You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong
November 21 2026 11.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong


Page 6 of 44 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Hoof Hearted 03 Dec 16 10.03am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3087922]

I think going on strike is akin to holding someone to ransom. It's playing on the survival of someone. In this case the MD. It is immoral.

I have no problem with unions, in fact I think they are needed more now than in the last 30 odd years. Negotiation between workers and management is at 1930's levels. But striking just piles on misery to countless innocents who have nothing to do with the perceived problem.

In this day and age, companies should be allowed to sack anyone who strikes, as there are plenty of other deserving workers who are desperate to earn their wages. I understand that this sounds Victorian, but workers rights have been established. Striking to merely increase wages (same as less hours, same wages) or to keep unnecessary jobs is downright idiotic. Negotiating pay rises, genuine H&S issues (which are already almost non-existant, bar stupidity) fine. But refuse to work to get that, P45! Work to rule, go slow, constant union pressure on the management (meetings every day) are legitimate methods of getting results.

Striking is only acceptable if pay or conditions are adverse to a workers well being. Those conditions are illegal. As is blackmail, which is how I view unions calling strikes over spurious matters.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (02 Dec 2016 8.16pm)

One of the best posts about this debate so far.

Well said Tim.

 

legaleagle Flag 03 Dec 16 12.51pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3087922]


I have no problem with unions, in fact I think they are needed more now than in the last 30 odd years.


Striking is only acceptable if pay or conditions are adverse to a workers well being.

Edited by Tim Gypsy Hill '64 (02 Dec 2016 8.16pm)

So,where public safety is a legitimate issue and the dispute directly affects the employees' own conditions(ie masses will lose their jobs)you,on the basis of your own analysis (lauded by Hoof), should think it legit that they strike in this instance,no?

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 03 Dec 16 9.48pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

So,where public safety is a legitimate issue and the dispute directly affects the employees' own conditions(ie masses will lose their jobs)you,on the basis of your own analysis (lauded by Hoof), should think it legit that they strike in this instance,no?

Public safety is not detrimental to the workers who are going to strike. It may be an argument for keeping guards, but that is in dispute. So, no reason to strike.

If public safety is proved not to be an issue, the guard's job is redundant. So, no reason to strike.

The guards who are being removed from the trains are being offered other positions. So, no reason to strike.

So, to answer your question. A strike is not legitimate. It is merely "arm-flexing", and should be made illegal in situations like this.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Hoof Hearted 04 Dec 16 10.38am

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3088524]

Public safety is not detrimental to the workers who are going to strike. It may be an argument for keeping guards, but that is in dispute. So, no reason to strike.

If public safety is proved not to be an issue, the guard's job is redundant. So, no reason to strike.

The guards who are being removed from the trains are being offered other positions. So, no reason to strike.

So, to answer your question. A strike is not legitimate. It is merely "arm-flexing", and should be made illegal in situations like this.

I "laud" you again Tim.

A strike in this instance is most definitely not legitimate and the Union are just sh1t stirring.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 04 Dec 16 10.50am

The strike is wholly legitimate. DOO is less safe... I worked to introduce it for years. I've sat in meetings where management have admitted it's less safe... but could we muddy the waters enough to get this thru. Halfing the safety trained staff is always going to impact safety... only a moron would say otherwise. The head of safety changed jobs at my company (he moved to driver training) he didn't wanna sign off on DOO. Now I don't know if it went against his morals or it was self preservation.., but he didn't want his name on DOO.
I spoke to a ex colleague last night... she says some middle management are voicing concerns. Also Southern lied about sickness and they also implemented a overtime ban(they thought staff would fund strike days with overtime) Southern denied this publicly, a few managers went broken arrow and released memos on social media proving Southern were lying.
There is now a massive distrust between senior and middle management. One manager also released sickness stats proving Southern were lying about high levels of sickness.

Edited by 7mins (04 Dec 2016 10.52am)

 

Hoof Hearted 04 Dec 16 11.05am

Originally posted by 7mins

The strike is wholly legitimate. DOO is less safe... I worked to introduce it for years. I've sat in meetings where management have admitted it's less safe... but could we muddy the waters enough to get this thru. Halfing the safety trained staff is always going to impact safety... only a moron would say otherwise. The head of safety changed jobs at my company (he moved to driver training) he didn't wanna sign off on DOO. Now I don't know if it went against his morals or it was self preservation.., but he didn't want his name on DOO.
I spoke to a ex colleague last night... she says some middle management are voicing concerns. Also Southern lied about sickness and they also implemented a overtime ban(they thought staff would fund strike days with overtime) Southern denied this publicly, a few managers went broken arrow and released memos on social media proving Southern were lying.
There is now a massive distrust between senior and middle management. One manager also released sickness stats proving Southern were lying about high levels of sickness.

Edited by 7mins (04 Dec 2016 10.52am)

Why is it that I and millions like me get on the tube every day which is DOO and it works like clockwork with no safety issues about the doors opening and closing?

When I was a very young lad in the 60's I used to get the BR train from Carshalton to Sutton and the grown ups let me open the door myself, get on board and shut it myself.

The Guard stood at the back of the train with a green flag and a whistle. He made no attempt to help anyone.... he just waved his flag and blew his whistle when all the doors were shut.

Safety my arse.... this is just blatant job protectionism nothing more nothing less... just like the opposition to removing ticket offices to replace them with more efficient ticket machines.

Stop talking bollocks man.

 

gambler Flag Kent 04 Dec 16 11.14am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Why is it that I and millions like me get on the tube every day which is DOO and it works like clockwork with no safety issues about the doors opening and closing?

When I was a very young lad in the 60's I used to get the BR train from Carshalton to Sutton and the grown ups let me open the door myself, get on board and shut it myself.

The Guard stood at the back of the train with a green flag and a whistle. He made no attempt to help anyone.... he just waved his flag and blew his whistle when all the doors were shut.

Safety my arse.... this is just blatant job protectionism nothing more nothing less... just like the opposition to removing ticket offices to replace them with more efficient ticket machines.

Stop talking bollocks man.

[Link]

 

gambler Flag Kent 04 Dec 16 11.15am

[Link]

 

gambler Flag Kent 04 Dec 16 11.15am

[Link]

 

gambler Flag Kent 04 Dec 16 11.16am

[Link]

 

gambler Flag Kent 04 Dec 16 11.19am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Why is it that I and millions like me get on the tube every day which is DOO and it works like clockwork with no safety issues about the doors opening and closing?

When I was a very young lad in the 60's I used to get the BR train from Carshalton to Sutton and the grown ups let me open the door myself, get on board and shut it myself.

The Guard stood at the back of the train with a green flag and a whistle. He made no attempt to help anyone.... he just waved his flag and blew his whistle when all the doors were shut.

Safety my arse.... this is just blatant job protectionism nothing more nothing less... just like the opposition to removing ticket offices to replace them with more efficient ticket machines.

Stop talking bollocks man.

Yes slam door trains. And no one standing on the platform ever got wiped out by some prick opening the door while the train was still moving did they? No one ever fell out of the train while it was moving because they were fiddling with the doors did they? No one ever got decapitated because they leaned out of the windows on a moving train did they?

 

Hoof Hearted 04 Dec 16 11.24am

Originally posted by gambler

Yes slam door trains. And no one standing on the platform ever got wiped out by some prick opening the door while the train was still moving did they? No one ever fell out of the train while it was moving because they were fiddling with the doors did they? No one ever got decapitated because they leaned out of the windows on a moving train did they?

That was the 60's.

You have proved my point - A guard is as much use as balls on the Pope.

We now have a system that actually closes the doors and ensures that they stay shut.

They don't rely on some fat 55 year old w*nker in a uniform with shiny arsed trousers and egg down his tie to "oversee" matters from his Guards van (whereas we all knew he was doing fcuk all! ).

And as for your examples above.... how would the Guard have spotted these and dealt with them?

He wouldn't have.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (04 Dec 2016 11.31am)

 

gambler Flag Kent 04 Dec 16 11.30am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

That was the 60's.

You have proved my point - A guard is as much use as balls on the Pope.

We now have a system that actually closes the doors and ensures that they stay shut.

They don't rely on some fat 55 year old w*nker in a uniform with shiny arsed trousers and egg down his tie to "oversee" matters from his Guards van (whereas we all knew he was doing fcuk all! ).

I think the point is that joe public don't always do as they should.

Refer to my three other posts with links. Not saying D.O.O. is necessarily not workable, but its definitely not as safe as it should be.

My own opinion is that the correlation between the amount of money to be saved in wages, against the amount of money paid out in compensation for injuries and deaths needs to be looked at. Surely the public should not accept any deaths or injuries? Obviously for the companies and government so long as the amount of compensation paid is below the amount of wages saved then they will be happy.

*Edit - sorry just seen that you've referred to the links.

Edited by gambler (04 Dec 2016 11.32am)

 

Hoof Hearted 04 Dec 16 11.36am

Originally posted by gambler

I think the point is that joe public don't always do as they should.

Refer to my three other posts with links. Not saying D.O.O. is necessarily not workable, but its definitely not as safe as it should be.

My own opinion is that the correlation between the amount of money to be saved in wages, against the amount of money paid out in compensation for injuries and deaths needs to be looked at. Surely the public should not accept any deaths or injuries? Obviously for the companies and government so long as the amount of compensation paid is below the amount of wages saved then they will be happy.

I did and amended my post.

Guards on board a train would not have seen those incidents any more than the Driver would have.

Station staff on the platform should have seen those incidents and alerted the driver - but you are right the public are unpredictable, impatient and stupid and dangerous to one another at times.

But I repeat, putting a Guard onboard for safety reasons is not required.

 

gambler Flag Kent 04 Dec 16 11.45am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

I did and amended my post.

Guards on board a train would not have seen those incidents any more than the Driver would have.

Station staff on the platform should have seen those incidents and alerted the driver - but you are right the public are unpredictable, impatient and stupid and dangerous to one another at times.

But I repeat, putting a Guard onboard for safety reasons is not required.

Yes sorry I edited when I noticed.

Not all the locations would have platform staff. And a guard wold be looking directly at the side of the train rather than the driver looking at crappy Cctv.

The thing is its not as simple as you hate the unions so they must be wrong or taking the piss, or someone else supports unions so the company are c***s.

In this case a fair proportion of passengers support the workers side of the argument, although rightly by this stage they are severely pissed off with everyone for f***ing their daily lives up.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 04 Dec 16 12.02pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Why is it that I and millions like me get on the tube every day which is DOO and it works like clockwork with no safety issues about the doors opening and closing?

When I was a very young lad in the 60's I used to get the BR train from Carshalton to Sutton and the grown ups let me open the door myself, get on board and shut it myself.

The Guard stood at the back of the train with a green flag and a whistle. He made no attempt to help anyone.... he just waved his flag and blew his whistle when all the doors were shut.

Safety my arse.... this is just blatant job protectionism nothing more nothing less... just like the opposition to removing ticket offices to replace them with more efficient ticket machines.

Stop talking bollocks man.

Stop taking your own experiences and extrapolating that to determine health and safety regulation for a massive and complex industry.

Makes you look like the thicko down the pub.

 

7mins Flag In the bush 04 Dec 16 12.05pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

That was the 60's.

You have proved my point - A guard is as much use as balls on the Pope.

We now have a system that actually closes the doors and ensures that they stay shut.

They don't rely on some fat 55 year old w*nker in a uniform with shiny arsed trousers and egg down his tie to "oversee" matters from his Guards van (whereas we all knew he was doing fcuk all! ).

And as for your examples above.... how would the Guard have spotted these and dealt with them?

He wouldn't have.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (04 Dec 2016 11.31am)

You seem very informed on the guards role, can you give me your thoughts on taking TCOC, SCB training away from them? Cos RSSB had concerns?

 

Hoof Hearted 04 Dec 16 12.44pm

Originally posted by 7mins

You seem very informed on the guards role, can you give me your thoughts on taking TCOC, SCB training away from them? Cos RSSB had concerns?

Yes 7 mins.... that comes about from 56 years of travelling.

Never mind all those initials.....you need to remember KISS - Keep It Simple Stupid.

Expect the public to do something stupid, don't react after they've done it.

The Croydon tram disaster came about because no one anticipated the driver taking that bend too fast and building in safeguards to stop him. having a Guard on board wouldn't have prevented that happening, but a better safety operation system would have.

Calling someone a Guard doesn't make him/her a safety expert.

As I said above, the Guard would not have prevented those incidents with trapped bags/coats etc. You need to educate the public, putting up warning signs, reminding them to stay behind safety lines etc etc.

BUt more importantly, build in safety features that prevent accidents happening and don't just rely on the vigilance of one man calling him a guard or whatever fancy title the RMT want.

 

Hoof Hearted 04 Dec 16 12.48pm

Originally posted by 7mins

Stop taking your own experiences and extrapolating that to determine health and safety regulation for a massive and complex industry.

Makes you look like the thicko down the pub.

And your responses so far using silly acronyms to big yourself up just makes you look like the bog cleaner in the pub pretending to be the landlord.

I can be just as insulting as you can if I want to be.

 

Hoof Hearted 04 Dec 16 12.53pm

Originally posted by gambler

Yes sorry I edited when I noticed.

Not all the locations would have platform staff. And a guard wold be looking directly at the side of the train rather than the driver looking at crappy Cctv.

The thing is its not as simple as you hate the unions so they must be wrong or taking the piss, or someone else supports unions so the company are c***s.

In this case a fair proportion of passengers support the workers side of the argument, although rightly by this stage they are severely pissed off with everyone for f***ing their daily lives up.

I don't hate the unions, but its obvious they are paid to protect jobs.

The Miners union, the the wheeltappers union... they tried to preserve jobs in industries where technology etc had made their jobs redundant... you don't get many people developing films these days due to digital cameras.

The Guards job is redundant. There are better ways to promote safety on board trains and outside of them.

 

Page 6 of 44 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Southern Rail Strike - right or wrong