This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
I really don't understand your post, the crowbarring part. Please let us know some facts that show Brexit is an economic disaster. For me, the Ukraine Invasion and Covid make it impossible to assess the overall economic impact of Brexit at this point in time. I would treat Northern Ireland differently as Brexit has caused real problems there, blame lies on both the UK govt and EU for this. Edited by HKOwen (23 Jan 2023 12.21pm) What's the alternative to forecasting that you would prefer when making economic decisions? Of course every leaver feels it's a complete impossibility to assess the impact - it's so transparent.
|
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
The point is a forecast is just that, it is not a fact it's an opinion. Look forward to your examples of Brexit being an economic disaster, and Brexit was not only about economic performance. I appreciate that you believe what you are saying, but that doesn't make it so. You keep avoiding the question re alternatives to economic planning? I'm sure you're not suggesting just blind faith? A forecast is not fact but it is also not pulled out of thin air - it is infinitely more sensible to use the information we have to make projections than to ignore it altogether. Worse still would be to dismiss it because it hurts out feelings. It's a bit boring you're asking me to provide the examples when there are so many of them - it's also boring because you will not accept any of them because you they are projections and sticking your figures in your ears is preferable. "OBR reports that Brexit costs us £40bn a year in lost tax revenue" "The only member of the G7 with a smaller economy than before the pandemic" "The British pound has lost nearly a fifth of it's value since the EU referendum" "Research by the Centre for European Reform, a think tank, estimates that over the 18 months to June 2022, UK goods trade is 7% lower than it would have been had Britain remained in the European Union." "Researchers at the London School of Economics estimate that the variety of UK products exported to the European Union declined by 30% during the first year of Brexit. " "A British Chambers of Commerce survey of more than 1,168 businesses published this month reported that 77% said Brexit has not helped them increase sales or grow their businesses." "Brexit to reduce Britain’s output by 4% over 15 years compared to remaining in the bloc. Exports and imports are projected to be around 15% lower in the long run." "in the fourth quarter of 2021, UK goods export volumes to the European Union were 9% below 2019 levels, with imports from the European Union 18% lower. Goods exports to non-EU countries were 18% weaker than in 2019." "By the end of 2021, total goods export volumes among advanced economies had rebounded to 3% above their pre-pandemic levels, while UK goods export volumes remained about 12% weaker." "The United Kingdom “appears to have become a less trade-intensive economy, with trade as a share of GDP falling 12% since 2019, two and a half times more than in any other G7 country,” the OBR said in the March report."
|
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Edited by HKOwen (23 Jan 2023 12.21pm) i would blame the EU and their puppet regime of Leo Varadkar for all the problems. knowing people in England, Northern Ireland and South of Ireland , i can say categorically that Nothing Varadkar ever says has the support of anybody......other than nasty Angela Merkel & her cronies. the EU are trying to use Ulster as a stick to beat John Bull. And its a really bad idea. Edited by PalazioVecchio (23 Jan 2023 1.55pm)
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
It is entirely the EU's fault, for insisting that their inflexible protectionist, racketeering diktats are adhered to.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
i would blame the EU and their puppet regime of Leo Varadkar for all the problems. knowing people in England, Northern Ireland and South of Ireland , i can say categorically that Nothing Varadkar ever says has the support of anybody......other than nasty Angela Merkel & her cronies. the EU are trying to use Ulster as a stick to beat John Bull. And its a really bad idea. Edited by PalazioVecchio (23 Jan 2023 1.55pm) You can't claim to be an authority on Ireland and then use the term 'South of Ireland'!
|
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
i would blame the EU and their puppet regime of Leo Varadkar for all the problems. knowing people in England, Northern Ireland and South of Ireland , i can say categorically that Nothing Varadkar ever says has the support of anybody......other than nasty Angela Merkel & her cronies. the EU are trying to use Ulster as a stick to beat John Bull. And its a really bad idea. Edited by PalazioVecchio (23 Jan 2023 1.55pm) The EU are very good at very bad ideas.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
You keep avoiding the question re alternatives to economic planning? I'm sure you're not suggesting just blind faith? A forecast is not fact but it is also not pulled out of thin air - it is infinitely more sensible to use the information we have to make projections than to ignore it altogether. Worse still would be to dismiss it because it hurts out feelings. It's a bit boring you're asking me to provide the examples when there are so many of them - it's also boring because you will not accept any of them because you they are projections and sticking your figures in your ears is preferable. "OBR reports that Brexit costs us £40bn a year in lost tax revenue" "The only member of the G7 with a smaller economy than before the pandemic" "The British pound has lost nearly a fifth of it's value since the EU referendum" "Research by the Centre for European Reform, a think tank, estimates that over the 18 months to June 2022, UK goods trade is 7% lower than it would have been had Britain remained in the European Union." "Researchers at the London School of Economics estimate that the variety of UK products exported to the European Union declined by 30% during the first year of Brexit. " "A British Chambers of Commerce survey of more than 1,168 businesses published this month reported that 77% said Brexit has not helped them increase sales or grow their businesses." "Brexit to reduce Britain’s output by 4% over 15 years compared to remaining in the bloc. Exports and imports are projected to be around 15% lower in the long run." "in the fourth quarter of 2021, UK goods export volumes to the European Union were 9% below 2019 levels, with imports from the European Union 18% lower. Goods exports to non-EU countries were 18% weaker than in 2019." "By the end of 2021, total goods export volumes among advanced economies had rebounded to 3% above their pre-pandemic levels, while UK goods export volumes remained about 12% weaker." "The United Kingdom “appears to have become a less trade-intensive economy, with trade as a share of GDP falling 12% since 2019, two and a half times more than in any other G7 country,” the OBR said in the March report."
So ref your 2 nd paragraph; do we act and respond as how it is on said forecasts as truth then. By begging to rejoin the EU or something. Recent forecasts about inflation have been wrong I will add.
|
|
|
This is quite long and a bit Sir Humphrey Appleby-ish but interesting.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
So ref your 2 nd paragraph; do we act and respond as how it is on said forecasts as truth then. By begging to rejoin the EU or something. Recent forecasts about inflation have been wrong I will add. “it is infinitely more sensible to use the information we have to make projections than to ignore it altogether. Worse still would be to dismiss it because it hurts our feelings.” It’s not about rejoining the EU - that’s not purely economical and there are politics to consider, so it’s a non-starter for now. But we can still honestly acknowledge where we are in relation to Brexit and make decisions based on that - pretending “there’s just no way to know” all these years later is disingenuous and it achieves nothing. Recent forecasts have also been right, that’s the nature of forecasting, I will add.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
“it is infinitely more sensible to use the information we have to make projections than to ignore it altogether. Worse still would be to dismiss it because it hurts our feelings.” It’s not about rejoining the EU - that’s not purely economical and there are politics to consider, so it’s a non-starter for now. But we can still honestly acknowledge where we are in relation to Brexit and make decisions based on that - pretending “there’s just no way to know” all these years later is disingenuous and it achieves nothing. Recent forecasts have also been right, that’s the nature of forecasting, I will add. Ok rejoining would not be a starter but as another poster mentioned, we have had a £400 billion spend on covid, x millions on the fuel/ cost of living crisis and recently the Ukraine war. Put that half a trillion back in our coffers and just maybe it’s not that bad.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Can someone explain to me why our economic performance is so much worse than comparable economies over the last year or two, if we're so sure it's not Brexit? Covid-19 was worldwide, as was the impact of the Ukraine invasion and yet we are the only G7 economy not to recover to pre-pandemic size... why could that be? What am I missing? Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (24 Jan 2023 3.46pm) Other countries don't spent £192 bn on a national health service: which doesn't work?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Other countries don't spent £192 bn on a national health service: which doesn't work? Our healthcare spending is not high relative to similar sized economies, so I don't think it's that...
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Ok rejoining would not be a starter but as another poster mentioned, we have had a £400 billion spend on covid, x millions on the fuel/ cost of living crisis and recently the Ukraine war. Put that half a trillion back in our coffers and just maybe it’s not that bad. We know we have performed worse than equivalent economies that have been through the same issues. Pretty clear cut surely.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
We know we have performed worse than equivalent economies that have been through the same issues. Pretty clear cut surely. Honestly, Covid is the best thing that could have happened for Brexit - as this thread proves, it's a ready-made excuse to buy those responsible considerably more time as to why it hasn't been what they said it would. And for people who want Brexit to succeed, it's easier to accept that excuse than to consider that they may have been sold a dud.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Honestly, Covid is the best thing that could have happened for Brexit - as this thread proves, it's a ready-made excuse to buy those responsible considerably more time as to why it hasn't been what they said it would. And for people who want Brexit to succeed, it's easier to accept that excuse than to consider that they may have been sold a dud. How has brexit impacted you directly then ?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.