You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tax rises needed 'to prevent NHS misery'
November 21 2026 10.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tax rises needed 'to prevent NHS misery'


Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
europalace Flag Europe 24 May 18 6.06am

"it would require rises of 3p in the pound on each of income tax, VAT and National Insurance by 2033."

[Link]

 

7mins Flag In the bush 24 May 18 7.05am

NHS saved my Nan’s life. Whatever they want from me, they can have.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 May 18 7.47am

I'd be more sympathetic if they didn't waste so much money. I also resent paying out to fund care for the 250k new arrivals every year who have contributed next to nothing and keep on coming year after year.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 24 May 18 8.09am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I'd be more sympathetic if they didn't waste so much money. I also resent paying out to fund care for the 250k new arrivals every year who have contributed next to nothing and keep on coming year after year.

Agreed. Heard a doctor on LBC who said the costs around health tourists is vastly underestimated. He say he has been campaigning for 5 years but NHS management don't care.

On a previous show I heard a doctors receptionist complain that many people were wrongly listed as UK citizens and that it was nudge nudge wink wink. You do wonder if we had id cards how many people would disappear from the lists.

I went to Moorfields recently as a walk in. I first had to prove I was eligible for free treatment this took about 2 mins it was no big deal and it wasn't done by doctors or nurses but by admin staff.

Cameron had the right idea but it was never passed. Anyone coming to this country cannot claim benefits until they have paid taxes for for so many years (I would say 5 ). This would not apply to genuine refugees.

Do all this and I will support more taxes.

Oh I forgot to mention before we cut up taxes cancel HS2 and reduce the foreign aid budget that should give the NHS a bit more.

Edited by Badger11 (24 May 2018 8.28am)

 


One more point

.TUX. Flag 24 May 18 8.27am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I'd be more sympathetic if they didn't waste so much money. I also resent paying out to fund care for the 250k new arrivals every year who have contributed next to nothing and keep on coming year after year.

#2 Agreed.

 


Buy Litecoin.

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 24 May 18 8.52am

Although there are 120 thousand non-British citizens working in the NHS...

The people 'contributing next to nothing' are the elderly, whose number is also going up year on year and who are in most need of medical support and social care. How are we supposed to solve that crisis without turning to migration?

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 24 May 18 8.52am

Originally posted by Badger11

Agreed. Heard a doctor on LBC who said the costs around health tourists is vastly underestimated. He say he has been campaigning for 5 years but NHS management don't care.

On a previous show I heard a doctors receptionist complain that many people were wrongly listed as UK citizens and that it was nudge nudge wink wink. You do wonder if we had id cards how many people would disappear from the lists.

I went to Moorfields recently as a walk in. I first had to prove I was eligible for free treatment this took about 2 mins it was no big deal and it wasn't done by doctors or nurses but by admin staff.

Cameron had the right idea but it was never passed. Anyone coming to this country cannot claim benefits until they have paid taxes for for so many years (I would say 5 ). This would not apply to genuine refugees.

Do all this and I will support more taxes.

Oh I forgot to mention before we cut up taxes cancel HS2 and reduce the foreign aid budget that should give the NHS a bit more.

Edited by Badger11 (24 May 2018 8.28am)

We can’t do that. It’s racist or xenophobic, despite most of the world operating that way.

The increases needed or treatment to be dropped are no surprise.

We could start charging a few people for prescriptions, appointments, missing appointments.

 


COYP

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 24 May 18 9.03am

Originally posted by serial thriller

Although there are 120 thousand non-British citizens working in the NHS...

The people 'contributing next to nothing' are the elderly, whose number is also going up year on year and who are in most need of medical support and social care. How are we supposed to solve that crisis without turning to migration?


Yea,them old people who have paid in all their working lives and now receiving...bunch of old cnuts taking out now but not putting in anymore.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 24 May 18 9.07am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I'd be more sympathetic if they didn't waste so much money. I also resent paying out to fund care for the 250k new arrivals every year who have contributed next to nothing and keep on coming year after year.

Evidence doesn't support either of your claims.

All evidence shows immigrants pay more in than they take out and are less likely to claim benefits or healthcare than people from the UK. They also provide a significant proportion of the NHS staff (my wife is French and is a doctor at Great Ormond Street Hospital dealing with children with traumatic brain injuries and othe neurological conditions such as brain cancer as an example).

The NHS also "wastes" vastly less than they do in the US, and other systems which use insurance and require inordinate amounts spent on administration. The NHS has also managed to increase productivity by c1.2% pa, in line with it's long term trend, since the GFC, something the wider economy has failed to do. This is in spite of cuts to services and cuts to per patient budgets and investment in services.

[Link]

I'd suggest you think before you spout bigotry next time.

 

.TUX. Flag 24 May 18 9.08am

Originally posted by serial thriller

Although there are 120 thousand non-British citizens working in the NHS...

The people 'contributing next to nothing' are the elderly, whose number is also going up year on year and who are in most need of medical support and social care. How are we supposed to solve that crisis without turning to migration?

Necessary migration is one thing, opening the floodgates to every Tom, Dick and Harry is on a different level.

 


Buy Litecoin.

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 24 May 18 9.08am

Originally posted by europalace

"it would require rises of 3p in the pound on each of income tax, VAT and National Insurance by 2033."

[Link]

Labour's extra 5p on high earners doesn't look quite so "outrageous" all of a sudden.

The Tories would get this money from cutting elsewhere and disproportionately taxing the poor.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 24 May 18 9.09am

Originally posted by .TUX.

Necessary migration is one thing, opening the floodgates to every Tom, Dick and Harry is on a different level.

You don't understand the current system. In fairness few do.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 24 May 18 9.13am

Originally posted by aquickgame2


Yea,them old people who have paid in all their working lives and now receiving...bunch of old cnuts taking out now but not putting in anymore.


Are you suggesting younger people aren't paying in and will not do so all their working lives? For what return?

The baby boomers have benefited from innumerable things no longer available to younger generations, wealth (largely held by older people) has continued to grow apace, yet incomes (largely earned by the younger) stagnate. Evidence shows that the baby boomers spent more relative to older generations than the young do now, yet the young are still relatively poorer and cost of living, especially housing, significantly higher.

Having paid in is not an argument as everyone will do so, it's just a matter of timing. You can't use that as an excuse to pillage from future generations. The elderly don't have some sort of divine right to resources without the responsibility of replacing them.

 

.TUX. Flag 24 May 18 9.17am

Originally posted by aquickgame2


Yea,them old people who have paid in all their working lives and now receiving...bunch of old cnuts taking out now but not putting in anymore.

I'm sure the majority have paid in for many many years but due to inflation (1300% since the 70's) they've not put anywhere near enough to cover their costs in later life though.
It's not their fault as they've 'done as they were told', the blame lies with every single govt for decades now.

This problem will never go away.

 


Buy Litecoin.

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 24 May 18 9.20am

Originally posted by .TUX.

I'm sure the majority have paid in for many many years but due to inflation (1300% since the 70's) they've not put anywhere near enough to cover their costs in later life though.
It's not their fault as they've 'done as they were told', the blame lies with every single govt for decades now.

This problem will never go away.

This is true. The problem is that the older generations seem to feel that, despite having accrued massive benefits from these awful policies, they should bear none of the cost now in rectifying the damage.

 

.TUX. Flag 24 May 18 9.31am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Evidence doesn't support either of your claims.

All evidence shows immigrants pay more in than they take out and are less likely to claim benefits or healthcare than people from the UK. They also provide a significant proportion of the NHS staff (my wife is French and is a doctor at Great Ormond Street Hospital dealing with children with traumatic brain injuries and othe neurological conditions such as brain cancer as an example).

The NHS also "wastes" vastly less than they do in the US, and other systems which use insurance and require inordinate amounts spent on administration. The NHS has also managed to increase productivity by c1.2% pa, in line with it's long term trend, since the GFC, something the wider economy has failed to do. This is in spite of cuts to services and cuts to per patient budgets and investment in services.

[Link]

I'd suggest you think before you spout bigotry next time.

Having spent the majority of April last year in hospital visiting the father-in-law (sadly passed) then i'd say 'foreigners' are certainly getting their monies worth regarding health treatment. The place was packed with all sorts of languages, English being around 20% from what i remember.
Having spent many days in the past 2wks visiting aunty Betty (broken hip and now back home) i'd say nothing's changed.
From schooling, infrastructure and medical needs, migration as a whole has cost us dearly. Whatever they may have paid in doesn't come close to covering the real costs.


Edited by .TUX. (24 May 2018 9.37am)

 


Buy Litecoin.

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 24 May 18 9.32am

They ( the different governments ) took out as much as they wanted during my working life,I had no choice as to what they wanted,where they allocated it.

Now its my time to take as much as I can out of it..selfish,you bet I am.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 24 May 18 9.57am

Originally posted by aquickgame2

They ( the different governments ) took out as much as they wanted during my working life,I had no choice as to what they wanted,where they allocated it.

Now its my time to take as much as I can out of it..selfish,you bet I am.

The government is of the people. Their bungling benefited their own generation at the expense of their children and grandchildren. They aren't some sort of aliens who aren't themselves part of society. If they damage the country while benefiting themselves and their peers (who voted for them) it seems right that once this becomes apparent they should be responsible for repairing the damage.

The Tories won't touch them though as they are their base. With the Tories in power the workers will not get a fair crack of the whip and will continue to see their wealth diminish relative to their parents and grandparents, who use age as an excuse to avoid any rightful liabilities.

We're having to work now to plug the gaps in pension funds which we don't benefit from! They are all closed. We now have to work for our own pensions as well. So we're paying double to receive half.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 May 18 10.25am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Evidence doesn't support either of your claims.

All evidence shows immigrants pay more in than they take out and are less likely to claim benefits or healthcare than people from the UK. They also provide a significant proportion of the NHS staff (my wife is French and is a doctor at Great Ormond Street Hospital dealing with children with traumatic brain injuries and othe neurological conditions such as brain cancer as an example).

The NHS also "wastes" vastly less than they do in the US, and other systems which use insurance and require inordinate amounts spent on administration. The NHS has also managed to increase productivity by c1.2% pa, in line with it's long term trend, since the GFC, something the wider economy has failed to do. This is in spite of cuts to services and cuts to per patient budgets and investment in services.

[Link]

I'd suggest you think before you spout bigotry next time.

How can you have contributed when you have just arrived?
If immigration is the answer, then why does the NHS appear to be in deeper trouble every year? Or is that just Labour scaremongering around election time? Which way do you want it?

Hospitals are full of foreign workers because they can often earn more here than in their own countries where as many British workers were never offered enough pay or encouraged into training. More short sighted government policy.
Despite the good work done in hospitals, my experience is that the services provided are often of an abysmal standard. If you are old, you are more likely to die in hospital than out and not necessarily from what you went in with.
Too many people and expanding expectations that can never be met. Any amount of tax will never be enough because it will always be spent.

And I suggest that anyone calling someone a bigot while hiding being their laptop is a cowardly t***.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (24 May 2018 10.33am)

 

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 24 May 18 10.29am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

The government is of the people. Their bungling benefited their own generation at the expense of their children and grandchildren. They aren't some sort of aliens who aren't themselves part of society. If they damage the country while benefiting themselves and their peers (who voted for them) it seems right that once this becomes apparent they should be responsible for repairing the damage.

The Tories won't touch them though as they are their base. With the Tories in power the workers will not get a fair crack of the whip and will continue to see their wealth diminish relative to their parents and grandparents, who use age as an excuse to avoid any rightful liabilities.

We're having to work now to plug the gaps in pension funds which we don't benefit from! They are all closed. We now have to work for our own pensions as well. So we're paying double to receive half.

You and you.........I'm gonna milk it as much as I can,it's lovely being a selfish retired old fart.

 

Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tax rises needed 'to prevent NHS misery'