You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mismanagement
November 16 2026 4.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mismanagement


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Swindy Flag Bromley 26 Jun 21 5.49pm

Having followed the club for the best part of 50 years, every time that relegation from the top flight has happened in all that time (probably barring 1992-93), it has carried a certain inevitability.
There is a lot to be pleased about from the Parish years. Salvation, the longest top-flight stay, significant strides last season taken by the academy, though a successful academy is more of an asset outside the Premiership.
However, the finger of blame for the current squad situation and the seemingly unending and embarassing manager searches etc stands firmly at Mr P's door. Whether it came as a surprise that Roy was leaving at the end of the season or not (and great job that he did on keeping the club up with limited resources, he was not the future), clearly no succession planning was done.
Then there is the ludicrous situation that there are so many players out of contract at the end of this month - I mean, who knew ???
Further, apparently the players concerned were told that they'd have to wait till a new manager is appointed before anything gets resolved. Now clearly, Palace won't want to keep them all but it surely unnecessarily encourages other clubs and certainly diminishes any remaining likelihood of Wilf being persuaded to stay.
In these years in the Premiership this club has made more money than EVER before, yet do any of the fans really feel that at the start of the season we are any more established ?? (and I do accept that we have no divine right to stay up) or does it feel that we are still little more than a newly-promoted club with a number of games written off ??
Apparently 1 reason why Nuno & Favre said no was the likely size of the 'war chest' for the new season - perhaps there would be more if Mr Parish had not spent shedloads on professional crocks Sakho, Wickham and Fergusson etc. The Wan-Bissaka money went towards to balancing the books.
It is not his fault, but why do we seem to get so many more injuries than other top-flight clubs each season ?
I do not yearn for movement to the mythical 'next level', but it would be good if it felt that the club was progressing in a calm, businesslike way and even had a cup run again next season, instead of playing out as being a media soap opera.
The quality in the Premiership reduces every year so there is a chance, even starting from this point of unattractiveness to a prospective new manager, that things might not be as bad as many fear next season, but Mr Parish needs to sort it out very quickly or it will be pre-season training with Messrs Derry, Mccarthy and Kiely and extremely frantic attempts in the transfer market.

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 26 Jun 21 5.56pm

Eminently reasonable, but beware the Two Selhurst Commandments:

1. Thou shalt not think ill of Roy Hodgson.
2. Thou shalt not think ill of Steve Parish.

 

deleted 25 Flag 26 Jun 21 6.06pm

Parish and co have done a lot of great things for the club.

Choosing managers has long been the Achilles heal for the board.

Same scenario happened with appointment of FdB.

Basically we seem to be going for Cooper because nobody else wants to come and a lack of vision for what we want

We are not alone, Clubs bigger than us like Spurs also Wing it.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 26 Jun 21 7.18pm

We are in a sorry state at present and I don't blame prospective managers walking away from taking on the job. Nobody wants a relegation on their CV, and even a top coach may find the job of keeping us up next season beyond them, if transfer funds are limited.

Whilst I agree with most points made by the OP I would question how much succession planning can be done. Unless you are one of the big clubs I'm not sure how likely it is that you can get a quality coach to commit themselves to you in advance. Is a prospective manager really going to prematurely close down all other options for a job at Palace? Ultimately I believe we are hostage to whoever is available when the role becomes vacant.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 26 Jun 21 7.25pm

Didn’t even bother reading. Sick of the moaning and abuse hurled at club heroes who are doing their best.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 26 Jun 21 7.52pm

Originally posted by Pete53

I don't blame prospective managers walking away from taking on the job.

I don't blame them either unless they've spent three days interviewing, have agreed a contract on the basis of which they've asked for a work permit, and they've verbally indicated they're going to accept the job. Then, I blame them.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

becky Flag over the moon 26 Jun 21 8.26pm

Originally posted by Pete53

We are in a sorry state at present and I don't blame prospective managers walking away from taking on the job. Nobody wants a relegation on their CV, and even a top coach may find the job of keeping us up next season beyond them, if transfer funds are limited.

Whilst I agree with most points made by the OP I would question how much succession planning can be done. Unless you are one of the big clubs I'm not sure how likely it is that you can get a quality coach to commit themselves to you in advance. Is a prospective manager really going to prematurely close down all other options for a job at Palace? Ultimately I believe we are hostage to whoever is available when the role becomes vacant.

Sense: a rare commodity on here sometimes...

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 26 Jun 21 8.50pm

i dont think you can claim mismanagement.

none of the other PL teams, who work on a different level to us have appointed managers, and its not like we havnt tried to get somebody in.

its very easy to point the finger & shout from a pedestal about this, that & whatever but you need to be realistic.

the only criticism i would have right now
is that andros/cahill/ward/clyne (if fit) need signing up before they go elsewhere.

other than that, yes i would have liked a manager in place by now, but its not a simple process.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 26 Jun 21 9.34pm

OK I get that there are other clubs who like us are looking for managers. That does make our quest harder as those clubs (Everton and Spurs) are financially better placed than us.

But what does seem an issue is the sheer number of what have been key players who have been allowed to run down their contracts and who can leave for nothing. OK Wickham is a load off the wage bill but others are key players.

These players will not want the uncertainty of no manager and will now also want a nice signing on fee to re sign. That is poor management.

I also would guess that whilst we do need to rebuild, there is little actual money to do it.

All the signs in recent transfer activity are of a club that is simply skint.

Running any business should involve a bit of forward planning and future forecasting. From where I stand that may be an issue.

But there are others I know who do believe Mr Parish can do no wrong. But equally they also probably believe Simon Jordan was an ace business man and bought back Selhurst Park.

 

CT Charlie Flag 26 Jun 21 10.51pm

Certainly we're in a discouraging, possibly even dire, situation, but let's be reasonable, shall we?

1) Despite the passionate fan base, ours is not a club that would appeal to a top-level manager or one who aspires to be. Because of the aging squad, uncertain contract situations, and lack of funds, relegation is a real possibility regardless of the talent of the manager.

2) The uncertain contract situations are part of a Catch-22. Palace don't want to commit to players (nor they to us) until we find a new manager, but the new manager would not want to commit to Palace without knowing the core of the roster.

3) Who could have foreseen that both Spurs and Everton would be searching for managers when we were? And both are far more attractive, stable positions.

4) The pandemic has complicated the search for new players and a manager in unprecedented fashion. In normal times, it would have been far easier for S.P. to look for the right person. Furthermore, many foreign candidates may be more reluctant to even consider the Palace job - would they want to move to England under these circumstances?

I'm not especially optimistic, and I acknowledge that the responsibility falls in the lap of Steve Parish. But it's only fair to acknowledge there's a perfect storm of circumstances that make the process almost impossible to have been done swiftly or well.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 27 Jun 21 12.18am

Does it not make sense then to have a safe pair of hands in for now, start a properly planned and structured recruitment exercise and find a manger who is willing to take the job and then hopefully bring him in mid season for a smooth handover for the 22/23 season.

Of course we could have done that.........

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 27 Jun 21 12.27am

Originally posted by Swindy

Having followed the club for the best part of 50 years, every time that relegation from the top flight has happened in all that time (probably barring 1992-93), it has carried a certain inevitability.
There is a lot to be pleased about from the Parish years. Salvation, the longest top-flight stay, significant strides last season taken by the academy, though a successful academy is more of an asset outside the Premiership.
However, the finger of blame for the current squad situation and the seemingly unending and embarassing manager searches etc stands firmly at Mr P's door. Whether it came as a surprise that Roy was leaving at the end of the season or not (and great job that he did on keeping the club up with limited resources, he was not the future), clearly no succession planning was done.
Then there is the ludicrous situation that there are so many players out of contract at the end of this month - I mean, who knew ???
Further, apparently the players concerned were told that they'd have to wait till a new manager is appointed before anything gets resolved. Now clearly, Palace won't want to keep them all but it surely unnecessarily encourages other clubs and certainly diminishes any remaining likelihood of Wilf being persuaded to stay.
In these years in the Premiership this club has made more money than EVER before, yet do any of the fans really feel that at the start of the season we are any more established ?? (and I do accept that we have no divine right to stay up) or does it feel that we are still little more than a newly-promoted club with a number of games written off ??
Apparently 1 reason why Nuno & Favre said no was the likely size of the 'war chest' for the new season - perhaps there would be more if Mr Parish had not spent shedloads on professional crocks Sakho, Wickham and Fergusson etc. The Wan-Bissaka money went towards to balancing the books.
It is not his fault, but why do we seem to get so many more injuries than other top-flight clubs each season ?
I do not yearn for movement to the mythical 'next level', but it would be good if it felt that the club was progressing in a calm, businesslike way and even had a cup run again next season, instead of playing out as being a media soap opera.
The quality in the Premiership reduces every year so there is a chance, even starting from this point of unattractiveness to a prospective new manager, that things might not be as bad as many fear next season, but Mr Parish needs to sort it out very quickly or it will be pre-season training with Messrs Derry, Mccarthy and Kiely and extremely frantic attempts in the transfer market.

Every other team in the Premier League has made a lot of money as well and the technical ability in terms of playing and coaching is eons better than when we were promoted eight years ago.

I think the situation is a mess but we've (comparatively) run out of money like Stoke and West Brom did.


Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (27 Jun 2021 12.31am)

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 27 Jun 21 5.44am

Originally posted by sprites

Didn’t even bother reading. Sick of the moaning and abuse hurled at club heroes who are doing their best.

You are amusing.

So you think it’s ok to be a week away from preseason, having had months to sort this out, and have no manager? During a period of massive squad upheaval no less.

If this Parish’s “best” I would hate to see his worst.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Midlands Eagle Flag 27 Jun 21 6.34am

Originally posted by sydtheeagle


I don't blame them either unless they've spent three days interviewing, have agreed a contract on the basis of which they've asked for a work permit, and they've verbally indicated they're going to accept the job. Then, I blame them.

The trouble with that is that we've only heard one side of the story. Maybe Nuno's and Favre's side of the story might not be quite the same

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 27 Jun 21 7.27am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The trouble with that is that we've only heard one side of the story. Maybe Nuno's and Favre's side of the story might not be quite the same

I think Palace’s version relating to Nuno is possibly near the truth, as similar happened at Everton. However, I cannot believe the Favre reasoning. If he wanted a longer break, he would not have even spoken to the Club. There was something that arose, late on, that had not been divulged before, actual transfer funds? Transfer targets? Dougie’s role? I doubt we will ever know
In a bizarre way I hoped he pitched up at another club, Everton or Spurs. At least then it could not be attributed to a problem at Palace, unfortunately there obviously is a problem

Edited by Spiderman (27 Jun 2021 7.29am)

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 27 Jun 21 7.34am

I wonder how the Eddie Howe version of the discussions with Parish mentioned in the WED documentary would compare with the Parish version.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 27 Jun 21 7.45am

I cannot understand why anyone thinks its a bad thing that the contract situation is bad, its 11 players,
Sakho, Batshuayi ,Clyne, Dann, Wickham, PVA, McCarthy, Ward, Hennessey, Townsend And Cahill,
Only the last too might be worth keeping
The other players are finished anyway, The saving on wages is 700k a week, 37million a year,
There is some very good young players knocking on the door, Partially in my view Rich-Baghuelou, Rak-Sakyi and Hannam,
3 loan stops are available, CD, RB, AM,
All is not Awful, if it is Cooper (who wouldn't be my Choice) he must be backed 100% by Players, Staff, and fans until he has been given a fair chance

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

sprites Flag Auckland 27 Jun 21 7.46am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

You are amusing.

So you think it’s ok to be a week away from preseason, having had months to sort this out, and have no manager? During a period of massive squad upheaval no less.

If this Parish’s “best” I would hate to see his worst.

I don’t think it’s ideal, but I also don’t think it’s as black and white as Parish is a failure etc. Sounds like he’s been hard done by twice...not much he can do about ridiculous demands on Nuno’s part of personal decisions on Favre’s.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 27 Jun 21 7.52am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

OK I get that there are other clubs who like us are looking for managers. That does make our quest harder as those clubs (Everton and Spurs) are financially better placed than us.

But what does seem an issue is the sheer number of what have been key players who have been allowed to run down their contracts and who can leave for nothing. OK Wickham is a load off the wage bill but others are key players.

These players will not want the uncertainty of no manager and will now also want a nice signing on fee to re sign. That is poor management.

I also would guess that whilst we do need to rebuild, there is little actual money to do it.

All the signs in recent transfer activity are of a club that is simply skint.

Running any business should involve a bit of forward planning and future forecasting. From where I stand that may be an issue.

But there are others I know who do believe Mr Parish can do no wrong. But equally they also probably believe Simon Jordan was an ace business man and bought back Selhurst Park.

All of whom are over 30 years old!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 27 Jun 21 7.53am

Originally posted by sprites

I don’t think it’s ideal, but I also don’t think it’s as black and white as Parish is a failure etc. Sounds like he’s been hard done by twice...not much he can do about ridiculous demands on Nuno’s part of personal decisions on Favre’s.

I think it is a useful exercise to look at the previous managers experiences and how things ended up.
It seems to me that Parish is very much part of the problem.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mismanagement