You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 60 of 65 < 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 May 19 12.16pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Lets see what happens when he is allowed to bring in a couple of players OK, then I'll agree with you if with a more competent midfield set up we play exactly the same because I see our midfield apart from two possibly are well below what we need to hurt teams at home with the sort of football you want to see.

Hodgson did well with England, you are falling into that hole about thinking the players were actually better then they actually were.
England is very average, especially when facing technical ability.

I don’t want to divert this thread because this has happened on this subject before, but, Hodgson beat all the cr@ppy countries in qualifiers and then when it came to anyone half decent, or Iceland ffs, not a flaming clue. Kane at corners LAUGH OUT LOUD.

Hodgson is not a big team manager but he’s a safe pair of hands for our size. But please don’t fool yourself he’s maximising our chances of cup or attractiveness progress if you like. Same tactics all the time. At first we thought it was because he had no choice. Wrong. No subs or in game management vs the opposition and their manager.

I accept Roy as manager but it isn’t progressive, entertaining or something you look forward to. It’s a chore during a time we need to stay in the league to get the stand done, but if it isn’t done it’ll seem like a waste all round.

 


COYP

cpj Flag Kent 06 May 19 12.28pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Lets see what happens when he is allowed to bring in a couple of players OK, then I'll agree with you if with a more competent midfield set up we play exactly the same because I see our midfield apart from two possibly are well below what we need to hurt teams at home with the sort of football you want to see.

Hodgson did well with England, you are falling into that hole about thinking the players were actually better then they actually were.
England is very average, especially when facing technical ability.

He's had 3 transfer windows already and the signings have been less than inspired.

 

est1905 Flag 06 May 19 12.40pm

Originally posted by cpj

He's had 3 transfer windows already and the signings have been less than inspired.

I do get the feeling that often (maybe not always) players are identified by people other than Roy and are bought in and Roy just works with them on the training ground and picks where and how he wants them to play.
That's not always a bad system except one day Freedman and Parish might just blow a truck load of money on someone that Roy just doesn't rate/want. This is why I prefer the Allardyce way of signing players. Manager has complete control of who comes and who goes. PVA is a perfect example in that Sam knew exactly how he would slot into our first 11 before he even arrived.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 May 19 1.09pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I don’t want to divert this thread because this has happened on this subject before, but, Hodgson beat all the cr@ppy countries in qualifiers and then when it came to anyone half decent, or Iceland ffs, not a flaming clue. Kane at corners LAUGH OUT LOUD.

Hodgson is not a big team manager but he’s a safe pair of hands for our size. But please don’t fool yourself he’s maximising our chances of cup or attractiveness progress if you like. Same tactics all the time. At first we thought it was because he had no choice. Wrong. No subs or in game management vs the opposition and their manager.

I accept Roy as manager but it isn’t progressive, entertaining or something you look forward to. It’s a chore during a time we need to stay in the league to get the stand done, but if it isn’t done it’ll seem like a waste all round.

I think you could take the stadium redevelopment out of the equation. With or without that, the first priority is to stay in the Premier League. And Hodgson is a safe pair of hands in that respect.

While I am pro-Roy, I do accept some of the criticism levelled at him.

But if I was a CEO and major shareholder in a multi million pound business then I would want to work with people I trust and have confidence in. And that is the SP/RH relationship.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 06 May 19 1.27pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

I think you could take the stadium redevelopment out of the equation. With or without that, the first priority is to stay in the Premier League. And Hodgson is a safe pair of hands in that respect.

While I am pro-Roy, I do accept some of the criticism levelled at him.

But if I was a CEO and major shareholder in a multi million pound business then I would want to work with people I trust and have confidence in. And that is the SP/RH relationship.

Pretty much yeah

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 06 May 19 11.06pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I don’t want to divert this thread because this has happened on this subject before, but, Hodgson beat all the cr@ppy countries in qualifiers and then when it came to anyone half decent, or Iceland ffs, not a flaming clue. Kane at corners LAUGH OUT LOUD.

Hodgson is not a big team manager but he’s a safe pair of hands for our size. But please don’t fool yourself he’s maximising our chances of cup or attractiveness progress if you like. Same tactics all the time. At first we thought it was because he had no choice. Wrong. No subs or in game management vs the opposition and their manager.

I accept Roy as manager but it isn’t progressive, entertaining or something you look forward to. It’s a chore during a time we need to stay in the league to get the stand done, but if it isn’t done it’ll seem like a waste all round.

I agree with that. Fans that go to away games will not agree, but to be successful in this league with the standard of players we can afford some of the games will definitely not be attractive, sadly well too many at home. Roy like Alan Curbishley is a safe pair of hands for our club.

Edited by Tickled pink (06 May 2019 11.07pm)

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 07 May 19 10.42pm

Some poor moments at home this season but to add some context to the “negative” football;

Palace 0 Southampton 2 BBC MOM Alex MaCarthy
Palace 0 Newcastle 0 BBC MOM Martin Dubravka
Palace 0 Spurs 1 Hugo Lloris
Palace 1 Watford 2 Ben Foster
Palace 0 Cardiff 0 31 shots
Palace 1 West Ham 1 25 shots
Palace 2 Burnley 0 29 shots

Personally prefer we play badly and get a result but nonetheless think some of football has been better than suggested.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 08 May 19 12.44am

Like Willo says

Originally posted by Willo

Losing to Brighton twice and have some of their supporters crowing about it is somewhat galling.
Without those 6 pts they wouldn't be safe now but in the bottom 3 !

Edited by Willo (06 May 2019 9.18am)

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 09 May 19 11.55am

Originally posted by Willo

I like Kouyate in the side.
Provides physicality in midfield and makes penetrating runs forward both with and without the ball.Plays with his head up and likes to open up his body and run at opponents.
He filled-in at centre-half at W.Ham when they had injuries.
I recall speaking to someone about Kouyate when he was at W.Ham - he told me that in his opinion he wasn't the finished article but that was probably about 5 years ago.

So what was it that held up his development for 5 years. just saying, don't take it serious.

 

DeVito Flag Surbiton 09 May 19 2.54pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I don’t want to divert this thread because this has happened on this subject before, but, Hodgson beat all the cr@ppy countries in qualifiers and then when it came to anyone half decent, or Iceland ffs, not a flaming clue. Kane at corners LAUGH OUT LOUD.

Hodgson is not a big team manager but he’s a safe pair of hands for our size. But please don’t fool yourself he’s maximising our chances of cup or attractiveness progress if you like. Same tactics all the time. At first we thought it was because he had no choice. Wrong. No subs or in game management vs the opposition and their manager.

I accept Roy as manager but it isn’t progressive, entertaining or something you look forward to. It’s a chore during a time we need to stay in the league to get the stand done, but if it isn’t done it’ll seem like a waste all round.


You're right Rudi, his record at England and Liverpool definitely suggests he's not really a manager suited to the very highest level. Also didn't have the best time at Inter either.

But I would argue that he's perhaps a bit better than you're making out here. I think he's better than simply a 'safe pair of hands'. We've played some great football at times, particularly away. Our away record this season is amazing. I would say home performances on the whole have been better than results suggest. Home defeats to Brighton and Watford don't help perception though, and some games like at home to Chelsea really were frustrating.

Towards the end of last season, when we had RLC, some of our home games were great e.g 5-0 demolition of Leicester. I think this highlights that when he has the right blend of players at his disposal he can get his teams playing attractive, attacking football.

I would also point to his time at Fulham. He arrived when they were really struggling, made a few good signings, and then guided them to 7th. And then to the final of the Europa league the following season. They played some great football. Not bad for a 'safe pair of hands'

He hasn't particularly been backed in the transfer market since arriving, apart from Max, so he's done what he's done with the same squad that he inherited plus a couple of loans.

If (and I guess that's a big IF) he sticks around for another couple of seasons, I'm hopeful that we can do more than just survive.

Edited by DeVito (09 May 2019 2.57pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 09 May 19 3.34pm

Yes some fair points I’m well aware of. It’s just how many times I’ve watched at Selhurst and seen Roy not utilise the bench or divert from plan A and settle for the 0-1 home loss.

I completely understand why he’s here, and I don’t want him out, unless of course Parish has someone marvellous lined up, which will never happen. It’s just frustrating watching 60-70 minutes of football you know what will happen. Nothing.

 


COYP

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 09 May 19 3.36pm

My take on Hodgson is that he is a percentage manager. He has found a formula that works more often than not and he believes in that and sticks to it.

Occasionally it is annoying as we should roll over lesser sides and we don't always do. However on balance he has brought stability and a system and that the players appear to believe in.

When I was a manager I appreciated the people who turned up on time and put in a shift. I was never a fan of the lone maverick who disappears when you need them and every now and then does something great. I suspect that is how Roy manages the team he will forgive a player within reason if they put in a shift and play within the system as he has asked them.

It is to his credit that he is also able to accommodate a mercurial talent like Zaha.

Overall he has been a positive for Palace.

Edited by Badger11 (09 May 2019 3.36pm)

 


One more point

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 09 May 19 3.42pm

Originally posted by DeVito


You're right Rudi, his record at England and Liverpool definitely suggests he's not really a manager suited to the very highest level. Also didn't have the best time at Inter either.

But I would argue that he's perhaps a bit better than you're making out here. I think he's better than simply a 'safe pair of hands'. We've played some great football at times, particularly away. Our away record this season is amazing. I would say home performances on the whole have been better than results suggest. Home defeats to Brighton and Watford don't help perception though, and some games like at home to Chelsea really were frustrating.

Towards the end of last season, when we had RLC, some of our home games were great e.g 5-0 demolition of Leicester. I think this highlights that when he has the right blend of players at his disposal he can get his teams playing attractive, attacking football.

I would also point to his time at Fulham. He arrived when they were really struggling, made a few good signings, and then guided them to 7th. And then to the final of the Europa league the following season. They played some great football. Not bad for a 'safe pair of hands'

He hasn't particularly been backed in the transfer market since arriving, apart from Max, so he's done what he's done with the same squad that he inherited plus a couple of loans.

If (and I guess that's a big IF) he sticks around for another couple of seasons, I'm hopeful that we can do more than just survive.

Is he having any input in the transfer signings, never really comments, or transfer policy for the last 3 years has been pathetic, if Derby dont win promotion, Frank Lampard could be a good choice, if change is needed

Edited by DeVito (09 May 2019 2.57pm)

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 13 May 19 12.50pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Change of heart' by Midlands Eagle

How many of us are having a change of heart with regards to Roy? Have to say personally up until relatively recently I was in the camp of I would probably like to see a change. The home form has been abysmal, it’s been a tough watch at Selhurst all season. The subs thing and his unwillingness to change bugs me.. but what you can’t do is argue with the final result. Our points tally and league position is a very good achievement. Yet it could have been much more.. He can certainly be considered a safe pair of hands. Yesterday was encouraging. He’s got to be given next season.

Edited by MonsterMunch (13 May 2019 12.51pm)

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 13 May 19 12.54pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Change of heart' by Midlands Eagle

Never an issue for me. We’re fortunate to have him and I hope he stays.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

matthau Flag South Croydon 13 May 19 1.01pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Change of heart' by Midlands Eagle

I like him and whatever ya palace fans want or don’t want, he’ll be palace manager next season either way

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 13 May 19 1.09pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Change of heart' by Midlands Eagle

my worry is that with Zaha and others likely leaving in the summer, we will have a decent amount of money to spend, the sort money that should shape the first 11 for the next few years. I just don't trust Roy to invest it in the sort of talent that is going to move us on as a football club. He's with us for one more year so that's as far as he's planning.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 13 May 19 1.13pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Change of heart' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by matthau

I like him and whatever ya palace fans want or don’t want, he’ll be palace manager next season either way[/

I like how you begin your insightful post with you like him yet state that it doesn’t matter what palace fans think of him.

Edited by MonsterMunch (13 May 2019 1.14pm)

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 13 May 19 1.13pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Change of heart' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

my worry is that with Zaha and others likely leaving in the summer, we will have a decent amount of money to spend, the sort money that should shape the first 11 for the next few years. I just don't trust Roy to invest it in the sort of talent that is going to move us on as a football club. He's with us for one more year so that's as far as he's planning.

Ultimately Parish and Freedman dictate who is coming in and they are going to be at the club for longer than Roy.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 13 May 19 1.18pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Change of heart' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by NEILLO

Ultimately Parish and Freedman dictate who is coming in and they are going to be at the club for longer than Roy.

Roy still puts his wants in to those two

 

Page 60 of 65 < 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread