This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by doombear
Eventually yes, but how fit is he? He hasn't played since before lockdown. His contract at Bournemouth ended on 30th June. So how long will it take him to get up to speed and be match fit? Fraser's last game was on 7th March.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sotac464
Fair enough but he called me a liar, which I am not, when he was a moderator he used it as a power trip. I am not the only one, there are many on here that he has done the same thing to. If our posts were so bad why didn't the other moderator's issue us with yellows and reds? ^^^^^ THIS ^^^^^
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by dazza
The only way we will not buy a Striker is if Zaha stays as he could well be used as another striker option especially if Fraser signs as that gives another wide option. Personally I still think we will sign a striker. I’m hearing 2 signings will be announced by end of this week. Gallagher Dazza So on that basis is the suggestion that Zaha is going?
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Yes I agree, it will take him time to get up to speed. Possible he might be on the bench? Hodgson requires players to earn their way into the squad, and then to start, but of course there's the minor matter of him signing for us first!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Petereagle
Very informative Willo, thank you Willo - is Brewster an out and out striker?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
Willo - is Brewster an out and out striker? In a word yes, and Willo will testify to, mentioned in a previous thread, his best work is in the box.
My equalibrium unbalanced me. Paul Draper Brighton 19/2/2018 |
|
|
Originally posted by sotac464
In a word yes, and Willo will testify to, mentioned in a previous thread, his best work is in the box. Nice - I for one am getting very excited about us looking towards youth. Hope we can keep Zaha then this season could see the sort of attacking football we have all been craving for rather than the solid and look for Zaha to do something for us on the break..!! COYP
|
|
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
Nice - I for one am getting very excited about us looking towards youth. Hope we can keep Zaha then this season could see the sort of attacking football we have all been craving for rather than the solid and look for Zaha to do something for us on the break..!! COYP Trouble with Brewster, will we get the ball in the box enough for him?
My equalibrium unbalanced me. Paul Draper Brighton 19/2/2018 |
|
|
Originally posted by sotac464
In a word yes, and Willo will testify to, mentioned in a previous thread, his best work is in the box. Except with penalties as proven in Community Shield. What will that do to his confidence?
|
|
|
Originally posted by AdaSirin
The consensus I’ve seen elsewhere from trusted sources (e.g. Carl and Clapham Grand) is that it’s highly unlikely for Wilf to leave this window. In fact, they seem to generally think that Wilf signing a new and more lucrative contract is the likelier scenario. Of course, there could still be a late bid for him, but there have been absolutely no indications of it happening so far. I still would’ve expected us to sign a striker this window regardless of Wilf, though. Neither Wilf or Ayew are proper strikers, so beginning a new season with no improvement in that area seems foolish, even if we’ve strengthened elsewhere. Edited by AdaSirin (31 Aug 2020 7.08pm)
Edited by doombear (31 Aug 2020 7.51pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Edited by doombear (31 Aug 2020 7.51pm) Sure, I mostly agree with that. I'm really happy that we signed Eze and I think he brings an attacking threat and level of creativity in the midfield that we've been sorely lacking. If we can manage to sign Fraser too (which is looking possible, but I'm not all that confident we'll get him in the end) or Bright Osayi-Samuel then we'd definitely be looking more threatening than in recent seasons. Progress is being made, and I've really liked the general approach of this transfer window so far. But the elephant in the room still remains: we don't have a dedicated, specialist striker. We have a striker who's been morbidly out of form for multiple seasons now (Benteke), another who's perpetually injured (Wickham), and then two wide players who do their best as strikers when called upon but who are actually better suited to different roles (Zaha and Ayew). We've managed to scrape by for multiple seasons now without a specialist striker, but each new season we attempt to do so is a big gamble. And now it looks like we're going to roll the dice yet again... I really have been of the mind that this is a transformative transfer window for us. After consecutive seasons of doing our best with an ageing squad and no reliable goalscorer, things have finally been catching up with us and it's finally time to act. In some ways we have acted (Eze and Ferguson both seem like great signings in positions we desperately needed), but going into yet another season with Wilf (hopefully) and Ayew doing their best as strikers doesn't fill me with very much confidence. I really expected this to be the window where we finally addressed the striker issue in a meaningful way. Edited by AdaSirin (31 Aug 2020 8.08pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by AdaSirin
Sure, I mostly agree with that. I'm really happy that we signed Eze and I think he brings an attacking threat and level of creativity in the midfield that we've been sorely lacking. If we can manage to sign Fraser too (which is looking possible, but I'm not all that confident we'll get him in the end) or Bright Osayi-Samuel then we'd definitely be looking more threatening than in recent seasons. Progress is being made, and I've really liked the general approach of this transfer window so far. But the elephant in the room still remains: we don't have a dedicated, specialist striker. We have a striker who's been morbidly out of form for multiple seasons now (Benteke), another who's perpetually injured (Wickham), and then two wide players who do their best as strikers when called upon but who are actually better suited to different roles (Zaha and Ayew). We've managed to scrape by for multiple seasons now without a specialist striker, but each new season we attempt to do so is a big gamble. And now it looks like we're going to roll the dice yet again... I really have been of the mind that this is a transformative transfer window for us. After consecutive seasons of doing our best with an ageing squad and no reliable goalscorer, things have finally been catching up with us and it's finally time to act. In some ways we have acted (Eze and Ferguson both seem like great signings in positions we desperately needed), but going into yet another season with Wilf (hopefully) and Ayew doing their best as strikers doesn't fill me with very much confidence. I really expected this to be the window where we finally addressed the striker issue in a meaningful way. Edited by AdaSirin (31 Aug 2020 8.08pm) I am beginning to think that the rumours about Mateta were just, well, rumours. But ya never know...
|
|
|
As it stands at Present Zaha is more likely to still be a Palace Player come end of window. Great news for us all.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dazza
As it stands at Present Zaha is more likely to still be a Palace Player come end of window. Great news for us all. Would be very attacking side with eze zaha Gallagher in the team add another striker and that is hopefully a top 10 side but we need a striker definitely would love Brewster or batman but I'm dreaming
|
|
|
Originally posted by bashy2
Would be very attacking side with eze zaha Gallagher in the team add another striker and that is hopefully a top 10 side but we need a striker definitely would love Brewster or batman but I'm dreaming The Holmesdale is a place to dream!
|
|
|
Originally posted by sotac464
Fair enough but he called me a liar, which I am not, when he was a moderator he used it as a power trip. I am not the only one, there are many on here that he has done the same thing to. If our posts were so bad why didn't the other moderator's issue us with yellows and reds? I got a yellow from him for absolutely nothing back in the day. He was on a massive power trip when he was a mod constantly merging threads that didn’t need to be merged and warning people every 5 minutes. Been posting on here for like 10 years and he was the only mod to ever give me a card.
|
|
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
Back to the matter at hand. If we do sign OS or Fraser what does that mean for Gallagher. I don’t want him playing ahead of players we will have long term. If we are going to use a loan spot, why not go for a position we need cover in? We are short up top and out wide still. Also Dazza have you heard anything about outgoings, particularly for our academy kids. If Bright can’t get them loans again this window he needs to go. We are not giving them a chance to develop here. Fraser/OS are wide players and would be competing for Townsend's position. Gallagher would be competing for McCarthy/MacArthur's CM position. So I don't see any problems with overlap there.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.