You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Margaret Thatcher
November 19 2026 6.28pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Margaret Thatcher


Page 51 of 76 < 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 >
dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 12 Apr 13 9.51pm

Bat slapped.

558084_10151391218488517_1264197004_n.jpg Attachment: 558084_10151391218488517_1264197004_n.jpg (29.22Kb)

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Buzzcock Flag In an underground lair near Bright... 12 Apr 13 9.51pm

Just an observation but his tactics seem so HalfManHalfSlug-like or is this just a standard leftie tactic?
For the younger posters he was a prodigious former poster on here.

I.E. Make a ludicrous statement. See it shot down with facts.
Ignore follow up with next ludicrous statement and post/quote link to totally biased blog. Ditto.
Deflect comment with attack on some small unimportant aside made ages ago and/or accuse others of also using biased information which patently isn't or attempt to inject humour when losing a point.
Ad nauseum.
As i say, just an observation.
On another aside is the lack of CF and WH on this thread a clue they are one and the same?

 


In the woods there grew a tree. And a fine fine tree was he.

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 12 Apr 13 9.54pm

Quote Seth at 12 Apr 2013 6.15pm

That hotbed of rabid communism and anti-Tory bias, the BBC, has decided not to play Ding Dong the Witch is Dead on the Radio 1 chart show.

What do those who regularly attack the Beeb for being rampant lefties think of this blatant piece of Tory-appeasing censorship?

Typical right wing press in the UK.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 12 Apr 13 10.00pm

Quote Forest Hillbilly at 12 Apr 2013 9.34pm

You can never 'win' an internet argument/discussion, lively and interesting as they are.

People are already entrenched into their viewpoints and have a wealth of 'supporting evidence' to back their stance.

i would like to feel i have been educated by this thread. Particularly relating to the miners strike.

*I have learnt of how shlt Labour were before the Tories got in.
*Reform was needed by the tories, but perhaps could have been done a lot better by Thatcher.
*How badly some elements of The Met behaved in the miners strike
* How bad the Union leaders were.
* How compassionate some elements of the police were.
* The polarisation of elements of society. (divide and conquer)

The miners weren't shirkers. They wanted to work, and in fvcking shlt conditions, too. (unlike a significant % of today's population)
Some steel and mineworkers even committed suicide due to enforced changes to their life/communities.(if they didn't suffer enough from COPD, or industrial 'white-finger'

The souring after-taste for these ex-workers, is that many people, government, investors, bankers, property magnates (including Union leaders) got massive financial rewards, for fundamentally doing fck-all.


Edited by Forest Hillbilly (12 Apr 2013 9.37pm)


What I have learnt - less from here and more from the 2 Parliamentary debates - is that

* there were 2 completely contrasting sides to Maggie, which were almost like 2 different people.
* she worked for 18 hours a day, more than twice most people
* she was the mother of twins, which is a known genetic inheritance

My conclusion is therefore that there were actually 2 Mrs Thatchers, not just one....

...which means that one may still be alive!

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 12 Apr 13 10.01pm

Quote Buzzcock at 12 Apr 2013 9.51pm

Just an observation but his tactics seem so HalfManHalfSlug-like or is this just a standard leftie tactic?
For the younger posters he was a prodigious former poster on here.

I.E. Make a ludicrous statement. See it shot down with facts.
Ignore follow up with next ludicrous statement and post/quote link to totally biased blog. Ditto.
Deflect comment with attack on some small unimportant aside made ages ago and/or accuse others of also using biased information which patently isn't or attempt to inject humour when losing a point.
Ad nauseum.
As i say, just an observation.
On another aside is the lack of CF and WH on this thread a clue they are one and the same?


Don't remember "Buzzcock" debating with HMHS nor his pseudonym eulalio.

I seem to remember he talked sense, and backed it up when debating with Peterliator, Funty and even famed islamophobe Reborn.

Just an observation as you say.

a postscript the lovely balance right ring opinion o HOL

"face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005"


Edited by pefwin (12 Apr 2013 10.04pm)

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Buzzcock Flag In an underground lair near Bright... 12 Apr 13 10.19pm

Quote pefwin at 12 Apr 2013 10.01pm

Quote Buzzcock at 12 Apr 2013 9.51pm

Just an observation but his tactics seem so HalfManHalfSlug-like or is this just a standard leftie tactic?
For the younger posters he was a prodigious former poster on here.

I.E. Make a ludicrous statement. See it shot down with facts.
Ignore follow up with next ludicrous statement and post/quote link to totally biased blog. Ditto.
Deflect comment with attack on some small unimportant aside made ages ago and/or accuse others of also using biased information which patently isn't or attempt to inject humour when losing a point.
Ad nauseum.
As i say, just an observation.
On another aside is the lack of CF and WH on this thread a clue they are one and the same?


Don't remember "Buzzcock" debating with HMHS nor his pseudonym eulalio.

I seem to remember he talked sense, and backed it up when debating with Peterliator, Funty and even famed islamophobe Reborn.

Just an observation as you say.

Edited by pefwin (12 Apr 2013 10.02pm)

Except for the odd throw-away comment on a thread I didn't debate with them which is probably why you don't remember. Never said I did anyway.
He was an entertaining read old HMHS although I was more on Pete and CF's side however as I'm sure you'll disagree he often resorted to the above with his "I'm superior" attitude because he could post a link to an 18th century left wing scholar.

 


In the woods there grew a tree. And a fine fine tree was he.

Bubbs Flag Edinburgh 12 Apr 13 10.22pm

Quote Forest Hillbilly at 12 Apr 2013 9.34pm

You can never 'win' an internet argument/discussion, lively and interesting as they are.

People are already entrenched into their viewpoints and have a wealth of 'supporting evidence' to back their stance.

i would like to feel i have been educated by this thread. Particularly relating to the miners strike.

*I have learnt of how shlt Labour were before the Tories got in.
*Reform was needed by the tories, but perhaps could have been done a lot better by Thatcher.
*How badly some elements of The Met behaved in the miners strike
* How bad the Union leaders were.
* How compassionate some elements of the police were.
* The polarisation of elements of society. (divide and conquer)

The miners weren't shirkers. They wanted to work, and in fvcking shlt conditions, too. (unlike a significant % of today's population)
Some steel and mineworkers even committed suicide due to enforced changes to their life/communities.(if they didn't suffer enough from COPD, or industrial 'white-finger'

The souring after-taste for these ex-workers, is that many people, government, investors, bankers, property magnates (including Union leaders) got massive financial rewards, for fundamentally doing fck-all.


Edited by Forest Hillbilly (12 Apr 2013 9.37pm)


You know, one of the most heart wrenching stories i heard from that conflict was when the police were baton charging some miners in Sheffield. The older miners that had fought in the 2nd World War, just stood still not expecting their police force to actually attack them, but they went right through them.

 


'Better stop dreaming of the quiet life 'cos it's the one we'll never know'

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 12 Apr 13 10.22pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Apr 2013 9.15pm

Quote Penge Eagle at 12 Apr 2013 9.05pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 9.02pm

Quote Penge Eagle at 12 Apr 2013 8.41pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 7.27pm

Quote Penge Eagle at 12 Apr 2013 5.22pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 12.29am

WhiteHorse hasn't been on for a while, was he really a senile Thatch?

I notice in the Daily Mirror that of all the council homes sold off, one third are being rented out by private landlords...Probably for a lot more than council rent would cost!!!

Edited by nickgusset (12 Apr 2013 12.31am)

Again, you are simply parroting what the likes of Owen Jones says.

Please explain in a bit more detail how landlords are profiteering or the "Probably for a lot more than council rent would cost!" bit.

I asked Owen Jones about this through twitter and he didn't get back to me, funnily enough!

Edited by Penge Eagle (12 Apr 2013 5.23pm)


I was merelysharing the Daily Mirrors story, I haven't read what Owen Jones wrote, although he did touch upon housing benefit being paid directly to unscrupulous landlords (not into the pockets of the inhabitants) during his excellent speech at the NUT conference.

If you repeat anything in a paper, may I accuse you of 'parroting' Littlejohn.

Once again Penge, you resort to personal digs rather than countering the argument. Do you have evidence against the fact that a third of sold off council houses are owned by private landlords? If you do, I'd be more than happy to read it.

Sorry Nick, I fail to see any personal insult there.

Why are you quoting a story to score points without being aware of the facts of the actual story?

I said you [in the case of this Mirror link] and "the likes of Owen Jones" as I've heard it so many times before and it's rubbish. By you quoting that Mirror story, you clearly agree with it. "Greedy landlords" is regularly trotted out by left wing commentators and politicians.

I am really interested to know how landlords who provide a service for the population profiteer on vulnerable people or are unscrupulousness.

I genuinely don't understand your point about landlords. Is it because they earn money and are therefore evil?

I'm not arguing over housing stock, but the issue about landlords.

For your information, housing benefit IS paid directly to the tenant unless they ask otherwise. Owen Jones said different at the NUT jolly, so it must be true? You are parroting what he said.

Edited by Penge Eagle (12 Apr 2013 8.49pm)


I was paraphrasing, not saying word for word.
Landlords are profiting out of your taxes, did you know that the son of the housing minister at the time of the council house sell off has a portfolio of over 40 ex council houses?

"Landlords are profiting out of your taxes". I just don't understand what is wrong with that? The State gives money to the private sector all of the time...

Do you have a problem with landlords?

Edited by Penge Eagle (12 Apr 2013 9.07pm

Landlord's are inherently risk takers. We have had two major property slumps in my memory. In the SE property prices may be fairly stable at the moment, but elsewhere they are not. If you are prepared to invest, take on risk and provide a service, what is wrong with those that get right making a profit?


I don't have a problem with landlords per se.

One and a half million council houses were sold off at up to 50% of their value. 1/3 of these houses are now owned by private landlords, fair play to private landlords if that is their way of making money. However the rent they are charging is way above what the council rent would have been. In the vast majority of cases, the houses are being rented back to people who would have, had there been enough, been renting off of the council. As tax payers, we are paying a lot of the (now inflated when compared to council)rent through housing benefit.
Rents have increased by 36% in the last few years- now whether this is partly because landlords know they are onto a good thing because they know they have a guaranteed income from benefit tenants is debatable but not unlikely-I know there are other reasons, supply/demand etc-(a hangover from the original sold off housing stock not being replaced)

So as tax payers, we are paying a great deal more to support those who need housing benefit in order to provide a profit for individuals rather than to a council who could use the money for other projects-building more houses, fixing the facking pothole in the road, keeping libraries open etc etc.

That is where my beef lies.


Edited by nickgusset (12 Apr 2013 10.24pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Apr 13 10.31pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 10.22pm

I don't have a problem with landlords per se.

One and a half million council houses were sold off at up to 50% of their value. 1/3 of these houses are now owned by private landlords, fair play to private landlords if that is their way of making money. However the rent they are charging is way above what the council rent would have been. In the vast majority of cases, the houses are being rented back to people who would have, had there been enough, been renting off of the council. As tax payers, we are paying a lot of the (now inflated when compared to council)rent through housing benefit.
Rents have increased by 36% in the last few years- now whether this is partly because landlords know they are onto a good thing because they know they have a guaranteed income from benefit tenants is debatable but not unlikely-I know there are other reasons, supply/demand etc-(a hangover from the original sold off housing stock not being replaced)

So as tax payers, we are paying a great deal more to support those who need housing benefit in order to provide a profit for individuals rather than to a council who could use the money for other projects-building more houses, fixing the facking pothole in the road, keeping libraries open etc etc.

That is where my beef lies.


Edited by nickgusset (12 Apr 2013 10.24pm)

It's a valid beef in my view.

However it's a beef that White Horse refuses to accept when he attacked over Labour's three terms of doing bugger all about housing.

Collectively both parties let large sections of the country down over social housing.....Building houses is expensive, doesn't have a short term payback and there's always something else more pressing to do.

That's politicians for you - being paid to f*ck the country up and then blame the other lot.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

chris123 Flag hove actually 12 Apr 13 10.32pm

Quote Bubbs at 12 Apr 2013 10.22pm

Quote Forest Hillbilly at 12 Apr 2013 9.34pm

You can never 'win' an internet argument/discussion, lively and interesting as they are.

People are already entrenched into their viewpoints and have a wealth of 'supporting evidence' to back their stance.

i would like to feel i have been educated by this thread. Particularly relating to the miners strike.

*I have learnt of how shlt Labour were before the Tories got in.
*Reform was needed by the tories, but perhaps could have been done a lot better by Thatcher.
*How badly some elements of The Met behaved in the miners strike
* How bad the Union leaders were.
* How compassionate some elements of the police were.
* The polarisation of elements of society. (divide and conquer)

The miners weren't shirkers. They wanted to work, and in fvcking shlt conditions, too. (unlike a significant % of today's population)
Some steel and mineworkers even committed suicide due to enforced changes to their life/communities.(if they didn't suffer enough from COPD, or industrial 'white-finger'

The souring after-taste for these ex-workers, is that many people, government, investors, bankers, property magnates (including Union leaders) got massive financial rewards, for fundamentally doing fck-all.


Edited by Forest Hillbilly (12 Apr 2013 9.37pm)


You know, one of the most heart wrenching stories i heard from that conflict was when the police were baton charging some miners in Sheffield. The older miners that had fought in the 2nd World War, just stood still not expecting their police force to actually attack them, but they went right through them.


Well if they fought in the war and were still mining in at the start of the 80's they must have been fairly senior, that's at least 35 years.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 12 Apr 13 10.43pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 10.22pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Apr 2013 9.15pm

Quote Penge Eagle at 12 Apr 2013 9.05pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 9.02pm

Quote Penge Eagle at 12 Apr 2013 8.41pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 7.27pm

Quote Penge Eagle at 12 Apr 2013 5.22pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 12.29am

WhiteHorse hasn't been on for a while, was he really a senile Thatch?

I notice in the Daily Mirror that of all the council homes sold off, one third are being rented out by private landlords...Probably for a lot more than council rent would cost!!!

Edited by nickgusset (12 Apr 2013 12.31am)

Again, you are simply parroting what the likes of Owen Jones says.

Please explain in a bit more detail how landlords are profiteering or the "Probably for a lot more than council rent would cost!" bit.

I asked Owen Jones about this through twitter and he didn't get back to me, funnily enough!

Edited by Penge Eagle (12 Apr 2013 5.23pm)


I was merelysharing the Daily Mirrors story, I haven't read what Owen Jones wrote, although he did touch upon housing benefit being paid directly to unscrupulous landlords (not into the pockets of the inhabitants) during his excellent speech at the NUT conference.

If you repeat anything in a paper, may I accuse you of 'parroting' Littlejohn.

Once again Penge, you resort to personal digs rather than countering the argument. Do you have evidence against the fact that a third of sold off council houses are owned by private landlords? If you do, I'd be more than happy to read it.

Sorry Nick, I fail to see any personal insult there.

Why are you quoting a story to score points without being aware of the facts of the actual story?

I said you [in the case of this Mirror link] and "the likes of Owen Jones" as I've heard it so many times before and it's rubbish. By you quoting that Mirror story, you clearly agree with it. "Greedy landlords" is regularly trotted out by left wing commentators and politicians.

I am really interested to know how landlords who provide a service for the population profiteer on vulnerable people or are unscrupulousness.

I genuinely don't understand your point about landlords. Is it because they earn money and are therefore evil?

I'm not arguing over housing stock, but the issue about landlords.

For your information, housing benefit IS paid directly to the tenant unless they ask otherwise. Owen Jones said different at the NUT jolly, so it must be true? You are parroting what he said.

Edited by Penge Eagle (12 Apr 2013 8.49pm)


I was paraphrasing, not saying word for word.
Landlords are profiting out of your taxes, did you know that the son of the housing minister at the time of the council house sell off has a portfolio of over 40 ex council houses?

"Landlords are profiting out of your taxes". I just don't understand what is wrong with that? The State gives money to the private sector all of the time...

Do you have a problem with landlords?

Edited by Penge Eagle (12 Apr 2013 9.07pm

Landlord's are inherently risk takers. We have had two major property slumps in my memory. In the SE property prices may be fairly stable at the moment, but elsewhere they are not. If you are prepared to invest, take on risk and provide a service, what is wrong with those that get right making a profit?


I don't have a problem with landlords per se.

One and a half million council houses were sold off at up to 50% of their value. 1/3 of these houses are now owned by private landlords, fair play to private landlords if that is their way of making money. However the rent they are charging is way above what the council rent would have been. In the vast majority of cases, the houses are being rented back to people who would have, had there been enough, been renting off of the council. As tax payers, we are paying a lot of the (now inflated when compared to council)rent through housing benefit.
Rents have increased by 36% in the last few years- now whether this is partly because landlords know they are onto a good thing because they know they have a guaranteed income from benefit tenants is debatable but not unlikely-I know there are other reasons, supply/demand etc-(a hangover from the original sold off housing stock not being replaced)

So as tax payers, we are paying a great deal more to support those who need housing benefit in order to provide a profit for individuals rather than to a council who could use the money for other projects-building more houses, fixing the facking pothole in the road, keeping libraries open etc etc.

That is where my beef lies.


Edited by nickgusset (12 Apr 2013 10.24pm)


Giving council tenents the right to buy their homes and create some security of tenure is surely a good thing. The discount to market was on a sliding scale depending on the number of years you'd occupied your property. Council houses were not sold to landlords, landlords have purchased ex council stock on the open market, they were generally very well built. Of course rents have increased in some areas, that's the market working, creating choice.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Apr 13 10.53pm

Quote Seth at 12 Apr 2013 6.15pm

That hotbed of rabid communism and anti-Tory bias, the BBC, has decided not to play Ding Dong the Witch is Dead on the Radio 1 chart show.

What do those who regularly attack the Beeb for being rampant lefties think of this blatant piece of Tory-appeasing censorship?

The very nadir of radio coverage came on Tuesday evening when the BBC unearthed some chap who had been promoting the song. This was in appallingly bad taste to give airtime to someone capable of promoting such a song about a woman who had died the previous day.This poison should have been kept off the airwaves. Disgusting and repugnant.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Apr 13 10.57pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Apr 2013 10.43pm

Giving council tenents the right to buy their homes and create some security of tenure is surely a good thing. The discount to market was on a sliding scale depending on the number of years you'd occupied your property. Council houses were not sold to landlords, landlords have purchased ex council stock on the open market, they were generally very well built. Of course rents have increased in some areas, that's the market working, creating choice.


If a house was built as social housing then it is valid to state what has become of it when we discuss what was done to social housing in this country.

If landlords now own around 1/3 of original social housing that is a valid point to make.

It doesn't show 'choice' it shows an abuse of the original intent of social housing insomuch as it was intended to be affordable.

One of the main reasons social housing was created was because the market aren't driven by providing what is affordable but only in making the most money. This means that if there are enough people willing to pay a rent then that's good enough.....This isn't providing 'choice' to those who can't afford it.

What you call 'choice' for many is no choice at all.

Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Apr 2013 11.02pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 12 Apr 13 10.58pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Apr 2013 10.31pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 10.22pm

I don't have a problem with landlords per se.

One and a half million council houses were sold off at up to 50% of their value. 1/3 of these houses are now owned by private landlords, fair play to private landlords if that is their way of making money. However the rent they are charging is way above what the council rent would have been. In the vast majority of cases, the houses are being rented back to people who would have, had there been enough, been renting off of the council. As tax payers, we are paying a lot of the (now inflated when compared to council)rent through housing benefit.
Rents have increased by 36% in the last few years- now whether this is partly because landlords know they are onto a good thing because they know they have a guaranteed income from benefit tenants is debatable but not unlikely-I know there are other reasons, supply/demand etc-(a hangover from the original sold off housing stock not being replaced)

So as tax payers, we are paying a great deal more to support those who need housing benefit in order to provide a profit for individuals rather than to a council who could use the money for other projects-building more houses, fixing the facking pothole in the road, keeping libraries open etc etc.

That is where my beef lies.


Edited by nickgusset (12 Apr 2013 10.24pm)

It's a valid beef in my view.

However it's a beef that White Horse refuses to accept when he attacked over Labour's three terms of doing bugger all about housing.

Collectively both parties let large sections of the country down over social housing.....Building houses is expensive, doesn't have a short term payback and there's always something else more pressing to do.

That's politicians for you - being paid to f*ck the country up and then blame the other lot.


It should be devoted a thread to itself I know...

A hypothetical idea-sorry if it is a bit simplistic...

Currently the rate of interest for the government to borrow on a 15 year loan is 2.43%. Therefore, it would cost the government £24.3 million a year in repayments if it borrowed £1bn.

In the north west, new homes for social housing cost about £120,000 to build. With £1bn you could build 8,330 houses.

If the rent for each house was set at about £5,500 a year (affordable) then the total income would be £45.8m per year, a surplus of £21.5m on the repayments. Over 15 years, this would amount to a surplus of around £322m.

Of course you have to take inflation into account, say 2% a year - the £1bn would devalue by 2% a year meaning after 15 years the original loan of £1bn would actually be worth about 30% less than it is today. So we would repay the equivalent of about £666m.

Of course people are needed to build the houses, this will take people off of benefits, If the average amount of benefits is £100 a week (jsa and housing benefit) it amounts to £5200 a year. If the same person were to earn an average wage of £22k a year building the houses, then they would pay around £3500 Tax and NI a year. So the public purse will make a gain of about £8700 a year from that person who is not receiving benefit and paying taxes.

Multiply this by the number of people taken off benefits to build the houses (say 500 for arguments sake) and you now have £4.35m a year into the public purse. Of course with more money, these people will buy more goods and services which means more tax paid.

Additionally, you would have companies supplying the goods and contracts to build the houses, their profits would increase with additional corporation tax to pay.

So not only do we get people off of benefits and into work, we save on benefits and generate more tax but we also go some way to solving the housing crisis, especially if this model is repeated around the country.

Edited by nickgusset (12 Apr 2013 11.02pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Apr 13 10.58pm

Quote Willo at 12 Apr 2013 10.53pm

Quote Seth at 12 Apr 2013 6.15pm

That hotbed of rabid communism and anti-Tory bias, the BBC, has decided not to play Ding Dong the Witch is Dead on the Radio 1 chart show.

What do those who regularly attack the Beeb for being rampant lefties think of this blatant piece of Tory-appeasing censorship?

The very nadir of radio coverage came on Tuesday evening when the BBC unearthed some chap who had been promoting the song. This was in appallingly bad taste to give airtime to someone capable of promoting such a song about a woman who had died the previous day.This poison should have been kept off the airwaves. Disgusting and repugnant.


Seconded.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 12 Apr 13 11.12pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 10.58pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Apr 2013 10.31pm

Quote nickgusset at 12 Apr 2013 10.22pm

I don't have a problem with landlords per se.

One and a half million council houses were sold off at up to 50% of their value. 1/3 of these houses are now owned by private landlords, fair play to private landlords if that is their way of making money. However the rent they are charging is way above what the council rent would have been. In the vast majority of cases, the houses are being rented back to people who would have, had there been enough, been renting off of the council. As tax payers, we are paying a lot of the (now inflated when compared to council)rent through housing benefit.
Rents have increased by 36% in the last few years- now whether this is partly because landlords know they are onto a good thing because they know they have a guaranteed income from benefit tenants is debatable but not unlikely-I know there are other reasons, supply/demand etc-(a hangover from the original sold off housing stock not being replaced)

So as tax payers, we are paying a great deal more to support those who need housing benefit in order to provide a profit for individuals rather than to a council who could use the money for other projects-building more houses, fixing the facking pothole in the road, keeping libraries open etc etc.

That is where my beef lies.


Edited by nickgusset (12 Apr 2013 10.24pm)

It's a valid beef in my view.

However it's a beef that White Horse refuses to accept when he attacked over Labour's three terms of doing bugger all about housing.

Collectively both parties let large sections of the country down over social housing.....Building houses is expensive, doesn't have a short term payback and there's always something else more pressing to do.

That's politicians for you - being paid to f*ck the country up and then blame the other lot.


It should be devoted a thread to itself I know...

A hypothetical idea-sorry if it is a bit simplistic...

Currently the rate of interest for the government to borrow on a 15 year loan is 2.43%. Therefore, it would cost the government £24.3 million a year in repayments if it borrowed £1bn.

In the north west, new homes for social housing cost about £120,000 to build. With £1bn you could build 8,330 houses.

If the rent for each house was set at about £5,500 a year (affordable) then the total income would be £45.8m per year, a surplus of £21.5m on the repayments. Over 15 years, this would amount to a surplus of around £322m.

Of course you have to take inflation into account, say 2% a year - the £1bn would devalue by 2% a year meaning after 15 years the original loan of £1bn would actually be worth about 30% less than it is today. So we would repay the equivalent of about £666m.

Of course people are needed to build the houses, this will take people off of benefits, If the average amount of benefits is £100 a week (jsa and housing benefit) it amounts to £5200 a year. If the same person were to earn an average wage of £22k a year building the houses, then they would pay around £3500 Tax and NI a year. So the public purse will make a gain of about £8700 a year from that person who is not receiving benefit and paying taxes.

Multiply this by the number of people taken off benefits to build the houses (say 500 for arguments sake) and you now have £4.35m a year into the public purse. Of course with more money, these people will buy more goods and services which means more tax paid.

Additionally, you would have companies supplying the goods and contracts to build the houses, their profits would increase with additional corporation tax to pay.

So not only do we get people off of benefits and into work, we save on benefits and generate more tax but we also go some way to solving the housing crisis, especially if this model is repeated around the country.

440 Quid a week seriously? as a Carpenter myself I was earning this back in the 80s shopfitting. Double that & I may consider It..

Edited by nickgusset (12 Apr 2013 11.02pm)


 


Pro USA & Israel

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Apr 13 11.21pm

440 Quid a week working as a Carpenter back in the 80s?

Jesus.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 12 Apr 13 11.38pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Apr 2013 11.21pm

440 Quid a week working as a Carpenter back in the 80s?

Jesus.



Long Long hours...other trades earned more. You may have only had a few weeks to fit out a shop. I did loads of Pizza Huts back then. The flagship one at Leicester Sq I think we did in 20 weeks... mind you tax for a Subbie back then was 30odd % thank God for Maggie that went down to 27%

 


Pro USA & Israel

chris123 Flag hove actually 12 Apr 13 11.39pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 12 Apr 2013 10.57pm

Quote chris123 at 12 Apr 2013 10.43pm

Giving council tenents the right to buy their homes and create some security of tenure is surely a good thing. The discount to market was on a sliding scale depending on the number of years you'd occupied your property. Council houses were not sold to landlords, landlords have purchased ex council stock on the open market, they were generally very well built. Of course rents have increased in some areas, that's the market working, creating choice.


If a house was built as social housing then it is valid to state what has become of it when we discuss what was done to social housing in this country.

If landlords now own around 1/3 of original social housing that is a valid point to make.

It doesn't show 'choice' it shows an abuse of the original intent of social housing insomuch as it was intended to be affordable.

One of the main reasons social housing was created was because the market aren't driven by providing what is affordable but only in making the most money. This means that if there are enough people willing to pay a rent then that's good enough.....This isn't providing 'choice' to those who can't afford it.

What you call 'choice' for many is no choice at all.

Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Apr 2013 11.02pm)


It has to be affordable, otherwise you'd have a bunch of empty properties. If you're a landlord it's difficult to see how you can be successful marketing a suite of properties at unaffordable rents.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Apr 13 12.29am

Quote chris123 at 12 Apr 2013 11.39pm

It has to be affordable, otherwise you'd have a bunch of empty properties. If you're a landlord it's difficult to see how you can be successful marketing a suite of properties at unaffordable rents.

If you have a set number of properties then you can charge the rate the market will bear to fill those properties.

If there isn't enough houses the basic demand and supply means the rate is higher.

The market isn't there to house everyone, that isn't its role. It has a set number of properties (which isn't enough to house everyone) and the market is going to make as much money as it can.

This is a key reason why we had government build social housing in the first place and not the market.....The market aren't interested in housing everyone...At the lower end the profit is too low to risk the expensive outlay to build the property.....Much more profit in chasing the better earners.

This isn't 'choice' for a large number of people who don't earn enough.....This is no choice.


Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Apr 2013 3.29am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 51 of 76 < 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Margaret Thatcher