably not proper MPs and shouldn’t be in office. Trade unionists and rebel rousers most likely. I’m sure they won in a local election….!
|
|
| W12 08 Jun 22 7.57pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
As we don't have a constitution, that's obviously impossible. What your, my and any other voter's opinion of this might be is largely irrelevant. What matters is how those elected understand their role, and that has been defined for them by their leaders over the centuries. If it matters so much, then enough people need to return candidates prepared to make this an issue and have it legally defined the way you think fit. Until then our MPs will go on behaving as their conscience dictates. Some already hold to your approach. That's their decision, but others don't and that's theirs too. MPs who use their conscience to reach decisions don't "betray" their voters! Quite the reverse! They aren't sheep. You might as well send a voting machine to Parliament and save a lot of expense. We need people to think, challenge and rebel on occasions. You didn't like the one in question, but there will come a time when you do, and will be very grateful your MP is fully engaged. So we are a constitutional monarchy that doesn’t have a constitution?
|
|
| W12 08 Jun 22 8.03pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Yes I agree. In reference to both your own comments and PV's, even the slightest notion of a logical objection to this can be tarred with that brush, or in fact will be by many. If, for instance, thousands upon thousands of young white Americans or let's say Europeans started pouring into the country, daily, almost exclusively through illegal means would it the be considered 'racist' or otherwise to say 'Hold on a second, perhaps this isn't too dandy'? That’s not the argument. The argument is about power. If there is democracy then the will of the people is enacted. If it isn’t then there simply is no democracy. It would be the same on any other major issue.
|
|
|
Originally posted by W12
So we are a constitutional monarchy that doesn’t have a constitution?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
No, not at all. I believe a cultural homogony, belief system and value set are necessary for a nation to thrive and for individuals as well. I also believe very much of the grey in between the two ends of the spectrum, as I do many things. I do not nor will ever support the demonization, persecution etc of any set of peoples based on nothing more than ethnicity, background etc. I feel that this is necessary to mention these days. But that is separate to logical, rational or otherwise motivated 'beefs' with certain sets of people. All must be judged on their behaviours and what they themselves espouse. You should never have 'carte blanche' to live as you so wish whether that be claimed on grounds of race, religion, ideology or otherwise. A common sense approach should be taken to all matters. To the same extent I do not believe that the idea of some sort of world village, no matter what sort of egalitarian or utopian belief system supports it, is within any realms of reason and therefore possibility. It seems very much to be what some are proposing these days which is, for lack of articulation, pure f**king stupidity and ignorance of human beings in my book. I'm not saying all people are evil but as cynical as it may seem, I do believe enough are, across the spectrum. Men have been trying to kill each-other off since the dawn of time, I'd like to please be pointed as to where this has changed? In short: You want to hurl racist and xenophobic abuse at my 'BAME' or any other identity neighbours, yeah you and I will have a problem! You want me to accept the mass migration of every corner of the world onto my tiny island alongside a complete pass for these people to live as they so choose as 'it's what they believe'? No, I completely reject that. I'd say there is a lot of common sense in your commentary. It's certainly wrong to 'blame' or abuse people for their genetics. However, the neo liberal state is fully committed to the world village. Any objection to that future is regarded as 'hate' or 'abuse'. For an example, look at what happened to those cricketers in Yorkshire. Does anyone serious outside of the usual suspects really believe that Asians were subjected to 'hate' or 'abuse'? Yet look at what the state and the institutions made happen.....they didn't even really care about the truth, the accusations were all they needed. The same tactics are used if you point out things you might not agree with over the Israeli state these last seventy years (not that these are arguments I tend to make). The system is set up in such a way that those criticisms will see you branded an 'antisemite'. You will suddenly see people who disagree using words like 'hate' and 'abuse'. You will be subjected to the Maoist practice of being told what you really think instead of your actual words speaking for themselves....instead they will 'interpret' those words for you. Whether it's a debate on race or gender or anything else the current power structure wants, it's a tactic used to head off actual debate or justify whatever the system wants to punish you with for ideas it fears. I think it's a valid question to ask how we got here.....why we got here....and where are we going....and is any of that an improvement and if so....for whom. Because Nicholas it has to be stated, the system that raised me was fully committed to exactly the beliefs as you stated them....I'd describe them as the Martin Luther King Jr mindset....or what it's called in my circles, 'boomer truth'. It is that exact same system that led us to exactly this place now. Personally I think we are living in an age where there is a disconnect between what people like me were brought up to believe in....that kind of Martin Luther King Jr, 'I have a dream' speech and what actually occurred once all the boomer egalitarians enacted their ideas. As I say I was raised on those same 'boomer truths' and ideals. I advocated for them for most of my adult life. Things changed in my approach only when I actually paid attention to what was actually happening. What the actual laws and institutions started to resemble. I think that point is very important...actually connecting the rhetoric to what the consequences to them were are on the ground once it was implemented. I don't see that as an accident or incidental at all. It was always what was going to happen. We both lived in Lewisham and its surrounding areas. So we both know what the holistic realities are once the demographics were made to change....the crime rate, the change in social cohesion, the actual real group loyalties and allegiances. You only have to look at the areas on a before and after basis. Look at Detroit in the 1950s and now, or Luton or Brixton then and now. Look at how things are run, from the rubbish on the streets to the actual lack of diversity on them....because the boxer Ali was definitely right about actual group living dynamics. To me, you have to either be on the far left and anti white or a complete and utter utopian to see think the harmonious global village is going to work...they can't point to any location on earth where it does and few of them will live in those locations. Yet they will still point to their 'I have a dream' ideas like a Disney fan holds onto a world of Princesses and ivory towers....or perhaps for the modern Disney degenerate, drag queens dancing for children. They know what they want the world to be like and so they will keep saying what they believe regardless of what the reality is.....like the rich gated communities in LA, who keep voting Democrat just as long as their secured patch is kept safe from the consequences of those votes outside the gates. I regard it as the difference between a utopian and a utilitarian. They don't care about the holistic reality, only their reality and the conceit of virtue signalling to fit in with their political peers. Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Jun 2022 9.38pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
So brexit mps who believe it is in the uk’s best interest are all wrong. They are as entitled to their opinion as I am to mine. It seems an established fact that in 2016 a majority of MPs favoured us remaining in the EU whilst, after a "campaign" on the issue, the electorate voted to leave by a narrow margin. As others have pointed out, the reasons why they did so often had little to do with whether our membership was wise, or not. For me this has always raised the question on why we held a referendum on such a specialised matter when we pay our representatives to study, debate and consult, so they can take an informed decision on our behalf. Who do we trust? Our MPs, or the people after they have been exposed to vested interests, the Daily Mail and Russian troll farms? Neither are perfect, but on balance I trust our MPs much more than the Daily Mail or the Russians. Our own security forces were telling the government the result was compromised, but they feared political annihilation by Farage so decided not to act. So we left the EU not because our MPs thought it was in our best interests to do so, but to save the Tory Party. Cameron, and to a lesser extent May, will go down in history as the PMs who set the UK back for decades. That their successor is a self-serving opportunist just makes things worse.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by W12
So we are a constitutional monarchy that doesn’t have a constitution? Correct. We don't have a written constitution, but we do have Acts of Parliament (and common laws) which are vested in an elected Parliament. The Monarch signs them into law, but has no influence over them. The Monarch reigns, but does not rule.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I'd say there is a lot of common sense in your commentary. It's certainly wrong to 'blame' or abuse people for their genetics. However, the neo liberal state is fully committed to the world village. Any objection to that future is regarded as 'hate' or 'abuse'. For an example, look at what happened to those cricketers in Yorkshire. Does anyone serious outside of the usual suspects really believe that Asians were subjected to 'hate' or 'abuse'? Yet look at what the state and the institutions made happen.....they didn't even really care about the truth, the accusations were all they needed. The same tactics are used if you point out things you might not agree with over the Israeli state these last seventy years (not that these are arguments I tend to make). The system is set up in such a way that those criticisms will see you branded an 'antisemite'. You will suddenly see people who disagree using words like 'hate' and 'abuse'. You will be subjected to the Maoist practice of being told what you really think instead of your actual words speaking for themselves....instead they will 'interpret' those words for you. Whether it's a debate on race or gender or anything else the current power structure wants, it's a tactic used to head off actual debate or justify whatever the system wants to punish you with for ideas it fears. I think it's a valid question to ask how we got here.....why we got here....and where are we going....and is any of that an improvement and if so....for whom. Because Nicholas it has to be stated, the system that raised me was fully committed to exactly the beliefs as you stated them....I'd describe them as the Martin Luther King Jr mindset....or what it's called in my circles, 'boomer truth'. It's is that exact same system that led us to exactly this place now. Personally I think we are living in an age where there is a disconnect between what people like me were brought up to believe in....that kind of Martin Luther King Jr, 'I have a dream' speech and what actually occurred once all the boomer egalitarians enacted their ideas. As I say I was raised on those same 'boomer truths' and ideals. I advocated for them for most of my adult life. Things changed in my approach only when I actually paid attention to what was actually happening. What the actual laws and i1nstitutions started to resemble. I think that point is very important...actually connecting the rhetoric to what the consequences to them were are on the ground once it was implemented. I don't see that as an accident or incidental at all. It was always what was going to happen. We both lived in Lewisham and its surrounding areas. So we both know what the holistic realities are once the demographics were made to change....the crime rate, the actual real group loyalties and allegiances. You only have to look at the areas on a before and after basis. Look at Detroit in the 1950s and now, or Luton or Brixton then and now. Look at how things are run, from the rubbish on the streets to the actual lack of diversity on them....because the boxer Ali was definitely right about actual group living dynamics. To me, you have to either be on the far left and anti white or a complete and utter utopian to see think the harmonious global village is going to work...they can't point to any location on earth where it does and few of them will live in those locations. Yet they will still point to their 'I have a dream' ideas like a Disney fan holds onto a world of Princesses and ivory towers. They know what they want the world to be like and so they will keep saying what they believe regardless of what the reality is.....like the rich gated communities in LA, who keep voting Democrat just as long as their secured patch is kept safe from the consequences of those votes outside the gates. I regard it as the difference between a utopian and a utilitarian. They don't care about the holistic reality, only their reality and the conceit of virtue signalling to fit in with their political peers. Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Jun 2022 8.11pm) Ha, thanks for getting back to me. Yep I agree with a lot of that. I think for myself, the overriding thought of recent times has been that what has been raised or idealised by the 'hoi polloi', you know, 'let's try and be nice to one-another' etc has indeed by weaponised and scaled by malevolent entities. Therefore whilst basic tenets should not be lost neither should they be surrendered to malignant forces, which I am inclined to believe there is ample evidence to prove has occurred in many corners. The highlighted is very much an example of this, you know, 'we are proposing x which we will proclaim as virtue however impose it to a degree that of course benefits us and includes the demonisation of those who in anyway don't toe the line, which you know, may disrupt that which we seek to profit from'. I have long stated that what we are seeing prevalent in society these days is not a result of egalitarianism at all, it's for profit. I desperately want to believe in the good and intelligence of people however I am constantly staggered, bemused, left disillusioned and so on by many others. You only have to take to the likes of Twitter to start questioning whether or not you are in some sort of matrix, where other people are computer generated as you cannot fathom what runs through their minds... if anything... or more precisely anything of their own creation. I think many actually are on Twitter if you believe Elon! I'm not saying that all people do not have different perspectives, experiences, make mistakes, articulate themselves poorly or even change from time to time but the complete submission to what is more and more becoming somewhat an Orwellian nightmare however is unnerving at the very, very least. As previously mentioned, for me there is a huge and very obvious chasm between 'don't be racist' and 'lets encourage and facilitate for the entire world to come to England, or more notably London'. That's two different notions/things entirely. I will forever fight for what I believe to be 'common sense' and just as previously mentioned, no I don't believe you can abuse anyone for things that are not relevant to your experience, but neither should you submit to anything other than 'what makes sense' for yet more lack of articulation. 'Be nice to people' - yes. 'The unregulated acceptance of the rest of the world and it's social/moral/religious etc. systems into your society without any questioning' - no.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by W12
But the fact that it’s not “codified” (not sure where that world came from but sounds suspiciously post modern) doesn’t mean it’s not law and it’s not written down. We do 100% have a constitution. Only if post-modernism includes the past 200 years.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.