Quote Kermit8 at 01 Aug 2014 1.50pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 01 Aug 2014 1.35pm
Quote Kermit8 at 01 Aug 2014 1.24pm
Lucky them. They probably can't hear the assaults and mortar rounds and rockets.
80% of Gazans are displaced refugees and their children from way back. They are most certainly not living in their homes.
Are you getting paid via Tel Aviv for this?
Some of the stuff you come out with.
Edited by Kermit8 (01 Aug 2014 1.28pm)
They are mostly living in their own homes. You are talking about 47/48.....Which is at least 67 years ago. Do you own the home that your family lived in 67 years ago?
The population from that time would...at the very least be in their eighties....In a Gaza population which is hugely populated by younger inhabitants.
I can't imagine many people alive in Gaza today who hold deeds to those original properties.
I say this to counter the silly emotionalism of your point with rationalism....I don't seek to deny the injustice of what happened in 47/48.
Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Aug 2014 1.35pm)
Hmmm..you are parroting how the US senate sees it -
'Only those alive in 1947/48 and their families are classed as refugees. 30,000 in the West Bank and Gaza.'
UN disagrees. Their total is 2million - Children born in refugee camps/under occupation and grow up in those same camps and then have kids of their own are too refugees.
Which classification is fairer do you think?
It is a very tricky question....the right of return....There is no real justice here but sticking plaster.
I don't claim to have the 'right' answer to it....I don't really know if there is one.
To an extent whether someone has the 'right' of return depends upon the borders of a two state solution....Something along the 67 borders is possible.
If it were my decision I would ensure compensation for those affected still alive from 47/48.
I would allow the right of return in the west bank areas cleared of settlers......Though the longer this doesn't happen the harder this becomes.
I can't imagine Israel giving over compensation that they would think would go into weapons to harm them in a future war......So whatever two state solution it would have to have a demilitarized element to it.
The 'right of return' element is hugely difficult if we accept the right of Israel to exist.
Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Aug 2014 2.07pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|