You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Stadium Redevelopment
November 16 2026 4.13am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Stadium Redevelopment


Page 6 of 154 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Apr 16 5.48pm

Originally posted by rikz

It's pretty common knowledge that we've had discussions with sainsburys about the redevelopment of the ground. I ment they owned the land they occupy and their car park, I would be very surprised if we could do anything without their permission. It's not just planning permission you need, you also have to pass building regulations, building on our own land would surely affect them.

Very few people know exactly what discussions have been held or what/if anything is holding things up but it seems like any redevelopment at the moment would include a brand new superstore for sainsburys.


Yeah course you did. That's why you posted this, 'You do realise that sainsburys own the land and car park.', after I said we own our car park and Sainsbury's own their's.

Maybe you need a dictionary.

There has certainly been hesitancy or a methodical or a strategic management decision to delay things because we never had the f***ing money in 2010 onwards and a 'concept design' at CPP was just that, nothing more, something you refuse to admit.

I've had enough of it now.

 


COYP

rikz Flag Croydon 21 Apr 16 6.08pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Yeah course you did. That's why you posted this, 'You do realise that sainsburys own the land and car park.', after I said we own our car park and Sainsbury's own their's.

Maybe you need a dictionary.

There has certainly been hesitancy or a methodical or a strategic management decision to delay things because we never had the f***ing money in 2010 onwards and a 'concept design' at CPP was just that, nothing more, something you refuse to admit.

I've had enough of it now.

Yeah because I really think sainsburys own our stadium, that was the whole point of the protest gainst lloyds so we could buy the stadium, and what saved our club you idiot, you've shown you know absolutely nothing on the subject. You are know all but f*** all and are really boring me now. Next time how about doing some actual research on a subject you know so little about. It's not hard there are plenty of sources. straight from the owners mouth how we need to work with sainsburys to redevelop. Tara

 

tonymair Flag 21 Apr 16 6.58pm

I want to renew my season tickets, I plan to...but don't know what I am buying in to!
Will my seats in the Grand Stand be there next season?
Will they be there ALL season?
I plan to do nothing until I know more, and do not understand the silence.
Over to you Steve
TM

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Apr 16 7.35pm

Originally posted by rikz

Yeah because I really think sainsburys own our stadium, that was the whole point of the protest gainst lloyds so we could buy the stadium, and what saved our club you idiot, you've shown you know absolutely nothing on the subject. You are know all but f*** all and are really boring me now. Next time how about doing some actual research on a subject you know so little about. It's not hard there are plenty of sources. straight from the owners mouth how we need to work with sainsburys to redevelop. Tara

What a trying little man. If you're going to be specific, then be specific rather than general so I or anyone else doesn't have to go back to your previous drivel to fill in the gaps or know what you're dribbling about. As if I think Sainsbury's own our land/stadium. You said 'THE car park.'

I've been supporting this club a lot longer than you. I know where our car park ends. I know what Noades leased to us, I know the history of admins and bank protests. I also know you're quite a moron.

Your black and white views are very simple for someone who thinks they're smart. You're a gullible idiot. You don't appreciate finances were pausing this from progressing at all and you think football fans aren't as intelligent as you. You also take what people say as gospel when it's plainly obvious the money was being saved before anything was going to happen, but you refuse to believe it. Anyway, it's laughable. Laters.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (21 Apr 2016 7.46pm)

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Apr 16 7.48pm

Originally posted by tonymair

I want to renew my season tickets, I plan to...but don't know what I am buying in to!
Will my seats in the Grand Stand be there next season?
Will they be there ALL season?
I plan to do nothing until I know more, and do not understand the silence.
Over to you Steve
TM

The new stand they want to build, the back half they want to build behind the current one. When that's built, the current one is dismantled. The the front half is built. I doubt anyone will lose their main stand ST. You might be moved from old to new upper back to new lower, but it won't be happening next season that's for sure.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (21 Apr 2016 8.15pm)

 


COYP

rikz Flag Croydon 21 Apr 16 10.10pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

What a trying little man. If you're going to be specific, then be specific rather than general so I or anyone else doesn't have to go back to your previous drivel to fill in the gaps or know what you're dribbling about. As if I think Sainsbury's own our land/stadium. You said 'THE car park.'

I've been supporting this club a lot longer than you. I know where our car park ends. I know what Noades leased to us, I know the history of admins and bank protests. I also know you're quite a moron.

Your black and white views are very simple for someone who thinks they're smart. You're a gullible idiot. You don't appreciate finances were pausing this from progressing at all and you think football fans aren't as intelligent as you. You also take what people say as gospel when it's plainly obvious the money was being saved before anything was going to happen, but you refuse to believe it. Anyway, it's laughable. Laters.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (21 Apr 2016 7.46pm)

Look mate I understand every point you've made. Regardless The best thing for the club is to relocate, the last thing the owners wanted to do was redevelop selhurst. As it turns out that is our only option. We could be the best and richest team in the world, it would not change a thing.

The club has had to work tirelessly and hold god knows how many discussion just to make plans to redevelop the main stand and still nothing concrete, we've got problems with local residents, who will get full backing from local MP's and we've never had a decent relationship with the local council.

Then we need to look into the whitehorse end, who just so happen to have a sainsburys (one of the biggest companies in the UK) attatched. They are probably worth more than every club in britian put together. Do you really think they will just alow us to do as we please and go along with it. No we will need to work with them to ensure it suits and works best for them aswell.

That's supposedly the easiest 2 stands to redevelop aswell. The club haven't even looked into redeveloping the arthur due to it causing the most problems. This is a stand that half the pitch you can see and you can barely move in at half time. Add into it that the holmesdale end, not even 30 years old is sinking and you can see why it's not so straight forward.

This brand new redeveloped selhurst that some fans seem to envisage is pretty much impossible regardless of money and success on the pitch. The fact is the only people who care about the club are the fans and owners, no one else could care less unfortunately for us, we need a lot of people to care to make these things happen.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Apr 16 10.53pm

Originally posted by rikz

Look mate I understand every point you've made. Regardless The best thing for the club is to relocate, the last thing the owners wanted to do was redevelop selhurst. As it turns out that is our only option. We could be the best and richest team in the world, it would not change a thing.

The club has had to work tirelessly and hold god knows how many discussion just to make plans to redevelop the main stand and still nothing concrete, we've got problems with local residents, who will get full backing from local MP's and we've never had a decent relationship with the local council.

Then we need to look into the whitehorse end, who just so happen to have a sainsburys (one of the biggest companies in the UK) attatched. They are probably worth more than every club in britian put together. Do you really think they will just alow us to do as we please and go along with it. No we will need to work with them to ensure it suits and works best for them aswell.

That's supposedly the easiest 2 stands to redevelop aswell. The club haven't even looked into redeveloping the arthur due to it causing the most problems. This is a stand that half the pitch you can see and you can barely move in at half time. Add into it that the holmesdale end, not even 30 years old is sinking and you can see why it's not so straight forward.

This brand new redeveloped selhurst that some fans seem to envisage is pretty much impossible regardless of money and success on the pitch. The fact is the only people who care about the club are the fans and owners, no one else could care less unfortunately for us, we need a lot of people to care to make these things happen.

Blimey, eloquent and not a hint of delusional superiority or in anyway pugnacious.

MP's have a duty to their constituents but during the Lloyds protests they stepped in to support CPFC. We're now establishing ourselves as a Premier League club permanently. That's a change from a shabby 2nd tier club that cannot fill it's seats anyway. The residents that are a current issue are the houses behind the main stand and to the side of the Holmesdale, not as far back as Clifton Rd. There are a few, but if SP has his initial architects drawings ready, and it sounds as if these don't need to be changed, but surrounding bits like access might need to be, you could be fretting about nothing. What's more, construction means jobs means economic growth. That'll apply to CPFC and Sainsbury's for that matter. Plus extra jobs after.

Sainsbury's are notoriously tight and apathetic when it comes to modernising. In the '90s they stayed asleep when Tesco went aggressively expanding or buying up land on the cheap for the next round of expansion, some of it with dubious methods with local councils. Look at Purley. Tesco took market share under their noses. Sainsbury's had 1 then a different Sainsbury's for decades. Look at Purley Way. Morrisons there now as well. The Selhurst Sainsbury's is a dump and never as full as the Tesco. Tesco are now on the decline. Still largest but in decline. What's more, Parish and co are more than able to communicate fairly and produce mutually beneficial proposals. I wouldn't be surprised if that's how it goes. A better store and ironically more parking. The Sainsbury's is 30 years old for a start. There are some very imaginative solutions to this kind of thing.

Whole rebuild not impossible. Bl00dy expensive, yes. Impossible, no. If it was impossible SP would not be presenting drawings to those he trusts and obtaining US investment. What would be the point? He'd be better off selling up or moving somewhere everyone wouldn't want.

The Holmesdale. Sinking it might be, but waiting to be the final stand rebuilt it will be able to survive for. It is perfectly acceptable for a while and impressive things can be done with foundation problems.

Arfur. With other stands having exec boxes there will be little need for that there. It can be the same height as the current one and with more concourse areas but with probably less seating. Possibly one large concourse in the middle and similar entry there is now. The other stands will make up for the few seats lost there. Were looking at between 30-40k anyway, not 50k.

 


COYP

rikz Flag Croydon 22 Apr 16 7.21pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Blimey, eloquent and not a hint of delusional superiority or in anyway pugnacious.

MP's have a duty to their constituents but during the Lloyds protests they stepped in to support CPFC. We're now establishing ourselves as a Premier League club permanently. That's a change from a shabby 2nd tier club that cannot fill it's seats anyway. The residents that are a current issue are the houses behind the main stand and to the side of the Holmesdale, not as far back as Clifton Rd. There are a few, but if SP has his initial architects drawings ready, and it sounds as if these don't need to be changed, but surrounding bits like access might need to be, you could be fretting about nothing. What's more, construction means jobs means economic growth. That'll apply to CPFC and Sainsbury's for that matter. Plus extra jobs after.

Sainsbury's are notoriously tight and apathetic when it comes to modernising. In the '90s they stayed asleep when Tesco went aggressively expanding or buying up land on the cheap for the next round of expansion, some of it with dubious methods with local councils. Look at Purley. Tesco took market share under their noses. Sainsbury's had 1 then a different Sainsbury's for decades. Look at Purley Way. Morrisons there now as well. The Selhurst Sainsbury's is a dump and never as full as the Tesco. Tesco are now on the decline. Still largest but in decline. What's more, Parish and co are more than able to communicate fairly and produce mutually beneficial proposals. I wouldn't be surprised if that's how it goes. A better store and ironically more parking. The Sainsbury's is 30 years old for a start. There are some very imaginative solutions to this kind of thing.

Whole rebuild not impossible. Bl00dy expensive, yes. Impossible, no. If it was impossible SP would not be presenting drawings to those he trusts and obtaining US investment. What would be the point? He'd be better off selling up or moving somewhere everyone wouldn't want.

The Holmesdale. Sinking it might be, but waiting to be the final stand rebuilt it will be able to survive for. It is perfectly acceptable for a while and impressive things can be done with foundation problems.

Arfur. With other stands having exec boxes there will be little need for that there. It can be the same height as the current one and with more concourse areas but with probably less seating. Possibly one large concourse in the middle and similar entry there is now. The other stands will make up for the few seats lost there. Were looking at between 30-40k anyway, not 50k.

So why bother with it ?

I agree with you, corporate facilities are a must, with tv money, clubs, rely less on ticket sales these days they really make little difference to the club. Corporate are the only ones that can make a difference financially to the club. the owners will be getting a redeveloped main stand pushed out asap, they have to to compete.

Then the whitehorse, sainsburys are supposedly holding a hard bargain but thats to be expected. I see it being a win win for them, pretty sure it will happen eventually, with sainsburys getting a very good deal. so a new stand with the idea of putting away fans there.

So now we have a new Whitehorse for away fans and a new main stand for corporate. Even if it adds 6k that brings us upto 32k.

We've got the arthur that holds 8k, tell me what benefit redeveloping that stand would bring to the club. It would cost millions and where is the financial return. Maybe it could include amneties for the local community, tho there's not much space. But redeveloping the arthur, is the squeeze worth the juice ?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Apr 16 7.54pm

Originally posted by rikz

So why bother with it ?

I agree with you, corporate facilities are a must, with tv money, clubs, rely less on ticket sales these days they really make little difference to the club. Corporate are the only ones that can make a difference financially to the club. the owners will be getting a redeveloped main stand pushed out asap, they have to to compete.

Then the whitehorse, sainsburys are supposedly holding a hard bargain but thats to be expected. I see it being a win win for them, pretty sure it will happen eventually, with sainsburys getting a very good deal. so a new stand with the idea of putting away fans there.

So now we have a new Whitehorse for away fans and a new main stand for corporate. Even if it adds 6k that brings us upto 32k.

We've got the arthur that holds 8k, tell me what benefit redeveloping that stand would bring to the club. It would cost millions and where is the financial return. Maybe it could include amneties for the local community, tho there's not much space. But redeveloping the arthur, is the squeeze worth the juice ?

Why bother with the Arfur?

- Well you complained that there was little room to move, get to the toilets, move about in the concourse area.

- You said away fans always complain about it being so sh1t and SP commenting on it.

- It is 47 years old. The main stand will be corporate or those ST holders who generally prefer staying seated with little comotion, the maturer supporters amongst us if you like, and the slightly vocal who like the interior bars in the Glaziers sections. Holmesdale almost sold out. WH Lane for away fans, possibly ST holders as well if segregated. Separate tiers possibly. So where do the ordinary people you're trying to attract go? Mainly the Arfur, as is pretty much the case now. What do modern day newcomers want? Modernity/comfort/decent food/drink outlets. A stadium redevelopment is just that, not half of one and leave a stand be when it's 47 years old. By the time the main stand and WH are finished it'll be older. The Holmesdale is 20 years old and although acceptable, that'll be much older too being the last in line.

- It needs to be done if you're planning to maximise seating within a confined space because joining the stands up adds quite a few thousand onto capacity. You cannot join stands without them being purpose built for that.

- If away fans are in the WH end then you probably will not need anything like the segregation there is now. More tickets to be sold.

 


COYP

rikz Flag Croydon 22 Apr 16 8.20pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Why bother with the Arfur?

- Well you complained that there was little room to move, get to the toilets, move about in the concourse area.

- You said away fans always complain about it being so sh1t and SP commenting on it.

- It is 47 years old. The main stand will be corporate or those ST holders who generally prefer staying seated with little comotion, the maturer supporters amongst us if you like, and the slightly vocal who like the interior bars in the Glaziers sections. Holmesdale almost sold out. WH Lane for away fans, possibly ST holders as well if segregated. Separate tiers possibly. So where do the ordinary people you're trying to attract go? Mainly the Arfur, as is pretty much the case now. What do modern day newcomers want? Modernity/comfort/decent food/drink outlets. A stadium redevelopment is just that, not half of one and leave a stand be when it's 47 years old. By the time the main stand and WH are finished it'll be older. The Holmesdale is 20 years old and although acceptable, that'll be much older too being the last in line.

- It needs to be done if you're planning to maximise seating within a confined space because joining the stands up adds quite a few thousand onto capacity. You cannot join stands without them being purpose built for that.

- If away fans are in the WH end then you probably will not need anything like the segregation there is now. More tickets to be sold.

Of course I want it done, I'm a fan that uses it, luckily 2010 are also fans but at the same time very astute businessman, I wouldn't expect them to chuck god knows how much of their money at something with no return, plus it would make them very poor businessmen. Basically we have to make do. Nothing will drastically change my match day experience in my lifetime.

 

pint Flag Near Dunstable, Bedfordshire 22 Apr 16 8.32pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Why bother with the Arfur?

- Well you complained that there was little room to move, get to the toilets, move about in the concourse area.

- You said away fans always complain about it being so sh1t and SP commenting on it.

- It is 47 years old. The main stand will be corporate or those ST holders who generally prefer staying seated with little comotion, the maturer supporters amongst us if you like, and the slightly vocal who like the interior bars in the Glaziers sections. Holmesdale almost sold out. WH Lane for away fans, possibly ST holders as well if segregated. Separate tiers possibly. So where do the ordinary people you're trying to attract go? Mainly the Arfur, as is pretty much the case now. What do modern day newcomers want? Modernity/comfort/decent food/drink outlets. A stadium redevelopment is just that, not half of one and leave a stand be when it's 47 years old. By the time the main stand and WH are finished it'll be older. The Holmesdale is 20 years old and although acceptable, that'll be much older too being the last in line.

- It needs to be done if you're planning to maximise seating within a confined space because joining the stands up adds quite a few thousand onto capacity. You cannot join stands without them being purpose built for that.

- If away fans are in the WH end then you probably will not need anything like the segregation there is now. More tickets to be sold.

am i classed as 'mature' now that I am 34? I agree about comotion though, i quite like it with the old fellas.

 


"Players lose you games, not tactics. There's so much crap talked about tactics by people who barely know how to win at dominoes." (Brian Clough)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Apr 16 9.36pm

Originally posted by pint

am i classed as 'mature' now that I am 34? I agree about comotion though, i quite like it with the old fellas.

You'd fit more into the demographic of the Glaziers section of the main stand rather than around The Stephensons or the bit next to the Directors on that same side.

Generalisations of course because you do get irate fans throwing abuse at refs and linos all over the main stand but you probably get the picture.

 


COYP

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 22 Apr 16 9.36pm

Originally posted by pint

am i classed as 'mature' now that I am 34? I agree about comotion though, i quite like it with the old fellas.

Yep. No more 18-30 club holidays for you. Get used to it.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Apr 16 9.42pm

Originally posted by rikz

Of course I want it done, I'm a fan that uses it, luckily 2010 are also fans but at the same time very astute businessman, I wouldn't expect them to chuck god knows how much of their money at something with no return, plus it would make them very poor businessmen. Basically we have to make do. Nothing will drastically change my match day experience in my lifetime.

Not looking for a long argument here but I don't get it. You say we, or you, deserve better, and that somewhere this is being prevented. Then later on you say you want better but then you don't expect them to make it better for you. So why complain about it and say we deserve better if you understand it won't happen (or you think it won't happen)

 


COYP

rikz Flag Croydon 23 Apr 16 8.32am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Not looking for a long argument here but I don't get it. You say we, or you, deserve better, and that somewhere this is being prevented. Then later on you say you want better but then you don't expect them to make it better for you. So why complain about it and say we deserve better if you understand it won't happen (or you think it won't happen)

No that was my point from the beginning, we do deserve better but staying at selhurst we won't get it, it's definitely not the owners fault. You make a good argument and make it sound easy in writting but earlier said we needed to be in the prem so all this happening is on the assumption that we remain in the prem for however long,we are currently 17th with our strongest squad and most of my life we have played in the 2nd tier, sorry for not being quite the optimist.

 

taldous123 Flag Perth 23 Apr 16 4.50pm

Originally posted by rikz

No that was my point from the beginning, we do deserve better but staying at selhurst we won't get it, it's definitely not the owners fault. You make a good argument and make it sound easy in writting but earlier said we needed to be in the prem so all this happening is on the assumption that we remain in the prem for however long,we are currently 17th with our strongest squad and most of my life we have played in the 2nd tier, sorry for not being quite the optimist.


'

You two are both boring and pathetic and have ruined this thread. Get a room!!!!!

 


We're the red and blue army!!

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 11 May 16 7.55am

[Link]

London's new stadiums - we are not even on the list behind Brentford and Wimbledon.
Come on management, give us some news!!

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 11 May 16 10.48am

As I recall we only got planning permission for the Arfur as long as it was no higher than it is now because the residents complained about their light being reduced. Although the Holmesdale is huge so maybe the planners would allow the Arfur to be rebuilt on the same lines. I don't live in Croydon any more so have no idea what the planners there allow these days.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Zebedee Flag Surrey 11 May 16 11.02am

Coming into Croydon you can see how much money they are pumping into the local area (well East Croydon), They are all so allowing new development to go up higher than before.

My Dad a palace fan told me that in the 90's they had planning granted for a new upper stand, is this true and did they renew the planning permission?

 

cpfc84 Flag 11 May 16 11.09am

just redevelop the main stand and incorporate the holmesdale to connect to main stand with seats in the corner to fill in the gap the main stand only holds 6,163 while the arthur holds 9,754 no point to develop that stand firs to help away fans 1st f*** them they stated the money is in corporate functions so has to be main stand also the arthur is up against planning permissions from the stand been to high and blocking light to residents

 

Page 6 of 154 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Stadium Redevelopment