You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Is the Devil good, and God evil?
November 21 2026 10.42pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is the Devil good, and God evil?


Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Park Road Flag 14 Jun 18 8.00am

What if God was actually the evil one and Satan was in fact good? After all, God is responsible for billions upon billions deaths, while Satan is responsible for only 10, all of which God commanded of him. If something bad happens like an earthquake or a Tsunami, we tend to call it 'an act of god' not an 'act of the devil'. Why?

It beggars my belief that millions of 'believers' claim that god is good, when the 'evidence' from his alleged behaviours and teachings is so comprehensively the opposite. Throughout the bible there are numerous accounts of god dishing out divine punishment by way of genocide, plagues, ethnic cleansing, and the like. If the bible were the word of god, then god supports infanticide, slavery, torture genocide and all manner of death destruction and suffering. I do not know of any mention of the devil being blamed for such things.
God is clearly a tyrant. He has committed many acts of evil, and somehow managed to amass an incredible following. That means God must be the ultimate deceiver. He has painted Satan as the deceiver to disguise his own faults and gain worshipers in a classic manner. 

Satan is the only deity who truly stands for free will. God threatens us with punishments for not adhering to his wishes. But Satan tells us that we should enjoy our lives and be happy and free to do what we think is right.

 

DanH Flag SW2 14 Jun 18 8.03am

Always knew you lot rooted for the villain in Disney films when you were kids.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 Jun 18 8.06am

I don't believe in god or the devil. I do believe in good and evil. When I was at school we read John MIlton's Paradise Lost. It is a poem in which the devil persuasively argues that he is the victim (must be a scouser) and that he was hard done by god for simply exercising his free will.

The devil's argument follows closely to the ideas in your post. However those who are religious would point out that Milton is actually saying that the devil is a liar, an attractive and plausible one as the best liars are.

 


One more point

Park Road Flag 14 Jun 18 8.38am

Originally posted by DanH

Always knew you lot rooted for the villain in Disney films when you were kids.

Us lot???
mmmmmwwwwahahahahahaha!

 

Park Road Flag 14 Jun 18 8.43am

Originally posted by Badger11

I don't believe in god or the devil. I do believe in good and evil. When I was at school we read John MIlton's Paradise Lost. It is a poem in which the devil persuasively argues that he is the victim (must be a scouser) and that he was hard done by god for simply exercising his free will.

The devil's argument follows closely to the ideas in your post. However those who are religious would point out that Milton is actually saying that the devil is a liar, an attractive and plausible one as the best liars are.

The whole poem really has to be a justification (successful or not) of God's ways. But is it? Is Milton really putting himself where he can vindicate God's perspective on things?
Or, is it just one of the first examples of "Fake news"?

 

Cannonball Flag High in the Ozarks. 14 Jun 18 9.32am

Originally posted by Park Road

What if God was actually the evil one and Satan was in fact good? After all, God is responsible for billions upon billions deaths, while Satan is responsible for only 10, all of which God commanded of him. If something bad happens like an earthquake or a Tsunami, we tend to call it 'an act of god' not an 'act of the devil'. Why?

It beggars my belief that millions of 'believers' claim that god is good, when the 'evidence' from his alleged behaviours and teachings is so comprehensively the opposite. Throughout the bible there are numerous accounts of god dishing out divine punishment by way of genocide, plagues, ethnic cleansing, and the like. If the bible were the word of god, then god supports infanticide, slavery, torture genocide and all manner of death destruction and suffering. I do not know of any mention of the devil being blamed for such things.
God is clearly a tyrant. He has committed many acts of evil, and somehow managed to amass an incredible following. That means God must be the ultimate deceiver. He has painted Satan as the deceiver to disguise his own faults and gain worshipers in a classic manner. 

Satan is the only deity who truly stands for free will. God threatens us with punishments for not adhering to his wishes. But Satan tells us that we should enjoy our lives and be happy and free to do what we think is right.

Excellent post. I have always thought that was the case since I was a kid and had to read the Bible.Two stories stuck in my mind about just how nasty God was.
First When the people of Sodom knocked on Lot's door to see his visitors (angels) he said they could have his little daughters to rape if they would go and leave his visitors in peace.
Secondly. When some kids made fun of Elijah,God sent a bear to devour them.Doesnt sound like a good and just God to me.

 


Touch my coffee and I will slap you so hard even Google won't be able to find you.

YT Flag Oxford 14 Jun 18 10.01am

Originally posted by Cannonball

Excellent post. I have always thought that was the case since I was a kid and had to read the Bible.Two stories stuck in my mind about just how nasty God was.
First When the people of Sodom knocked on Lot's door to see his visitors (angels) he said they could have his little daughters to rape if they would go and leave his visitors in peace.
Secondly. When some kids made fun of Elijah,God sent a bear to devour them.Doesnt sound like a good and just God to me.

Yeah but I think ‘God Lite’ later on in the Bible (New Testament) was a bit more touchy-feely.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

DanH Flag SW2 14 Jun 18 10.14am

It’s all just a load of bollocks really, isn’t it?

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 14 Jun 18 10.16am

All you heretics, apostates and blasphemers are going to burn in hell.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 Jun 18 10.21am

Originally posted by YT

Yeah but I think ‘God Lite’ later on in the Bible (New Testament) was a bit more touchy-feely.

The old testament is all about people begetting and smiting. So nothing's really changed then? Seems like the human race never learns.

 


One more point

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 14 Jun 18 10.56am

Why do we exist?

Keep asking yourself the same question and you will eventually find the answer?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Jun 18 11.20am

It might have started with unstable people desperate to believe in something but it grew because It's all just a means of control.....jobs for clerics.

It's why religions have sprang up thousands of times in numerous places all throughout history.

Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jun 2018 11.22am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Jun 18 11.26am

Originally posted by YT

Yeah but I think ‘God Lite’ later on in the Bible (New Testament) was a bit more touchy-feely.

Is that why the Catholic Church have got into so much trouble?

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Park Road Flag 14 Jun 18 11.45am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Is that why the Catholic Church have got into so much trouble?

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 14 Jun 18 11.57am

An act of god forced my flight to be delayed so he can feck right off.

Devil.png Attachment: Devil.png (76.91Kb)

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Harpo Flag Oxfordshire 14 Jun 18 12.00pm

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

Why do we exist?

It's the most successful strategy to keep meat fresh.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 14 Jun 18 12.01pm

I assume/hope that the OP is discussing this as you would characters in a novel. There is obviously no God or Devil in the Biblical sense.
Both characters have evolved over many generations and became fixed, I suppose, at the point that the masses had access to books.
Since both are figments of imagination, they both represent aspects of human the psyche.

 

Park Road Flag 14 Jun 18 12.50pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I assume/hope that the OP is discussing this as you would characters in a novel. There is obviously no God or Devil in the Biblical sense.
Both characters have evolved over many generations and became fixed, I suppose, at the point that the masses had access to books.
Since both are figments of imagination, they both represent aspects of human the psyche.

No need to hope. Your assumption is correct.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 Jun 18 5.41pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I assume/hope that the OP is discussing this as you would characters in a novel. There is obviously no God or Devil in the Biblical sense.
Both characters have evolved over many generations and became fixed, I suppose, at the point that the masses had access to books.
Since both are figments of imagination, they both represent aspects of human the psyche.

So on that statement are all religious books a load of physiological bull crap including the Jewish one the Muslim one the Indian one.
Don't know the names apart from one but I won't name it for obvious reasons.

 

Park Road Flag 14 Jun 18 5.50pm

Originally posted by cryrst



So on that statement are all religious books a load of physiological bull crap including the Jewish one the Muslim one the Indian one.

Don't know the names apart from one but I won't name it for obvious reasons.

To be blunt yes. Each religion has its own doctrine and good and bad messages.
Equally, so do the fairy tales of The brothers Grimm.

 

Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Is the Devil good, and God evil?