This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
How so? Pulis walked out with no warning two days before the season started and then tried to claim a bonus he wasn't due, a fact that was upheld in the resulting court case. I'd say "money-grabbing c***", if a trifle uncouth, covers it like a bedspread. Pulis bonus was for keeping us up, which he did. He has said that the reason he left was due to failure to be backed (rightly or wrongly) in the transfer market, and it was by mutual consent. He oversaw arguably the best pre-season we've had in the PL, and it seems unlikely he would have put in all that effort if he was intending to walk. The court case related to his receiving the bonus two weeks early, when his reasons for requesting that were found to be untrue. He earned that bonus and I personally thought we looked extremely cheap, going to court, in light of what staying up meant in financial terms. He certainly deserved it more than the amounts we no doubt paid to Pardew and de Boer. Allardyce was supposedly leaving to permanently retire, which wasn't the case, and which no doubt affected our pre-season, yet he doesn't get the same level of opprobrium. Perhaps he'd already got wind of the backing he was likely to get with respect to transfers? If another successful manager walks this summer some serious questions would need to be asked of the board.
Bexley Dave Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing! "The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum) |
|
|
Originally posted by bifffabazz
Am I alone in being somewhat uncomfortable with this thread? To take the club from the edge of oblivion to where we are now, with the prospect of a fantastic new stand and continuing our record run in the top flight....it's pinch yourself stuff. Everyone makes mistakes in business, especially one as unscientific and risk-laden as professional football. I do not feel comfortable debating those mistakes though and instead just want to shake the bloke's hand. Great post - brings us all back to the true reality of our situation. However the other reality is that ALL teams in the EPL except: ManU, Liverpool, Arsenal & Spurs (plus Chelski & Man City, but only whilst they have their current owners) are there on borrowed time - apart from these 6, there's absolute NO thing as an established EPL club. Regardless of Parish achievements & uncomfortable at it is to acceptable , unfortunately our day will come.
|
|
|
Originally posted by bexleydave
Pulis bonus was for keeping us up, which he did. He has said that the reason he left was due to failure to be backed (rightly or wrongly) in the transfer market, and it was by mutual consent. He oversaw arguably the best pre-season we've had in the PL, and it seems unlikely he would have put in all that effort if he was intending to walk. The court case related to his receiving the bonus two weeks early, when his reasons for requesting that were found to be untrue. He earned that bonus and I personally thought we looked extremely cheap, going to court, in light of what staying up meant in financial terms. He certainly deserved it more than the amounts we no doubt paid to Pardew and de Boer.
Thank you for putting it more eloquently than I would have done
|
|
|
Originally posted by bexleydave
Pulis bonus was for keeping us up, which he did. He has said that the reason he left was due to failure to be backed (rightly or wrongly) in the transfer market, and it was by mutual consent. He oversaw arguably the best pre-season we've had in the PL, and it seems unlikely he would have put in all that effort if he was intending to walk. The court case related to his receiving the bonus two weeks early, when his reasons for requesting that were found to be untrue. He earned that bonus and I personally thought we looked extremely cheap, going to court, in light of what staying up meant in financial terms. He certainly deserved it more than the amounts we no doubt paid to Pardew and de Boer. Allardyce was supposedly leaving to permanently retire, which wasn't the case, and which no doubt affected our pre-season, yet he doesn't get the same level of opprobrium. Perhaps he'd already got wind of the backing he was likely to get with respect to transfers? If another successful manager walks this summer some serious questions would need to be asked of the board.
Taken from the High Court judgement : It was common ground in the arbitration that under his contract of employment the Claimant was due to be paid a bonus of £2 million gross, if he successfully kept Crystal Palace in the Premier League after the 2013/2014 season, which he did, and if he remained in employment on 31 August 2014, which latter condition was in the event not fulfilled.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Taken from the High Court judgement : It was common ground in the arbitration that under his contract of employment the Claimant was due to be paid a bonus of £2 million gross, if he successfully kept Crystal Palace in the Premier League after the 2013/2014 season, which he did, and if he remained in employment on 31 August 2014, which latter condition was in the event not fulfilled. I think that we all know that whilst Pulis performed a miracle and kept us up he didn't fulfil his contractual obligations to stay with the club until 31st August. I agree with BD that the court case made us look cheap as whilst Pulis earned his £2m by virtue of keeping us up his actions also increased Parish's share value by many tens of millions Edited by Midlands Eagle (12 May 2018 11.03am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I think that we all know that whilst Pulis performed a miracle and kept us up he didn't fulfil his contractual obligations to stay with the club until 31st August. I agree with BD that the court case made us look cheap as whilst Pulis earned his £2m by virtue of keeping us up his actions also increased Parish's share value by many tens of millions Edited by Midlands Eagle (12 May 2018 11.03am) I'm not going to get into the minutiae of the High Court judgement but I disagree with your viewpoint.I will leave it at this.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I think that we all know that whilst Pulis performed a miracle and kept us up he didn't fulfil his contractual obligations to stay with the club until 31st August. I agree with BD that the court case made us look cheap as whilst Pulis earned his £2m by virtue of keeping us up his actions also increased Parish's share value by many tens of millions Edited by Midlands Eagle (12 May 2018 11.03am) Personally I think £2m is reasonable compensation for the situation he left us in and that he could have handled that in a way that didn't leave us in the s***. The contract was drafted to protect us from that, he tried to wangle the money despite it and failed, and we could have gone down partly because of what he did. If you can forgive him for that you're a better man that I am, Gunga Din. Allardyce OTOH gave good notice of leaving and left us good time to find a replacement, which of course we and we alone f***ed up.
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Personally I think £2m is reasonable compensation for the situation he left us in and that he could have handled that in a way that didn't leave us in the s***. The contract was drafted to protect us from that, he tried to wangle the money despite it and failed, and we could have gone down partly because of what he did. If you can forgive him for that you're a better man that I am, Gunga Din. Allardyce OTOH gave good notice of leaving and left us good time to find a replacement, which of course we and we alone f***ed up. Parish has himself admitted to "Muddled thinking" and I am sure he has learnt from that experience. At that time there was a great deal of positivity about the high-profile De Boer being appointed. Had Hodgson been appointed instead, I should imagine that Parish would have been pilloried for his decision !!!!
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Parish has himself admitted to "Muddled thinking" and I am sure he has learnt from that experience. At that time there was a great deal of positivity about the high-profile De Boer being appointed. Had Hodgson been appointed instead, I should imagine that Parish would have been pilloried for his decision !!!! You ate quite right there. Thank God it isn't us taking these decisions.
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
You ate quite right there. Thank God it isn't us taking these decisions. Just a thought. We have been linked with all sorts of players who have signed for other clubs probably because Parish wouldn't pay the fee or wages. How many of them have been a success? Maybe someone would like to start a thread "we dodged a bullet". I have no facts but I have seen quite a few where I was gutted they did not sign and now I am glad. The striker that Wet Spam poached on transfer day and hasn't set the world alight for one. And yes I know we have one of those as well.
One more point |
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Just a thought. We have been linked with all sorts of players who have signed for other clubs probably because Parish wouldn't pay the fee or wages. How many of them have been a success? Maybe someone would like to start a thread "we dodged a bullet". I have no facts but I have seen quite a few where I was gutted they did not sign and now I am glad. The striker that Wet Spam poached on transfer day and hasn't set the world alight for one. And yes I know we have one of those as well. There is precisely such a thread on the BBS :-) Edited by chateauferret (12 May 2018 11.41am)
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The 'Close' season it is normally called, now just pre-season. Whatever, to me it is the most important season. It is also the worst season for us, a look back to last years close season will tell you everything about our relegation struggle, and tbh previous years as well. Let's hope RH is on it, from his press conference yesterday he is certainly not spreading any false optimism about next season. He seems to be saying 12 clubs could be relegation candidates, the rich 6 safe as usual and a couple of others. After this year, good outfits who have invested lots with good players and PL records are just as likely to go down. West Brom, Stoke and Swansea all have good players stadiums and setup to play PL football. The margins are so slim, a couple of defeats can send you down. At the minimum we must be primed and ready to go from day 1, that has not been the case really before. Stoke and Swansea I think have been making profits of £20 mil on transfers. Can’t remember on wba. Mentalists.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by bexleydave
when he was still in charge he even stated he wasn't happy that the club had already setup pre-season plans without him being consulted and it was not ideal the plans in place. Two quality managers not being allowed to do what they want and getting backing needed resulted in both walking. Roy is saying a lot of the same stuff that Sam did about not fighting relegation again and club needs to move forward. Money talks if you have the staff you need the money to bring in the players for them thats how City won the title (we are not expected to spend like them but we do need to spend the squad is too small and really lacking quality outside starting 11)
|
|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
when he was still in charge he even stated he wasn't happy that the club had already setup pre-season plans without him being consulted and it was not ideal the plans in place. Two quality managers not being allowed to do what they want and getting backing needed resulted in both walking. Roy is saying a lot of the same stuff that Sam did about not fighting relegation again and club needs to move forward. Money talks if you have the staff you need the money to bring in the players for them thats how City won the title (we are not expected to spend like them but we do need to spend the squad is too small and really lacking quality outside starting 11) Good post. At this stage it would be the ultimate folly to lose Roy, sell Wilf, and pretend that it didn't happen. We are in a good space right now - a few signings (outing the crap) and bringing forth the youngsters should see us fine
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The 'Close' season it is normally called, now just pre-season. Whatever, to me it is the most important season. It is also the worst season for us, a look back to last years close season will tell you everything about our relegation struggle, and tbh previous years as well. Let's hope RH is on it, from his press conference yesterday he is certainly not spreading any false optimism about next season. He seems to be saying 12 clubs could be relegation candidates, the rich 6 safe as usual and a couple of others. After this year, good outfits who have invested lots with good players and PL records are just as likely to go down. West Brom, Stoke and Swansea all have good players stadiums and setup to play PL football. The margins are so slim, a couple of defeats can send you down. At the minimum we must be primed and ready to go from day 1, that has not been the case really before. Totally agree. I was very interested to hear that Steve Parish voted against bringing the transfer deadline forward. Did he give any idea of his reasoning? I think that could be really good for us so that we have all players in place before all the August games are played. In the past we have possibly dropped points by having an incomplete squad (and an underwhelming pre season) Since Parish likes to do all his signings just before the deadline why should it be a problem to bring that process forward? If anything it will give the agents less time to spread rumours that complicate discussions.
|
|
|
Originally posted by mileend
Totally agree. I was very interested to hear that Steve Parish voted against bringing the transfer deadline forward. Did he give any idea of his reasoning? I think that could be really good for us so that we have all players in place before all the August games are played. In the past we have possibly dropped points by having an incomplete squad (and an underwhelming pre season) Since Parish likes to do all his signings just before the deadline why should it be a problem to bring that process forward? If anything it will give the agents less time to spread rumours that complicate discussions.
The transfer deadline being moved will only work if all the other EU leagues do the same other wise it really is not going to offer an advantage to clubs like Palace it would be a disadvantage. It's about time football got on the same page the rules should be the same over all of europe the same with transfer windows.
|
|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
Parish doesn't like doing the last minute deals he has even said so himself he said most times clubs/agents force this to happen (i think he plays hardball too much as well which doesn't help) The transfer deadline being moved will only work if all the other EU leagues do the same other wise it really is not going to offer an advantage to clubs like Palace it would be a disadvantage. It's about time football got on the same page the rules should be the same over all of europe the same with transfer windows. Good points Pochettino is in the paper today saying this, that it gives a 'massive advantage' to European clubs as you have a risk that 'things will happen'. I guess he is more worried because he is in the Champions League and if he has an injury on 10th August he can't do anything about it but his European competitors can. That would be what Steve Parish calls a 'luxury problem'. What has been a problem is that the clubs we try and buy from don't have time to find replacements for our late bids. That at least won't be an issue - they will have 3 extra weeks! Interesting to see how it pans out.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I think that we all know that whilst Pulis performed a miracle and kept us up he didn't fulfil his contractual obligations to stay with the club until 31st August. I agree with BD that the court case made us look cheap as whilst Pulis earned his £2m by virtue of keeping us up his actions also increased Parish's share value by many tens of millions Edited by Midlands Eagle (12 May 2018 11.03am) Made us look cheap? Pulls has well documented previous. I take it from your stance you condone TPs behaviour? How else could you consider someone stiffing us for the equivalent of a decent player’s annual salary as something not worth pursuing? SP did the right thing in the right way. No grandstanding, went to arbitration where legally, all details would remain private, but TP refused to accept the judgement and decided to play it out in public. We didn’t look cheap, Pulis looked and was proven to be a liar and cheat.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch
Made us look cheap? Pulls has well documented previous. I take it from your stance you condone TPs behaviour? How else could you consider someone stiffing us for the equivalent of a decent player’s annual salary as something not worth pursuing? SP did the right thing in the right way. No grandstanding, went to arbitration where legally, all details would remain private, but TP refused to accept the judgement and decided to play it out in public. We didn’t look cheap, Pulis looked and was proven to be a liar and cheat. Would we have been in a better position then if Pulis had waited a fortnight and then told us he wanted out? How many PL players "annual salaries" would it have cost if, rather than staying up, we'd been relegated? As already stated, his departure was by mutual consent and he'd done what was required to earn that bonus. It's difficult for a club that's been in administration twice in a decade to start taking a moral stance over monies owed. Parish and co left it 'til the 11th hour to purchase the club, when Jordan, who'd recued us previously, was totally on the rack, and they could pick it up for a relative song. Never mind the major creditors, look at the long list of small local businesses that lost small fortunes. It was left to the supporters to repay the St John's ambulance. Were you one of those, like myself, who chucked in their £50 to keep us afloat before the buyout (I suspect not)? For us, and the current owners, to pretend our sh*t doesn't stink when it comes to who owes what to who is either arrogant or delusional.
Bexley Dave Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing! "The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.