You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic
November 2 2026 8.47am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Christian Benteke (SIGNED) (LOCKED)


Page 58 of 200 < 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 >
thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 12 Jul 16 9.38am

Best news this summer if Benteke is NOT coming. We have a bad record of expensive striker signings. And 30 mill transfer plus and 120-130 000 weekly contradicts everything Palace stands for. So happy this is only rumours. OK, CB was great for Villa but s*** for Liverpool and not in the Belgium line-up in Euro 2016. If the club are willing to splash out that sum for one player, we should be able to attract good enough players to make an impact. Happy with our signings so far and yes, a striker in the Gayle mould would be great, but 30 mill - no way!

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 12 Jul 16 9.51am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Best news this summer if Benteke is NOT coming. We have a bad record of expensive striker signings. And 30 mill transfer plus and 120-130 000 weekly contradicts everything Palace stands for. So happy this is only rumours. OK, CB was great for Villa but s*** for Liverpool and not in the Belgium line-up in Euro 2016. If the club are willing to splash out that sum for one player, we should be able to attract good enough players to make an impact. Happy with our signings so far and yes, a striker in the Gayle mould would be great, but 30 mill - no way!

What exactly do Palace stand for? A history of yo-yoing in and out of the top division, never having won a major trophy or is it just the regular administrations?

Hmmm...a 'striker in the Gayle mould', so not favoured by any of our managers in the PL, can't play as a lone-striker (the system favoured by AP) and, when we do play two up front, Bolasie is chosen over him. Yes, let's get another striker just like that, I mean it's not like we have a problem with our goal tally is it?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

kirbyeagle Flag south east london 12 Jul 16 9.56am

Spot on

Originally posted by bexleydave

What exactly do Palace stand for? A history of yo-yoing in and out of the top division, never having won a major trophy or is it just the regular administrations?

Hmmm...a 'striker in the Gayle mould', so not favoured by any of our managers in the PL, can't play as a lone-striker (the system favoured by AP) and, when we do play two up front, Bolasie is chosen over him. Yes, let's get another striker just like that, I mean it's not like we have a problem with our goal tally is it?

 

kirbyeagle Flag south east london 12 Jul 16 10.14am

Smoke and mirrors, benteke to be signed soon for sure, I think agents and such like have said a lot on his behalf yet nothing from himself, obviously he wants best wage possible and if I know steve parish then there would be a compromise somewhere to legislate poor number of games played last term and if he is near meeting last years value paid then somewhere there will be a compromise, sounds to me as if agents trying to get his wack, normal in a deal this size, this is unfamiliar transfer dealings for palace and we might find many players agents in the high earning bracket will fight tooth and nail for all the extras, just the way it is unfortunately, I still think this is a goer and despite everyone frustrations the time scale is a hazard of modern football, if players are taking what is to be considered a backward step then they ultimately lose money , so they are just trying to make up the shortfall IMO

Benteke announced as a palace player end of this week or beginning of next week

 

DeSouza Flag In a cave 12 Jul 16 10.17am

Originally posted by kirbyeagle

Smoke and mirrors, benteke to be signed soon for sure, I think agents and such like have said a lot on his behalf yet nothing from himself, obviously he wants best wage possible and if I know steve parish then there would be a compromise somewhere to legislate poor number of games played last term and if he is near meeting last years value paid then somewhere there will be a compromise, sounds to me as if agents trying to get his wack, normal in a deal this size, this is unfamiliar transfer dealings for palace and we might find many players agents in the high earning bracket will fight tooth and nail for all the extras, just the way it is unfortunately, I still think this is a goer and despite everyone frustrations the time scale is a hazard of modern football, if players are taking what is to be considered a backward step then they ultimately lose money , so they are just trying to make up the shortfall IMO

Benteke announced as a palace player end of this week or beginning of next week

I hope you're right, I think he's the player we need.

Quick question, are you any relation to David and Claire Kirby?

 


*BUMP*

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 12 Jul 16 10.19am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Best news this summer if Benteke is NOT coming. We have a bad record of expensive striker signings. And 30 mill transfer plus and 120-130 000 weekly contradicts everything Palace stands for. So happy this is only rumours. OK, CB was great for Villa but s*** for Liverpool and not in the Belgium line-up in Euro 2016. If the club are willing to splash out that sum for one player, we should be able to attract good enough players to make an impact. Happy with our signings so far and yes, a striker in the Gayle mould would be great, but 30 mill - no way!

Time to start thinking bigger Thai Eagle. Do you think teams like Liverpool enjoy forking out 30 million for bench-warmers? This is the EPL and this is what it costs to just SURVIVE in it. We all hate the sh1tloads of dosh these punks make, but that is the way it is. And BTW, the money teams now get just for surviving in the EPL is also just as obscene. But no complaints there I think. I for one want Benteke because he will be awesome for Palace. I've said before that we at Palace need to change our mindsets and I am thrilled to see that the guys running the club have done that. COYP!

 


[Link]

kirbyeagle Flag south east london 12 Jul 16 10.19am

No sorry I dont know them

Originally posted by DeSouza

I hope you're right, I think he's the player we need.

Quick question, are you any relation to David and Claire Kirby?

 

andyg Flag york 12 Jul 16 10.25am

[Link]

Football365 explain why Benteke at palace seems like a good fit

Gist:

Since 2012 - when Benteke joined Villa the only people to score more league goals than him are Aguero, Lukaku, Giroud + Sourez

His record at Villa was 42 goals in 89 games, for a team that finished 15th, 15th & 17th. He just didnt suit Liverpools style.

News today that Newcastle are demanding £35 million for Sissoko. With the crazy transfer fee inflation is 30 million such a rediculous fee.

 

tylerbrook Flag perth 12 Jul 16 10.27am

What price can you put on a 20 goal a season striker.
If we do sign him we are definitely paying over the odds by a good 6 or 7m. But he will score goals.
Other than a Chinese club I can't really see anyone else paying that for him & he definitely won't get game time at Liverpool so I think his hands are tied.
I would have thought him & his agent are just waiting as long as long as they can incase another offer comes in.
This transfer is killing me though. The Lombardo one was bad, checking teletext every two minutes. But this one is painful.

 

Sir James Hird Flag Mount Martha 12 Jul 16 10.31am

Originally posted by kirbyeagle

No sorry I dont know them

Is there a prize if we guess who you are?
Are you Steve Parish?
Your smoke and mirrors comments of reassurance sounded as if you were close to the action.

 

daven Flag Hailsham 12 Jul 16 10.34am

I agree that to stay in the premier league means we need to buy more expensive players.But the money in wages seems to be a step up too far.Its ok getting a player in for £130,000 per week when the average is close to that like Liverpool, but our average must be well below that.He seems to want more money after being a flop,and Liverpool want all their money back for a mistake.

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 12 Jul 16 10.35am

Originally posted by kirbyeagle

Smoke and mirrors, benteke to be signed soon for sure, I think agents and such like have said a lot on his behalf yet nothing from himself, obviously he wants best wage possible and if I know steve parish then there would be a compromise somewhere to legislate poor number of games played last term and if he is near meeting last years value paid then somewhere there will be a compromise, sounds to me as if agents trying to get his wack, normal in a deal this size, this is unfamiliar transfer dealings for palace and we might find many players agents in the high earning bracket will fight tooth and nail for all the extras, just the way it is unfortunately, I still think this is a goer and despite everyone frustrations the time scale is a hazard of modern football, if players are taking what is to be considered a backward step then they ultimately lose money , so they are just trying to make up the shortfall IMO

Benteke announced as a palace player end of this week or beginning of next week

Agree with this. We are in the territory of the top 6 with this one and agents hold a lot of power and fight for every last penny. I believe it'll happen but may be another week or so yet.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Jul 16 10.35am

I don't know if it's been mentioned anywhere in this thread but a few weeks ago a Villa fan told me that Beneteke's agent, Kismet Eris, is a really sh1tty person to deal with and a reptation for being one of the worst around.

I cannot believe Benteke or LFC (Klopp to be precise) will be happy with Benteke staying at Liverpool. He has no chance of playing and Klopp will ostracise more to get the message across.

He'll be leaving Liverpool and I think it will be in this window. Question is where to?

If the CB deal is off at the moment (we don't know if it is off), we need to advance with other targets and if CB is on again, it's on again. If not, there's nothing much we can do.

 


COYP

davehuggins Flag 12 Jul 16 10.39am

Guys, this saga is a nightmare. Firstly SP will have all the angles covered as he loves Palace as much as we do. If Benteke does sign then it will be right for the club that I am sure of. If he doesn't come then AP & SP will get in a good alternative of that I am also sure. So lets keep everything crossed and hope for the correct outcome in 2010 I trust!!

 

Cannonball Flag High in the Ozarks. 12 Jul 16 10.42am

There are better strikers around available for less money I'm sure. Our scouts need to get working harder.

 


Touch my coffee and I will slap you so hard even Google won't be able to find you.

slubglurge Flag welling 12 Jul 16 10.44am

Have we actually made a bid? Haven't heard a dicky bird from both clubs, it's just media frenzy from so called ITK journos

 

sprites Flag Auckland 12 Jul 16 10.44am

Originally posted by Cannonball

There are better strikers around available for less money I'm sure. Our scouts need to get working harder.

Yeah? Who?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 12 Jul 16 10.49am

Originally posted by tylerbrook

What price can you put on a 20 goal a season striker.
If we do sign him we are definitely paying over the odds by a good 6 or 7m.

<snip>

I would have thought him & his agent are just waiting as long as long as they can incase another offer comes in.

You claim that we will be paying "over the odds" and that the correct figure should be £24m or £25m but how do you arrive at that figure?

I have no objection to the player and his agent keeping us waiting to see if any better offers come along as long as we are doing the same and seeing if we can come up with a "better" alternative too

 

tylerbrook Flag perth 12 Jul 16 11.01am

Yea I'd say 24 or 25m.
He's had a poor season at a big club. His value should have dropped but Liverpool know we're desperate for a goalscorer & are playing hardball.
I think SP knows exactly what he's doing.
He won't mind paying over the odds for somone like Benteke.

 

MichaelCPFC Flag Darlington, Up Norf! 12 Jul 16 11.05am

Originally posted by tylerbrook

Yea I'd say 24 or 25m.
He's had a poor season at a big club. His value should have dropped but Liverpool know we're desperate for a goalscorer & are playing hardball.
I think SP knows exactly what he's doing.
He won't mind paying over the odds for somone like Benteke.

You also have to take into account the market increase with the new TV deal kicking in. What you'd have paid £20m for last season is £30m this year as a general example.

 


This club of mine constantly tests my loyalty but I as do many other fans never falter or crumble My loyalty to the Palace will never waver My unadulterated passion for a club I’ve grown up supporting wont die, and my desire to keep coming back and take the blows won’t succumb to negativity

Page 58 of 200 < 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic