This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote bubble wrap at 03 Sep 2015 12.17pm
Quote oldcodger at 02 Sep 2015 11.06pm
Quote bright&wright at 02 Sep 2015 8.13am
A mass exodus of a country's population is not an answer. You can't just run away from a situation. If we had in the 40's the whole world would look very different right about now. If I were so desperate to leave a war-torn country I'd settle in the first peaceful place I could find. So how the f*ck do they end up in Sweden? Oh yeah, because they want the p*ss-easy life that the Socialist Swedish Government will offer them. Free-loaders the lot of them, nothing more. Self preservation. I can understand both sides but when dead kids are getting washed up on beaches and people are using words like 'free loaders, the lot of them' it really does shine a light on the very worst side of human nature.
Was one child. Majority of imigrants/refugees/asylum seekers all seem to be men aged between 18-40 what about the women and children? Where are they fleeing too? Away, as opposed to. It seems they were hoping to end up in Canada, where they have relatives. Presumably they were intending to travel indirectly. Currently there are 1m Syrian refugees in Lebanon, which has a population of 4m.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Ironically, UKIP Nige seems to think we should be taking in more Syrian Refugees, and has called on the Prime Minister to do so. We should never confuse immigration with Asylum.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote johnfirewall at 03 Sep 2015 1.05pm
So are we going to send a few Hercules to collect refugees then? Banging on about needing to take more means absolutely nothing and isn't going to save kids from drowing in dodgy boats despite the accompanying pictures. It would reduce the frequency and probability though. What generally tends to happen is that refugees flee the country, to a bordering country, like Lebanon, and end up in a refugee camp. The UNHCR tries to then locate placements for refugees. The likelihood is that most of the people who are on the boats have likely passed through a Refugee camp at some point. The problem tends to be that there are more refugees than the UNHCR can place, and unsurprisingly people aren't keen on staying in refugee camps on the borders of the nation they've fled. So they try to make some headway, because its easier to get Asylum if your actually in a country, than not (even if the UK refused asylum, they'd never send people back into Syria). Currently around 5000 Syrians have asylum status in the UK, only around 200 were granted asylum via the UNHCR, most of them were Syrian nationals working/studying or residing in the UK when the war broke out. The simple fact is that we couldn't deport someone who is Syrian whilst the civil war is ongoing anyhow (there is no authority to deport them to). We can resist taking more from orthodox channels such as the UNHCR, but we'd never actually send anyone back if they happened to be in the country.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote bubble wrap at 03 Sep 2015 1.55pm
I might be selfish and am not racist but please, no more in our country. No objection to helping them but the problem is they never go back. Its ok for people to say yes let them come and we should let more in but they are not living on council estates or in areas flooded with Refugees/Imigrants/Asylum seekers who are stealing from the local shops, Stealing washing off lines and my gran had her She emptied Somalians who tried to sell the stuff to my uncle. If children are drowning trying to leave their country then stop them leaving, stop them getting into ramshackle boats and try and solve the problem they are fleeing from. Yeah, presumably though the only way to actually do that would be to offer them asylum somewhere, rather than just leaving them in crowded camps on the countries with a Syrian border. Lebanon, which has a population of 4m, has taken in some 850,000 Syrian refugees. As for solving the problem they are fleeing from, well that would be either the Al Nasar Front, IS or the Syrian Loyalists factions. Which would involve a full scale military intervention, with ground troops, in a region with minimal logistic support, engaging in an on going civil war. I'd imagine the losses of British Service men would probably be at least on a scale with Iraq and Afghanistan combined (not to mention the risk dragging Lebanon and Turkey into the conflict). The Assad regime and allies number in or around at least 200,000 without counting air and naval forces. IS and allies around 80,000. That's a very serious conflict to then put British ground troops into, especially given the only reliable line of support would be either via Israel via the Golan Heights, or the Kurdish regions, via Turkey.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote bubble wrap at 03 Sep 2015 12.17pm
Quote oldcodger at 02 Sep 2015 11.06pm
Quote bright&wright at 02 Sep 2015 8.13am
A mass exodus of a country's population is not an answer. You can't just run away from a situation. If we had in the 40's the whole world would look very different right about now. If I were so desperate to leave a war-torn country I'd settle in the first peaceful place I could find. So how the f*ck do they end up in Sweden? Oh yeah, because they want the p*ss-easy life that the Socialist Swedish Government will offer them. Free-loaders the lot of them, nothing more. Self preservation. I can understand both sides but when dead kids are getting washed up on beaches and people are using words like 'free loaders, the lot of them' it really does shine a light on the very worst side of human nature.
Was one child. Majority of imigrants/refugees/asylum seekers all seem to be men aged between 18-40 what about the women and children? Where are they fleeing too? Another five confirmed, with a separate incident involving 12 adults.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 03 Sep 2015 2.53pm
Quote oldcodger at 03 Sep 2015 8.14am
Quote Stirlingsays at 03 Sep 2015 7.50am
Quote oldcodger at 02 Sep 2015 11.06pm
Quote bright&wright at 02 Sep 2015 8.13am
A mass exodus of a country's population is not an answer. You can't just run away from a situation. If we had in the 40's the whole world would look very different right about now. If I were so desperate to leave a war-torn country I'd settle in the first peaceful place I could find. So how the f*ck do they end up in Sweden? Oh yeah, because they want the p*ss-easy life that the Socialist Swedish Government will offer them. Free-loaders the lot of them, nothing more. Self preservation. I can understand both sides but when dead kids are getting washed up on beaches and people are using words like 'free loaders, the lot of them' it really does shine a light on the very worst side of human nature.
I have some sympathy for women and children to an extent but what are these young men doing running away? They should be fighting IS. Personally I doubt the worth of people who have no pride in their own country enough to not fight for it. What about the Syrians fighting IS.....Where is the money and aid for them? By fighting those animals they are keeping them from your door. Edited by Stirlingsays (03 Sep 2015 7.51am) Through our bad decision making as nations we have done more to help the ISIS of today come into being than these people who just want to get on with life. I honestly don't blame them for wanting to get out. It takes guts to make this journey too you know. Many have died whatever decision they made. You're not in a warzone, it's easy to sit there in your comfortable existence telling people risking their lives through one way or another that you 'doubt their worth' because they don't share your outlook. What a joke. Edited by oldcodger (03 Sep 2015 8.18am) No more of a joke than your opinion, no one said it was an easy choice to make, but make it they did. How do you think WW2 would have panned out if it weren’t for the French resistance? Hunted down and shot on sight, and that was the lucky ones, did they flee their own country ? nope they stayed and fought. I’m just saying there are two view points not just yours. I'm not saying it's not a s***ty situation to be in, nor am I dehumanising people (love to know how you worked that out) but is gathering up your family and getting on a dodgy tub and trusting your luck (and life) to a dodgy pirate any better than staying put ? Jamie made a good point, there are over a million refugees in bordering countries, what if they got together and tackled ISIS a million strong is bigger than our Army ten times over ! It would seem that when a country destabilises in the Middle Eastern part of the globe, Europe has to carry the can for it? I don't recall many Syrians risking life and limb to get to Britain during the Blitz to help us out, in fact we had to draw upon common wealth countries to keep our necks out of the brown stuff, Syria and the Middle East not so much. And as for you accusation that "our bad decision making as nations we have done more to help the ISIS of today come into being" is utterly wrong and as daft as saying it was Poland’s fault Hitler invaded for having to many Jews. ISIS are a fanatical bunch of loons we've always had them bleating on about hard done by this, and Allah that, HAMAS in 1986 proceeded by the Muslim Brother hood formed 1928, I could go on, but it's always been there. Total side note, but Syria of the time was part of the French empire, and occupied by the Vichy-French. So there wasn't really much as a nation they could have done. Although the Arab Legion, of around 12,000 did fight along side the allies in the North Africa Campaign. On a side note, the rise of IS doesn't have a basis in the 2003 Invasion of Iraq, which established Al-Qaeda in Iraq and created the Sunni insurgency, that would essentially form the basis of ISIS; that insurgency never really ended, it just switched towards a new focus with the rise of the Syrian Civil War - establishing a independent Sunni state. Many of the founders of ISIS and the Sunni allied groups, were also prisoners during the US occupation of Iraq, and forged alliances in detainment. ISIS in some form or another probably would have existed, but the driving force behind its capacity in Syria and Iraq, has been the Sunni Insurgency that had previously been directed against the Iraq state. What made it so effective in becoming a major force was being able to tap into the leaders and resources of that Insurgency, which included ex-Bathhist officers and troops of the Saddam Era. Almost certainly though without the 2003 Invasion, and the decision to sack the Iraqi army, de-baathisation and the insurgency of the Sunni triangle, ISIS would never have been able to establish itself as a major player let alone capture territory sufficient to declare its self IS (the Caliphate). So to an extent, IS grew out of the decisions and failures of the 2003 Invasion of Iraq, and the aftermath - I wouldn't really say they were UK errors, as the UK role was largely limited to the south of Iraq, but the US certainly made important decisions that essentially set in motion events that defined where we are now.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 03 Sep 2015 2.57pm
Quote leggedstruggle at 03 Sep 2015 2.47pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Sep 2015 12.31pm
Quote leggedstruggle at 03 Sep 2015 10.54am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Sep 2015 9.30am
Quote leggedstruggle at 03 Sep 2015 9.27am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Sep 2015 3.14pm
Quote leggedstruggle at 02 Sep 2015 1.54pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Sep 2015 1.21pm
What constitutes an anti-British community though? In terms of the UK, terrorism, seems to have a history of being by people who are British (UK Born Muslims and British Irish). Doesn't that illustrate one of the problems - born here but loyalties lay elsewhere. Not necessarily, some of those terrorists were very pro-British. In what sense? Their own sense, loyalist groups. The Northern Ireland 'loyalist' terrorists are not particularly pro-British, they are anti-Catholic. They are Irish and want to live in a Protestant Ireland. They are anti-British in that they carried out terrorist acts contrary to British law and sometimes involving British targets. Their 'loyalties' do not lie with Britain but to a Protestant partition of Ireland. It is like saying 'British' Muslim extremists are pro-British because they want an Islamic state in Britain. Good response, I'd have said that the loyalists terrorists supported the loyalist political parties cause of anti-republicanism, but the anti-Catholic element of loyalism can't really be down played. I think they're only really pro-British as it would be impossible for them to survive as an independent state. The left try to play down the fact that it is basically a Catholic/Protestant thing. Imagine if the Reformation had not taken place in England. The English settlers/invaders in Ireland would have been Catholics. Many years ago a united and independent Ireland would have come about, probably without any violence at all. Not to mention the Church of England only came about because one Syph ridden serial adulterer (King ‘Enery) didn’t like the Catholics ideas on divorce and monogamy True, but it had already granted him a divorce at that point. Effectively though, the issue isn't just that, its a series of issues between the authority of the English Crown and the power of the Church, that just came to a head with Henry VIII being in a place and time, where he could do something about it once and for all.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 03 Sep 2015 2.26pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 03 Sep 2015 1.21pm
Ironically, UKIP Nige seems to think we should be taking in more Syrian Refugees, and has called on the Prime Minister to do so. We should never confuse immigration with Asylum.
Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (03 Sep 2015 2.26pm) A valid point of course is that had we not agreed to the EU right to work, taking in a large number of refugees wouldn't be an issue. Problem of course is that the driver behind the EU working laws, was corporate interests, who were sponsors of both the Conservative and Labour party of the time, so there never was a chance of us not signing up.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote leggedstruggle at 03 Sep 2015 2.47pm
The left try to play down the fact that it is basically a Catholic/Protestant thing. Imagine if the Reformation had not taken place in England. The English settlers/invaders in Ireland would have been Catholics. Many years ago a united and independent Ireland would have come about, probably without any violence at all. I don't think you can dismiss it entirely, especially in regards to the rise of 'troubles' in the 60s, the origin of the Provisional IRA and the UK military in NI relates entirely to Protests 'burning out' Catholics. The Provisional split from the IRA over the official IRA's hesitancy to take a direct hand, and British troops initially were sent to Ireland to protect Catholic communities.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.