You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Sadiq Khan v Donald Trump
November 22 2026 1.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sadiq Khan v Donald Trump


Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 17 May 16 7.09pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Problem is, no one actually knows what the majority think 'Britishness is'. Its not like we all got together and voted on it. At a default, people who 'are passionate' about a subject, such as Nationalism, tend to assume that their opinion is the reflection of the majority (and when that turns out to be incorrect that the majority is deluded, corrupted or otherwise a victim of propaganda).

Slightly more problematic, even if its the opinion of the majority, that doesn't make it right. Its important to make a clear distinction about that. Popularity does not justify an attitude.

The other problem of opinions, is that they meaningless. One of the great failures of humanity and free speech, is that its raised opinion to a valued level.

Opinions only have value if you can defend them or at least reasonably present a rationalisation for why there more applicable.

People really need to think about why they think and feel something, rather than assuming that its just true or right.

All valid points.

I would suggest that opinion is important even if it is uninformed and or prejudices. It is, after all, the basis of our democracy.
That is a long way from saying that it is intellectual or "right". In any case, who is to say what is moral or correct? That is as much about consensus as anything else. We hope that wisdom prevails but wisdom of course has so many grey areas. One mans wise is another man's foolish and that is why we have democracy. The less well educated have and voice and those who are better educated aren't always as clever as they think they are. The alternative is to be told how to think by a self appointed elite.I think we have moved to far in that direction already.

That moves nicely onto another issue. Getting people to be honest about their opinions. Many, if questioned, will say something completely different to what they actually think. There is a pressure to conform and rarely has there been a stronger one that over issues related to immigration .
Let's not forget that we are all victims of propaganda from birth and that such an influence can often be dressed up as intellectualism.

Some people have a fixed and clear idea of what being British is. Some have a broader more flexible view. For others it is what someone else tells them it is.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 May 16 11.28am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

All valid points.

I would suggest that opinion is important even if it is uninformed and or prejudices. It is, after all, the basis of our democracy.
That is a long way from saying that it is intellectual or "right". In any case, who is to say what is moral or correct? That is as much about consensus as anything else. We hope that wisdom prevails but wisdom of course has so many grey areas. One mans wise is another man's foolish and that is why we have democracy. The less well educated have and voice and those who are better educated aren't always as clever as they think they are. The alternative is to be told how to think by a self appointed elite.I think we have moved to far in that direction already.

That moves nicely onto another issue. Getting people to be honest about their opinions. Many, if questioned, will say something completely different to what they actually think. There is a pressure to conform and rarely has there been a stronger one that over issues related to immigration .
Let's not forget that we are all victims of propaganda from birth and that such an influence can often be dressed up as intellectualism.

Some people have a fixed and clear idea of what being British is. Some have a broader more flexible view. For others it is what someone else tells them it is.

This has long been an cause of great debate within psychology and social sciences, and is at the centre of the schism between empirical based methodology (the individual-environment duality model) and modern social psychology (individual-structure models). From this comes Discourse Analysis, which regards that the truth of what people feel and think, is better approached from analysis of their use of language in a subject. This has its basis in the idea that people aren't neutral, but positional in how they use language, utilising it to present their 'point of view' on a continual basis

Its also an interesting area, because it allows for people to be reflexive of their environment (social constructionism criticises trait theory on the basis that it only allows for either the individual or social environment to be relevant). Social constructionism, allows to present not just the individual, but social influences and factors (for a controversial area, a police officer might not be racist, however the way that the police operates can create an institutional racial bias that then informs the actions of that officer - from data such as crime statistics on ethnicity etc).

This is exemplified by the MacPherson report, most famously, but can also be seen in the 'measure' of race and intelligence in Eysenck IQ bell curve. The issue in both cases isn't racism in individuals, but differences in how races and racial issues exist within a greater social discourse.

Its an interesting theoretical perspective, as it takes the individual out of the question and the idea that there are simply defined positions or that people can be easily defined in terms of simple traits.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 May 16 11.35am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

All valid points.

I would suggest that opinion is important even if it is uninformed and or prejudices. It is, after all, the basis of our democracy.
That is a long way from saying that it is intellectual or "right". In any case, who is to say what is moral or correct? That is as much about consensus as anything else. We hope that wisdom prevails but wisdom of course has so many grey areas. One mans wise is another man's foolish and that is why we have democracy. The less well educated have and voice and those who are better educated aren't always as clever as they think they are. The alternative is to be told how to think by a self appointed elite.I think we have moved to far in that direction already.

That moves nicely onto another issue. Getting people to be honest about their opinions. Many, if questioned, will say something completely different to what they actually think. There is a pressure to conform and rarely has there been a stronger one that over issues related to immigration .
Let's not forget that we are all victims of propaganda from birth and that such an influence can often be dressed up as intellectualism.

Some people have a fixed and clear idea of what being British is. Some have a broader more flexible view. For others it is what someone else tells them it is.

They do, and only by challenging those ideas, can we establish a greater understanding of what British is. If we fail to view our own ideas and options critically, we cannot progress to a greater understanding. The acceptance of any idea as somehow more than just an idea, requires evidence. Our personal opinions are no different - they are just ideas we hold, unless we test their null hypothesis.

As such, I would hold, that to first determine what is British, you must first define what you mean by British, and then it can be assessed. We should also try to establish any universal traits, to form a kind of baseline (i.e what are requirements of all British people).

Interestingly of course, being British is also defined by people who aren't British, through their discourses on being British - especially in a mass media age. This also can critically inform our view of Britishness, as whilst they are bias, their bias (as is our own) they present a different critical construct of ideas, that can present a critique of our own bias.

Otherwise its just what we have faith in.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 May 16 12.10pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

This has long been an cause of great debate within psychology and social sciences, and is at the centre of the schism between empirical based methodology (the individual-environment duality model) and modern social psychology (individual-structure models). From this comes Discourse Analysis, which regards that the truth of what people feel and think, is better approached from analysis of their use of language in a subject. This has its basis in the idea that people aren't neutral, but positional in how they use language, utilising it to present their 'point of view' on a continual basis

Its also an interesting area, because it allows for people to be reflexive of their environment (social constructionism criticises trait theory on the basis that it only allows for either the individual or social environment to be relevant). Social constructionism, allows to present not just the individual, but social influences and factors (for a controversial area, a police officer might not be racist, however the way that the police operates can create an institutional racial bias that then informs the actions of that officer - from data such as crime statistics on ethnicity etc).

This is exemplified by the MacPherson report, most famously, but can also be seen in the 'measure' of race and intelligence in Eysenck IQ bell curve. The issue in both cases isn't racism in individuals, but differences in how races and racial issues exist within a greater social discourse.

Its an interesting theoretical perspective, as it takes the individual out of the question and the idea that there are simply defined positions or that people can be easily defined in terms of simple traits.

Yes. Interesting.

It is very ambitious to try and pin down the complex workings of the individual mind and how many minds might influence the actions of institutions or groups.

Psychologists are also prone to the same type of bias as the rest of us of course and that can even make the scientific method a little less reliable.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 May 16 12.31pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

They do, and only by challenging those ideas, can we establish a greater understanding of what British is. If we fail to view our own ideas and options critically, we cannot progress to a greater understanding. The acceptance of any idea as somehow more than just an idea, requires evidence. Our personal opinions are no different - they are just ideas we hold, unless we test their null hypothesis.

As such, I would hold, that to first determine what is British, you must first define what you mean by British, and then it can be assessed. We should also try to establish any universal traits, to form a kind of baseline (i.e what are requirements of all British people).

Interestingly of course, being British is also defined by people who aren't British, through their discourses on being British - especially in a mass media age. This also can critically inform our view of Britishness, as whilst they are bias, their bias (as is our own) they present a different critical construct of ideas, that can present a critique of our own bias.

Otherwise its just what we have faith in.

I don't think Britishness is anymore than an idea.
Defining it analytically is rather beside the point. One could apply numerous criteria and arrive at a different definition, none of which would be satisfactory.
For me it can only remain a general consensus or a personal feeling and never quite within reach.

A bit of a crap conclusion I know.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (18 May 2016 12.32pm)

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 18 May 16 12.51pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I don't think Britishness is anymore than an idea.
Defining it analytically is rather beside the point. One could apply numerous criteria and arrive at a different definition, none of which would be satisfactory.
For me it can only remain a general consensus or a personal feeling and never quite within reach.

A bit of a crap conclusion I know.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (18 May 2016 12.32pm)

Surely that's the point of Citezenship? I mean if everyone has these arbitrary ideas of what's English or British, then that can be dangerous and let's people say you are not British in my opinion because X Y or Z.

It isn't a perfect system but I guess we have to accept the legal definition rather than a subjective idea.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 May 16 12.58pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I don't think Britishness is anymore than an idea.
Defining it analytically is rather beside the point. One could apply numerous criteria and arrive at a different definition, none of which would be satisfactory.
For me it can only remain a general consensus or a personal feeling and never quite within reach.

A bit of a crap conclusion I know.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (18 May 2016 12.32pm)

I think the most central importance, is that we all engage in discourse about what it means to be British - Its something that exists in a continual flux of being made and remade by social interactions on the subject.

In effect its something both within us and external, that exists in almost a 'quantum state' of uncertainty.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 May 16 1.19pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I think the most central importance, is that we all engage in discourse about what it means to be British - Its something that exists in a continual flux of being made and remade by social interactions on the subject.

In effect its something both within us and external, that exists in almost a 'quantum state' of uncertainty.

I think this is a natural and inevitable process but it is subject to the propaganda of various agendas.
How much of what people really think is original thought or free from the influence of various agendas?

Society exists because it is driven by certain ideas.
Some are beneficial to all and some introduced into society to benefit those who control it, wish to control it or benefit the most from it and wish to maintain that position.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 May 16 6.32pm

Although, its besides the point. People with nationalist beliefs should not be taking an unelected US candidates side over a democratically elected UK official representative.

That's bloody treason I tell yas.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 18 May 16 6.38pm

Originally posted by DanH


Yeah but according to him those people aren't actually English.

Not true and lazy.

If you had actually been reading my posts I said that those who consider themselves English are English in my book regardless of colour.

I included that in my main point about the English being in the minority.

The fact that a significant number of people born in England don't consider themselves English is a significant failure of multiculturalism which has given us multiple problems.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 18 May 16 6.42pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

I wonder what people like Punch, Zaha, Kaikai or Boateng would think id they read some of these threads.

It's not exactly a stretch to think some of their family might.

Or are they different?

How does this post relate to what I wrote?

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Jamesrichards8 Flag 18 May 16 7.17pm

This post is depressing the s*** out of me. Because of the multicultural s*** mess that London is in. And people wonder why Americans love trump. Is it so racist to not want to lose your country's culture and heritage?

And the people who claim trump is racist are victims of the propaganda of the liberal media. How is an end to illegal immigration racist? How is stemming the flow of Arabs to protect your country from unidentified terrorists racist? A lot of anti-trump people are very ignorant. I urge you to look at his earlier television appearances in the 1980s, when asked political questions. His answers not only provide excessive insight into his beliefs and desires for the country, but they also predict several huge future events, like the recession and the gulf war. He seems a very intelligent man.

My mother is American and I hold dual citizenship- UK and USA. I'm voting trump

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

leifandersonshair Flag Newport 18 May 16 7.29pm

The thing is, what are 'British culture' and 'British values?' Ask 10 people, you'll get 20 different answers!

Most people know nothing about the history of this country- does that make them not British? You ask 10 white British teenagers what the Magna Carta is you'll more than likely get 10 blank looks. Are they not British because of it?

I hate cricket, and Wimbledon- the tennis, not the place Some might argue that these 2 things are as intrinsically British as they come.

Basically, there are very few things that most people would agree make up what it is to be British.

2 people talking about British values may well be talking at completely cross purposes- as an example, the Daily Mail and the Guardian could both write lead articles on 'what it means to be British'- probably find very few points of agreement, but have plenty of people agreeing with both sides. The Guardian might say multiculturalism and tolerance are the epitome of British values- the Daily Mail would probably disagree! And yet plenty of people would agree with both.

 

glory Flag 18 May 16 7.54pm

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

This post is depressing the s*** out of me. Because of the multicultural s*** mess that London is in. And people wonder why Americans love trump. Is it so racist to not want to lose your country's culture and heritage?

And the people who claim trump is racist are victims of the propaganda of the liberal media. How is an end to illegal immigration racist? How is stemming the flow of Arabs to protect your country from unidentified terrorists racist? A lot of anti-trump people are very ignorant. I urge you to look at his earlier television appearances in the 1980s, when asked political questions. His answers not only provide excessive insight into his beliefs and desires for the country, but they also predict several huge future events, like the recession and the gulf war. He seems a very intelligent man.

My mother is American and I hold dual citizenship- UK and USA. I'm voting trump

Do you honestly believe that Trump plans on building a mile high wall or stopping all Muslims from entering the States for a period of time? He's just said what he needed to say to win the Republican nomination since it's a party that in a weakened state. Trump isn't all that conservative or nationalistic at all.

Fast forward a month and you'll hear no mention of banning Muslims or any of that stuff. By all means vote for him but at the same time understand when you're being played. His intelligence isn't in believing the rabble rousing stuff he's come out with, it's in knowing how to reduce and shape complicated and nuanced issues in such a way that appeals to peoples fears or prejudices.

Edited by glory (18 May 2016 8.58pm)

 

Jamesrichards8 Flag 18 May 16 9.38pm

Originally posted by glory

Do you honestly believe that Trump plans on building a mile high wall or stopping all Muslims from entering the States for a period of time? He's just said what he needed to say to win the Republican nomination since it's a party that in a weakened state. Trump isn't all that conservative or nationalistic at all.

Fast forward a month and you'll hear no mention of banning Muslims or any of that stuff. By all means vote for him but at the same time understand when you're being played. His intelligence isn't in believing the rabble rousing stuff he's come out with, it's in knowing how to reduce and shape complicated and nuanced issues in such a way that appeals to peoples fears or prejudices.

Edited by glory (18 May 2016 8.58pm)

I'm sorry but, again, you're simply believing the propaganda proliferated by the Liberal-biased media. They've crafted an image of Trump as a maniacal crowd-reader who is manipulating the mind of the simple voter by espousing lies and deceit. In actuality, these are his real views. The reason i know this? Look at his interviews from the 1980's. His views have NOT changed. He simply embodies the viewpoints of the common man. Which is reflected in polls and the primaries.

Additionally, the media has crafted an image of the trump voter as an ignorant, unintelligent bigot, so that they can guilt people into silence. I will vote for Trump, via absentee ballot. I am in my second year of university, studying political science. My views are my own, and they are resultants of research and original thought.

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

legaleagle Flag 18 May 16 9.53pm

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

Look at his interviews from the 1980's. His views have NOT changed.

I am in my second year of university, studying political science. My views are my own, and they are resultants of research and original thought.

Its a pity your research and original thought have not led you to realise quite how much dear Donald flips and flops in his views to suit the audience at hand/situation he's in:

2000
“I generally oppose gun control, but I support the ban on assault weapons and I also support a slightly longer waiting period to purchase a gun.” — “The America We Deserve,” by Donald J. Trump

2016
Asked about the assault ban in a G.O.P. debate on Fox News: “I don’t support it anymore. I do not support the ban on assault —” [Audience boos.]

Syrian refugees

SEPT. 2015
On the U.S. taking them in: “I hate the concept of it, but on a humanitarian basis with what’s happening, you have to.” — on Fox News

NOV. 2015
“When the Syrian refugees are going to start pouring into this country, we don’t know if they’re ISIS, we don’t know if it’s a Trojan horse.” If he wins the presidency, the refugees are “going back, we can’t have them.” — on ABC News; campaign rally

Hillary Clinton
2012
“Hillary Clinton I think is a terrific woman. I am biased because I have known her for years. … I really like her and her husband both a lot. I think she really works hard.” — on Fox News

2015
“Hillary Clinton was the worst secretary of state in the history of the United States. … The world blew up around us. We lost everything, including all relationships. There wasn’t one good thing that came out of that administration or her being secretary of state.” — on MSNBC

Health care
2000
“I’m a conservative on most issues but a liberal on this one … We must have universal health care.” — from “The America We Deserve”

2016
“It is not enough to simply repeal this terrible legislation,” referring to Obamacare. “We will work with Congress to make sure we have a series of reforms ready for implementation that follow free market principles” on health care. — from campaign website

Abortion rights
1999
“Well, look, I’m very pro-choice. I hate the concept of abortion. I hate it. I hate everything it stands for. I cringe when I listen to people debating the subject. But you still — I just believe in choice.” — on “Meet the Press”

FEB. 22, 2016
“You know, many years ago, I’d be asked the question, and as a developer and a real estate person and as a business person, I was, like, never asked a question about pro-life. And they should leave that whole statement because I said, you know, I really don’t like it. They don’t show that. But I’m pro-life. [Inaudible] When I said this, I guess I said pro-choice.” — on Fox News

MARCH 30
Women who get abortions should be punished.
— on MSNBC

MARCH 30
Only doctors should be punished; women are victims. — from campaign website

NY Times


 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 18 May 16 9.55pm

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

I'm sorry but, again, you're simply believing the propaganda proliferated by the Liberal-biased media. They've crafted an image of Trump as a maniacal crowd-reader who is manipulating the mind of the simple voter by espousing lies and deceit. In actuality, these are his real views. The reason i know this? Look at his interviews from the 1980's. His views have NOT changed. He simply embodies the viewpoints of the common man. Which is reflected in polls and the primaries.

Additionally, the media has crafted an image of the trump voter as an ignorant, unintelligent bigot, so that they can guilt people into silence. I will vote for Trump, via absentee ballot. I am in my second year of university, studying political science. My views are my own, and they are resultants of research and original thought.

Great point. Trump simply embodies the viewpoints of the common man. No irony there then.

By the way, resultant doesn't take an S in this context. Blo*dy students.

 

glory Flag 18 May 16 9.56pm

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

I'm sorry but, again, you're simply believing the propaganda proliferated by the Liberal-biased media. They've crafted an image of Trump as a maniacal crowd-reader who is manipulating the mind of the simple voter by espousing lies and deceit. In actuality, these are his real views. The reason i know this? Look at his interviews from the 1980's. His views have NOT changed. He simply embodies the viewpoints of the common man. Which is reflected in polls and the primaries.

Additionally, the media has crafted an image of the trump voter as an ignorant, unintelligent bigot, so that they can guilt people into silence. I will vote for Trump, via absentee ballot. I am in my second year of university, studying political science. My views are my own, and they are resultants of research and original thought.

Actually it's the liberal media that wants us to think that he does believe these things because it serves their interests. It's aspects of the conservative media uncomfortable with him being the face of the party that would prefer we believe he's just paying lip service to actual conservative beliefs.

All I can say is wait and see. It's beyond clear that 'the magnificent wall paid for by Mexicans' will never materialise. It was just easy to digest idea that played well with voters so he used it. The Muslim ban too, he will back away from because now he has to appeal to the wider public. He's a politician, it's about what plays well and at the time this stuff formed part of a republican primaries strategy. Now that is less relevant. None of these things will ever happen. Our opinions really do not matter because the facts will be the facts.


Edited by glory (18 May 2016 10.03pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 May 16 10.41pm

Donald Trump is a self serving politician like almost every politician before him.
Why would any sensible person believe what he says or what any other politician says for that matter?

 

glory Flag 18 May 16 10.45pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Donald Trump is a self serving politician like almost every politician before him.
Why would any sensible person believe what he says or what any other politician says for that matter?

That sums it up nicely.

 

Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Sadiq Khan v Donald Trump