You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Putin
November 21 2026 9.55pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Putin


Page 7 of 10 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 21 Mar 22 12.12am

Originally posted by BlueJay

Be aware that this is now at least the second time that you've refereed to behaviour that involves the murder of women and children as if it's some kind of fun day out. To you his behaviour may well be the equivalent of the tending of his front porch and back garden. To most it is not. Not everything has to be 'cleansed' through some kind of political lens that removes you from care for those involved.

so you get all your understanding of World Politics from Sky News ? i feel sorry for you.

Trump was right about the belligerent West and its constant Wars.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Mar 22 3.13am

Originally posted by georgenorman

"There are some ideas so wrong that only a very intelligent person could believe in them." [Orwell]

Unfortunately Orwell isn't here to comment.

However, unlike you I doubt he would have viewed the last thirty years without criticism. A huge opportunity for peace on the continent has been idiotically thrown away.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Mar 22 3.37am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

If you seriously think this is just "elites" playing a game, then I regret to say that seems an idiotic idea to me. I doubt whether the collective leadership of the western world are responsible for an insane policy.

Do you seriously think we should just stand back and let Putin do whatever he wants? Think of what the consequences of that might be. They would be far worse than these already are.

How the aftermath and the impact on the poor and vulnerable is managed is another question entirely, but the response so far has been impressive.

It's not about 'letting Putin do what he wants'. It's about plotting a course that lessens the damage.

The western elites have chosen a path and use the media to support it. They omit whatever would challenge that position and voices like you just support whatever their consensus is.

I make the point that under the direction I support this war would never have occurred. As for what should be done I simply don't support taking highly self destructive paths that achieve very little.

I agree with criticising Putin for starting this war and I agree with support for the Ukrainians...however the decision to effectively create a cold war is very dangerous to humanity both militarily and only economically hurts the vulnerable.....and for what....so that you can claim some moral victory. Well, when the poor have to choose between heating their homes or feeding their children I'm sorry but I think that moralism is highly suspect.

So I heavily criticise the approach that led us here.

Instead of this constant support for war and aggression I support the same energy being placed towards peace. I don't see this happening....all I see is media...which is directed...being used to support cold war....a decision that can only hurt the middle and lower classes....but not the elites themselves. It also doesn't help the Ukrainians either.

You made the claim the other day that because I'm conservative...well I'm a social conservative....that caring about the poor was somehow socialist.....this irritated me. I come from the council estates and been poor for a good portion of my life and consider myself working class. I've seen what the practical affect of leftist policies has been....so don't play that leftist game that caring about those with less is somehow the domain of the left. I regard that as a myth.

Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Mar 2022 3.58am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 21 Mar 22 7.40am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

so you get all your understanding of World Politics from Sky News ? i feel sorry for you.

Trump was right about the belligerent West and its constant Wars.

You should change your username to Der Sturmer.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 21 Mar 22 8.15am

Originally posted by georgenorman

You should change your username to Der Sturmer.

a classy comment from you there. Mods, this bloke just accused me of being more extreme than the Nazi's. Simply because i disapprove of all the sabre-rattling from NATO.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Mar 22 8.26am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

a classy comment from you there. Mods, this bloke just accused me of being more extreme than the Nazi's. Simply because i disapprove of all the sabre-rattling from NATO.

Grass

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 21 Mar 22 9.21am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

It's not about 'letting Putin do what he wants'. It's about plotting a course that lessens the damage.

The western elites have chosen a path and use the media to support it. They omit whatever would challenge that position and voices like you just support whatever their consensus is.

I make the point that under the direction I support this war would never have occurred. As for what should be done I simply don't support taking highly self destructive paths that achieve very little.

I agree with criticising Putin for starting this war and I agree with support for the Ukrainians...however the decision to effectively create a cold war is very dangerous to humanity both militarily and only economically hurts the vulnerable.....and for what....so that you can claim some moral victory. Well, when the poor have to choose between heating their homes or feeding their children I'm sorry but I think that moralism is highly suspect.

So I heavily criticise the approach that led us here.

Instead of this constant support for war and aggression I support the same energy being placed towards peace. I don't see this happening....all I see is media...which is directed...being used to support cold war....a decision that can only hurt the middle and lower classes....but not the elites themselves. It also doesn't help the Ukrainians either.

You made the claim the other day that because I'm conservative...well I'm a social conservative....that caring about the poor was somehow socialist.....this irritated me. I come from the council estates and been poor for a good portion of my life and consider myself working class. I've seen what the practical affect of leftist policies has been....so don't play that leftist game that caring about those with less is somehow the domain of the left. I regard that as a myth.

Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Mar 2022 3.58am)

That is a typical unsupported and unverifiable claim of the right. It's the promise of the mythical green grass in the fields over the "if only" hills.

There is no "constant support for war and aggression"! All that is being done is to seek peace. We haven't created a new cold war. What Putin has done meant one was inevitable unless we stood back and did nothing.

The Soviet Union collapsed because the countries of Eastern Europe gathered the collective will to free themselves of the yoke imposed on them by Stalin. That an ex member of the KGB, and the bunch of ruthless thugs who support him, feel cheated by that and are manoeuvring to reverse it, doesn't mean we just allow them to. Those hard won freedoms need to be protected, not just for them, but for our safety and security too.

No-one wants to see the Ukrainians, or the poor and vulnerable at home and around the world, suffering. Ensuring that is kept to a minimum whilst making the necessary and unavoidable responses to Putin I am certain is in the minds of the decision takers.

Of course, with the benefit of hindsight, there will be things we have done wrong, or could have done better. The most obvious being that we were complacent in thinking that Putin really didn't mean it and could be shepherded into the modern world. We should have done this the moment he walked into Crimea.

This obsession with the "elites", as if there is a homogeneous group of people all conspiring together to protect themselves at the expense of everyone else, is just an invention of bogeymen. Of course, there are those in positions of authority. There are the wealthy, both old money and new. There are those who report on them. Their interests sometimes coincide, but not always, and there isn't, and cannot be, any co-ordination. In any case, most are not the evil despots that some imagine them to be. They are mostly good people trying to do their best.

We are where we are, and at times like these, politics need to be put in a box and allowed to gather dust. We need all hands on the wheel if we are going to turn the ship away from the course which will see us on the rocks. We can decide the best way to rebuild once we are back in calm water again.

Muttering into your coffee about "if only" just wastes energy and time.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 21 Mar 22 9.46am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

a classy comment from you there. Mods, this bloke just accused me of being more extreme than the Nazi's. Simply because i disapprove of all the sabre-rattling from NATO.

Where did I accuse you of being more extreme? Do you disapprove of the actual use of weapons by Putin and his sabre-rattling of possible escalation?

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Mar 22 10.21am

Originally posted by croydon proud

Saw lady on the news saying Russian troops are raping women before killing them , hope its not true but propoganda and truth in war etc.

No idea, but they do have some form for that...

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Mar 22 10.35am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

It's not about 'letting Putin do what he wants'. It's about plotting a course that lessens the damage.

The western elites have chosen a path and use the media to support it. They omit whatever would challenge that position and voices like you just support whatever their consensus is.

I make the point that under the direction I support this war would never have occurred. As for what should be done I simply don't support taking highly self destructive paths that achieve very little.

I agree with criticising Putin for starting this war and I agree with support for the Ukrainians...however the decision to effectively create a cold war is very dangerous to humanity both militarily and only economically hurts the vulnerable.....and for what....so that you can claim some moral victory. Well, when the poor have to choose between heating their homes or feeding their children I'm sorry but I think that moralism is highly suspect.

So I heavily criticise the approach that led us here.

Instead of this constant support for war and aggression I support the same energy being placed towards peace. I don't see this happening....all I see is media...which is directed...being used to support cold war....a decision that can only hurt the middle and lower classes....but not the elites themselves. It also doesn't help the Ukrainians either.

You made the claim the other day that because I'm conservative...well I'm a social conservative....that caring about the poor was somehow socialist.....this irritated me. I come from the council estates and been poor for a good portion of my life and consider myself working class. I've seen what the practical affect of leftist policies has been....so don't play that leftist game that caring about those with less is somehow the domain of the left. I regard that as a myth.

Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Mar 2022 3.58am)

This isn't an attack Stirling, it's a question. Your posts suggest that the West shares the blame for the war as we somehow could have prevented this. Unfortunately, all the posts I have seen you write make references to your points being set out elsewhere.

I know your bug bears of concentration of power into self-serving elites and globalism, but I fail to see a clear causal link between those elements and the present conflict.

Before you respond, I see a playground analogy of a bad boy being shouted at for not catching a nice boy who fell over a full 30 yards away. Yeah, the bad boy has issues, but he can hardly be blamed for that. Putin is a megalomaniac who absolute power has corrupted absolutely. The West did not make him what he is.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Mar 22 1.03pm

Originally posted by silvertop

This isn't an attack Stirling, it's a question. Your posts suggest that the West shares the blame for the war as we somehow could have prevented this. Unfortunately, all the posts I have seen you write make references to your points being set out elsewhere.

I know your bug bears of concentration of power into self-serving elites and globalism, but I fail to see a clear causal link between those elements and the present conflict.

Before you respond, I see a playground analogy of a bad boy being shouted at for not catching a nice boy who fell over a full 30 yards away. Yeah, the bad boy has issues, but he can hardly be blamed for that. Putin is a megalomaniac who absolute power has corrupted absolutely. The West did not make him what he is.

Busy today but I'll respond tonight or tomorrow on why I have that position on Nato and our elites of the last thirty years.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 21 Mar 22 1.09pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Where did I accuse you of being more extreme? Do you disapprove of the actual use of weapons by Putin and his sabre-rattling of possible escalation?

i have already said that both Putin and NATO are warmonger crooks.

jeez, do try to keep up with the debate.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 21 Mar 22 2.43pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

i have already said that both Putin and NATO are warmonger crooks.

jeez, do try to keep up with the debate.

I've taken the trouble to go through your posts on this thread and nowhere do you criticise Putin, you mainly blame NATO and their supposed 'aggression' for his actions. I did notice that in one post you 'look forward to us having a Putin in power'.

Edited by georgenorman (21 Mar 2022 2.44pm)

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 21 Mar 22 4.07pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

I've taken the trouble to go through your posts on this thread and nowhere do you criticise Putin, you mainly blame NATO and their supposed 'aggression' for his actions. I did notice that in one post you 'look forward to us having a Putin in power'.

Edited by georgenorman (21 Mar 2022 2.44pm)

says the Hol-Eagle who accused me of being a Nazi. Do try to at least have a basic understanding of the belligerents in Central Europe. Or ask your nurse to explain it to you.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 21 Mar 22 4.12pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

says the Hol-Eagle who accused me of being a Nazi. Do try to at least have a basic understanding of the belligerents in Central Europe. Or ask your nurse to explain it to you.

Fine, simply ignore the points made - very Putinesque.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 21 Mar 22 4.47pm

in 1946 the Marshall Plan helped to pick up Europe from the ashes of WWII.

yet, in 1990 the Soviet Union collapsed and people starved. No help from the West. Its our own fault that a dictator like Putin appeared. Another Hitler. Starving angry people always vote for Mr Angry.

Get rid of Putin and just another tinpot dictator will take his place.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 21 Mar 22 5.09pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

in 1946 the Marshall Plan helped to pick up Europe from the ashes of WWII.

yet, in 1990 the Soviet Union collapsed and people starved. No help from the West. Its our own fault that a dictator like Putin appeared. Another Hitler. Starving angry people always vote for Mr Angry.

Get rid of Putin and just another tinpot dictator will take his place.

Your posts get more and more absurd.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Mar 22 5.31pm

Originally posted by silvertop

This isn't an attack Stirling, it's a question. Your posts suggest that the West shares the blame for the war as we somehow could have prevented this. Unfortunately, all the posts I have seen you write make references to your points being set out elsewhere.

I know your bug bears of concentration of power into self-serving elites and globalism, but I fail to see a clear causal link between those elements and the present conflict.

Before you respond, I see a playground analogy of a bad boy being shouted at for not catching a nice boy who fell over a full 30 yards away. Yeah, the bad boy has issues, but he can hardly be blamed for that. Putin is a megalomaniac who absolute power has corrupted absolutely. The West did not make him what he is.

You're right I don't like to repeat myself, but as it's you I'll go over my perspective one more time. For brevity I'll just focus on the Putin stuff rather than the disaster of a new cold war and what it actually means.

I would disagree with the view that western policy had no affect on Putin's change of attitude towards it.

I would agree that Putin rules Russia as you'd expect a KGB agent to rule it.....like a mafia state. I would also agree that this is his war and while I've increasingly grown concerned over the Ukrainian leadership it is Putin who is responsible for the death and destruction.

However, I don't agree with the concepts promoted that he's mad or irrational. That doesn't make sense to me personally, that's the media relying upon people just nodding along to whatever they say and completely omitting the Russian perspective in the history since the break up of the Soviet Union.

To get a sense of my position we have to go back to the Berlin wall coming down and what the situation was then. Essentially you had a cold war....which was two empires...The US, with its main Nato arm and the Warsaw pack, which was the Soviet empire.

So to understand today, you have to understand 1990, when the US were trying to convince the Russians to give up East Berlin.

A link to a lecture given years ago that predicts where we are today and the bad faith that led us here.

[Link]

A link to a site showing the map of Europe in 1990 and links to documents of assurances given. It also has links to the lies told to the Russians back in the nineties. I had a better link to the actual documents that physically exist in Washington but I've lost it...this will have to do.

[Link]

My perspective is that both western and russian elites had a duty to act in the best interests of peace for both their peoples. Everything should have been done in the spirit of partnership with the west interested in the Russian economy being successful in its transition, just as the US was careful after WW2 in Germany with the Marshall plan, to ensure that Hitler mark two didn't emerge.

What in effect happened was that the west took advantage of Russian weakness, Yeltsin created the oligarchs to help him and that robbed the economy...all supported by the west, as Yeltsin was their man...living standards arrowed down. That produced and saw poverty in Russia, which in turn led to Putin...who Yeltsin himself promoted twice....Putin always had bad faith and a decline in living standards to point at and blame the west for.

Putin for all his problems, took the power away from the oligarchs turned the Russian economy around....here is a link to the improvements in living standards under Putin.

[Link]

Putin wasn't anti western when he took over, he apparently asked Clinton and Nato officials about joining Nato but was rebuffed. He offered the use of his bases after the 9/11 attacks....He attended the WEF, he can be seen with western leaders for many years...that is not the action of someone who wanted cold war 2.

No, Nato refusing to act bilaterally, putting weapons facing Russia into former republics and forgetting just how important Russia is both militarily and economically did that......it changed Putin and apparently the 2014 coup in Ukraine (which I believe had western interference) was his last straw.

Even if the war hadn't happened the argument isn't that Putin is good.....He isn't. He murders dissidents, has destroyed freedom of speech (though several posters on here would like the same for the west) and even though he is a social conservative I can't support any of that.

However that's hardly an issue for the west who have been dealing with and toadying along with the Saudis for decades.....No the issue is that our western elites acted in bad faith and instead of working with Russia, directly worked against them....keeping the flame of the cold war alive instead of extinguishing it for good.

Edited by Stirlingsays (21 Mar 2022 5.33pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 21 Mar 22 5.33pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

Your posts get more and more absurd.

my posts are about the OP. Yours are just petty personal attacks with a feather duster. With zero insight or contribution to the political debate.

Putin, Stalin, Catherine the Great....... Russia has always had dangerous nutters at the helm. And the West underestimates them at its peril.

An intelligent contribution just above this from Sterling. The West has irritated the Russian Bear....and now looks surprised when the Bear lashes out.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (21 Mar 2022 5.40pm)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 21 Mar 22 5.57pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

my posts are about the OP. Yours are just petty personal attacks with a feather duster. With zero insight or contribution to the political debate.

Putin, Stalin, Catherine the Great....... Russia has always had dangerous nutters at the helm. And the West underestimates them at its peril.

An intelligent contribution just above this from Sterling. The West has irritated the Russian Bear....and now looks surprised when the Bear lashes out.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (21 Mar 2022 5.40pm)

Your constant blaming of NATO and the West in general for the actions of the fascist Putin is absurd. The admiration of Putin expressed on here as a tough guy is sickening.

 

Page 7 of 10 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Putin