You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Post EU World
November 22 2026 1.34am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Post EU World


Page 108 of 156 < 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 >
Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 22 Feb 23 12.55am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

The way I see it is, if making all our own laws and striking out on our own works for us long term, great. Let's give it a go.

If it doesn't, we should be able to admit as much and think about what that means.

If the choice becomes make all our own laws but be significantly worse off vs. make most of our own laws and allow some concessions and be significantly better off, logically there's only one choice there.

Are you able to agree on that or would you prepared to cut your nose off to spite your own face / die on the hill of ideology by sticking with the former scenario, discarding all logic and reason?

Edited by SW19 CPFC (21 Feb 2023 10.58pm)

What do you mean by "significantly worse off vs." ...."significantly better off" exactly? How would this be measured?

Also, if it works, would you be able to agree on that or would you (be) prepared to cut your nose off to spite your own face / die on the hill of ideology by sticking with the latter scenario, discarding all logic and reason?

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 22 Feb 23 7.14am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

The way I see it is, if making all our own laws and striking out on our own works for us long term, great. Let's give it a go.

If it doesn't, we should be able to admit as much and think about what that means.

If the choice becomes make all our own laws but be significantly worse off vs. make most of our own laws and allow some concessions and be significantly better off, logically there's only one choice there.

Are you able to agree on that or would you prepared to cut your nose off to spite your own face / die on the hill of ideology by sticking with the former scenario, discarding all logic and reason?

Edited by SW19 CPFC (21 Feb 2023 10.58pm)

Who are more likely to make laws that are in the interests of our own country - elected British governments or non-elected people from 26 other countries?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 22 Feb 23 7.33am

Originally posted by HKOwen

MEPs have the power to approve, amend or reject nearly all EU legislation. They hold the European Commission to account and can force it to resign. The European Parliament also decides on the EU budget and influences how EU money is spent.

This is the fact

They are selective facts that do not give the whole picture. From the EU’s own website:
The EU ‘parliament’ can debate legislation. It can pass or reject laws, and it can also make amendments, but not in all cases. If the law is about EU budgets, the 'parliament' can only advise on it – it does not have the power to reject the law. For so called 'special legislative procedures' the EU 'parliament' has only a consultative role.
It establishes an EU budget (along with the Council of the EU). Laws must also be passed by the [self-appointed] Council of the EU in order to become law.
Unlike most national parliaments, the European Parliament cannot initiate legislation. The [unelected] European Commission is the only EU institution with the power to initiate new laws.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 22 Feb 23 8.15am

Originally posted by georgenorman

Who are more likely to make laws that are in the interests of our own country - elected British governments or non-elected people from 26 other countries?

Exactly.

I have no problem with international co-operation e.g. standards for electrical goods or food all makes sense to me.

No the real issue with the EU is when they try and set standards for social policy e.g. working time directive or increasingly foreign policy and taxation.

We are out of step with many other EU (socialist) countries on these things so it became a push and shove between the UK and the EU.

I think that the EU should have offered us an outer membership which was like the old EEC. Even Macron now recognises that has merit.

Anyway I don't see any movement for the time being. If they want us back it will have to be a good deal but at the moment they are playing hard ball.

Once the next group of poor countries join I wonder if that will encourage the richer nations to start wooing us back in.

Edited by Badger11 (22 Feb 2023 8.15am)

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 22 Feb 23 8.43am

Originally posted by georgenorman

The Oxford Dictionary gives the definition of 'parliament’ as “the group of people who are elected to make and change the laws of a country.” So perhaps they should change their name to the EU Parliamentary Charade.
The Commission is not obliged to take any notice of what the parliament proposes - as their own website says: "The European Parliament cannot initiate legislation. The European Commission is the only EU institution with the power to initiate new laws."

As that definition is true for our own, and other, national parliaments I can see why the OED define it like that. However, it isn't strictly true. It's a word that, like so many, has evolved over time. Merriam-Webster have a number of definitions including "a formal conference for the discussion of public affairs, specifically : a council of state in early medieval England". It comes from the French word "parler", meaning "to talk" and originally that's what parliaments did.

So the EU are using it in a broader sense than the narrower understanding that has evolved in the UK.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 22 Feb 23 8.53am

Originally posted by HKOwen

Quite a surprise you frame your argument around something entirely subjective.

That it is subjective doesn't mean it is neither important nor observable. My hope is that some kind of measurement tool can be devised, so a greater understanding becomes possible. Right now it's empirical but still seems pretty clear.

The alleged benefits of Brexit are just as subjective but have yet to be observed.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 22 Feb 23 9.02am

Originally posted by Badger11

Exactly.

I have no problem with international co-operation e.g. standards for electrical goods or food all makes sense to me.

No the real issue with the EU is when they try and set standards for social policy e.g. working time directive or increasingly foreign policy and taxation.

We are out of step with many other EU (socialist) countries on these things so it became a push and shove between the UK and the EU.

I think that the EU should have offered us an outer membership which was like the old EEC. Even Macron now recognises that has merit.

Anyway I don't see any movement for the time being. If they want us back it will have to be a good deal but at the moment they are playing hard ball.

Once the next group of poor countries join I wonder if that will encourage the richer nations to start wooing us back in.

Edited by Badger11 (22 Feb 2023 8.15am)

This has the merit of being both practical and possible. It matches my own expectations. How deeply we delegate responsibility is another debate, but once the general principle of subsidiarity is accepted then we are on the right track. I don't see either foreign policy or taxation ever being accepted as delegated powers by us. That might happen for the inner core countries, by separate arrangements. Some practical aspects of social policy might.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 22 Feb 23 9.07am

Originally posted by georgenorman

Who are more likely to make laws that are in the interests of our own country - elected British governments or non-elected people from 26 other countries?

It's always and only the British government which makes laws for our country. If they delegate some responsibilities to others then they do so because they believe it's in our interests to act collectively.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 22 Feb 23 9.16am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

It's always and only the British government which makes laws for our country. If they delegate some responsibilities to others then they do so because they believe it's in our interests to act collectively.

It is now, but when we were in the EU, EU law had precedence over UK law.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 22 Feb 23 9.18am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

As that definition is true for our own, and other, national parliaments I can see why the OED define it like that. However, it isn't strictly true. It's a word that, like so many, has evolved over time. Merriam-Webster have a number of definitions including "a formal conference for the discussion of public affairs, specifically : a council of state in early medieval England". It comes from the French word "parler", meaning "to talk" and originally that's what parliaments did.

So the EU are using it in a broader sense than the narrower understanding that has evolved in the UK.

Public affairs are discussed in my local pub and the talk has about as much affect on things as the EU 'parliament' talk.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 22 Feb 23 11.42am

Originally posted by georgenorman

It is now, but when we were in the EU, EU law had precedence over UK law.

Regulations applied automatically whilst Directives needed local legislation. They are just the way various decisions were implemented. None could have applied unless the UK government had taken the decision that they should, by signing the Treaties in the first place.

We joined the club and accepted the club's rules. You don't think the club is worth belonging to, even if it provides a safe space, comfort, a shared sense of purpose, common standards and strengthened negotiation abilities. You would rather keep the membership fee in your pocket and sit outside in the cold, happy in the knowledge that because that's your decision the cold and the duplicated effort doesn't matter. Others disagree with you.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 22 Feb 23 11.48am

Originally posted by georgenorman

Public affairs are discussed in my local pub and the talk has about as much affect on things as the EU 'parliament' talk.

Untrue. Your pub debates cannot do anything but produce hot air, of the kind you do here.

That the EU parliament doesn't function in the same way as a national parliament doesn't mean it has no purpose. If you can sack the Commission then you have a role overseeing their work.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards georgenorman Flag 22 Feb 23 12.10pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Untrue. Your pub debates cannot do anything but produce hot air, of the kind you do here.

That the EU parliament doesn't function in the same way as a national parliament doesn't mean it has no purpose. If you can sack the Commission then you have a role overseeing their work.

EU citizens should have the power to sack and appoint the EU commission via direct elections, as they would if they lived in a democracy.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 22 Feb 23 1.07pm

i don't recall any UK politicians being sacked. Some have resigned, or ousted at an election, but I don't recall voters ever forcing someone/sacking them from office.
I am of the opinion the UK is not a Democracy. When was the last Government voted in by the majority of the electorate ?

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 22 Feb 23 2.11pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3777273]

What do you mean by "significantly worse off vs." ...."significantly better off" exactly? How would this be measured?

Also, if it works, would you be able to agree on that or would you (be) prepared to cut your nose off to spite your own face / die on the hill of ideology by sticking with the latter scenario, discarding all logic and reason?

Now we are where we are I'm keen to go in whatever direction ends up being more beneficial to us as a country. i.e. follow the best path to success, whatever that may be, not make arbitrary decisions based on ideology. If Brexit is that path, then so be it – it would be hard to argue against prosperity and being 'better off' than our EU cousins.

However, equally, we might not end up being in a better place, and in that scenario I get the feeling it would be hard for some on here to stomach / follow observable fact and evidence and ditch an almost religious adherence to ideology.

So to answer your first question, I wouldn't need to cut off my nose in that scenario anyway because I'm not wedded to either one of the 'democracy at all costs' vs 'EU at all costs' ideology debate. I'm just going to evolve my viewpoint as the situation develops. Y'know, logic.

Being open to change ones opinion depending on leaning, experience and observable reality and evidence rather than blindly sticking to a pre-determined ideology is pretty important in my view. One approach leads to success, the other, demise.

On measurement – an unscientific, yet simple way of doing so would be to see how we're performing against other comparable countries still in the EU in a few years time. If we're doing better than them financially, socially, developmentally... that would be a pretty good sign we made the right choice by leaving.

If you were to look at it more scientifically it would be complex but not impossible to research and produce a measured conclusion.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 22 Feb 23 3.30pm

Originally posted by georgenorman

EU citizens should have the power to sack and appoint the EU commission via direct elections, as they would if they lived in a democracy.

EU citizens have plenty of democracy.

But what they really like is fruit and vegetables,

Especially Brussels.


 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 22 Feb 23 5.23pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

EU citizens have plenty of democracy.

But what they really like is fruit and vegetables,

Especially Brussels.


Plenty here I’ll send you some. Fing Brexit playing havoc with the weather, who’d have thought it

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 22 Feb 23 7.17pm

Ridiculous, Western Europe has no shortages at all.

'Brexit is not really a factor'.

Not much, it is an embarrassment tbh.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 22 Feb 23 7.54pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Ridiculous, Western Europe has no shortages at all.

'Brexit is not really a factor'.

Not much, it is an embarrassment tbh.

That would never happen to an EU member.


[Link]

 

Grumbles 22 Feb 23 7.57pm

FFS. it's about the weather.

 

Page 108 of 156 < 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Post EU World