This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by thegreatlardino
As we don't actually know what is actually going on with this war with the total lack of reporting....if as it has been mentioned the Ukrainian forces are tying to go through Russian static defences, not really sure what cluster munitions would do, they would work against massed troops out in the open, but there doesn't appear to be any.
Nothing in that to disagree with outside of the comment about the reporting. There is plenty of 'reporting' but it is beyond ludicrous. Almost zero attempt to try and portray the actual nuances of what the situation is, and has been, in Eastern Ukraine for well over a decade now. I have a family member, heavily invested in the Ukranian side of things, having been on the ground as part of an aid organisation. We disagree on many issues around this conflict but the one thing he does tell me is that what he has seen and experienced over there, bears very little resemblance to how it is reported in the West. Throw in how RT was banned almost straight away and I cannot recollect ever seeing so much one-sided reporting in my life. I was under no illusions about the MSM before this tawdry conflict but now, just see it primarily as pure propaganda. Whatever the outcome, the notion of us somehow enjoying a moral superiority around the West championing a 'free press' is simply not sustainable anymore.
"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
When this conflict started I made the point that both Napoleon and Hitler had come a cropper after early successes against Russia because no matter how incompetent Russian forces are they simply overwhelm you in the end with their massive resources. My opinion hasn't changed, the Russian are prepared to accept massive losses that no western country would put up with. Not wholly analogous. Napoleon and hitler came a cropper not just through the endless manpower but also the elements and vast land mass. Ironically it is the absence of resources relative to land area that hurts you as there is nothing to feed the troops and supply lines are long and vulnerable. Ukraine is Russia attacking not defending; and it is all taking place within a self contained theatre. Russia does have a much greater tolerance for body bags, as you say, but remember Afghanistan ended partly through pressure of the mums of the fallen. That still may happen if fortune turns against Russia. And the only way that can happen is if the west keeps feeding the meter.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Not wholly analogous. Napoleon and hitler came a cropper not just through the endless manpower but also the elements and vast land mass. Ironically it is the absence of resources relative to land area that hurts you as there is nothing to feed the troops and supply lines are long and vulnerable. Ukraine is Russia attacking not defending; and it is all taking place within a self contained theatre. Russia does have a much greater tolerance for body bags, as you say, but remember Afghanistan ended partly through pressure of the mums of the fallen. That still may happen if fortune turns against Russia. And the only way that can happen is if the west keeps feeding the meter. I get that is one possible outcome. But sending cluster bombs is treading on thin moral ground. All weapons kill/maim, i get that. But cluster bombs have inherent faults which make civilian casualties much more likely.
I disengage, I turn the page. |
|
|
Originally posted by Matov
Nothing in that to disagree with outside of the comment about the reporting. There is plenty of 'reporting' but it is beyond ludicrous. Almost zero attempt to try and portray the actual nuances of what the situation is, and has been, in Eastern Ukraine for well over a decade now. I have a family member, heavily invested in the Ukranian side of things, having been on the ground as part of an aid organisation. We disagree on many issues around this conflict but the one thing he does tell me is that what he has seen and experienced over there, bears very little resemblance to how it is reported in the West. Throw in how RT was banned almost straight away and I cannot recollect ever seeing so much one-sided reporting in my life. I was under no illusions about the MSM before this tawdry conflict but now, just see it primarily as pure propaganda. Whatever the outcome, the notion of us somehow enjoying a moral superiority around the West championing a 'free press' is simply not sustainable anymore. Pretty much. People actually believe that what they get told is the truth, whereas when you dig deeper it's actually the same as everything the media does.....it's a narrative, it's not lies as such, they just present the situation in a way that fits their narrative...but omitting anything that muddies or counters it....the only time the issues are raised is for them denying or demonising them. Ironically, it's very Soviet or China like....which is the direction we are heading in. We live in a time where most don't really care, it's just about winning for them....they don't really care much above that. If you raise any issue you're suddenly a Putin fan.....when Russia do exactly the same thing in their media. Russia are not the good guys, Russia are operating in their own interests....and that isn't ours. We operate in the US neo con's interests. There are no good guys in this war and hundreds of thousands of people have died thinking that they were on a good side when in truth they were lied to. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Jul 2023 7.06pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The USA are themselves running short on ammo and, until this catches up, feel this is the only answer at the moment. The cluster bombs are for battlefield use only, away from civilian areas and they are more sophisticated than the Russian ones. We cannot have the Ukraine weaker than their enemy. Etc.etc. So I guess I see why. So is that in the same way that none of Nato's weapons were meant to be used for an attack on Russia's territory? That didn't last long. Ukraine...like Russia....have no issues bombing residential areas. In truth, troops and ammo are often hidden there for obvious reasons. But they will also mortar and bomb them anyway. This happens in all wars....Blair justified bombing and killing journalists....I'll never forget that. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Jul 2023 7.10pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
So is that in the same way that none of Nato's weapons were meant to be used for an attack on Russia's territory? That didn't last long. Ukraine...like Russia....have no issues bombing residential areas. In truth, troops and ammo are often hidden there for obvious reasons. But they will also mortar and bomb them anyway. This happens in all wars....Blair justified bombing and killing journalists....I'll never forget that. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Jul 2023 7.10pm) Correct & then started having the service personnel prosecuted for doing what the Govt of the day wanted, same as the Vets who were in Ireland at the behest of the Govt of the day. IMHO, bLIAR is a traitor! Edited by eagleman13 (13 Jul 2023 4.33pm)
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
I see the US are trying to escalate this war by proxy. Get Sleeepy Joe out now!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Pretty much. People actually believe that what they get told is the truth, whereas when you dig deeper it's actually the same as everything the media does.....it's a narrative, it's not lies as such, they just present the situation in a way that fits their narrative...but omitting anything that muddies or counters it....the only time the issues are raised is for them denying or demonising them. Ironically, it's very Soviet or China like....which is the direction we are heading in. We live in a time where most don't really care, it's just about winning for them....they don't really care much above that. If you raise any issue you're suddenly a Putin fan.....when Russia do exactly the same thing in their media. Russia are not the good guys, Russia are operating in their own interests....and that isn't ours. We operate in the US neo con's interests. There are no good guys in this war and hundreds of thousands of people have died thinking that they were on a good side when in truth they were lied to. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Jul 2023 7.06pm) What you dont see is people in East Ukraine are actually pro Russian and to them they are liberated.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
What you dont see is people in East Ukraine are actually pro Russian and to them they are liberated. It's probably the biggest thing about this war that both media and government gross over. Yet, that separation from their government, is exactly the same reason why so many countries they recognise today exist....The US included.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Daddyorc
So how oppressed were these people in East Ukraine? As far as I could tell, not very. Donetsk was a thriving city, with some of the wealthiest Ukrainians there. Now, it's just a shattered empty image of what it used to be. Putin is a bully that uses the "liberation" factor to take lands that don't belong to Russia anymore. The reality is he doesn't "love" his people, if he did he wouldn't be sending so many of them to die or be maimed by fighting against a country where the people are so similar to his own. How many Ukrainians have you met or heard from that actually like what Putin is doing? There's lots of famous Ukrainians, but I have yet to hear one on his side. I know the media mostly reports positive stories about the Ukrainian war. But it doesn't make what Putin is doing any less despicable. Ok, it's time some truth was spoken about this. The south and east of Ukraine have the highest number of ethnic Russian speakers with Russian heritage in Ukraine. When past elections are looked at the vote for pro Russian parties was always high. This is completely ignored....Yet it is the truth. The democratically elected pro Russian government before 2014 was taken down in a coup. It was not voted out....the change in government was not put to a national vote. This is completely ignored....Yet it is the truth. This led to Ukrainian army units in the south and east taking over their own territories from the new government in Kiev.....they were willing to fight and die rather than live under the new regime which they knew was anti them. This is completely ignored....Yet it is the truth. The civil war that started carried out with both western financial backing, Russia backing and Russia supplied mercs and equipment, that's true all until the Minsk agreement. This agreement turned out to be abused with massive military build up and shelling. People rightly point to Russia as a corrupt and mafia state. Yet the Ukraine is little better. The US neo cons just use it as a low cost battering ram against the Russians.....Yet the harm done to the world over this far exceeds their short termism. Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jul 2023 7.29pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Daddyorc
So how oppressed were these people in East Ukraine? As far as I could tell, not very. Donetsk was a thriving city, with some of the wealthiest Ukrainians there. Now, it's just a shattered empty image of what it used to be. Putin is a bully that uses the "liberation" factor to take lands that don't belong to Russia anymore. The reality is he doesn't "love" his people, if he did he wouldn't be sending so many of them to die or be maimed by fighting against a country where the people are so similar to his own. How many Ukrainians have you met or heard from that actually like what Putin is doing? There's lots of famous Ukrainians, but I have yet to hear one on his side. I know the media mostly reports positive stories about the Ukrainian war. But it doesn't make what Putin is doing any less despicable. The reason you aren't hearing from any pro Russian propaganda from Ukrainians is exactly the same reason why Russians aren't hearing the opposite. Propaganda is a controlled narrative.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Ok, it's time some truth was spoken about this. The south and east of Ukraine have the highest number of ethnic Russian speakers with Russian heritage in Ukraine. When past elections are looked at the vote for pro Russian parties was always high. This is completely ignored....Yet it is the truth. The democratically elected pro Russian government before 2014 was taken down in a coup. It was not voted out....the change in government was not put to a national vote. This is completely ignored....Yet it is the truth. This led to Ukrainian army units in the south and east taking over their own territories from the new government in Kiev.....they were willing to fight and die rather than live under the new regime which they knew was anti them. This is completely ignored....Yet it is the truth. The civil war that started carried out with both western financial backing, Russia backing and Russia supplied mercs and equipment, that's true all until the Minsk agreement. This agreement turned out to be abused with massive military build up and shelling. People rightly point to Russia as a corrupt and mafia state. Yet the Ukraine is little better. The US neo cons just use it as a low cost battering ram against the Russians.....Yet the harm done to the world over this far exceeds their short termism. Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jul 2023 7.29pm) Your truths are mainly lies Ukrainians became very frustrated with the corruption in elections. For example look at the turnout figures in the East. There was a mass response, primarily driven by young people. For example In total 18.4% of Ukrainians have claimed to have taken part in the Orange Revolution (across Ukraine). As a result of Maidan in 2014, Parliament restored the 2004 amendments put in place by the Orange Revolution. Your words come straight from the mouth of Putin.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
Your truths are mainly lies Ukrainians became very frustrated with the corruption in elections. For example look at the turnout figures in the East. There was a mass response, primarily driven by young people. For example In total 18.4% of Ukrainians have claimed to have taken part in the Orange Revolution (across Ukraine). As a result of Maidan in 2014, Parliament restored the 2004 amendments put in place by the Orange Revolution. Your words come straight from the mouth of Putin.
Just as I have criticised us and the Zelensky regime I have criticised Russia and Putin many times in this thread. I don't care who says something what I care about is the truth and what the outcomes are of decisions that are made. This war has been a complete failure of US/Russia statecraft and was warned about many times by many different people many years ago: All ignored in probably the most avoidable war I've ever lived to see. As with Covid, people only have to look at my first posts on this war to see that I was open minded about the whole thing. The only difference with myself compared to someone like you perhaps is that I look at what both sides are saying and check against what actually happened. I actually bothered to research it......anyone who reads through this thread can see how Wisbech and myself and others went through this process of debating the issues. I say it with no pleasure but my positions and predictions on this war are largely panning out. It's absolute madness and fighting this war has only worsened the outcomes for everybody. If Trump had been in power it would have probably never happened and if it had it would have been settled back in March 21 with terms far more favourable to Ukraine than what it's going to get now. Edited by Stirlingsays (15 Jul 2023 4.06pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.