Quote Stirlingsays at 03 Sep 2015 7.35pm
Quote oldcodger at 03 Sep 2015 7.07pm
If you write off the value of men that leave a war torn country with their families to find a better life and then don't like that someone may disagree with you doing so, they haven't 'lied' and it doesn't make them 'retarded'.
When you then come out with stuff about you having no responsibility to others, with your kids comment, what you've clumsily and accidentally done is shine a light on the nuance of how people feel about their country and family and how best to protect everything they care about. People become torn. There is no, hero if tick box A, little worth as a person if tick box B. These are people trying to do their best in terrible situations beyond those we will ever face, while you sit there judging them from afar. Call me what you like in the process, but yes I'll comment on that.
Edited by oldcodger (03 Sep 2015 7.09pm)
Previously I simply responded to you upon the level you wished to operate on. It was you who wished to speculate upon people being plums and not having brains.....As well as previously disfiguring their position.
However, this post appears to be playing the ball and not the man so fair enough.
I'm very clear about how I regard men in terms of standing and fighting against extremists in Syria and those that decide to run.
Yes, I do see a difference in worth. I'd rather support those that fight and I have contributed to funds towards Kobane......The Kurds are a people I respect.....Personally once the Syrian crisis is finally over I'd support a Kurdish ruled region in northern Syria....Whether Turkey like it or not.
If my country was subject to invasion I'd stand and fight. Countries are only ever free because hundreds of thousands of people died fighting for that freedom.
It isn't won by young men running away.
I say again.....A point you haven't tackled....What about those in Syria fighting against IS....Where is their support? You are prepared to house and allow people to stay in rich western countries but what do the people standing and fighting get?
All these men fighting to get into rich countries..What happens once Syria is peaceful again...They get to return to the country braver men and women fought for.
Your damn right I see a difference. Your damn right I judge people over that.
I made a point about self interest.....About how its natural to be interested in your own children over the interests of someone else's.....though obviously you don't wish them harm.
If Syrians were sending their children or women aboard for Asylum while they fought for the future of their country I'd feel far more sympathy towards the situation......Hell, I'd take those men injured fighting IS who had been vouched for.
But in most situations this is young men and young men with families. These people took their money and ran....It is what it is.
My policy has been previously stated......A set number on asylum judged upon by my own government....People vouched for by those moderate groups fighting against IS and excepting anyone who willingly fought for Assad.
Edited by Stirlingsays (03 Sep 2015 7.40pm)
There's little sense in leaving your wife and child without a husband or father if your situation seems futile. It's easy to suggest otherwise on a forum, but it's when you're on the ground that you can gauge the situation and make that call. We had and have the opportunity to be more robust in our opposition to ISIS. There's an element of chickens coming home to roost to this on account of us not doing so.
As for the point of what about those left behind, that feeds directly into your idea of 'you take care of your children, I'll take care of mine'. You see your own attitude towards allegiance to country and family was mixed and that is the 'true' reality for most really. You gauge the situation and you act there and then. We can all be super heroes at a computer, harshly judging people making a journey they know they might not even survive. For supposed cowards though, it's a braver decision than any of us will ever have to make for our families.