You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Mr Bates vs The Post Office
November 21 2026 9.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mr Bates vs The Post Office


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
silvertop Flag Portishead 03 Apr 24 5.46pm

My wife raised a point I had no answer to.

The prosecutions were the consequence of a faulty software programme, not remote interference. I don't think it has been asserted by anyone that there were e.g. Fujitsu staffers in some secret bunker deliberately falsifying sub post office data to facilitate prosecutions, or even that there was post facto tampering with evidence to retrospectively justify earlier prosecutions.

If I am wrong, please can somebody out there correct me.

Otherwise, I fail to see the relevance of remote access if it has never been asserted that this ever occurred.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 03 Apr 24 5.47pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

It transpires, Paula Vennells, knew about withholding of the flawed system information to the defence lawyers of the prosecuted postmasters. She knew two years beforehand, and did nothing about it.
Her salary should be repaid and she should be put on criminal trial, along with all the prosecution lawyers.
Absolute disgrace, and if she isn't prosecuted , then it would seem to substantiate the link between politics and law.

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (03 Apr 2024 1.44pm)

No it wouldn't, but I suspect more than one lawyer is going to see the other side of the bars before this game is up.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 03 Apr 24 6.05pm

Originally posted by silvertop

My wife raised a point I had no answer to.

The prosecutions were the consequence of a faulty software programme, not remote interference. I don't think it has been asserted by anyone that there were e.g. Fujitsu staffers in some secret bunker deliberately falsifying sub post office data to facilitate prosecutions, or even that there was post facto tampering with evidence to retrospectively justify earlier prosecutions.

If I am wrong, please can somebody out there correct me.

Otherwise, I fail to see the relevance of remote access if it has never been asserted that this ever occurred.

As i understood it, from a radio broadcast,..the remote access was a (failed) attempt to identify software errors and correct them. This was a continual and ongoing program, rather than fixing the faulty software.

They knew the errors were there,...and tried to correct them with remote access, but this ultimately failed. And they continued to prosecute many Postmasters, most of whom lost their careers, some were jailed, and ultimately some took their own lives.

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (03 Apr 2024 6.08pm)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

silvertop Flag Portishead 03 Apr 24 6.14pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

I think an elected Second Chamber would cause more problems than it would solve. They would seek more and more powers and there would be constant antagonism between the two elected bodies - a bit like UK Parliament and Scottish Parliament. Better to just abolish the House of Lords altogether.

I agree the part highlighted but not the last sentence. We still need an upper house to peer review all legislation.

I think the upper house should be limited to, say, 300 in number and be people who represent expertise in a long list of designated fields that experience dictates requires it.

I am an atheist so would not want any cleric in that house, but so far as ethical all rounders go, it is difficult to think of anyone better to reflect this nation's mores. The whole Supreme Court bench must also be present. And perhaps all 24 of those holding the Order of Merit? Collectively, those 3 groups probably add up to about 40-odd, so would not dominate the House.

The appointment, periodic review and removal should be by way of a panel selected by the upper house. Nobody should be appointed to the panel or the House by the executive and/or the elected House. There needs to be a very clear division of power.

And no appointment is for life. When you leave the RA or Supreme Court or Oxfam etc. you leave the upper House.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 03 Apr 24 6.16pm

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

As i understood it, from a radio broadcast,..the remote access was a (failed) attempt to identify software errors and correct them. This was a continual and ongoing program, rather than fixing the faulty software.

They knew the errors were there,...and tried to correct them with remote access, but this ultimately failed. And they continued to prosecute many Postmasters, most of whom lost their careers, some were jailed, and ultimately some took their own lives.

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (03 Apr 2024 6.08pm)

So this was evidence of timing of knowledge, not of fabrication or tampering?

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 04 Apr 24 7.53am

Originally posted by silvertop

So this was evidence of timing of knowledge, not of fabrication or tampering?

Not fabrication or tampering. They were trying to correct the errors remotely that the software was generating.

this is evidence that the Post Office (it's executives) and Fujitsu knew of the software errors, and yet let the prosecutions of Postmasters continue, without disclosing the software errors to the Postmasters defence team.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

The Dolphin Flag 12 Apr 24 1.55pm

I have listened to some of Mr Cooks evidence today and now Crozier has started.
Given the money that they were robbing the taxpayer of, one might have thought that they knew how to run a business - they obviously didn't - and that their memories might be somewhat better than - " I do not recall" or "I am unsure".
Pathetic, and one suspects that this failing circus is the same all through our largest organisations where apparently we have to pay huge salaries to get the very best people.
If this lot are the very best then no wonder we are in such deep s***!

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 12 Apr 24 6.21pm

It seems the thieving b'stards were the people in charge of the Post Office, who whilst ruining innocent people's lives, were collecting huge salaries for doing very little,...to the point of sheer incompetence.

Jail would be just, and a re-payment of their salaries.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

The Dolphin Flag 13 Apr 24 9.16am

Correct on all counts Forest!

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 13 Apr 24 11.24am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

It seems the thieving b'stards were the people in charge of the Post Office, who whilst ruining innocent people's lives, were collecting huge salaries for doing very little,...to the point of sheer incompetence.

Jail would be just, and a re-payment of their salaries.

I saw this on a news feed, about Cook saying that all 'subbies' had their hand in the till . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 13 Apr 24 3.31pm

Former sub-postmaster Alan Bates says he will consider raising funds for private prosecutions of Post Office bosses over the Horizon IT scandal.
He told the BBC he would act if the authorities did not take cases forward.
"It was fine when the Post Office brought private prosecutions, so if we've got to do it in return so be it", he said.

I would give money to fund that, but prosecuting is something the CPS should really be investigating. Prosecute them, take back their salaries and a large damages claim.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

The Dolphin Flag 13 Apr 24 5.30pm

His gofundme page would be well supported.
Also Cook did make that comment in an email.
Disgraceful, but no doubt his pension will stop him worrying too much.

 

The Dolphin Flag 16 Apr 24 3.53pm

Lawyer says to a former CEO after he has failed to answer a question properly - "your are either lying or incompetent" - he replied that he wasn't lying and so the Lawyer said "you must be incompetent then" - if you say so says Mr Mills.
The sheer incompetence and deceit is laid bare at every turn.
The Post Office command had no idea what was going on anywhere in the organisations that they supposedly ran.
One would hope that this shambles will have ramifications elsewhere - but I doubt it!

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 27 Apr 24 4.59am

i don't know why this shocks me , or even surprises me. Just the depths of depravity that our 'leaders' will sink to to cover their own @r535.

"The widow of a sub-postmaster who took his own life had to sign a non-disclosure agreement with the Post Office in exchange for staggered compensation payments, an inquiry has heard.
The family of sub-postmaster Martin Griffiths also had to agree not to pursue legal action to try to clear his name and get more money.
During a second day of questioning, former Post Office executive Angela van den Bogerd was shown emails where she and her colleagues discussed hiring a media lawyer after learning that Mr Griffiths was seriously ill in hospital.
It also emerged that the then chief executive, Paula Vennells, questioned whether Mr Griffiths had "previous mental health issues and potential family issues" to feed back to the board"/media.

I think Van de Bogerd and Vennells look like they are going to take the biggest hit on this, while the other t0553rs hide back in the shadows
I want them (and others) to re-pay all their wages for the times they committed these activities under the banner of the PO.

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (27 Apr 2024 5.01am)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

dreamwaverider Flag London 27 Apr 24 5.30am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

i don't know why this shocks me , or even surprises me. Just the depths of depravity that our 'leaders' will sink to to cover their own @r535.

"The widow of a sub-postmaster who took his own life had to sign a non-disclosure agreement with the Post Office in exchange for staggered compensation payments, an inquiry has heard.
The family of sub-postmaster Martin Griffiths also had to agree not to pursue legal action to try to clear his name and get more money.
During a second day of questioning, former Post Office executive Angela van den Bogerd was shown emails where she and her colleagues discussed hiring a media lawyer after learning that Mr Griffiths was seriously ill in hospital.
It also emerged that the then chief executive, Paula Vennells, questioned whether Mr Griffiths had "previous mental health issues and potential family issues" to feed back to the board"/media.

I think Van de Bogerd and Vennells look like they are going to take the biggest hit on this, while the other t0553rs hide back in the shadows
I want them (and others) to re-pay all their wages for the times they committed these activities under the banner of the PO.

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (27 Apr 2024 5.01am)

These two and many more public sector executives who let their unconditional power go to their heads should really get hammered over this.
Besides the obvious punishments of hefty financial penalties and imprisonment (which knowing this country just will not happen), public humility on a savage scale may just help them realise what complete animals they have been.
I dont often use bad words, but think of the very worst and apply it to these individuals. They all stink and the more punishment to try to get them to come down a peg or two (times 100) the better.
In the old days I would have given them a weekend bank holiday in the stocks with plenty of rotten tomatoes to chuck at them They are a disgrace to human kind and need to understand this.

 

The Dolphin Flag 27 Apr 24 8.16am

These people were either very poor at doing their jobs - that is becoming obvious as it happens - or being complicit in waging war against the post masters and mistresses.
Either is inexcusable but I am sick to death of hearing comments like "I should obviously had paid more attention to that email" and so on.
These were people draining the public purse and they still are.
Just dreadful employees and management.
Send the whole lot to prison, take away their cushy pensions and drop all charges and pay huge compensation now!
Blood scandal next up.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 27 Apr 24 11.15am

Dolphin , I agree whole-heartedly. The penalties for failure at work for the lower classes is being sacked, pension impacted and possible criminal cases in the cases of theft.
These 'management types' have authorised encouraged and advocated the destruction of innocent people's lives. Yet being 'held to account' won't see salaries paid back, pensions impacted, or even facing charges. Absolutely shameful.

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (27 Apr 2024 11.16am)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Plumpton eagle Flag East Sussex 27 Apr 24 11.32am

These 'management types' have authorised encouraged and advocated the destruction of innocent people's lives. Yet being 'held to account' won't see salaries paid back, pensions impacted, or even facing charges. Absolutely shameful.
------------------------------------------------------------------

I think that it is even worse than that. Van den Bogerd admitted yesterday that in the year that wrongly convicted subpostmasters won acquittals and the judge said her evidence was misleading and tainted, she was given a bonus by the Post Office.

If ever there was an example of the powers that be in an organisation looking after themselves at the life shattering expense of others, this is it.

I really hope that she, Vennells, Crichton and other seniors are prosecuted. My only worry is that their defence of "nothing to do with me", "I never knew, I didn't see that email" or "I can't remember" will be hard to break down. Surely, they must at least be guilty of gross negligence - but I guess that is not a crime.

The public might need to arrange a get together with burning torches, buy some feathers and heat up some tar.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 27 Apr 24 11.39am

Bonfire night is to too far away. But there are people waiting to take an opportunity . .

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 23 May 24 4.39am

"Former Post Office boss Paula Vennells has admitted that evidence she gave to MPs looking into problems with the Horizon IT system in 2012 was not true.

Speaking publicly for the first time in almost ten years, Ms Vennells broke down as she was questioned over the scandal, saying her previous assertion that there had been no failed Horizon prosecutions was not correct.

In the most anticipated appearance of the long-running Post Office scandal inquiry, Ms Vennells was questioned in a packed inquiry room with sub-postmasters and post-mistresses coming to watch her give evidence.

Asked by inquiry lead counsel Jason Beer about evidence she gave to MPs in June 2012, in which she told them that every Horizon case brought against sub-postmasters had been successful, Mr Beer listed a number of cases that had not been.

"I fully accept now, that the Post Office - excuse me," said Ms Vennells as she paused and began crying.

"The Post Office knew that," she said. "I completely accept it. Personally, I didn't know that, and I'm incredibly sorry that it happened to those people and to so many others." (BBC website)

Vennells, a woman so bad at her job and a disgrace of a human being (who rejoiced at the (wrongful) imprisonment of a pregnant subpostmaster), has repeatedly lied under oath, and was rewarded with an honour and a six figure salary.
She has returned the 'honour', now i want the wages repaid,...else prison.
What's good for the goose,....

Edited by Forest Hillbilly (23 May 2024 4.40am)

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Mr Bates vs The Post Office