This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Cummins ridiculing Johnson's trivialising of covid19 against all the evidence.
|
|
|
Quite the set list so far [Tweet Link]
|
|
|
Cummings perfectly encapsulates the phrase "if you lie with dogs, you get fleas".
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
Just out of interest, why is everyone losing their s*** over the notion that herd immunity was a "strategy"? Surely, herd immunity is not a strategy, merely an ultimate scientific reality in the vast majority of viruses. Isn't everyone in the world aiming for herd immunity one way or the other? Isn't herd immunity the precise purpose of vaccination? Yeah don’t think anyone is questioning that part of it - more that the initial strategy was herd immunity without vaccination as it would not be available until 2021. They were going to be quite happy to let it spread naturally throughout the population and take the collateral damage that came with it. They only changed course when the numbers of deaths and the NHS being overwhelmed to the extent that it could do nothing else became more obvious than it already should have been.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
Yeah don’t think anyone is questioning that part of it - more that the initial strategy was herd immunity without vaccination as it would not be available until 2021. They were going to be quite happy to let it spread naturally throughout the population and take the collateral damage that came with it. They only changed course when the numbers of deaths and the NHS being overwhelmed to the extent that it could do nothing else became more obvious than it already should have been. Fine, but there was never any guarantee of a vaccination in the first place. So of course herd immunity such as the one you mention would be on the table. There is going to be an economic fall out as a result of this, one which has the potential to plunge millions of people in the world into abject poverty. Healthcare systems are also on their knees as a result of Covid. This can also potentially kill a lot of people, but for some reason people only regard direct Covid deaths as the deaths that come about as a result of the pandemic. Also, there would surely be a variety of ways to obtain herd immunity, even without vaccination. It probably would've still involved a host measures and not simply throwing everyone into a big room and getting them to cough on eachother. Edited by Mstrobez (26 May 2021 12.31pm)
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
Fine, but there was never any guarantee of a vaccination in the first place. So of course herd immunity such as the one you mention would be on the table. There is going to be an economic fall out as a result of this, one which has the potential to plunge millions of people in the world into abject poverty. Healthcare systems are also on their knees as a result of Covid. This can also potentially kill a lot of people, but for some reason people only regard direct Covid deaths as the deaths that come about as a result of the pandemic. Also, there would surely be a variety of ways to obtain herd immunity, even without vaccination. It probably would've still involved a host measures and not simply throwing everyone into a big room and getting them to cough on eachother. Edited by Mstrobez (26 May 2021 12.31pm) A lot of the focus is on the lack of seriousness this was given at the start and a lack of any plan before it was all too late. It was obvious from what had happened in China and closer to home what was happening in Italy how serious this was and that achieving herd immunity through natural means in a short space of time would be catastrophic. There were plenty of means available to the government to stop the virus seeding here such as shutting borders, enforced quarantines and an effective track and trace system that would have kept virus numbers much, much lower and allowed people to have gone about their business with a lot more freedom than we have been allowed to over the last 15 months.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
A lot of the focus is on the lack of seriousness this was given at the start and a lack of any plan before it was all too late. It was obvious from what had happened in China and closer to home what was happening in Italy how serious this was and that achieving herd immunity through natural means in a short space of time would be catastrophic. There were plenty of means available to the government to stop the virus seeding here such as shutting borders, enforced quarantines and an effective track and trace system that would have kept virus numbers much, much lower and allowed people to have gone about their business with a lot more freedom than we have been allowed to over the last 15 months. Not really. It's not obvious at all that keeping the economy largely open with obvious caveats in the run up to developing a vaccine would've been any less "catastrophic", considering the economic consequences mentioned already. As for the rest of your comment, I'm not here to defend the Tories handling of the pandemic. It's just that when people get mad about "herd immunity", I'm not sure why.
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
Just out of interest, why is everyone losing their s*** over the notion that herd immunity was a "strategy"? Surely, herd immunity is not a strategy, merely an ultimate scientific reality in the vast majority of viruses. Isn't everyone in the world aiming for herd immunity one way or the other? Isn't herd immunity the precise purpose of vaccination? Quite correct.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
Not really. It's not obvious at all that keeping the economy largely open with obvious caveats in the run up to developing a vaccine would've been any less "catastrophic", considering the economic consequences mentioned already. As for the rest of your comment, I'm not here to defend the Tories handling of the pandemic. It's just that when people get mad about "herd immunity", I'm not sure why. I think it was obvious, and a lot of the evidence coming out this morning, shows that the government had a lot of information to suggest what was coming and poor decision making at that time has cost tens of thousands of lives.
|
|
|
Hancock getting absolutely two footed about people being positive being sent back into care homes. Going in on Johnson about not shutting the borders too.
|
|
|
Originally posted by DanH
I think it was obvious, and a lot of the evidence coming out this morning, shows that the government had a lot of information to suggest what was coming and poor decision making at that time has cost tens of thousands of lives. Well I'm sorry but it's not obvious at all. People's businesses have been shutting down left right & centre, millions are being plunged into unemployment, there are reports of a cancer crisis in the NHS, the world's poorest are getting poorer. X number of Covid deaths is a headline, but it's only one factor.
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
Well I'm sorry but it's not obvious at all. People's businesses have been shutting down left right & centre, millions are being plunged into unemployment, there are reports of a cancer crisis in the NHS, the world's poorest are getting poorer. X number of Covid deaths is a headline, but it's only one factor. But that’s what has happened with what action (or lack of) the government has taken? We’ve had to get to this point because of the grip the virus has had and continued to have throughout the country. If the government had taken it more seriously at the start and kept the virus out as far as possible/enforced quarantine then we wouldn’t have had to have been in lockdown for so long over such a prolonged period. We’ve literally had the worst of both worlds.
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
Cummings is boring already in the circus that is politics today. The last word I would call today is boring. Been a great watch. Edited by DanH (26 May 2021 3.45pm)
|
|
|
Ravings of a bitter man who thought he should have been PM .
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.