This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Mathers
I agree. Vieira binned Derry as he was threatened by him. This squad need some harsh words and very quickly to ensure we don’t go down. PV’s ridiculous set up of playing high wing backs to cross the ball to nobody was the final straw. The bloke is absolutely clueless. There are managers in league 2 with better grip of the hand the him It certainly sounds like a theory, I agree regarding Gallagher however do not disagree too strenuously on other points but must add I have one myself: The centre of my thinking atm is that PV inherited an old 'Roy' team. One that was well drilled, resistant and resilient just lacking in attacking threat or any flair. I thought, with additions, PV built upon this by loosening us up a bit and we started to look like a team both with the inherited sturdiness but a bit more going forward. I did note this early doors as well must say. I gave PV a fair amount of credit then as there was quite an overhaul in playing staff too. For me, now, we have two fantastic CBs however do not have that sturdiness as a unit therefore weaker at the back, do not have a solid enough foundation for the attacking players and look absent of tactical instruction. Hence the lack of attacking threat, goals and subsequently any win for a very long time. I saw an interesting piece suggesting PV's Nice downfall was due to an absence of 'identity' for his football and subsequently the team. Sounds very familiar. Many used to bemoan Roy's 'style' however I'd struggle to even articulate our identity or approach under PV. There's no leadership on or off the pitch and we do not even look to ever have a game plan, style or even notion as to how to threaten the opposition's goal. PV has shown nothing to me that suggests he has any pragmatism, answers or even tricks up his sleeve to turn around our fortunes. I understand those saying he will not get sacked however I fear when he does leave, which he will soon, it may well be the overwhelming and obvious to state it should have been sooner. If things are not going to change then I can soon see us threatening records for longest PL run without a win and ultimately up excrement's creek without a paddle. A fitting idiom given we will be in the relegation battle and bereft of any other options beyond a new manager performing miracles. Shoot that down if you choose to however I do not see much evidence to the contrary. We're on a one-way road here and it's going steeply downhill without even a glimmer of hope from my perspective. We were very lucky vs BHA and I honestly thought we looked slightly better against L'pool, despite them being very very poor, however even that inspiration has quickly been stomped out. It's almost nostalgic for me as I haven't been this worried for Palace for a while. Edited by Nicholas91 (05 Mar 2023 12.00am)
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
It certainly sounds like a theory, I agree regarding Gallagher however do not disagree too strenuously on other points but must add I have one myself: The centre of my thinking atm is that PV inherited an old 'Roy' team. One that was well drilled, resistant and resilient just lacking in attacking threat or any flair. I thought, with additions, PV built upon this by loosening us up a bit and we started to look like a team both with the inherited sturdiness but a bit more going forward. I did note this early doors as well must say. I gave PV a fair amount of credit then as there was quite an overhaul in playing staff too. For me, now, we have two fantastic CBs however do not have that sturdiness as a unit therefore weaker at the back, do not have a solid enough foundation for the attacking players and look absent of tactical instruction. Hence the lack of attacking threat, goals and subsequently any win for a very long time. I saw an interesting piece suggesting PV's Nice downfall was due to an absence of 'identity' for his football and subsequently the team. Sounds very familiar. Many used to bemoan Roy's 'style' however I'd struggle to even articulate our identity or approach under PV. There's no leadership on or off the pitch and we do not even look to ever have a game plan, style or even notion as to how to threaten the opposition's goal. PV has shown nothing to me that suggests he has any pragmatism, answers or even tricks up his sleeve to turn around our fortunes. I understand those saying he will not get sacked however I fear when he does leave, which he will soon, it may well be the overwhelming and obvious to state it should have been sooner. If things are not going to change then I can soon see us threatening records for longest PL run without a win and ultimately up excrement's creek without a paddle. A fitting idiom given we will be in the relegation battle and bereft of any other options beyond a new manager performing miracles. Shoot that down if you choose to however I do not see much evidence to the contrary. We're on a one-way road here and it's going steeply downhill without even a glimmer of hope from my perspective. We were very lucky vs BHA and I honestly thought we looked slightly better against L'pool, despite them being very very poor, however even that inspiration has quickly been stomped out. It's almost nostalgic for me as I haven't been this worried for Palace for a while. Edited by Nicholas91 (05 Mar 2023 12.00am) I really do not believe that the departure of Vieira is imminent.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I really do not believe that the departure of Vieira is imminent. I did say ‘I understand… he won’t be sacked’ but also by ‘soon’ I’d clarify that as at the very least not ending next season with PV in charge but possibly this season. I’d also ask when does it become imminent then Willo? We’re 6 points off bottom and 7 away from the team above us. There’s less points between bottom of the table than us moving up it even one place. It’ll be nothing short of miraculous for us to get a win in the next three games so in the likely circumstance we do not it’s what 3 months without a win? Still the lowest work rate in league? Going entire games without registering a single effort on target consistently. No first half goals this year. Not scoring from open play. Hardly any goals at all this calendar year. At what point do the board say ‘this clearly isn’t working’ and decide to change things? That’s all without commentating or critiquing the actual performances, analysing the mangers decisions etc. I honestly don’t see where any optimism can be drawn from. It’s not an emotional assertion from me it really is more ‘well this is all horribly buggered’. There can only be one answer to try and mitigate that where we are now.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I really do not believe that the departure of Vieira is imminent. Willo, you're becoming very zen lately. I remember, not long ago, when a horrible Palace loss like today would have you cancelling your dinner reservations. What is the secret to your newfound serenity? I could use some of it!
2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro |
|
|
Originally posted by Vaibow
It's very simple, PV wants to be the cool, calm silent type... That's all very well, said and done if you actually have the experience, knowledge the back it up... A club like palace, we need passion and grit. that's our DNA. Transitioning into the poised, elegant team takes time, money and a lot of experience. We need someone 'like' Fat Sam - rally the tools, utilize what we have and get them playing to their strengths, he has the knowledge. PV doesn't have the experience, he doesn't have plan B, he's not up for the fight. Last year was amazing, but we had players working as a unit and enjoying themselves - we don't have 2 players who were beneficial in that... we have players off the boil and we don't have leadership. I said this before, say it again. If we stay up, we need to assume we got relegated, get rid of dead wood... then rebuild as if we got promoted and want to beat the drop on a realistic budget... be open to fans and share the rebuild that we need to do... but with an experienced manager. I agree with what you have said , this was suppose to be a “process” aswell as de boer , we have tried to change to be more better playing style on the eye but it just doesn’t work for a team like us unless you spend heavily, vieras continuous refusal to play edouard is mind boggling now , We lose next 2 games he gets sacked , because losing to Brighton will turn the fan base absolutely toxic and against him .
“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder |
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
You can't win games if you don't score goals. Been saying that about Zaha, Eze and Olise since the start of the season. Agree 100% with your comments :-(
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I really do not believe that the departure of Vieira is imminent. Touch complacent??
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
I’m going to cut Vieira some slack. He’s tried Eze left of midfield, attacking midfield and left of a front three. I didn’t agree with continual experiment of Schlupp in central midfield, but even there Vieira could argue that other options available at the time (Luka, Jairo, Hughes) didn’t have the required mobility or drive that he required. Of course Vieira is the manager and carries ultimate responsibility, but what can you do if the players continually let you down? But the players dont let him down, he lets them down, with his laxidasical approach to the roll as manager, players being played all over the place, a lack of using Hughes and McArthur, ridiculous post and pre match comments, the man is a fantasist and not a realist, he will lazily stroll us into relegation.
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by Wilbraham413
If you were to engage in conversation with my dear wife she would confirm that there was certainly no 'Serenity' in the Willo abode after today's result. Whilst there were no dinner reservations, she decided that it would be in her own interests not to accompany me for a tipple in a local Public House. The tone of my sentiments on HOL masked my inner feelings.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
If you were to engage in conversation with my dear wife she would confirm that there was certainly no 'Serenity' in the Willo abode after today's result. Whilst there were no dinner reservations, she decided that it would be in her own interests not to accompany me for a tipple in a local Public House. The tone of my sentiments on HOL masked my inner feelings. Never mind, what you think the board will do, what do you think should be done, should he stay or should he go, are we going to Clash
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by fish mitten
Ultimately the board are to blame. Look at our bench and think who you bring on to change a game. There are virtually no options. Vieira is left with about 15-16 players to choose from. They become undroppable however bad they perform as a result. Those who say we need a manager who will motivate players. I’m not sure we have the right type of players for that. Where are the leaders? We have a few skilful types who are lazy. Great when it’s going good, not so much when it isn’t. And we have a few who just shouldn’t be in a premier league team anymore. Sack the manager? It goes deeper than that. We are just going to have to see it out. Problems lie with Parish and the lack of investment. I've said it before, Vieira doesn't know his best side within the limitations you set out. The constant swapping of players for positions they're not suited for bears this out. Up front? Try Zaha central this week. Or maybe try Mateta. Tried Eduoard? Try Eze on the left or maybe Schlupp. Don't play a player who is suited to a role but shoehorn one of your favourites instead. And on it goes. Keep fiddling with the puzzle pieces and maybe, just maybe, the full picture will emerge. Fact is Vieira has had a whole season to know the team but he's still tinkering.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.