This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Hodgson to stay
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 21 May 23 7.49pm |
|
|
I have a 'Feeling in my water' that supporters won't have to wait long to find out if Mr Hodgson will be our manager next season.
Edited by Willo (21 May 2023 8.00pm)
|
Painter Croydon 21 May 23 8.04pm |
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
Training I said not Academy. (WOW you cant even get that correct)
SO who is posting rubbish someone with the name beginning with L
Brighton a team who has been in this league less time has embarrassed us in every department look how much better they are.
SP does a lot of fancy talking but its all sales pitches and controlled questions/discussion.
You seem consumed with envy, that someone can be successful. You highlight Brighton, who for the first season for a long time will finish above us, there are plenty of other teams promoted, since we were promoted that have failed and are languishing in the championship or League One.
|
Swindy Bromley 21 May 23 8.34pm |
|
|
If it's true that Paddy Mccarthy is being groomed to take over from Roy in a year's time then as usual Steve's lack of ambition & desire to do everything on the cheap is alive and kicking. Soon be another transfer window starting to showcase his customary amateur cluelessness.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 21 May 23 8.46pm |
|
Originally posted by Swindy
If it's true that Paddy Mccarthy is being groomed to take over from Roy in a year's time then as usual Steve's lack of ambition & desire to do everything on the cheap is alive and kicking. Soon be another transfer window starting to showcase his customary amateur cluelessness.
This is our TENTH season in the PL and it will be our ELEVENTH next campaign. Bringing back Mr Hodgson was also a master stroke. With the greatest of respect, one cannot place Steve Parish in the category labelled "Clueless".
Edited by Willo (21 May 2023 8.51pm)
|
Painter Croydon 21 May 23 8.51pm |
|
Originally posted by Swindy
If it's true that Paddy Mccarthy is being groomed to take over from Roy in a year's time then as usual Steve's lack of ambition & desire to do everything on the cheap is alive and kicking. Soon be another transfer window starting to showcase his customary amateur cluelessness.
Who said that McCarthy is being groomed to take over, apart from social media speculation, certainly no announcement from the club. Do you know how much it costs to run the Academy, it certainly isnt cheap.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 21 May 23 8.54pm |
|
Originally posted by Painter
Who said that McCarthy is being groomed to take over, apart from social media speculation, certainly no announcement from the club. Do you know how much it costs to run the Academy, it certainly isnt cheap.
I do not recognise the aforementioned scenario. Certainly has proved to be thought provoking with some deeming that such a scenario is plausible.
Edited by Willo (21 May 2023 9.10pm)
|
Vaibow vancouver/croydon 22 May 23 3.37am |
|
|
If we were an established championship club, I would say go ahead, let Roy train P{addy up.. you have time to build something and cash in on the youth... in the prem a whole other story.
We just had an iconic player with no prem or real top flight managerial success flop at palace, to recreate that with Paddy would be crazy.
My best bet, send Paddy out to manage for a couple of years elsewhere and when the time is right for both parties, it may work out... but we need an experienced manager that is able to play to our strengths.
No more projects please.
This was once a quality forum....
|
Teddy Eagle 22 May 23 5.15am |
|
|
Just ask Eze who he wants. He's the jewel in the crown and if he's happy with Roy then that's enough for me. We can't fill a team with £100m players but we potentially have one who we need to keep him for as long as possible and build a team around him.
|
sprites Auckland 22 May 23 5.36am |
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Just ask Eze who he wants. He's the jewel in the crown and if he's happy with Roy then that's enough for me. We can't fill a team with £100m players but we potentially have one who we need to keep him for as long as possible and build a team around him.
Agree. Although would add Guehi and Olise to that list. They're our gold trifecta.
Edited by sprites (22 May 2023 5.37am)
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 22 May 23 8.01am |
|
|
With the final game on Sunday, is anyone of the opinion that both Mr Hodgson and Steve Parish have NOT had dialogue about the managerial position beyond the end of this season ?
On Saturday, I overheard some chap with a loud voice opine that they "Both know the score" and were waiting for an opportune time to make an announcement !
Edited by Willo (22 May 2023 8.17am)
|
Dubai Eagle 22 May 23 8.15am |
|
|
Its difficult to believe that conversation wasn't at least started several weeks ago.
Originally posted by Willo
With the final game on Sunday, is anyone of the opinion that both Mr Hodgson and Steve Parish have NOT had dialogue about the managerial position beyond the end of this season ?
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 22 May 23 8.33am |
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
Its difficult to believe that conversation wasn't at least started several weeks ago.
There are those who might be concluding that the conversations have gallivanted down a different 'Alley' as results have unfolded. I suspect all will be revealed sooner rather than later !
Edited by Willo (22 May 2023 8.36am)
|
PatrickA London 22 May 23 8.36am |
|
|
It wouldn’t surprise me if there is an announcement in the first week of June that both Hodgson and Zaha are staying. I also wouldn’t be surprised if there are renewals for Ward, Tomkins and possibly even Clyne. I don’t think the AWB deal will happen now. I think both Luka and McArthur will go and will be replaced by Lerma or similar. Just my opinion , and if it happens some may argue that it’s Parish doing things on the cheap with no significant transfer outlay. There may be an element of truth in this. However, the squad and manager are in a good place at the moment and surely the key thing is to retain that harmonious stability while retaining Guehi, Anderson, Eze and Olise.
|
MrRobbo Chaldon 22 May 23 8.38am |
|
Originally posted by Vaibow
If we were an established championship club, I would say go ahead, let Roy train P{addy up.. you have time to build something and cash in on the youth... in the prem a whole other story.
We just had an iconic player with no prem or real top flight managerial success flop at palace, to recreate that with Paddy would be crazy.
My best bet, send Paddy out to manage for a couple of years elsewhere and when the time is right for both parties, it may work out... but we need an experienced manager that is able to play to our strengths.
No more projects please.
Yep, there is no way anyone would be silly enough to even think about giving Paddy the role.
Not saying he isn't a promising manager in the making, but this is a prem job. And there are plenty of experienced managers out there.
|
MrRobbo Chaldon 22 May 23 8.39am |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
It wouldn’t surprise me if there is an announcement in the first week of June that both Hodgson and Zaha are staying. I also wouldn’t be surprised if there are renewals for Ward, Tomkins and possibly even Clyne. I don’t think the AWB deal will happen now. I think both Luka and McArthur will go and will be replaced by Lerma or similar. Just my opinion , and if it happens some may argue that it’s Parish doing things on the cheap with no significant transfer outlay. There may be an element of truth in this. However, the squad and manager are in a good place at the moment and surely the key thing is to retain that harmonious stability while retaining Guehi, Anderson, Eze and Olise.
I cant see any world where Tomkins gets a new contract
|
PatrickA London 22 May 23 8.57am |
|
|
Tomkins wouldn’t be first on my list for renewal either. The reasoning behind a renewal would be that we have been quite fortunate this season with Guehi and Anderson available nearly all the time. This may not be the case I next season with injuries and suspensions. We need 4 centre backs in the squad. As one of the ‘reserve’ centre backs Richards has good potential but looks injury prone and we need one other experienced centre half as cover (although it must be acknowledged Tomkins isn’t exactly injury free either). We could seek to buy an experienced centre half as cover or stay with the existing one in Tomkins. Other options would be the inexperienced O’Brien or use of Ward as a fourth centre back but this smacks of a bare bones approach.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 22 May 23 9.07am |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Tomkins wouldn’t be first on my list for renewal either. The reasoning behind a renewal would be that we have been quite fortunate this season with Guehi and Anderson available nearly all the time. This may not be the case I next season with injuries and suspensions. We need 4 centre backs in the squad. As one of the ‘reserve’ centre backs Richards has good potential but looks injury prone and we need one other experienced centre half as cover (although it must be acknowledged Tomkins isn’t exactly injury free either). We could seek to buy an experienced centre half as cover or stay with the existing one in Tomkins. Other options would be the inexperienced O’Brien or use of Ward as a fourth centre back but this smacks of a bare bones approach.
I concur with the general thrust of these sentiments.
I can understand supporters concluding that those in the twilight of their careers who have not featured regularly should be shown the door but they do offer invaluable experience, besides to replace two or three etc can cost a significant sum.
|
Eaglecoops CR3 22 May 23 9.10am |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Tomkins wouldn’t be first on my list for renewal either. The reasoning behind a renewal would be that we have been quite fortunate this season with Guehi and Anderson available nearly all the time. This may not be the case I next season with injuries and suspensions. We need 4 centre backs in the squad. As one of the ‘reserve’ centre backs Richards has good potential but looks injury prone and we need one other experienced centre half as cover (although it must be acknowledged Tomkins isn’t exactly injury free either). We could seek to buy an experienced centre half as cover or stay with the existing one in Tomkins. Other options would be the inexperienced O’Brien or use of Ward as a fourth centre back but this smacks of a bare bones approach.
To be honest, everything we ever do smacks of a bare bones approach. We should be offloading Tomkins and bringing in O’Brien as 4th CB. Clyne or Ward (probably Clyne) should go and a new right back bought. Adaramola/Hannam either needs to be promoted to joining the first team or we need another left back. We haven’t even got onto the midfield or attack yet.
|
PatrickA London 22 May 23 9.26am |
|
|
Hannan has announced on social media that he is leaving the club. Adaramola couldn’t make the squad on loan with Coventry last season and appears to have gone backwards. O’Brien is unproven and inexperienced. I wouldn’t want to be throwing in these players into Premier League games with precious points at stake. The reality is that only very exceptional players like AWB will emerge from the youth team as first team contenders. If you get one of these every couple of seasons you’re doing well. Anybody remember Sam Woods and Brandon Pierrick in the past few seasons? Hailed as the future of the club I don’t know if they are still making a career in football. With the new Academy up and running we’ll hopefully enhance the quality of the intake and be able to compete better with the likes of Chelsea and produce more first team contenders. However, it’s still early days.
|
Eaglecoops CR3 23 May 23 10.28am |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Hannan has announced on social media that he is leaving the club. Adaramola couldn’t make the squad on loan with Coventry last season and appears to have gone backwards. O’Brien is unproven and inexperienced. I wouldn’t want to be throwing in these players into Premier League games with precious points at stake. The reality is that only very exceptional players like AWB will emerge from the youth team as first team contenders. If you get one of these every couple of seasons you’re doing well. Anybody remember Sam Woods and Brandon Pierrick in the past few seasons? Hailed as the future of the club I don’t know if they are still making a career in football. With the new Academy up and running we’ll hopefully enhance the quality of the intake and be able to compete better with the likes of Chelsea and produce more first team contenders. However, it’s still early days.
Yes, just read the piece that says he is definitely leaving the club. I must say there has to be something going on in the background with him because he looked decent a couple of seasons ago and yet last year he only managed something like 17 games for Bromley. It’s a shame, I genuinely thought he might make it.
It’s interesting what you say and a tad worrying that none of the current crop have made it into any decent level of football. Is that down to the initial scouting phase or is it so difficult to find rough diamonds and therefore becomes a numbers game with say 1 in 20 making it?
|