You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Our Daughter Holly
November 19 2026 5.31pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Our Daughter Holly


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 11 Mar 04 10.47pm

The program tonight.

I don't know what to say. It had me in tears throughout much of it. It upset me immensely, I really shouldn't have watched it, but I knew I would have to. I'm left feeling so very hollow and defeated by the sickness of this vile filthy world of perverts and evil, but my absolute and total admiration of the Wells family gives me something positive to cling to. Something to continue to strive for. Wonderful, strong, good people. The unimportant ordinary backbone of this island.

But I'm left feeling that with the aid of well-meaning liberal ideals and human rights for all no matter what; evil is winning the battle.

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

the despotic banana Flag Dept. of Baboon Maintenance 11 Mar 04 11.11pm

Petealiator, I'm not sure whether you're saying that all paedophiles or just Ian Huntley, or both, are evil so I'll approach this from two angles. Firstly, although the court found Huntley to be guilty and although the evidence may be stacked against him, the sad truth is that only Ian Huntley knows what happened that tragic day. The deaths of the two girls may have been a genuine accident, and without knowing what went on, we cannot judge Huntley and decide him to be evil on that basis.

Secondly, this is a problem of our own making - if paedophiles weren't so reviled by society then they wouldn't turn to such desperate measures. Paedophiles need to be helped not loathed. Tabloid papers whipping up frenzies and encouraging lynch mobs solves nothing, and it only makes the problem worse. If a paedophile knows that if he makes his problem public then he's going to be ostracised or worse, then he's better off keeping it a secret and letting it gnaw at him from the inside until one day he snaps with terrible consequences. We need to show them compassion and humanity, not seek to destroy them - it is not a conscious decision on a paedophile's part to become attracted to young children, they do not wake up one day and decide to find children arousing. Rather it would appear to be a mental problem, perhaps stemming from being abused as a child. It is not their fault, and we must acknowledge that.

 


Ask me about Ronald de Boer.

gambler Flag Kent 11 Mar 04 11.13pm

The programme brought it all home again.

How both girl's parents have conducted themselves throughout the whole thing. Never being able to get anywhere close to realising what they must have gone/are going through.

No matter how many times i hear the horrible details of it all, it still seems so unreal, the girls were just in the wrong place at the wrong time and some evil thing took advantage.

I have never really gone for the "hangings too good" thinking, but it really hit home. Why should Huntley still be breathing when he killed those girls, but executing him just doesn't seem to be the way to get justice - what other way is there to make him pay?

 

gambler Flag Kent 11 Mar 04 11.17pm

the despotic banana - i can't believe what i'm reading in your post. So you believe his story about drowning and suffocation do you?!

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 11 Mar 04 11.24pm

Quote the despotic banana at 11 Mar 2004 11:11pm

Petealiator, I'm not sure whether you're saying that all paedophiles or just Ian Huntley, or both, are evil so I'll approach this from two angles. Firstly, although the court found Huntley to be guilty and although the evidence may be stacked against him, the sad truth is that only Ian Huntley knows what happened that tragic day. The deaths of the two girls may have been a genuine accident, and without knowing what went on, we cannot judge Huntley and decide him to be evil on that basis.

Secondly, this is a problem of our own making - if paedophiles weren't so reviled by society then they wouldn't turn to such desperate measures. Paedophiles need to be helped not loathed. Tabloid papers whipping up frenzies and encouraging lynch mobs solves nothing, and it only makes the problem worse. If a paedophile knows that if he makes his problem public then he's going to be ostracised or worse, then he's better off keeping it a secret and letting it gnaw at him from the inside until one day he snaps with terrible consequences. We need to show them compassion and humanity, not seek to destroy them - it is not a conscious decision on a paedophile's part to become attracted to young children, they do not wake up one day and decide to find children arousing. Rather it would appear to be a mental problem, perhaps stemming from being abused as a child. It is not their fault, and we must acknowledge that.

I'm sorry mate, but the way I feel at the moment, my only response to your sickening hand-wringing liberal post can be f*** OFF YOU HEARTLESS c***! When I made my post I was talking from the heart, upset and low, the last thing I needed to read was that s***! So you go off and do your student stuff, smoke some dope, write some s*** meaningless poetry, feel really self-righteous and good about yourself, I'll go to bed and feel even more depressed and maybe I'll apologise for my crass post in the morning before I go to work, but then maybe I won't, you people grind me down and I'm tired, good night all!

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

the despotic banana Flag Dept. of Baboon Maintenance 11 Mar 04 11.25pm

Quote gambler at 11 Mar 2004 11:17pm

the despotic banana - i can't believe what i'm reading in your post. So you believe his story about drowning and suffocation do you?!

Weirder stuff has happened to me, although admittedly with less dire consequences as a result. But Huntley could have had an excellent explanation and you'd still hate him because you've presupposed him to be evil and guilty because you're revulsed by paedophiles.


 


Ask me about Ronald de Boer.

Bedge Flag Croydon 11 Mar 04 11.39pm

Quote Petealiator at 11 Mar 2004 10:47pm

The program tonight.

I don't know what to say. It had me in tears throughout much of it. It upset me immensely, I really shouldn't have watched it, but I knew I would have to. I'm left feeling so very hollow and defeated by the sickness of this vile filthy world of perverts and evil, but my absolute and total admiration of the Wells family gives me something positive to cling to. Something to continue to strive for. Wonderful, strong, good people. The unimportant ordinary backbone of this island.

But I'm left feeling that with the aid of well-meaning liberal ideals and human rights for all no matter what; evil is winning the battle.

Pete you just earnt maximum respect from me for that post of yours!

Ian Huntley does not deserve to be alive,he is a cruel,sick person and should not be allowed on this earth.

If there was one time where the Death Penalty should be imposed then this is it!


 


Extran Orange energy drink, Europe's number one hangover cure!

The Special One

gambler Flag Kent 11 Mar 04 11.39pm

Quote the despotic banana at 11 Mar 2004 11:25pm

But Huntley could have had an excellent explanation and you'd still hate him because you've presupposed him to be evil and guilty because you're revulsed by paedophiles.


Absolute rubbish.

You said in your original post that "The deaths of the two girls may have been a genuine accident, and without knowing what went on, we cannot judge Huntley and decide him to be evil on that basis."

But we can judge him, and thats exactly what the law of the land does - judge someone on the available evidence. He was found guilty after having a fair trial, because thats what we do.

And i never said he was evil. I said that i was unsure as to what punishment he should receive for the crimes that he undoubtedly did commit.


And i never said he was guilty just because i'm revulsed by paedophiles. The jury said he was guilty and quite frankly i can't understand how any right minded and normal person could not agree with that jury having heard the evidence.

 

the despotic banana Flag Dept. of Baboon Maintenance 11 Mar 04 11.49pm

Quote Petealiator at 11 Mar 2004 11:24pm
I'm sorry mate, but the way I feel at the moment, my only response to your sickening hand-wringing liberal post can be f*** OFF YOU HEARTLESS c***! When I made my post I was talking from the heart, upset and low, the last thing I needed to read was that s***! So you go off and do your student stuff, smoke some dope, write some s*** meaningless poetry, feel really self-righteous and good about yourself, I'll go to bed and feel even more depressed and maybe I'll apologise for my crass post in the morning before I go to work, but then maybe I won't, you people grind me down and I'm tired, good night all!

I'm sorry if you don't like what I said, and maybe I was being preachy and moralistic but that was just what I believe. I don't deny that the Soham murders were a terrible, terrible thing. I don't deny that any instance of child abuse, rape or murder is utterly unforgivable but I simply don't, can't, believe that the best way to react to these tragedies is with yet more hatred, bitterness and a desire to strike out with a thirst for vengeance. But it appears that you do, as do many others, and that saddens me. In the last few years my belief in humankind has been shaken - when I look around I see nothing but hatred and destruction everywhere. I'm sorry for not wanting to give in to that, it would probably be easier to after all, but I won't. And it's fine if you want to dismiss all this as the lefty liberal didactic ramblings of a smug little self-righteous pot-smoking student, in fact go right ahead. But it won't change what I believe. Yes, sh*tty things happen in this world, but if you're telling me that the best way to respond to them is with even more sh*t, then quite frankly you can f*ck right off. And now I'm going to go to bed and fell even more deoressed too.

 


Ask me about Ronald de Boer.

danpalace Flag 11 Mar 04 11.50pm

Quote the despotic banana at 11 Mar 2004 11:11pm

Secondly, this is a problem of our own making - if paedophiles weren't so reviled by society then they wouldn't turn to such desperate measures. Paedophiles need to be helped not loathed. Tabloid papers whipping up frenzies and encouraging lynch mobs solves nothing, and it only makes the problem worse. If a paedophile knows that if he makes his problem public then he's going to be ostracised or worse, then he's better off keeping it a secret and letting it gnaw at him from the inside until one day he snaps with terrible consequences. We need to show them compassion and humanity, not seek to destroy them - it is not a conscious decision on a paedophile's part to become attracted to young children, they do not wake up one day and decide to find children arousing. Rather it would appear to be a mental problem, perhaps stemming from being abused as a child. It is not their fault, and we must acknowledge that.


hmmm, maybe, but it is a conscious decision for a paedophile to rape and kill two young girls with their whole lives ahead of them, therefore, huntley the piece of nob cheese should be burnt alive

sorry but your talking alot of b*llocks mate

Edited by danpalace (11 Mar 2004 11:54pm)

 

the despotic banana Flag Dept. of Baboon Maintenance 11 Mar 04 11.56pm

Obviously if sex with women above the age of 16 was outlawed tomorrow you'd have the strength of mind to go your whole life without giving in to your sexual desires. And obviously you'd be able to cope with knowing that if anyone ever found out your secret you'd have a lynch mob round your house in seconds wanting to tear you limb from limb. You can't imagine what it must feel like to have that gnawing away inside you for years, and you can't imagine what lengths that would drive you to. Obviously I don't condone rape or murder but let's face it, society drives them to it.

Edited by the despotic banana (11 Mar 2004 11:57pm)

 


Ask me about Ronald de Boer.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 11 Mar 04 11.59pm

I didn't have the courage to watch the programme. I've got 2 teenage children and as a father, I don't know how I would cope in the Wells's situation.

Pete you summed it up. We reap what we sow ultimately...and we have sown people like Despotic Banana. The evidence against Huntley was overwhelming, there was no credibility in his defence, and yet we have someone on this site making a case for the man. Unbelievable.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

alexh_17 Flag The Site of The Worlds Biggest Pil... 12 Mar 04 12.02am

Quote gambler at 11 Mar 2004 11:39pm

Quote the despotic banana at 11 Mar 2004 11:25pm

But Huntley could have had an excellent explanation and you'd still hate him because you've presupposed him to be evil and guilty because you're revulsed by paedophiles.


Absolute rubbish.

You said in your original post that "The deaths of the two girls may have been a genuine accident, and without knowing what went on, we cannot judge Huntley and decide him to be evil on that basis."

But we can judge him, and thats exactly what the law of the land does - judge someone on the available evidence. He was found guilty after having a fair trial, because thats what we do.

And i never said he was evil. I said that i was unsure as to what punishment he should receive for the crimes that he undoubtedly did commit.


And i never said he was guilty just because i'm revulsed by paedophiles. The jury said he was guilty and quite frankly i can't understand how any right minded and normal person could not agree with that jury having heard the evidence.

I'm as liberal as the next man but this is exactly what I was going to say...once its been decided in Court at a fair trial (and there has been no appeal against this as such) then we can accept what was decided as fact. Yes not all trials get it right, but 99.9% do!

My personal view is that there is no crime worse than that of someone who rapes and kills a child. Having just had a week of lectures on sexual offences I am sick to the stomach with hearing case after case of vile rape. But most are against adults. I can't begin to contemplate this crime against a defenceless child.

If an act is something that a person cannot stop themselves from committing, then they have a mental disorder and should be committed to an asylum. BUT if someone has the forethought to plan and carry out such a vile act, there is no mental illness. This is not an irresistable impulse. They are as criminally liable as he who goes into a bank and puts a gun to the cashier's head. Call me evil, but let them rot.

 


Head Honcho of the CPFC Pillow Fighting Force

alexh_17 Flag The Site of The Worlds Biggest Pil... 12 Mar 04 12.05am

Quote the despotic banana at 11 Mar 2004 11:56pm

Obviously if sex with women above the age of 16 was outlawed tomorrow you'd have the strength of mind to go your whole life without giving in to your sexual desires. And obviously you'd be able to cope with knowing that if anyone ever found out your secret you'd have a lynch mob round your house in seconds wanting to tear you limb from limb. You can't imagine what it must feel like to have that gnawing away inside you for years, and you can't imagine what lengths that would drive you to. Obviously I don't condone rape or murder but let's face it, society drives them to it.

Edited by the despotic banana (11 Mar 2004 11:57pm)

Regardless of the age then...rape is rape, murder is murder.

 


Head Honcho of the CPFC Pillow Fighting Force

HorshamEagle Flag under the union jack 12 Mar 04 12.07am

Quote the despotic banana at 11 Mar 2004 11:56pm

Obviously if sex with women above the age of 16 was outlawed tomorrow you'd have the strength of mind to go your whole life without giving in to your sexual desires. And obviously you'd be able to cope with knowing that if anyone ever found out your secret you'd have a lynch mob round your house in seconds wanting to tear you limb from limb. You can't imagine what it must feel like to have that gnawing away inside you for years, and you can't imagine what lengths that would drive you to. Obviously I don't condone rape or murder but let's face it, society drives them to it.

Edited by the despotic banana (11 Mar 2004 11:57pm)

So we as a society drove Huntly to rape and murder? That is the biggest amount of bulls*** i have ever read on these boards. It is also incredibly insulting.

You argue that peadophillia is not a choice but that their urges drive them to such acts? Surely that lack of self restraint for something they know is wrong is why they are so loathed?

 


Do you know where hell is?

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 12 Mar 04 12.21am

It's a shame you didn't stick to your word and go to bed after your post before this one.I've never heard such rubbish. Please explain how you think that " society " drove Huntly and his like into doing what they did ? Are you saying that we are all collectively to blame ?? Well speak for yourself, I'm not accepting any responsibility for those sick deeds...although I assume you are ??

Quote the despotic banana at 11 Mar 2004 11:56pm

Obviously if sex with women above the age of 16 was outlawed tomorrow you'd have the strength of mind to go your whole life without giving in to your sexual desires. And obviously you'd be able to cope with knowing that if anyone ever found out your secret you'd have a lynch mob round your house in seconds wanting to tear you limb from limb. You can't imagine what it must feel like to have that gnawing away inside you for years, and you can't imagine what lengths that would drive you to. Obviously I don't condone rape or murder but let's face it, society drives them to it.

Edited by the despotic banana (11 Mar 2004 11:57pm)


 


Old, Ungifted and White

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 12 Mar 04 1.06am

Oh, my word.

It is simply not possible or appropriate to place any kind of blame on society for Huntley's actions. In fact, linking this crime to any perceived flaw in our society is completely and totally irrelevant. Leaving out the hysteria whipped up by the press over this case, Huntley's actions can only be interpreted as pure, unadulterated evil. It's really as simple as that. Throughout history, society has evolved what we might call 'norms' of behaviour and no civilisation has ever, ever accommodated either paedophilia or child murder. This has been the case the world over. Offences against children have always attracted greater disapproval, for a variety of reasons - the rape of innocence, the destruction of that society's future, the sheer defencelessness and blamelessness of the victim and so on. There can never, ever be any excuse within a sophisticated social system.

Society can, and to an extent does, take the blame for a variety of types of criminal behaviour - poverty, discrimination and exploitation are prime motives behind what we call 'crime'. But society can accept no responsibility for the actions of people like Huntley. His kind are an evil that lurks within our civilisation; there is no justification, no possible excuse that can be offered in mitigation of his actions, in much the same way that there can be no excuses for the Bradys, Hindleys, Wests and all the other monsters who exist completely outside the boundaries of acceptable behaviour. The penal and judicial systems are, as matters stand, utterly powerless to differentiate between degrees of seriousness - murder is murder, regardless of who the victim is or what the killer's motives were.

If 'society' has any responsibility at all, it is to create some kind of separate legal definition of crimes of the kind committed by Huntley so that a sentencing policy that reflects the universal disapproval of such action can be implemented. In this case, I have to conclude that death can be the only realistic option. This is not about retribution and rehabilitation, the twin pillars of the penal system; the Huntleys of this world fall entirely outside the scope of such principles. It is about satisfying society's demand for genuine justice, acknowledging the outrage that society feels and clinically removing from the face of the earth an influence which is inherently and unequivocally evil.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

the despotic banana Flag Dept. of Baboon Maintenance 12 Mar 04 1.06am

Quote NEILLO at 12 Mar 2004 12:21am

It's a shame you didn't stick to your word and go to bed after your post before this one.I've never heard such rubbish. Please explain how you think that " society " drove Huntly and his like into doing what they did ? Are you saying that we are all collectively to blame ?? Well speak for yourself, I'm not accepting any responsibility for those sick deeds...although I assume you are ??

Consider a society that is compassionate and humane. A society where tabloids don't propagate hate-mongering. A society where a paedophile can openly admit to suffering with a problem and seek help and support without fear of having some News Of The World-reading-lynch mob smashing down his door. Would this paedophile then be as likely to commit these horrendous crimes? Well maybe so, but as we don't live in a society where people are given a chance we will continue to force paedophiles underground. They will be left isolated and this can only serve to make the problem worse. It may comfort you to think of them as monsters but paedophiles are human, just like you and me. We are no better than them - I fully expect to be pilloried for saying that, but I think it's something some of you need to hear.


 


Ask me about Ronald de Boer.

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 12 Mar 04 1.28am

Quote the despotic banana at 12 Mar 2004 1:06am

Quote NEILLO at 12 Mar 2004 12:21am

It's a shame you didn't stick to your word and go to bed after your post before this one.I've never heard such rubbish. Please explain how you think that " society " drove Huntly and his like into doing what they did ? Are you saying that we are all collectively to blame ?? Well speak for yourself, I'm not accepting any responsibility for those sick deeds...although I assume you are ??

Consider a society that is compassionate and humane. A society where tabloids don't propagate hate-mongering. A society where a paedophile can openly admit to suffering with a problem and seek help and support without fear of having some News Of The World-reading-lynch mob smashing down his door. Would this paedophile then be as likely to commit these horrendous crimes? Well maybe so, but as we don't live in a society where people are given a chance we will continue to force paedophiles underground. They will be left isolated and this can only serve to make the problem worse. It may comfort you to think of them as monsters but paedophiles are human, just like you and me. We are no better than them - I fully expect to be pilloried for saying that, but I think it's something some of you need to hear.

I can see what you're getting at but paedophiles are as responsible as anyone else in controlling their urges. Just because someone may fancy blondes more than brunettes doesn't mean that he's going to abduct, torture and rape them. If someone feels that that is where his inclinations lie, then there is help available, be that via their GP or through the many, free confidential counselling services that are available. It is safe to classify Huntley and his type as evil because he knew that he had those urges - if he acknowledged them as being wrong, somewhere along the line conscience would have kicked in. But it didn't. He actively concealed his past brushes with the law for related offences, he showed utterly no remorse during the trial and even now he refuses to reveal what truly happened that day; anyone with a shred of humanity or decency would have at least done that, if only to put the girls' parents out of their misery. He's content to sentence them to a lifetime of anguish, knowing that they'll never know what really happened to their daughters. Why not acknowledge that evil exists instead of trying to find some justification for them, be it mental problems or some kind of flaw in society? This guy is a monster, pure and simple, and I think you're on very, very shaky ground if you suggest that we are no better than his kind; the overwhelming majority of us have an acute sense of right and wrong, something Huntley failed to demonstrate and continues to do so.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

the despotic banana Flag Dept. of Baboon Maintenance 12 Mar 04 1.51am

Quote Cucking Funt at 12 Mar 2004 1:28am

Quote the despotic banana at 12 Mar 2004 1:06am

Quote NEILLO at 12 Mar 2004 12:21am

It's a shame you didn't stick to your word and go to bed after your post before this one.I've never heard such rubbish. Please explain how you think that " society " drove Huntly and his like into doing what they did ? Are you saying that we are all collectively to blame ?? Well speak for yourself, I'm not accepting any responsibility for those sick deeds...although I assume you are ??

Consider a society that is compassionate and humane. A society where tabloids don't propagate hate-mongering. A society where a paedophile can openly admit to suffering with a problem and seek help and support without fear of having some News Of The World-reading-lynch mob smashing down his door. Would this paedophile then be as likely to commit these horrendous crimes? Well maybe so, but as we don't live in a society where people are given a chance we will continue to force paedophiles underground. They will be left isolated and this can only serve to make the problem worse. It may comfort you to think of them as monsters but paedophiles are human, just like you and me. We are no better than them - I fully expect to be pilloried for saying that, but I think it's something some of you need to hear.

I can see what you're getting at but paedophiles are as responsible as anyone else in controlling their urges. Just because someone may fancy blondes more than brunettes doesn't mean that he's going to abduct, torture and rape them. If someone feels that that is where his inclinations lie, then there is help available, be that via their GP or through the many, free confidential counselling services that are available. It is safe to classify Huntley and his type as evil because he knew that he had those urges - if he acknowledged them as being wrong, somewhere along the line conscience would have kicked in. But it didn't. He actively concealed his past brushes with the law for related offences, he showed utterly no remorse during the trial and even now he refuses to reveal what truly happened that day; anyone with a shred of humanity or decency would have at least done that, if only to put the girls' parents out of their misery. He's content to sentence them to a lifetime of anguish, knowing that they'll never know what really happened to their daughters. Why not acknowledge that evil exists instead of trying to find some justification for them, be it mental problems or some kind of flaw in society? This guy is a monster, pure and simple, and I think you're on very, very shaky ground if you suggest that we are no better than his kind; the overwhelming majority of us have an acute sense of right and wrong, something Huntley failed to demonstrate and continues to do so.

1. Being attracted to blondes isn't a criminal offence though.
2. If Huntley did intentionally kill the girls then yes, his continued refusal to reveal what actually happened to the girl's families is utterly heartless. But if his testimony was the truth then what more has he to say?
3. I acknowledge that evil exists and I'm not trying to justify it, but I believe that those who seek to punish evil with such fervent blood-lust, either through vigilante action or by calling for capital punishment are themselves no better than the evil they so loathe.
4. We are no better than 'his kind' as you put it. We all are, after all, human and therefore it could have just as likely have been one of us in his position. And if we consider that then maybe we won't be so quick to bay for blood next time.

 


Ask me about Ronald de Boer.

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Our Daughter Holly