This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 2.31pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.06pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 1.29pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 1.11pm
Quote Kermit8 at 08 Dec 2015 8.23pm
Countries like Canada, New Zealand, Finland and the Netherlands have successfully combined a free market capitalist economy with a high class state run health, education and welfare systems that are supported by high taxes which prove that socialism can thrive and survive when it is implemented in a moderate fashion.
Canada... NZ... high taxes... No. You keep saying these countries are examples of socialism but none of them are. And the ones that actually are or were, you dismiss.
14th paragraph onward Maybe he knows a bit more than you or I about such matters.
That's 5 years old.
Some think Nova Scotians pay 42% tax whilst others say 30%
Income tax rates all lower, sales tax rates all lower. What ones are you talking about?
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.33pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 2.31pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.06pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 1.29pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 1.11pm
Quote Kermit8 at 08 Dec 2015 8.23pm
Countries like Canada, New Zealand, Finland and the Netherlands have successfully combined a free market capitalist economy with a high class state run health, education and welfare systems that are supported by high taxes which prove that socialism can thrive and survive when it is implemented in a moderate fashion.
Canada... NZ... high taxes... No. You keep saying these countries are examples of socialism but none of them are. And the ones that actually are or were, you dismiss.
14th paragraph onward Maybe he knows a bit more than you or I about such matters.
That's 5 years old.
Some think Nova Scotians pay 42% tax whilst others say 30%
Income tax rates all lower, sales tax rates all lower. What ones are you talking about?
I am just bowing to that Forbes guy. He seems to know his stuff. Nothing you or Matthew have posted has come up with anything to truly negate the seeming fact that some of the most successful countries in the world have a strong sense of moderate socialism functioning well within their societies. I don't see why that can't be admired for what it is rather than sniped at. Just because to some 'socialism' is 100% unworkable I suppose, no matter the evidence of today and in the past to say otherwise. The NHS? Free education? Etc. They must count for something via the left field.
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
|
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 3.08pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.33pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 2.31pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.06pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 1.29pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 1.11pm
Quote Kermit8 at 08 Dec 2015 8.23pm
Countries like Canada, New Zealand, Finland and the Netherlands have successfully combined a free market capitalist economy with a high class state run health, education and welfare systems that are supported by high taxes which prove that socialism can thrive and survive when it is implemented in a moderate fashion.
Canada... NZ... high taxes... No. You keep saying these countries are examples of socialism but none of them are. And the ones that actually are or were, you dismiss.
14th paragraph onward Maybe he knows a bit more than you or I about such matters.
That's 5 years old.
Some think Nova Scotians pay 42% tax whilst others say 30%
Income tax rates all lower, sales tax rates all lower. What ones are you talking about?
I am just bowing to that Forbes guy. He seems to know his stuff. Nothing you or Matthew have posted has come up with anything to truly negate the seeming fact that some of the most successful countries in the world have a strong sense of moderate socialism functioning well within their societies. I don't see why that can't be admired for what it is rather than sniped at. Just because to some 'socialism' is 100% unworkable I suppose, no matter the evidence of today and in the past to say otherwise. The NHS? Free education? Etc. They must count for something via the left field.
Having a social welfare programme is different from being socialist. This is what you plainly do not see, or want to see. For example, One Nation politics is capitalism with social welfare built in not with a 'bit' of socialism. I fail to see how you can be a 'bit' socialist. Socialism is an ideology seeking control of markets. All of the countries you mention are free market economies running social welfare programmes. What does a 'bit' socialist mean? It's like saying someone is a bit gay, it is meaningless and disingenuous. What you are trying to do is convince yourself that some sort of 'third way', as espoused by Tony Blair and French politicians exists which provides the best of both Worlds. It doesn't and won't happen. Cue a s*** load of years old internet links provided to back up your spurious 'thoughts'.
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
|
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 3.08pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.33pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 2.31pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.06pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 1.29pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 1.11pm
Quote Kermit8 at 08 Dec 2015 8.23pm
Countries like Canada, New Zealand, Finland and the Netherlands have successfully combined a free market capitalist economy with a high class state run health, education and welfare systems that are supported by high taxes which prove that socialism can thrive and survive when it is implemented in a moderate fashion.
Canada... NZ... high taxes... No. You keep saying these countries are examples of socialism but none of them are. And the ones that actually are or were, you dismiss.
14th paragraph onward Maybe he knows a bit more than you or I about such matters.
That's 5 years old.
Some think Nova Scotians pay 42% tax whilst others say 30%
Income tax rates all lower, sales tax rates all lower. What ones are you talking about?
I am just bowing to that Forbes guy. He seems to know his stuff. Nothing you or Matthew have posted has come up with anything to truly negate the seeming fact that some of the most successful countries in the world have a strong sense of moderate socialism functioning well within their societies. I don't see why that can't be admired for what it is rather than sniped at. Just because to some 'socialism' is 100% unworkable I suppose, no matter the evidence of today and in the past to say otherwise. The NHS? Free education? Etc. They must count for something via the left field. f***ing hell, Kerm. You could at least try. Pick a tax, any tax. Nothing the Forbes bloke has written says that NZ and Canada have higher taxes, you did. That was what I questioned of your post and it seems you were wrong, you certainly haven't backed it up whereas I've found the first two examples, that most people think of in terms of taxation, disprove your statement. Edited by Stuk (09 Dec 2015 3.41pm)
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 3.32pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 3.08pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.33pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 2.31pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.06pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 1.29pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 1.11pm
Quote Kermit8 at 08 Dec 2015 8.23pm
Countries like Canada, New Zealand, Finland and the Netherlands have successfully combined a free market capitalist economy with a high class state run health, education and welfare systems that are supported by high taxes which prove that socialism can thrive and survive when it is implemented in a moderate fashion.
Canada... NZ... high taxes... No. You keep saying these countries are examples of socialism but none of them are. And the ones that actually are or were, you dismiss.
14th paragraph onward Maybe he knows a bit more than you or I about such matters.
That's 5 years old.
Some think Nova Scotians pay 42% tax whilst others say 30%
Income tax rates all lower, sales tax rates all lower. What ones are you talking about?
I am just bowing to that Forbes guy. He seems to know his stuff. Nothing you or Matthew have posted has come up with anything to truly negate the seeming fact that some of the most successful countries in the world have a strong sense of moderate socialism functioning well within their societies. I don't see why that can't be admired for what it is rather than sniped at. Just because to some 'socialism' is 100% unworkable I suppose, no matter the evidence of today and in the past to say otherwise. The NHS? Free education? Etc. They must count for something via the left field. f***ing hell, Kerm. You could at least try. Pick a tax, any tax. Nothing the Forbes bloke has written says that NZ and Canada have higher taxes, you did. That was what I questioned of your post and it seems you were wrong, you certainly haven't backed it up whereas I've found the first two examples, that most people think of in terms of taxation, disprove your statement. Edited by Stuk (09 Dec 2015 3.41pm)
I made no comparison to the UK. You did. What are we disagreeing about again?
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
|
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 4.51pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 3.32pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 3.08pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.33pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 2.31pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.06pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 1.29pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 1.11pm
Quote Kermit8 at 08 Dec 2015 8.23pm
Countries like Canada, New Zealand, Finland and the Netherlands have successfully combined a free market capitalist economy with a high class state run health, education and welfare systems that are supported by high taxes which prove that socialism can thrive and survive when it is implemented in a moderate fashion.
Canada... NZ... high taxes... No. You keep saying these countries are examples of socialism but none of them are. And the ones that actually are or were, you dismiss.
14th paragraph onward Maybe he knows a bit more than you or I about such matters.
That's 5 years old.
Some think Nova Scotians pay 42% tax whilst others say 30%
Income tax rates all lower, sales tax rates all lower. What ones are you talking about?
I am just bowing to that Forbes guy. He seems to know his stuff. Nothing you or Matthew have posted has come up with anything to truly negate the seeming fact that some of the most successful countries in the world have a strong sense of moderate socialism functioning well within their societies. I don't see why that can't be admired for what it is rather than sniped at. Just because to some 'socialism' is 100% unworkable I suppose, no matter the evidence of today and in the past to say otherwise. The NHS? Free education? Etc. They must count for something via the left field. f***ing hell, Kerm. You could at least try. Pick a tax, any tax. Nothing the Forbes bloke has written says that NZ and Canada have higher taxes, you did. That was what I questioned of your post and it seems you were wrong, you certainly haven't backed it up whereas I've found the first two examples, that most people think of in terms of taxation, disprove your statement. Edited by Stuk (09 Dec 2015 3.41pm)
I made no comparison to the UK. You did. What are we disagreeing about again? No I read it as high, as I wrote. and then said i.e. any that are higher than ours? You clearly hold those countries as more socialist than the UK and said they do it via high taxes, so I asked for any taxes they have that are higher than ours. I chose income and sales tax and neither country has higher tax rates than us for either. That any of the 4 countries you listed could be classed as socialist, partly socialist, semi socialist etc are not, they're capitalist just like us.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Quote matt_himself at 09 Dec 2015 3.25pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 3.08pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.33pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 2.31pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.06pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 1.29pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 1.11pm
Quote Kermit8 at 08 Dec 2015 8.23pm
Countries like Canada, New Zealand, Finland and the Netherlands have successfully combined a free market capitalist economy with a high class state run health, education and welfare systems that are supported by high taxes which prove that socialism can thrive and survive when it is implemented in a moderate fashion.
Canada... NZ... high taxes... No. You keep saying these countries are examples of socialism but none of them are. And the ones that actually are or were, you dismiss.
14th paragraph onward Maybe he knows a bit more than you or I about such matters.
That's 5 years old.
Some think Nova Scotians pay 42% tax whilst others say 30%
Income tax rates all lower, sales tax rates all lower. What ones are you talking about?
I am just bowing to that Forbes guy. He seems to know his stuff. Nothing you or Matthew have posted has come up with anything to truly negate the seeming fact that some of the most successful countries in the world have a strong sense of moderate socialism functioning well within their societies. I don't see why that can't be admired for what it is rather than sniped at. Just because to some 'socialism' is 100% unworkable I suppose, no matter the evidence of today and in the past to say otherwise. The NHS? Free education? Etc. They must count for something via the left field.
Having a social welfare programme is different from being socialist. This is what you plainly do not see, or want to see. For example, One Nation politics is capitalism with social welfare built in not with a 'bit' of socialism. I fail to see how you can be a 'bit' socialist. Socialism is an ideology seeking control of markets. All of the countries you mention are free market economies running social welfare programmes. What does a 'bit' socialist mean? It's like saying someone is a bit gay, it is meaningless and disingenuous. What you are trying to do is convince yourself that some sort of 'third way', as espoused by Tony Blair and French politicians exists which provides the best of both Worlds. It doesn't and won't happen. Cue a s*** load of years old internet links provided to back up your spurious 'thoughts'.
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
|
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 5.01pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 4.51pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 3.32pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 3.08pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.33pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 2.31pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.06pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 1.29pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 1.11pm
Quote Kermit8 at 08 Dec 2015 8.23pm
Countries like Canada, New Zealand, Finland and the Netherlands have successfully combined a free market capitalist economy with a high class state run health, education and welfare systems that are supported by high taxes which prove that socialism can thrive and survive when it is implemented in a moderate fashion.
Canada... NZ... high taxes... No. You keep saying these countries are examples of socialism but none of them are. And the ones that actually are or were, you dismiss.
14th paragraph onward Maybe he knows a bit more than you or I about such matters.
That's 5 years old.
Some think Nova Scotians pay 42% tax whilst others say 30%
Income tax rates all lower, sales tax rates all lower. What ones are you talking about?
I am just bowing to that Forbes guy. He seems to know his stuff. Nothing you or Matthew have posted has come up with anything to truly negate the seeming fact that some of the most successful countries in the world have a strong sense of moderate socialism functioning well within their societies. I don't see why that can't be admired for what it is rather than sniped at. Just because to some 'socialism' is 100% unworkable I suppose, no matter the evidence of today and in the past to say otherwise. The NHS? Free education? Etc. They must count for something via the left field. f***ing hell, Kerm. You could at least try. Pick a tax, any tax. Nothing the Forbes bloke has written says that NZ and Canada have higher taxes, you did. That was what I questioned of your post and it seems you were wrong, you certainly haven't backed it up whereas I've found the first two examples, that most people think of in terms of taxation, disprove your statement. Edited by Stuk (09 Dec 2015 3.41pm)
I made no comparison to the UK. You did. What are we disagreeing about again? No I read it as high, as I wrote. and then said i.e. any that are higher than ours? You clearly hold those countries as more socialist than the UK and said they do it via high taxes, so I asked for any taxes they have that are higher than ours. I chose income and sales tax and neither country has higher tax rates than us for either. That any of the 4 countries you listed could be classed as socialist, partly socialist, semi socialist etc are not, they're capitalist just like us.
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
|
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 5.03pm
Quote matt_himself at 09 Dec 2015 3.25pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 3.08pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.33pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 2.31pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.06pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 1.29pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 1.11pm
Quote Kermit8 at 08 Dec 2015 8.23pm
Countries like Canada, New Zealand, Finland and the Netherlands have successfully combined a free market capitalist economy with a high class state run health, education and welfare systems that are supported by high taxes which prove that socialism can thrive and survive when it is implemented in a moderate fashion.
Canada... NZ... high taxes... No. You keep saying these countries are examples of socialism but none of them are. And the ones that actually are or were, you dismiss.
14th paragraph onward Maybe he knows a bit more than you or I about such matters.
That's 5 years old.
Some think Nova Scotians pay 42% tax whilst others say 30%
Income tax rates all lower, sales tax rates all lower. What ones are you talking about?
I am just bowing to that Forbes guy. He seems to know his stuff. Nothing you or Matthew have posted has come up with anything to truly negate the seeming fact that some of the most successful countries in the world have a strong sense of moderate socialism functioning well within their societies. I don't see why that can't be admired for what it is rather than sniped at. Just because to some 'socialism' is 100% unworkable I suppose, no matter the evidence of today and in the past to say otherwise. The NHS? Free education? Etc. They must count for something via the left field.
Having a social welfare programme is different from being socialist. This is what you plainly do not see, or want to see. For example, One Nation politics is capitalism with social welfare built in not with a 'bit' of socialism. I fail to see how you can be a 'bit' socialist. Socialism is an ideology seeking control of markets. All of the countries you mention are free market economies running social welfare programmes. What does a 'bit' socialist mean? It's like saying someone is a bit gay, it is meaningless and disingenuous. What you are trying to do is convince yourself that some sort of 'third way', as espoused by Tony Blair and French politicians exists which provides the best of both Worlds. It doesn't and won't happen. Cue a s*** load of years old internet links provided to back up your spurious 'thoughts'.
Michael, I gave you a critique of where your politics was misguided. You, to quote one of your chums, went for the man not the ball. Sadly, you do this all too often because, as I said above, your posts are mostly self deluded bulls***. With the time you have on your hands, you would have thought that you could research your 'opinion' a bit more before posting.
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
|
Quote matt_himself at 09 Dec 2015 9.53pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 5.03pm
Quote matt_himself at 09 Dec 2015 3.25pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 3.08pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.33pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 2.31pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 2.06pm
Quote Kermit8 at 09 Dec 2015 1.29pm
Quote Stuk at 09 Dec 2015 1.11pm
Quote Kermit8 at 08 Dec 2015 8.23pm
Countries like Canada, New Zealand, Finland and the Netherlands have successfully combined a free market capitalist economy with a high class state run health, education and welfare systems that are supported by high taxes which prove that socialism can thrive and survive when it is implemented in a moderate fashion.
Canada... NZ... high taxes... No. You keep saying these countries are examples of socialism but none of them are. And the ones that actually are or were, you dismiss.
14th paragraph onward Maybe he knows a bit more than you or I about such matters.
That's 5 years old.
Some think Nova Scotians pay 42% tax whilst others say 30%
Income tax rates all lower, sales tax rates all lower. What ones are you talking about?
I am just bowing to that Forbes guy. He seems to know his stuff. Nothing you or Matthew have posted has come up with anything to truly negate the seeming fact that some of the most successful countries in the world have a strong sense of moderate socialism functioning well within their societies. I don't see why that can't be admired for what it is rather than sniped at. Just because to some 'socialism' is 100% unworkable I suppose, no matter the evidence of today and in the past to say otherwise. The NHS? Free education? Etc. They must count for something via the left field.
Having a social welfare programme is different from being socialist. This is what you plainly do not see, or want to see. For example, One Nation politics is capitalism with social welfare built in not with a 'bit' of socialism. I fail to see how you can be a 'bit' socialist. Socialism is an ideology seeking control of markets. All of the countries you mention are free market economies running social welfare programmes. What does a 'bit' socialist mean? It's like saying someone is a bit gay, it is meaningless and disingenuous. What you are trying to do is convince yourself that some sort of 'third way', as espoused by Tony Blair and French politicians exists which provides the best of both Worlds. It doesn't and won't happen. Cue a s*** load of years old internet links provided to back up your spurious 'thoughts'.
Michael, I gave you a critique of where your politics was misguided. You, to quote one of your chums, went for the man not the ball. Sadly, you do this all too often because, as I said above, your posts are mostly self deluded bulls***. With the time you have on your hands, you would have thought that you could research your 'opinion' a bit more before posting.
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote NickRobinson at 09 Dec 2015 7.29pm
Quote Kermit8 at 08 Dec 2015 8.23pm
Countries like Canada, New Zealand, Finland and the Netherlands have successfully combined a free market capitalist economy with a high class state run health, education and welfare systems that are supported by high taxes which prove that socialism can thrive and survive when it is implemented in a moderate fashion.
You are merely trying to redefine socialism. The core of socialism is taking into public ownership (actually running things really badly by an inefficient state bureaucracy not remotely owned by the public) all means of production, distribution and exchange. You then say that countries that have a health service are partially socialist. Saudia Arabia and Israel have what amounts to National Health Services - do you regard those countries as socialist? Socialism needs and should redefine itself in line with modern developments and changes, and there is nothing wrong with that - It vital for all society to redefine its concepts as society changes and evolves (what Foucault describes as Discourse Resolution). That's the problem with Religion, a tendency to look back at particular texts. Harking back to just Karl Marx is a failure to understand the importance of history and social development.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by matt_himself
Venezuela is in melt down. Food shortages, lack of basic services and a totalitarian paranoid hard left regime refusing to bend: [Link] Interesting that all the media leftie luvvies have ceased their support for Venezuela: Really? Whaddaloadabull.
|
|
|
Originally posted by matt_himself
Venezuela is in melt down. Food shortages, lack of basic services and a totalitarian paranoid hard left regime refusing to bend: Vote Corbyn and this is what you will get. Interesting that all the media leftie luvvies have ceased their support for Venezuela: They have the largest oil reserves in the world and a population of 30 million. It should be one of the most prosperous countries on the planet.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Really? Whaddaloadabull. Corbyn and Chavez share the same politics, the same economics and both believe in state intervention. Worryingly, Chavez destroyed democracy and moved the country towards leftish fascism. How can you say what you say? Corbyn will wreck this country if he was given the chance, just like Chavez and Maduro have done to Venezuela. Venezuela is a prime example of the dangers of socialism. Ignore it at your peril.
"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02 |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by matt_himself
Corbyn and Chavez share the same politics, the same economics and both believe in state intervention. Worryingly, Chavez destroyed democracy and moved the country towards leftish fascism. How can you say what you say? Corbyn will wreck this country if he was given the chance, just like Chavez and Maduro have done to Venezuela. Venezuela is a prime example of the dangers of socialism. Ignore it at your peril. Venezuela is a prime example of an economy that relies on a commodity of which the value has crashed due to circumstances beyond its control.
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 21 May 16 10.02am | |
|---|---|
|
No arguing today lads...... Get behind Palace!
|
|
|
I hate Venezuela Ruined the South African World cup
Lend me a Tenor 31 May to 3 June 2017 John McIntosh Arts Centre with Superfly in the chorus |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.