This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
Its true what you say of course, But.. the big but now is we have Eze (accepting the fact he comes back the same player) and Olise I am massively excited about. We are in a much better place now than before. Wilf is King though, always. Quite a trio if we can ever get them fit.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
Yes, and Barcelona had Messi. They just got further into debt relying on the memory of his past success. Wilf is undoubtedly a fine player and one of the best in our history. But I am firmly of the opinion that we would now be better off without him. He shows flashes of his old form, but is far too easily aggravated by the opposition and his temperament lets him down. Whatever people may say, we still rely on him too much. If we sold him PV could rebuild the team with a new player(s) bought with the proceeds of his sale. The trouble is, nobody wants him. Not sure you can put Wilf and Messi in the same bracket
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Not sure you can put Wilf and Messi in the same bracket I wasn't really, only in relative terms. Messi at Barca. Wilf at Palace. Could add Ronaldo at Real. Too much emphasis on one player equals long term issues that's all. Just my POV. Plenty will disagree.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled. |
|
|
Spot on. Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
Yes, and Barcelona had Messi. They just got further into debt relying on the memory of his past success. Wilf is undoubtedly a fine player and one of the best in our history. But I am firmly of the opinion that we would now be better off without him. He shows flashes of his old form, but is far too easily aggravated by the opposition and his temperament lets him down. Whatever people may say, we still rely on him too much. If we sold him PV could rebuild the team with a new player(s) bought with the proceeds of his sale. The trouble is, nobody wants him.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
Yes, and Barcelona had Messi. They just got further into debt relying on the memory of his past success. Wilf is undoubtedly a fine player and one of the best in our history. But I am firmly of the opinion that we would now be better off without him. He shows flashes of his old form, but is far too easily aggravated by the opposition and his temperament lets him down. Whatever people may say, we still rely on him too much. If we sold him PV could rebuild the team with a new player(s) bought with the proceeds of his sale. The trouble is, nobody wants him. I fully agree, Wilf as great as he is prone more to sulking these days than being man-of-the-match. His recent ratings and performances have not been that great and I really do believe it would be better to let him go and rebuild around a team rather than one individual.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Not sure you can put Wilf and Messi in the same bracket Not sure you can put Eze and Olise in the same bracket as Wilf, but it keeps happening.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
Not sure you can put Eze and Olise in the same bracket as Wilf, but it keeps happening. Haven’t seen enough of Olise to comment, but I think you can absolutely put Eze in the same bracket. He’s an absolute player. Outshone Wilf for much of last season.
|
|
|
Originally posted by sprites
Haven’t seen enough of Olise to comment, but I think you can absolutely put Eze in the same bracket. He’s an absolute player. Outshone Wilf for much of last season. The most reasonable way to look at it is probably to set aside the (possibly incomparable?) sum total of what Zaha has contributed to Palace in his whole career, and just compare Zaha and Eze last season. It's not a totally fair comparison as Zaha played upfront and Eze was playing wide, though you could argue that Wilf moved from the centre away from the goal to find space whilst Eze drifted in from the flank towards the goal. Either way, the figures were: League appearances - Zaha 30 Eze 34. In four less games Wilf got almost three times the goals Eze got without being found wanting when it comes to chance creation. Even things like tackles made might surprise - Zaha 26 Eze 27. Considering Eze was in midfield, and we hardly pressed from the front, Wilf put himself about as much as his younger teammate. I loved watching Eze play, and like many I've found Wilf increasingly petulant and joyless in recent years but even at his apparent worst Zaha is significantly more productive and effective than Eze has yet shown he can be. He can't play Sheffield United every week.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
The most reasonable way to look at it is probably to set aside the (possibly incomparable?) sum total of what Zaha has contributed to Palace in his whole career, and just compare Zaha and Eze last season. It's not a totally fair comparison as Zaha played upfront and Eze was playing wide, though you could argue that Wilf moved from the centre away from the goal to find space whilst Eze drifted in from the flank towards the goal. Either way, the figures were: League appearances - Zaha 30 Eze 34. In four less games Wilf got almost three times the goals Eze got without being found wanting when it comes to chance creation. Even things like tackles made might surprise - Zaha 26 Eze 27. Considering Eze was in midfield, and we hardly pressed from the front, Wilf put himself about as much as his younger teammate. I loved watching Eze play, and like many I've found Wilf increasingly petulant and joyless in recent years but even at his apparent worst Zaha is significantly more productive and effective than Eze has yet shown he can be. He can't play Sheffield United every week. Yeah, that's a fair post. But I think like you say, different roles. If we're looking at them more generally, I think it's pretty close now.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
The most reasonable way to look at it is probably to set aside the (possibly incomparable?) sum total of what Zaha has contributed to Palace in his whole career, and just compare Zaha and Eze last season. It's not a totally fair comparison as Zaha played upfront and Eze was playing wide, though you could argue that Wilf moved from the centre away from the goal to find space whilst Eze drifted in from the flank towards the goal. Either way, the figures were: League appearances - Zaha 30 Eze 34. In four less games Wilf got almost three times the goals Eze got without being found wanting when it comes to chance creation. Even things like tackles made might surprise - Zaha 26 Eze 27. Considering Eze was in midfield, and we hardly pressed from the front, Wilf put himself about as much as his younger teammate. I loved watching Eze play, and like many I've found Wilf increasingly petulant and joyless in recent years but even at his apparent worst Zaha is significantly more productive and effective than Eze has yet shown he can be. He can't play Sheffield United every week. Across the season as a whole that is fair, but I would argue it was a season of two halves with Zaha king in the first half and Eze the second. First half of the season Eze was adapting to the PL and sometimes went missing in games while Zaha seemed to have recaptured his top form. Then in the second half Wilf seemed unable to score, was easily stopped by most defenders and just seemed to wander around moaning. In contrast, the further the season went on the more Eze grew in stature and the by the end when he moved into the middle, for me, was outshining Zaha resulting in him (apparently) being about to get an England call up. As others have said, they are different players and if they can both stay fit and with the option of Olise you can't help but get a little aroused at their potential.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
I wasn't really, only in relative terms. Messi at Barca. Wilf at Palace. Could add Ronaldo at Real. Too much emphasis on one player equals long term issues that's all. Just my POV. Plenty will disagree. Agree. Fairly sure you can trace Arsenals decline to Being overly reliant on Henry.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by Crystal_Clear
He is absolutely critical at the moment, and he needs to be involved in the game as much as possible against Brentford. If not, I can't see where we get our 1st point from. I wasn't at Selhurst today, but judging by the critical comments on the match thread from some of you about Wilf's game it does seem like his attitude hasn't improved. Patrick should take him on one side and make it plain that, unless he cuts out his petulant behaviour and concentrates on playing the quality football we all know he's capable of, then his days at Palace are numbered. Maybe the Chairman should tell him the facts of life too. He's not doing himself any favours with his approach to the game, but what's worse he's not doing CPFC any favours either.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.